Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 960 to 989 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

960

weeks before again visiting the animal, when he went into the stable and began to fondle the elephant as he had previously been accustomed to do. For a time no re- sentment was shown, so that the Captain began to think that the experiment had failed; but at last, watching for an opportunity, the elephant filled his trunk with dirty water, and drenched the Captain from head to foot. Griffiths says that at the siege of Bhurtpore, in 1805, the British army had been a long time before the city, and, owing to the hot dry winds, the ponds and tanks had dried up. There used therefore to be no little struggle for priority in procuring water at one of the large wells which still contained water :— %

961

On one occasion two elephant-drivers, each with his elephant, the one remarkably large and strong, and the other comparatively small and weak, were at the well together; the small elephant ~ had been provided by his master with a bucket for the occasion, which he carried on the end of his proboscis, but the larger animal, being destitute of this necessary vessel, either spon- taneously, or by the desire of his keeper, seized the bucket, and easily wrested it from his less powerful fellow-servant; the latter was too sensible of his inferiority openly to resent the insult, though it is obvious that he felt it; but great squabbling and abuse ensued between the keepers. At length the weaker animal, watching the opportunity when the other was standing with his side to the well, retired backwards a few paces in a very quiet and unsuspicious manner, and then, rushing forward with all his might, drove his head against the side of the other, and fairly pushed him into the well.

962

Great trouble was experienced in extricating this elephant from the well—a task which would, indeed, have been impossible but for the intelligence of the animal | itself. For when a number of fascines, which had been ~ employed by the army in conducting the siege, were thrown down the well, the elephant showed sagacity — enough to arrange them with his trunk so as to construct — a continuously rising platform, by which he gradually — raised himself to a level with the ground.

963

Allied to vindictiveness for small injuries is revenge for large ones, and this is often shown in a terrible manner by wounded elephants. For instance, Sir E. Tennent writes :— Some years ago an elephant which had been wounded by a native, near Hambangtotte, pursued the man into the town, followed him along the street, trampled him to death in the bazaar before a crowd of terrified spectators, and succeeded in making good its retreat to the jungle.

964

Many other cases of vindictiveness, more or less well authenticated, may be found mentioned by Broderip,! Bingley,’ Mrs. Lee,’ Swainson,‘ and Watson.® This trait of emotional character seems to be more generally present in the elephant than in any other animal, except perhaps Another emotion strongly developed in the elephant is sympathy. Numberless examples on this head might be adduced, but one or two may suffice. Bishop Huber saw an old elephant fall down from weakness, and another elephant was brought to assist the fallen one to rise. Huber says he was much struck with the almost human expression of surprise, alarm, and sympathy manifested by the second elephant on witnessing the condition of the first. A chain was fastened round the neck and body of the sick animal, which the other was directed to pull. For a minute or two the healthy elephant pulled strongly ; but on the first groan given by its distressed companion

965

roar, and with trunk and fore-feet began to loosen the chain from the neck.’ Again, Sir E. Tennent says :— The devotion and loyalty which the herd evince to their leader are very remarkable. This is more readily seen in the case of a tusker than any other, because in a herd he is gene- rally the object of the keenest pursuit by the hunters. On such occasions the others do their utmost, to protect him from danger : when driven to extremity they place their leader in the centre

966

* Habits and Instincts of Animals, p. 37. 5 Reasoning Power of Animals, chap. iv. and crowd so eagerly in front of him that the sportsmen have to shoot a number which they might otherwise have spared. In one instance a tusker, which was badly wounded by Major Rogers, was promptly surrounded by his companions, who sup- ported him between their shoulders, and actually succeeded in covering his retreat to the forest. Lastly, allusion may be made to the celebrated obser- vation of M. le Baron de Lauriston, who was at Laknaor during an epidemic which stretched a number of natives sick and dying upon the road. The Nabob riding his elephant over the road was careless whether or not the animal crushed the men and women to death, but not so the elephant, which took great pains to pick his steps among the people so as not to injure them.

967

The following account of emotion and sagacity is quoted from the Rev. Julius Young’s Memoirs of his father, Mr. Charles Young, the actor. The animal mentioned is the one that subsequently attained such widespread notoriety at Exeter Change, not only on account of his immense size, but still more because of his cruel death :— In July 1810, the largest elephant ever seen in England was advertised as ‘just arrived.’ As soon as Henry Harris, the manager of Covent Garden Theatre, heard of it, he determined, if possible, to obtain it; for it struck him that if it were to be introduced into the new pantomime of ‘ Harlequin Padmenaba,’ which he was about to produce at great cost, it would add greatly to its attraction. Under this impression, and before the proprietor of Exeter Change had seen it, he purchased it for the sum of 900 guineas. Mrs. Henry Johnston was to ride it, and Miss Parker, the columbine, was to play up to it. Young hap- pened to be one morning at the box-office adjoining Covent Garden Theatre, when his ears were assailed by a strange and unusual uproar within the walls. On asking one of the car- penters the cause of it, he was told ‘it was something going wrong with the elephant; he could not exactly tell what.’ I am not aware what the usage may be nowadays, but then, whenever a new piece had been announced for presentation on a given night, and there was but scant time for its preparation, a rehearsal would take place after the night’s regular performance was over, and the audience had been dismissed. One such there had been the night before my father’s curiosity had been roused. As it had been arranged that Mrs. Henry Johnston, seated in

968

a howdah on the elephant’s back, should pass over a bridge in the centre of a numerous group of followers, it was thought expedient that the unwieldy monster’s tractability should be tested. On stepping up to the bridge, which was slight and temporary, the sagacious brute drew back his fore-feet and refused to budge. It is well known as a fact in natural history that the elephant, aware of his unusual bulk, will never trust its weight on any object which is unequal to its support. The stage-manager, seeing how resolutely the animal resisted every attempt made to compel or induce it to go over the bridge in question, proposed that they should stay proceedings till next day, when he might be in a better mood. It was during the repetition of the experiment that my father, having heard the extraordinary sounds, determined to go upon the stage, and see if he could ascertain the cause of them. The first sight that met his eyes kindled his indignation. There stood the high animal, with downcast eyes and flapping ears, meekly submitting to blow after blow from a sharp iron goad, which his keeper was driving ferociously into the fleshy part of his neck, at the root of the ear. ‘The floor on which he stood was converted into a pool of blood. One of the proprietors, impatient at what he regarded as senseless obstinacy, kept urging the driver to pro- ceed to still severer extremities, when Charles Young, who was a great lover of animals, expostulated with him, went up to the poor patient sufferer, and patted and caressed him; and when the driver was about to wield his instrument again, with even still more vigour, he caught him by the wrist as in a vice, and stayed his hand from further violence.

969

While an angry alterca- tion was going on between Young and the man of colour, who was the driver, Captain Hay, of the Ashel, who had brought over ‘Chuny’ in his ship, and had petted him greatly on the voyage, came in and begged to know what was the matter. Before a word of explanation could be given, the much-wronged creature spoke for himself; for, as soon as he perceived the entrance of his patron, he waddled up to him, and, with a look of gentle appeal, caught hold of his hand with his pro- boscis, plunged it into his bleeding wound, and then thrust it before his eyes. The gesture seemed to say, as plainly as if it had been enforced by speech, ‘See how these cruel men treat Chuny. Can you approve of it?’ The hearts of the hardest present were sensibly touched by what they saw, and among them that of the gentleman who had been so energetic in promoting its harsh treatment. It was under a far better im- pulse that he ran out into the street, purchased a few apples at

970

a stall, and offered them to him. Chuny eyed him askance, took. them, threw them beneath his feet, and when he had crushed them to pulp, spurned them from him. Young, who had gone into Covent Garden on the same errand as the gentleman who had preceded him, shortly after re-entered, and also held out to him some fruit, when, to the astonishment of the bystanders, the elephant ate every morsel, and after he had done so, twined his trunk with studied gentleness around Young’s waist, mark-

971

ing by his action that, though he had resented a wrong, he did not forget a kindness. It was in the year 1814 that Harris parted with Chuny to Cross, the proprietor of the menagerie at Exeter Change. One of the purchaser’s first acts was to send Charles Young a life ticket of admission to his exhibition; and it was one of his little innocent vanities, when passing through the Strand with any friend, to drop in on Chuny, pay him a visit in his den, and

972

show the intimate relations which existed between them. Some years after, when the elephant’s theatrical career was run, and he was reduced to play the part of captive in one of the cages of Exeter Change, a thoughtless dandy one day amused himself by teasing him with the repeated offer of lettuces—a vegetable for which he was known to have an antipathy. At last he pre- sented him with an apple, but, at the moment of his taking it, drove a large pin into his trunk, and then sprang out of his.

973

reach. Thekeeper seeing that the poor creature was getting angry, warned the silly fellow off, lest he should become dangerous. With a contemptuous shrug of the shoulder, he trudged off to the: other end of the gallery, and there displayed his cruel ingenuity on other humbler beasts, till, after the absence of half-an-hour, he once more approached one of the cages opposite the elephant’s. By this time he had forgotten his pranks with Chuny, but Chuny had not forgotten him; and as he was standing with his back

974

towards him, he thrust his proboscis through the bars of his. prison, twitched off the offender’s hat, dragged it in to him, tore it to shreds, then threw it into the face of the offending gaby, consummating his revenge with a loud guffaw of exultation. All present proclaimed their approbation of this act of retributive justice, and the discomfited coxcomb had to retreat from the- scene in confusion, jump into a hackney coach, and betake him- self to the hatter’s in quest of a new tile for his unroofed skull.

975

The tragic end of poor Chuny must be within the recollection of . many of my readers. From some cause unknown he went mad,. and after poison had been tried in vain it took 152 shots, dis- charged by a detachment of the Guards, to despatch him.’ The elephant in many respects displays strange pe- culiarities of emotional temperament. Thus Mr. Corse says:—‘If a wild elephant happens to be separated from its young for only two or three days, though giving suck, she never after recognises or acknowledges it ;’! yet the young one knows its dam, and cries plaintively for her assistance. |

976

Again, in the wild state, the spirit of exclusiveness shown by members of a herd (7.¢. family) towards elephants of other herds is remarkable. Sir E. Tennent writes :— If by any accident an elephant becomes hopelessly separated from his own herd, he is not permitted to attach himself to any other. He may browse in the vicinity, or frequent the same place to drink and to bathe; but the mtercourse is only on a distant and conventional footing, and no familiarity or intimate association is under any circumstances permitted. To such a height is this exclusiveness carried, that even amidst the terror of an elephant corral, when an individual, detached from his own party in the mélée and confusion, has been driven into the enclosure with an unbroken herd, I have seen him repulsed in every attempt to take refuge among them, and driven off by heavy blows with their trunks as often as he attempted to in- sinuate himself within the circle which they had formed for common security. There can be no reasonable doubt that this jealous and exclusive policy not only contributes to produce, but mainly serves to perpetuate, the class of solitary elephants which are known by the term goondahs in India, and which from their vicious propensities and predatory habits are called Hora, or Rogues, in Ceylon.?

977

The emotional temper, or rather transformation of emotional psychology, which is exhibited by the Rogues. here mentioned, is as extraordinary as it is notorious. From being a peaceable, sympathetic, and magnanimous animal, the elephant, when excluded from the socicty of its kind, becomes savage, cruel, and morose to a degree un- equalled in any other animal. The repulsive accounts of the bloodthirsty rage and wanton destructiveness of Rogues show that their actions are not due to sudden bursts of fury at the sight of man or his works, but rather to a

978

deliberate and brooding resolve to wage war on everything, so that the animal patiently lies in wait for travellers, rushing from his ambush only when he finds that the latter are within his power. As showing the cold-blooded determination of this murderous desire, I may quote the following case, as it was communicated to Sir E. ‘Tennent :— brute where it had been seen half an hour before; but no sooner had one of our men, who was walking foremost, seen the animal at the distance of some fifteen or twenty fathoms, than he ex- claimed, ‘There! there!’ and immediately took to his heels, and we all followed his example. The elephant did not see us until we had run some fifteen or twenty paces from the spot where we turned, when he gave us chase, screaming frightfully as he came on. The Englishman managed to climb a tree, and the rest of my companions did the same; as for myself, I could not, although I made one or two superhuman efforts. But there was no time to be lost. The elephant was running at me with his trunk bent down in a curve towards the ground. At this critical moment Mr. Lindsay held out his foot to me, with the help of which and then of the branches of the tree, which were three or four feet above my head, I managed to scramble up to a branch. The elephant came directly to the tree and attempted to force it down, which he could not. He first coiled his trunk ~ round the stem, and pulled it with all his might, but with no effect. He then applied his head to the tree, and pushed for several minutes, but with no better success. He then trampled with his feet all the projecting roots, moving, as he did so, several times round and round the tree. Lastly, failing in all this, and seeing a pile of timber, which I had lately cut, at a short dis- tance from us, he removed it all (thirty-six pieces) one at a time to the root of the tree, and piled them up in a regular business- like manner ; then placing his hind feet on this pile, he raised ‘the fore part of his body, and reached out his trunk, but still he could not touch us, as we were too far above him. The English- man then fired, and the ball took effect somewhere on the elephant’s head, but did not kill him. It made him only the more furious.

979

The next shot, however, levelled him to the ground, [afterwards brought the skull of the animal to Colombo, and it is still to be seen at the house of Mr. Armitage.' Another highly curious trait in the emotional psycho- logy of the elephant is the readiness with which the huge animal expires under the mere influence of what the natives call a ‘broken heart.’ The facts on this head are without a parallel in any other animal, and are the more remarkable from the fact that, so far as natural length of life is any token, the elephant may be said to have more vitality, or innate power of living, than any other terres- trial mammal. Again, to quote from Sir E. Tennent :—

980

Amongst the last of the elephants noosed was the rogue. Though far more savage than the others, he joined in none of: their charges and assaults on the fences, as they uniformly drove him off, and would not permit him to enter their circle. When dragged past another of his companions in misfortune, who was lying exhausted on the ground, he flew upon him and attempted to fasten his teeth in his head; this was the only instance of viciousness which occurred during the progress of the corral. When tied up and overpowered, he was at first noisy and violent, but soon lay down peacefully, a sign, according to the hunters, that his death was at hand. Their prognostication was correct ; he continued for about twelve hours to cover himself with dust like the others, and to moisten it with water from his trunk ; but at length he lay exhausted, and died so calmly, that having been moving but a few moments before, his death was only per- ceived by the myriads of black flies by which his body was almost instantly covered, although not one was visible a moment before.!

981

But this peculiarity is not confined to rogue elephants. Thus Captain Yule, in his ‘Narrative of an Embassy to Ava in 1855,’ records an illustration of this tendency of the elephant to sudden death. One newly captured, the process of taming which was exhibited to the British Envoy, ‘ made vigorous resistance to the placing of a collar on its neck, and the people were proceeding to tighten it, when the elephant, which had lain down as if quite ex- hausted, reared suddenly on the hind quarters, and fell on its side—dead !’

982

Mr. Strachan noticed the same liability of the ele- phants to sudden death from very slight causes. ‘Of the fall,’ he says, ‘at any time, though on plain ground, they — great weight occasioning them so much hurt by the fall’! _ And Sir E. Tennent observes that,— In the process of taming, the presence of the tame ones can — generally be dispensed with after two months, and the captive — may then be ridden by the driver alone; and after three or four monthshe may be entrusted with labour, so far as regards docility; but it is undesirable, and even involves the risk of life, to work an elephant too soon ; it has frequently happened that a valu- able animal has lain down and died the first time it was tried in harness, from what the natives believed to be ‘ broken heart,’ certainly without any cause inferable from injury or previous disease.”

983

Nor is this tendency to die under the influence of mere emotion restricted to the effect of a *‘ broken heart ;” it seems also to occur under the power of strong emo- tional disturbances of other kinds. For instance, an elephant caught and trained by Mr. Cripps is thus alluded to by Sir E. Tennent :— This was the largest elephant that had been tamed in Ceylon ; he measured upwards of nine feet at the shoulders, and belonged to the caste so highly prized for the temples. He was gentle after his first capture, but his removal from the corral to the stables, though only a distance of six miles, was a matter of the extremest difficulty ; his extraordinary strength rendering him more than a match for the attendant decoys. He on one occasion escaped, but was recaptured in the forest; and he afterwards became so docile as to perform a variety of tricks. He was at length ordered to be removed to Colombo; but such was his terror on approaching the fort, that on coaxing him to enter the gate he became paralysed in the extraordinary way elsewhere alluded to, and died on the spot.

984

The higher mental faculties of the elephant are more advanced in their development than in any other animal, except the dog and monkey. I shall, therefore, devote some considerable space to the narration of instances of its display. The general fact that elephants are habitually employed in certain parts of India for the purposes of building, storing timber, &c., in itself shows a level of docile intelligence which only that of the dog can rival; but I shall here confine myself to stating special instances of the display of sagacity unusually high, even for the elephant.

985

Capt. Shipp, in his ‘Memoirs,’ gives the following incident, of which he was an eye-witness. During a march with guns in the mountainous districts of India, the force of which he was a member came to a steep ascent. <A staircase of logs was prepared to enable the elephants to ascend the slope. When all was ready the first elephant was led to the bottom of the staircase :-— He looked up, shook his head, and when forced by his driver, roared piteously. There can be no question, in my opinion, but that this sagacious animal was competent instinc- tively to judge of the practicability of the artificial flight of steps thus constructed; for the moment some little alteration had been made, he seemed willing to approach. He then com- menced his examination and scrutiny by pressing with his © trunk the trees that had been thrown across; and after this he put his fore-leg on with great caution. . . . The next step for him to ascend by was a projecting rock, which he could not remove. Here the same sagacious examination took place, the elephant keeping his flat side close to the side of the trunk, and leaning against it. The next step was against a tree, but this, on the first pressure of his trunk, he did not like. Here the driver made use of the most endearing epithets, such as * Wonderful,’ ‘ My life,’ ‘ Well done, my dear,’ ‘ My dove,’ ‘ My son,’ ‘My wife ;’ but all these endearing appellations, of which elephants are so fond, would not induce him to try again. Force was at length resorted to, and the elephant roared terri- fically, hut would not move.

986

Something was then altered, the elephant was satisfied, and at last succeeded in mounting to the top of the stair- Case :— ! On reaching the top his delight was visible in a most eminent degree ; he caressed his keepers, and threw dirt about in a most playful manner. Another elephant, a much younger animal, had now to follow. He had watched the ascent of the other with the utmost interest, making motions all the while as though he was assisting him by shouldering him up the acclivity, in such gestures as I have seen some men make when spectators of gymnastic exercises. "When he saw his comrade up, he evinced his pleasure by giving a salute something like the sound of a trumpet. When called upon to take his turn, however, he seemed much alarmed, and would not act at all without force. —

987

After a performance similar to that of the previous elephant, however, he too neared the top, when ‘the other, who had already performed his task, extended his trunk to the assistance of his brother in distress, round - which the younger animal entwined his, and thus reached the summit.’ There was then a cordial greeting between the two animals, ‘as if they had been long separated from each other, and had just escaped from some perilous achievement. They mutually embraced each other, and stood face to face for a considerable time, as if whispering congratulations.’ !

988

Mr. Jesse says: ‘I was one day feeding the poor elephant (who was so barbarously put to death at Exeter Change) with potatoes, which he took out of my hand. One of them, a round one, fell on the floor, just out of reach of his proboscis.’ After several ineffectual attempts to reach it, ‘he at length blew the potato against the opposite wall with sufficient force to make it rebound, and he then without difficulty secured it.’ ? This remarkable observation has fortunately been cor- roborated by Mr. Darwin. He writes :—

989

I have seen, as I dare say have others, that when a small object is thrown on the ground beyond the reach of one of the elephants at the Zoological Gardens, he blows through his trunk on the ground beyond the object, so that the current reflected on all sides may drive the object within his reach.® The observation has also been corroborated by other observers.* Of the elephant’s sense and judgment the following instance is given as a well-known fact in a letter of Dr. Daniel Wilson, Bishop of Calcutta, to his son in England, printed in a Life of the bishop, published a few years ago. An elephant belonging to an Engineer officer in his diocese had a disease in his eyes, and had for three days been completely blind. His owner asked Dr. Webb, a physician intimate with the bishop, if he could do anything for the relief of the animal. Dr. Webb replied that he was willing to try, on one of the eyes, the effect of nitrate of silver, which was a remedy commonly used for

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.