Minds of small things  ·  Article

Sensitization and mechanical triggering of immersed leaves (brushing)

Darwin describes brushing trials in Insectivorous Plants (1875). He immersed leaves in a solution and, when they showed no inflection, brushed them. One leaf moved within minutes and shut completely. Another was strongly inflected in 4 minutes. One did not move for an hour.

Earliest held
1859, Darwin
Most discussed in
Insectivorous Plants, 1875
In the library
41 passages in 8 works
Rewritten
2026-11-14
01

Darwin's brushing trials

Darwin described three leaves in Insectivorous Plants. A large old leaf had been immersed for 10 minutes and did not look likely to be inflected soon. He brushed it. It began to move in 2 minutes and was completely shut in 3.1 A second leaf was brushed after 15 minutes of immersion and was strongly inflected in 4 minutes. A third was brushed after 17 minutes and did not move for an hour, which Darwin called a failure.2 He brushed it again, and in 9 minutes a few tentacles became inflected. He judged the failure not complete.3

02

Variation between leaves

Darwin's account of a camphor solution shows a similar spread in response. Of ten leaves immersed, five were well inflected after 15 minutes. Two of these showed a first trace of movement at 11 and 12 minutes.4 The last three leaves were old and very dark red. They were not inflected after 24 hours of immersion. Darwin concluded that such leaves should be avoided in camphor experiments.5 In the brushing trials, by contrast, a large old leaf responded quickly when brushed.

03

Other immersion experiments

Darwin used immersion for other questions too, and these are not brushing tests. In the Origin (1859), he reported experiments, made with Mr. Berkeley's aid, on how far seeds could resist sea-water. Of 87 kinds, 64 germinated after 28 days of immersion, and a few survived 137 days.6 In The Power of Movement in Plants (1880), he immersed leaves with motionless leaflets in cold water and raised it slowly to 103° F. The leaflets then moved quickly and described about a dozen small irregular circles in 40 minutes.7 That result concerns temperature, not touch.

04

Limits of the record

Darwin gives no measurement of the brushing itself. He does not say how hard he brushed or why brushing worked. Hertel (1904) found that Paramecium reacts to powerful ultraviolet light, and Jennings (1906) reports Hertel's result. Paramecia in a lighted region of a drop moved about rapidly, and Jennings read this as the usual avoiding reaction. He adds that Hertel did not observe the details of the movement.8

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. To my surprise I found that out of 87 kinds, 64 germinated after an immersion of 28 days, and a few survived an immersion of 137 days.Darwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 622
  2. A largo old leaf, after being immersed for 10 m. in the solution, did not appear likely to be soon inflected ; so I brushed it, and in 2 m. it began to move, and in 3 m. was completely shut.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 483
  3. A third leaf, after an immersion of 17 m., likewise showed no signs of in- flection ; it was then brushed, but did not move for 1 hr. ; so that here was a failure.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 483
  4. It was again brushed, and now in 9 m. a few tentacles became inflected ; the failure therefore was not complete.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 483
  5. Ten leaves were immersed in this solution ; after 15 m. five of them were well inflected, two showing a first trace of movement in 11 m. and 12 m.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 480
  6. The eighth, ninth, and tenth leaves were old and of a very dark red colour, and these were not inflected after an immersion of 24 hrs.; so that in making experiments with camphor it is necessary to avoid such leaves.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 480
  7. immersing leaves with motionless leaflets in cold water, which was slowly raised to 103° F., and the leaflets then moved quickly, describing about a dozen little irregular circles in 40m.Darwin, C., 1880 · The Power of Movement in Plants · open at passage 725
  8. When part of a drop of water containing Paramecia was subjected to this light, the animals in the lighted region at once began to move about rapidly.Jennings, H. S., 1906 · Behavior of the Lower Organisms · open at passage 214
Linked ideas
Inflection of tentacles is the response Darwin watched for after immersion and again after brushing.
Repeated brushing of the failed leaf, which moved only on the second try, bears on thresholds and repeated touch.
The immersion solutions that set up the brushing trials belong to Darwin's wider tests of chemical stimulation.
Brushing is a contact stimulus, so the response to touch sits in the same family of contact effects.
Different leaves moved after different delays, which raises the question of how response relates to stimulus strength.
Darwin's heated-water test on leaflets is another case of an external agent changing leaf movement.
Where it is discussedPassages matching brushed, and in, after an immersion of, began to move, completely shut
1875Insectivorous Plants · Darwin, C.28
1880The Power of Movement in Plants · Darwin, C.4
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.2
1906Behavior of the Lower Organisms · Jennings, H. S.2
1859On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · Darwin2
1911The Mechanism of Life · Leduc, S.1
1906Plant Response as a Means of Physiological Investigation · Bose, J. C.1
1957An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine · Bernard, C.1