Bioenergetics  ·  Article

Half-of-the-sites asymmetry and steric block of Rieske domain in the complex III dimer

In the bovine respirasome, the two Rieske iron-sulfur domains of the complex III dimer do not look alike. Sousa and colleagues resolved only one and read it as immobile and unable to transfer electrons.3 The other, unresolved and so mobile, forms the active monomer. They argued this directs electrons from complex I to complex IV.4 Other structures and a subunit count leave the picture unsettled.57

Earliest held
2008, Friston K
Most discussed in
Functional asymmetry and electron flow in the…, 2016
In the library
27 passages in 9 works
Rewritten
2026-11-15
01

Respirasome background

Native gel electrophoresis, developed in the 1990s, revealed large supercomplexes of complexes I, III and IV. Caruana and Stroud report that the assembly with one complex I, the complex III dimer and one complex IV is typically the most abundant, and so is treated as the base functional unit.8 They list proposed roles such as channelling of CoQ and cytochrome c, stability and protection from ROS. They note that the channelling advantage, though most often cited, is disputed on structural and biochemical evidence.9 The asymmetry of the complex III dimer is argued within this setting.

02

The bovine structure

Sousa, Mills, Vonck and Kühlbrandt (2016) determined the cryo-EM structure of the bovine heart supercomplex I1III2IV1. Only one of the two Rieske domains in the complex III dimer was resolved. They took this to mean that domain is immobile and cannot transfer electrons.3 The active monomer sits centrally between complexes I and IV. The authors said this is optimal for taking reduced quinone from complex I over a short diffusion distance of 11 nm.4 They offered the asymmetry as evidence for directed electron flow through the active monomer.3

03

Competing structures and models

The bovine result was not matched in other species. Sousa and colleagues note that both Rieske domains were resolved in porcine and ovine respirasomes, while one was disordered in the bovine one.5 They discuss a proposal by Letts and colleagues that the outer monomer's Rieske domain is blocked by its closeness to complex IV. Sousa and colleagues call this consistent with their findings. Separately, a re-analysis of X-ray structures proposed that the dimer holds only a single UQCRFS1N fragment. Caruana and Stroud say its implications need further structural work.7

04

Same phrase elsewhere

The phrase functional asymmetry is also used in unrelated fields such as neuroscience and developmental biology. Friston (2008) uses it for forward and backward connections in the brain, which may reflect distinct roles in recognition.1 Pai and colleagues (2012) cite earlier planarian work in which the right eye was more sensitive than the left to H,K-ATPase inhibition. Their own finding is that in Xenopus embryos, cells on the right side of the midline hyperpolarize first in the eye field.2 These uses do not concern the complex III dimer.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. Functional asymmetries in forwards (linear) and backwards (nonlinear) connections may reflect their distinct roles in recognitionFriston K, 2008 · Hierarchical models in the brain · open at passage 89
  2. the right eye was significantly more sensitive to inhibition of the H, K-ATPase ion pump than the left, in terms of frequency of induced patterning defectsPai VP, Vandenberg LN, Blackiston D, Levin M, 2012 · Neurally Derived Tissues in Xenopus laevis Embryos Exhibit a Consistent… · open at passage 7
  3. Of the two Rieske iron-sulfur cluster domains in the complex III dimer, one is resolved, indicating that this domain is immobile and unable to transfer electrons.Sousa JS, Mills DJ, Vonck J, Kühlbrandt W, 2016 · Functional asymmetry and electron flow in the bovine respirasome · open at passage 0
  4. The central position of the active complex III monomer between complex I and IV in the respirasome is optimal for accepting reduced quinone from complex I over a short diffusion distance of 11 nmSousa JS, Mills DJ, Vonck J, Kühlbrandt W, 2016 · Functional asymmetry and electron flow in the bovine respirasome · open at passage 0
  5. Surprisingly, the two iron-sulfur domains in the complex III dimer are both resolved in the porcine and ovine respirasome, whereas one of them is disordered in our structure of the bovine complex.Sousa JS, Mills DJ, Vonck J, Kühlbrandt W, 2016 · Functional asymmetry and electron flow in the bovine respirasome · open at passage 30
  6. neither structure shows any direct protein-protein contacts that would inhibit domain movements.Sousa JS, Mills DJ, Vonck J, Kühlbrandt W, 2016 · Functional asymmetry and electron flow in the bovine respirasome · open at passage 30
  7. suggest based on re-analysis of high-resolution X-ray structures [51,52] that the Complex III dimer contains only a single UQCRFS1N fragment [53].Caruana NJ, Stroud DA, 2020 · The road to the structure of the mitochondrial respiratory chain supercomplex · open at passage 8
  8. The supercomplex containing a single unit of Complex I, the Complex III dimer and a single unit of Complex IV (CI/III2/IV) is typically the most abundant assembly observed using native electrophoresis techniquesCaruana NJ, Stroud DA, 2020 · The road to the structure of the mitochondrial respiratory chain supercomplex · open at passage 13
  9. Though the bioenergetic advantage conferred by substrate channelling [75–77], is arguably the most often cited of proposed functions, the concept is disputed based on both structural and biochemical evidenceCaruana NJ, Stroud DA, 2020 · The road to the structure of the mitochondrial respiratory chain supercomplex · open at passage 13
Linked ideas
The mobility of the Rieske domain is the property that distinguishes the active from the inactive monomer in this asymmetry.
The asymmetry was read from cryo-EM maps of the respirasome, where resolved versus disordered domains were compared.
Complex III's quinone chemistry is the reaction that the active monomer is proposed to carry out.
Directed flow through one monomer bears on the disputed claim that supercomplexes channel substrates.
A short 11 nm quinone path favours channelling, while Caruana and Stroud note the channelling idea is contested.
Another case of consistent asymmetry between paired parts, though in embryos and regenerating planarians rather than enzymes.
Both are respirasome (I1III2IV1) components: the passages place complex I beside the complex III dimer, whose active monomer takes quinol from complex I. Open/closed states and inhibitors go unmentioned.
Oxidative phosphorylationpart of / contains
B is a mechanistic detail within A: in the bovine respirasome only one Rieske domain of complex III is mobile, supporting directed electron flow from complex I through III to IV.
Where it is discussedPassages matching functional asymmetry, complex III dimer, Rieske iron-sulfur domain disordered, outer monomer of complex III
2016Functional asymmetry and electron flow in the bovine respirasome · Sousa JS, Mills DJ, Vonck J, Kühlbrandt…9
2012Neurally Derived Tissues in Xenopus laevis Embryos Exhibit a Consistent… · Pai VP, Vandenberg LN, Blackiston D…4
2020The road to the structure of the mitochondrial respiratory chain supercomplex · Caruana NJ, Stroud DA4
2017Predicting green: really radical (plant) predictive processing · Calvo P, Friston K4
2008Hierarchical models in the brain · Friston K2
2015Structure and function of mitochondrial membrane protein complexes · Kühlbrandt W1
2016"Feature Detection" vs. "Predictive Coding" Models of Plant Behavior · Calvo P, Baluška F, Sims A1
2021Structure and Mechanism of Respiratory III-IV Supercomplexes in Bioenergetic… · Brzezinski P, Moe A, Ädelroth P1
2018The anticipating brain is not a scientist: the free-energy principle from an… · Bruineberg J, Kiverstein J, Rietveld E1