Self-recognition and responses to mirror images
Mirror responses are the reactions of an animal to its own reflection. In Romanes's Animal Intelligence, a monkey and a cat treated reflections as other animals13. James quotes the view that a mirror's surface is still seen behind the glass although no reality corresponds4. Other authors use "mirror image" for body symmetry, and "self-recognition" in plants is disputed8.
- Earliest held
- 1859, Darwin
- Most discussed in
- The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2, 1890
- In the library
- 2,060 passages in 255 works
- Rewritten
- 2026-11-18
Romanes's animal reports
Romanes (1882) reported a monkey that met a mirror placed on the floor and at once took the reflection for a real animal1. The monkey was at first a little afraid, then approached and tried to touch it, and went behind the mirror many times. Romanes contrasted this with a monkey described to him by Prof. Brown Robertson, which became angry. The monkey also appeared to mistake the sex of the image and courted it2. Romanes also relayed a report from Mr. T. B. Groves of a cat that tried to fight its reflection, felt round the glass's edge, and afterwards ignored mirrors3.
James on the mirror
James (1890) used the mirror in an argument about perception. He quotes the view that a mirror's surface continues to be seen behind the glass, although we know that no outward reality corresponds to the appearance4. The author he quotes granted that attention can be withdrawn from sensations with no reference to the outer world, such as weaker after-images. That author then asked what would become of perception if any part that differed from outward experience could be transformed into its opposite. His point concerns how appearances persist against knowledge, not how animals react to reflections.
Mirror images in form
Other authors use the mirror to describe symmetry in bodies. Bateson (1894) described extra appendages whose transverse sections are images of each other in parallel mirrors5. Child (1924) said that situs inversus and mirror imaging in twinning show that the components affect each other or share a common factor6. He added that there was as yet no experimental evidence to analyse these relations. Pai and colleagues (2017) counted mirror image reversal of organ position in Xenopus as heterotaxia when organ patterning was otherwise normal7.
Self-recognition in plants
Pecere (2026) places "self-recognition" among the terms used of plants that rest on an analogy with humans. Taiz and co-authors (2019) protested against what they called a resurgent anthropomorphism. Calvo and Trewavas (2020) replied that this was circular reasoning. Pecere takes the exchange to show the crux of the debate: how far the analogy can meaningfully be extended8.
I placed a mirror upon the floor, and the monkey at once mistook his reflection in it fora real animal.
Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 1237he appeared to mistake the sex of the image, and began in the most indescribably ludicrous manner to pay to it the addresses of courtship.
Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 1237whilst with his head twisted round to the front he assured himself of the per- sistence of the reflection. He never afterwards conde- scended to notice a mirror.
Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 1032a mirror's surface continues to be seen behind the mirror, although wo know that to all these appearances no outward reality corresponds.
James, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 2246Transverse sections of the three appendages taken at homologous points are thus images of each other in parallel mirrors.
Bateson, W., 1894 · Materials for the Study of Variation Treated with Especial Regard to… · open at passage 1451both situs inversus and mirror imaging indicate that the components concerned affect each other or are affected by a common factor.
Child, C. M., 1924 · Physiological Foundations of Behavior · open at passage 435Any instance of mirror image reversal of organ position, in the context of normal organ patterning and normal dorso-anterior index was counted as an instance of heterotaxia.
Pai VP, Willocq V, Pitcairn EJ, Lemire JM, Paré JF, Shi NQ…, 2017 · HCN4 ion channel function is required for early events that regulate anatomical… · open at passage 7Talk of plant “intelligence”, “learning”, “feeling” and “self-recognition” is based on an analogy with humans. The question is: How far can we meaningfully extend the analogy?
Pecere P, 2026 · Plant cognition after Darwin: historical and epistemological remarks · open at passage 51
| 1890 | The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · James, W. | 471 |
| 1907 | Comparative Electro-Physiology: A Physico-Physiological Study · Bose, J. C. | 55 |
| 1906 | The Integrative Action of the Nervous System · Sherrington, C. S. | 54 |
| 1906 | Plant Response as a Means of Physiological Investigation · Bose, J. C. | 54 |
| 1894 | Materials for the Study of Variation Treated with Especial Regard to… · Bateson, W. | 53 |
| 1908 | The Animal Mind: A Textbook of Comparative Psychology · Washburn, M. F. | 51 |
| 1925 | Elements of Physical Biology · Lotka, A. J. | 51 |
| 1915 | Principles of General Physiology · Bayliss, W. M. | 41 |
| 1882 | Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J. | 32 |
| 2019 | Optical estimation of absolute membrane potential using fluorescence lifetime… · Lazzari-Dean JR, Gest AM, Miller EW | 30 |