Morphogenesis and form  ·  Article

Position-dependent transformation of branches into roots

Heteromorphosis is the name Jacques Loeb gave to one organ being substituted for another5. In the hydroid Antennularia, a cut piece of stem laid horizontally grew roots from branches on its lower side6. The case matters because the same kind of branch became a branch or a root depending on where the piece lay7. Morgan wrote that how gravity acts remained undetermined2.

Earliest held
1896, Wilson, E. B.
Most discussed in
The Mechanistic Conception of Life, 1912
In the library
74 passages in 10 works
Rewritten
2026-11-09
01

Loeb's observations

Loeb's account was first given in lectures at Woods Hole in 1893 and reprinted in his 1912 book. A piece of Antennularia hung vertically formed roots at its lower end and a new stem at its upper end, which restored the old arrangement of organs4. Loeb reported that parts growing obliquely upward bore polyps on their upper side. He concluded that a root could replace a stem and an apex could replace a root, and he called this heteromorphosis5. Laid horizontally, a piece sent its lower branches straight down, and these were roots, not branches6. Wilson's 1896 bibliography lists Loeb's 1891 work on heteromorphosis1.

02

Gravity and posture

Loeb's 1906 book treated Antennularia as an animal that behaves toward gravitation like a geotropic plant. A stem placed obliquely in the aquarium bent its tip until it was vertical again, then kept growing upward3. Morgan, in his 1901 book, reported that pieces fixed to a rotating wheel gave negative results, with neither roots nor stems appearing. He thought rubbing against the water or agitation probably prevented regeneration. On the cause, he said gravity's action was not yet determined. His only suggestion was a rearrangement of the lighter and heavier parts of the tissues2.

03

Later restatement

Loeb repeated the experiment in his 1916 book. A piece cut from the stem and put in the water horizontally could form new stems on its upper side7. The small branches on the under side began to grow vertically downward. In appearance and function they differed from normal branches, and Loeb called them roots8. Child's 1921 index lists heteromorphosis as a normal axial feature of hydroid development. It lists axial heteromorphosis in Tubularia and Planaria as well9.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. Loeb, J. — Untersuchungen zur physiologischen Morphologie : I. Heteromorphosis. Wurzburg, 1891.Wilson, E. B., 1896 · The Cell in Development and Inheritance · open at passage 1020
  2. How gravity acts on antennularia has not as yet been determined. The only suggestion that we can offer at present is that it brings about a rearrangement of the lighter and heavier parts of the tissues.Morgan, T. H., 1901 · Regeneration · open at passage 84
  3. When the stem of Antennularia antennina, which normally grows vertically upward, is put into an oblique position in the aqua- rium, the tip bends until it is again in a vertical positionLoeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 399
  4. The old normal arrangement of organs is thus restored through the process of regeneration.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 141
  5. obliquely upward bore polyps on their upper side. From this we see that it was possible to substitute a root for a stem and an apex for a root. This phenomenon of the substitution of one organ for another I termed heteromorphosis.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 145
  6. the branches on the lower side suddenly began to grow vertically downward, and these downward growing elements were no longer branches but roots (Fig. 25).Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 145
  7. If we cut a piece a b (Fig. 37), from the stem ss oi Antennularia antennina (Fig. 38), a hydroid, and put it into the water in a horizontal position, new stems cd (Fig. 37) may arise on its upper side.Loeb, J., 1916 · The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · open at passage 308
  8. In appearance and function these downward-growing elements are entirely different from the branches of the normal Antennularia; they are roots.Loeb, J., 1916 · The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · open at passage 308
  9. Heteromorphosis: axial, as normal feature of hydroid development, 34; axial, in Tubularia, 123; axial, in Planaria, 126Child, C. M., 1921 · The Origin and Development of the Nervous System · open at passage 455
Linked ideas
Regenerationpart of / contains
The horizontal-piece experiment is a regeneration experiment: cut pieces form roots and stems, and Loeb's vertical case restores the normal arrangement.
Loeb compared Antennularia's upward bending of an oblique stem to the behaviour of a geotropic plant.
Polarityrelated to
Child's index links hydroid heteromorphosis to the origin of new polarity and to axial features of development.
Child's index lists reversal of gradient in hydroid development next to axial heteromorphosis in hydroids, Tubularia and Planaria.
Loeb's 1906 contents pair heteromorphosis with regeneration in Tubularia, another hydroid.
Both are regeneration cases where position decides what forms: new head only at the anterior nerve-cord end in earthworms; branches become roots or stems by position in Antennularia. Passages don't link them directly.
Determinism in physiologypart of / contains
Loeb's Antennularia experiments, where stems arise from upper cut ends and roots from lower ends under gravity, exemplify determinism: experimenters find and test definite conditions governing regeneration.
Both concern regeneration and heteromorphosis in lower animals, where form depends on position/gradient (Child on hydroids and Planaria; Antennularia cited). Passages don't directly link planarian memory to branch-to-root transformation.
Contact with the ground or with water decides whether root or polyp forms, in Loeb's reading of hydroid development.
Where it is discussedPassages matching stem placed in changed position, lateral branches transformed into roots, polyps on upper side, heteromorphosis
1912The Mechanistic Conception of Life · Loeb, J.22
1901Regeneration · Morgan, T. H.20
1906The Dynamics of Living Matter · Loeb, J.11
1916The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · Loeb, J.7
1921The Origin and Development of the Nervous System · Child, C. M.4
1924Physiological Foundations of Behavior · Child, C. M.4
1918Forced Movements, Tropisms, and Animal Conduct · Loeb, J.2
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.2
1896The Cell in Development and Inheritance · Wilson, E. B.1
1906Behavior of the Lower Organisms · Jennings, H. S.1