Minds of small things  ·  Article

Filopodia, active perception and tip cell selection (Notch)

Filopodia are actin-rich, finger-like protrusions of the cell membrane. Zakirov and colleagues (2021) asked whether, during blood vessel formation, filopodia are a form of active perception, a feedback between movement and sensing. They report that filopodia speed up collective endothelial decisions, including the choice of the tip cell through Notch lateral inhibition.23 They ask whether this counts as a basal cognitive function.4

Earliest held
1926, Crile, G. W.
Most discussed in
Active perception during angiogenesis…, 2021
In the library
122 passages in 31 works
Rewritten
2026-10-24
01

The tip cell problem

Zakirov and colleagues (2021) began with a question about tissue morphogenesis: how do cells make efficient collective decisions? They note that humans and other organisms use sensorimotor coordination, also called active perception, to inform behaviour. They state that it had not before been investigated at a cellular level within organs.2 Their case is tip cell selection, a time-constrained step in blood vessel formation, or angiogenesis. They describe their work as a proof of concept combining simulation with live imaging of intersegmental vessel growth in zebrafish. They report that simulation predictions were validated in vivo.2

02

A bistable switch

Further simulation studies led Zakirov and colleagues to a mechanism. They attribute the effect to coupled positive feedback between movement and sensing on filopodia. Further simulation studies indicate that this feedback confers a bistable, switch-like property on Notch lateral inhibition. In their account, it ensures that tip selection is rapid and robust.3 The authors frame the finding as filopodia speeding up a decision.2

03

Notch and bioelectric signals

Work on bioelectricity also discusses Notch. George and Bates (2022) describe Notch as a conserved pathway. Its ligands are transmembrane proteins, so it acts as a short-range signal.5 In HEK293 cells and myocytes, raised Notch signalling was associated with more cytosolic calcium and less potassium flux. They suggest that Notch signalling may both regulate and be regulated by ion channel function.6 Monteiro and colleagues (2014) cite earlier work showing that the V-ATPase proton pump is essential for activation of Wnt, JNK and Notch signalling, by regulating endosomal pH.1

04

Open questions

Zakirov and colleagues state the larger question directly. They ask whether filopodia are a form of active perception, akin to a basal cognitive function that lets endothelial cells adapt to changing local conditions by deciding faster and more efficiently.4 O'Hara-Wright and colleagues (2022) note that bioelectric signals are reported to influence angiogenesis, citing other work such as Wei et al. 2020.7 Iorio and colleagues (2024) note that Myo10 is needed for both filopodia and tunneling nanotube formation.8

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. The same H+ pump is essential for activation of Wnt, JNK and Notch signalling, by regulating endosomal pHMonteiro J, Aires R, Becker JD, Jacinto A, Certal AC…, 2014 · V-ATPase proton pumping activity is required for adult zebrafish appendage… · open at passage 4
  2. filopodia (actin-rich, dynamic, finger-like cell membrane protrusions) play an unexpected role in speeding up collective endothelial decisionsZakirov B, Charalambous G, Thuret R, Aspalter IM…, 2021 · Active perception during angiogenesis: filopodia speed up Notch selection of… · open at passage 0
  3. the effect is due to the coupled positive feedback between movement and sensing on filopodia conferring a bistable switch-like property to Notch lateral inhibitionZakirov B, Charalambous G, Thuret R, Aspalter IM…, 2021 · Active perception during angiogenesis: filopodia speed up Notch selection of… · open at passage 0
  4. Are they akin to a basal cognitive function exploiting sensorimotor coordination to enable endothelial cells to adapt their function to the changing local environmental conditionsZakirov B, Charalambous G, Thuret R, Aspalter IM…, 2021 · Active perception during angiogenesis: filopodia speed up Notch selection of… · open at passage 46
  5. The ligands in the Notch pathway are transmembrane proteins rather than secreted ones and thus Notch signaling acts as a short range signalGeorge LF, Bates EA, 2022 · Mechanisms Underlying Influence of Bioelectricity in Development · open at passage 40
  6. These results suggest that Notch signaling may both regulate and be regulated by ion channel function.George LF, Bates EA, 2022 · Mechanisms Underlying Influence of Bioelectricity in Development · open at passage 42
  7. Bioelectric signals are reported to influence angiogenesis, the formation of blood vessels within existing vasculature.O'Hara-Wright M, Mobini S, Gonzalez-Cordero A, 2022 · Bioelectric Potential in Next-Generation Organoids: Electrical Stimulation to… · open at passage 50
  8. Myo10 is an unconventional myosin that has critical functions in TNTs and filopodia formationIorio R, Petricca S, Mattei V, Delle Monache S, 2024 · Horizontal mitochondrial transfer as a novel bioenergetic tool for mesenchymal… · open at passage 29
Linked ideas
Basal cognitionpart of / contains
Zakirov and colleagues ask whether filopodia-based decisions are a basal cognitive function.
Tip cell selection is a collective decision made by cells without neurons, using movement and sensing.
Monteiro and colleagues cite work showing the V-ATPase is needed for Notch activation through endosomal pH.
George and Bates link Notch signalling to potassium and calcium channel activity in both directions.
Myo10 acts in both filopodia and tunneling nanotube formation, though the mechanisms may differ.
Bistable switching is the property Zakirov and colleagues credit for fast, robust tip cell choice.
Zakirov and colleagues' account of how filopodia speed up Notch-based tip cell selection.
The detailed case of filopodia speeding Notch-based tip cell selection, which this article uses as its main example.
The memAgent-spring model is the platform behind that article's account of filopodia and tip cell selection.
Where it is discussedPassages matching active perception, filopodia, tip cell selection, Notch signalling
2021Active perception during angiogenesis: filopodia speed up Notch selection of… · Zakirov B, Charalambous G, Thuret R…70
2022Mechanisms Underlying Influence of Bioelectricity in Development · George LF, Bates EA7
2024Horizontal mitochondrial transfer as a novel bioenergetic tool for mesenchymal… · Iorio R, Petricca S, Mattei V, Delle…5
2022Bioelectric Dysregulation in Cancer Initiation, Promotion, and Progression · Sheth M, Esfandiari L3
2015Cancer as a channelopathy: ion channels and pumps in tumor development and… · Litan A, Langhans SA3
2013Membrane potential and cancer progression · Yang M, Brackenbury WJ2
2012Developing neurons form transient nanotubes facilitating electrical coupling… · Wang X, Bukoreshtliev NV, Gerdes HH2
2021Extracellular Matrix Signals as Drivers of Mitochondrial Bioenergetics and… · Urra FA, Fuentes-Retamal S, Palominos…2
2017Studying Electrotaxis in Microfluidic Devices · Sun YS2
2019Inherency of Form and Function in Animal Development and Evolution · Newman SA2