Control experiments and the logic of testing for stimulus specificity
A control experiment repeats a test with the suspected cause removed or replaced. The result shows whether an effect belongs to the stimulus or to something that came with it. The device runs from Darwin's plant work (1875–1880) to modern regeneration and slime-mould studies. It is how a claim of stimulus specificity is checked.138
- Earliest held
- 1875, Darwin, C.
- Most discussed in
- Relation between learning process and…, 2023
- In the library
- 66 passages in 37 works
- Rewritten
- 2026-11-14
Darwin's plant controls
Darwin (1875) used control experiments in Insectivorous Plants, for example with sugar and gum solutions and with chondrin. He first applied solutions of white sugar and of gum, one part to 218 of water, to see whether they changed the glands.1 He also had to ask whether cutting off the summits of the bladders affected the glands. He examined four, one after 2 hrs. 30 m. and three after 23 hrs., and found no marked change.1 For chondrin he left small cubes in water for four days as a control, and they retained their angles.2 In The Power of Movement (1880), unvarnished transparent tubes did not prevent cotyledons bending towards the light, which separated the tube from the varnish.3
Controls in physiology and embryology
Verworn (1899) described plasmodia creeping up a strip and onto the surface of water. He wrote that proper control-experiments showed with certainty that only the streaming water afforded the stimulus.4 Bose (1902) tested anaesthetics and poisons on plants using two groups of stalks, exactly similar. One group absorbed chloroform-water. The second was placed simply in water to serve as the control.5 Loeb (1912) ran controls with each artificial-development experiment. Unfertilized eggs kept in the same normal sea-water formed no membrane and showed no development. A few did divide into two cells after about twenty-four hours.6
Controls in modern network studies
Lobo and Levin (2015) ran a control in silico. With no perturbation the model worm regenerated the correct head-trunk-tail pattern. With β-catenin blocked, the same network predicted a double-head worm, which matched the phenotype seen in vivo.7 Pietak and colleagues (2019) injected VenusGFP dsRNA as a control into planaria. It produced no phenotype different from uninjected worms, with 20 replicates per group.8 Yoneoka and Takamatsu (2023) found that a speed reduction seen in a control was not always reproduced, since half of eight sets differed. Because speed depended on the conditions on the day, they normalized it to the control run on the same date.9
As a control experiment solutions of one part of white sugar and of one part of gum to 218 of water were first used, to see whether these produced any change in the glands.
Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 888The undried jelly was next tried, and as a control experi- ment small cubes were left in water for four days and retained their angles.
Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 246As a control experiment, similar unvarnished and _ trans- parent tubes were tried, and they did not prevent the cotyledons bending towards the light.
Darwin, C., 1880 · The Power of Movement in Plants · open at passage 900By proper control-experiments it was possible to determine with certainty that it was only the streaming water which afforded the stimulus.
Verworn, M., 1899 · General Physiology: An Outline of the Science of Life · open at passage 1120The second group of stalks was placed simply in water, in order to serve for control experiment.
Bose, J. C., 1902 · Response in the Living and Non-Living · open at passage 75Part of the unfertilized eggs were put into the same normal sea-water that was used for the eggs that did develop.
Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 206In the control experiment (Fig 4B), no genetic or pharmacological perturbation was applied to the worm, resulting in the regeneration of the correct head-trunk-tail pattern.
Lobo D, Levin M, 2015 · Inferring regulatory networks from experimental morphological phenotypes: a… · open at passage 15As a control, VenusGFP dsRNA was injected, and displayed no phenotype different from uninjected worms.
Pietak A, Bischof J, LaPalme J, Morokuma J, Levin M, 2019 · Neural control of body-plan axis in regenerating planaria · open at passage 31Therefore, speed was evaluated using values normalized by those of the control experiment of the same date.
Yoneoka E, Takamatsu A, 2023 · Relation between learning process and morphology of transport tube network in… · open at passage 27
| 2023 | Relation between learning process and morphology of transport tube network in… · Yoneoka E, Takamatsu A | 16 |
| 1875 | Insectivorous Plants · Darwin, C. | 6 |
| 1912 | The Mechanistic Conception of Life · Loeb, J. | 3 |
| 2015 | Bioelectric patterning during oogenesis: stage-specific distribution of… · Krüger J, Bohrmann J | 3 |
| 2024 | Stress sharing as cognitive glue for collective intelligences: A computational… · Shreesha L, Levin M | 2 |
| 2020 | An in vivo brain-bacteria interface: the developing brain as a key regulator of… · Herrera-Rincon C, Paré JF, Martyniuk… | 2 |
| 2016 | Formin Is Associated with Left-Right Asymmetry in the Pond Snail and the Frog · Davison A, McDowell GS, Holden JM… | 2 |
| 1880 | The Power of Movement in Plants · Darwin, C. | 2 |
| 2014 | Reinstatement of long-term memory following erasure of its behavioral and… · Chen S, Cai D, Pearce K, Sun PY… | 2 |
| 2014 | Light as stress factor to plant roots - case of root halotropism · Yokawa K, Fasano R, Kagenishi T… | 1 |