Minds of small things  ·  Article

Sympathy and cooperation in animals

Sympathy in animals means distress or concern shown by one animal for the pain or capture of another. Romanes collected such reports in 1882 and read them as evidence of sympathy.2 Kropotkin later tied compassion to sociability and the limits it sets on struggle.4 Recent authors treat concern for others as a way an agent's boundary and intelligence can grow.8

Earliest held
1859, Darwin
Most discussed in
Animal Intelligence, 1882
In the library
174 passages in 29 works
Rewritten
2026-11-17
01

Early animal reports

Romanes (Animal Intelligence, 1882) gathered anecdotes. He held that the solicitude of gregarious birds for a wounded or captured fellow is strong evidence of sympathy.2 He cited Jesse on rooks, which stay near a companion shot in a field and cry out instead of fleeing.2 He also repeated Clavigero's account of Mexican hunters who use a captive pelican's cries of distress to draw other pelicans, which then disgorge fish for it.1 A parrot of the Buffon family was said to show sympathy for a servant with a sore finger.3

02

Sociability and struggle

Kropotkin (Mutual Aid, 1902) set sympathy inside a wider argument about sociable animals. He said sociability limits physical struggle and leaves room for better moral feelings.4 He pointed to well-certified cases of compassion between wild animals at liberty and named Perty and Buchner as sources of such cases. His index also records Darwin on compassion among pelicans, next to a long analysis of struggle for life and competition.5 The index entries show where he placed the topic. They do not show what Darwin concluded.

03

Limits on sympathy

James (The Principles of Psychology, 1890) wrote about human sympathy as an instinct that other instincts can block. Fear or disgust can inhibit sympathy, while habits, reasoned reflection, and love or hate may check or reinforce it.6 He added that the hunting and pugnacious instincts can suppress it entirely. Metchnikoff (The Nature of Man, 1903) treated social instinct and human sympathy as nearly the same thing. He warned that sympathy pushed too far may become harmful, and he asked whether it should reach all humanity or only part of it.7

04

Concern as scaling

Doctor, Witkowski, Solomonova, Duane and Levin (2022) argue that adding others' stress to an agent's own stress-reduction goals enlarges its cognitive boundary and scales its intelligence.8 They say this needs only that inward-facing sensors come to face outward. Baluška and Miller (2018) describe human sympathy and bonding as emergent aspects of shared Senomes.9 Doctor and colleagues describe the enlarging of one agent's cognitive boundary. Only Baluška and Miller link shared Senomes to multicellularity and social networks.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. The bird is then tied to a tree, and being both in pain and captivity, it utters cries of distress. Other pelicans are attracted by the criesRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 670
  2. The solicitude which most gregarious birds display when one of their number is wounded or captured, constitutes strong evidence of sympathy.Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 665
  3. The parrot which belonged to the Buffon family showed much sympathy with a female servant to whom it was attached when the girl had a sore fingerRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 670
  4. sympathy is peculiarly liable to inhibition from other instincts which its stimulus may call forth.James, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 2643
  5. Sociability thus puts a limit to physical struggle, and leaves room for the development of better moral feel- ings.Kropotkin, P., 1902 · Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · open at passage 118
  6. compassion among pelicans, 59 ; struggle for life and competition, analysis of this theory, 60-75Kropotkin, P., 1902 · Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · open at passage 606
  7. Sympathy, when pushed too far, may become harmful.Metchnikoff, E., 1903 · The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy · open at passage 234
  8. Social and emotional closeness, sympathy, bonding/friendship of humans are emergent self-similar aspects of shared subject SenomesBaluška F, Miller WB, 2018 · Senomic view of the cell: Senome versus Genome · open at passage 20
  9. the inclusion of others’ stress as a primary goal necessarily increases the cognitive boundary of an individual and scales its intelligence.Doctor T, Witkowski O, Solomonova E, Duane B, Levin M, 2022 · Biology, Buddhism, and AI: Care as the Driver of Intelligence · open at passage 9
Linked ideas
Doctor and colleagues describe concern for others as a widening of the cognitive boundary of the self.
Own-stress reduction is the loop that concern for others is said to extend outward.
Kropotkin argued that sociability and compassion limit struggle, a counterweight to competition-centred readings of Darwin.
Shared concern and social bonding are treated as ways individual agents join into larger cognitive units.
Baluška and Miller place sympathy and bonding among emergent aspects of shared Senomes.
Romanes read animal solicitude as evidence of mental life, a question that criteria of mind address directly.
Kropotkin's mutual aid among ants and the limits of nest loyalty sit beside Romanes' accounts of colonies in opposition.
Where it is discussedPassages matching sympathy, cries of distress, pelican, compassion
1882Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J.45
1890The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · James, W.44
1902Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · Kropotkin, P.22
1880The Power of Movement in Plants · Darwin, C.8
1930The History of Biological Theories · Rádl, E.7
2022Biology, Buddhism, and AI: Care as the Driver of Intelligence · Doctor T, Witkowski O, Solomonova E…5
1894Materials for the Study of Variation Treated with Especial Regard to… · Bateson, W.5
1992On Growth and Form · Thompson, D. A. W.4
1903The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy · Metchnikoff, E.4
1925Elements of Physical Biology · Lotka, A. J.4