HB
Henri Bergson
Portrait: Henri Manuel, Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
1859–1941

Henri Bergson

Bergson was a philosopher whose Creative Evolution put an élan vital in place of both mechanism and strict finalism. Driesch also praised Bergson's earlier work on memory and action1.

Born
18 October 1859
Died
4 January 1941
Country
France
Field
philosopher, professor, sociologist
In the library
1 work, named in 11 passages elsewhere
Facts from
Wikidata · Wikipedia · Open Library
01

Critique of Darwinian history

Rádl reports that Bergson argued against Darwinian theories on one point. They did not describe what actually happened. They showed a series of forms, like frames of a film, that could be pictured as all existing together5. For Bergson, evolution was a continual process of change, driven by an impetus present since life began. Rádl judges that the theory did not directly shape evolutionary biology, but added to growing doubt about Darwinian ideas6.

02

Vitalism and its critics

Driesch thought his own category of individuality met the same point. Henderson judged Bergson's hypothesis no less vitalistic than Driesch's3. Child saw no reason to think entelechy or élan vital was needed to explain the creation of new patterns in development4.

03

Use by Thompson and Driesch

Thompson borrowed Bergson's phrase "ideal kinship" for the relation of likeness between forms. Driesch, separately, credited Bergson's work on memory with establishing an autonomy of acting, in parallel with his own argument1.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. had, as early as 1896, established what I should call the autonomy of acting, by a discussion which, though confined to Psychology, and therefore differentDriesch, H., 1908 · The Science and Philosophy of the Organism · open at passage 158
  2. Bergson only analyses phylogeny ; in ontogeny le tout est donne — and yet there is "vitalism.Driesch, H., 1908 · The Science and Philosophy of the Organism · open at passage 633
  3. Bergson's hypothesis is, however, in es- sence not less vitalistic than that of Driesch.Henderson, L. J., 1913 · The Fitness of the Environment · open at passage 428
  4. there is no reason so far to believe that Driesch’s entelechy or Bergson’s élan vital is any more necessary for such creation than for the creation of a new chemical compoundChild, C. M., 1924 · Physiological Foundations of Behavior · open at passage 621
  5. Bergson proves, however, that Darwinian theories do not really represent an effort to discover the history of events, to describe what actually happened.Rádl, E., 1930 · The History of Biological Theories · open at passage 927
  6. Bergson's theory did not directly influence evolutionary theories. But indirectly it was of considerable importanceRádl, E., 1930 · The History of Biological Theories · open at passage 927
  7. what Bergson calls* the “ideal kinship” is plain and certain, but the “material affiliation” is problematic and obscureThompson, D. A. W., 1992 · On Growth and Form · open at passage 1328
In the library1 work