Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 1050 to 1079 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

1050

As further instances corroborating the fact that both these faculties are developed in cats to a wonderful degree,. I may add the following. Couch (‘Illustrations of Instinct,’ p. 196) gives a case within his own knowledge of a cat which, in order to get at milk kept in a locked cupboard, used to unlock the door by seating herself on an adjoining table, and ‘repeatedly patting on the bow of the key with her paw, when with a slight pull on the door’ she was able to open it; the lock was old, and the | key turned in it ‘on a very slight impulse.’

1051

As a still further instance of the high appreciation of mechanical appliances to which cats attain, I shall quote an extract from a paper by Mr. Otto, which will have been read at the Linnean Society before this work is pub- half a dozen times, gaining admittance on each occasion by springing’ at the knocker. Lastly, Dr. W. H. Kesteven writes to ‘Nature’ (xx., p. 428) of a cat which used to knock at a knocker to gain admittance, in the way already described of so many other cats; but as showing how much more readily cats acquire this practice than dogs, it is interesting to note that Dr. Kesteven adds that a dog which lived in the same house ascertained that the cat was able to gain admittance by knocking, and yet did not imitate the action, but ‘was in the habit of searching for her when he wanted to come in, and either waiting till she was ready to knock at the door, or inducing her to do it io please him.’

1052

' Consul E. L. Layard gives in Nature (xx., p. 839) a precisely similaz case of a cat habitually and without tuition ringing a bell by pulling at an exposed wire. lished. After describing the case of a cat opening a thumb-latch in the same way as those already mentioned, this writer proceeds :— At Parara, the residence of Parker Bowman, Esq., a full- grown cat was one day accidentally locked up in a room with- - out any other outlet than a small window, moving on hinges, and kept shut by means of a swivel. Not long afterwards the window was found open and the cat gone. This having — happened several times, it was at last found that the cat jumped upon the window-sill, placed her fore-paws as high as she could reach against the side, deliberately reached with one over to the swivel, moved it from its horizontal to a perpendicular posi- tion, and then, leaning with her whole weight against the window, swung it open and escaped.

1053

in this animal, Mr. W. Brown, writing from Greenock to ‘Nature ’ (vol. xxi., p. 397), gives a remarkable story of a cat, the facts in which do not seem to have admitted of _ mal-observation. While a paraffine lamp was being trimmed, some of the oil fell upon the back of the cat, - and was afterwards ignited by a cinder falling upon it from the fire. The cat with her back ‘in a blaze, in an instant made for the door (which happened to be open) and sped up the street about 100 yards,’ where she plunged into the village watering-trough, and extinguished the flame. ‘The trough had eight or nine inches of water, and puss was in the habit of seeing the fire put out with water every night.’ The latter point is important, as it shows the data of observation on which the animal rea- soned.

1054

THE general psychology of these animals is, of course, very much the same as that of the dog; but, from never having been submitted to the influences of domestication, their mental qualities present a sufficient number of differences from those of the dog to require another chapter for their consideration. If we could subtract from the domestic dog all the emotions arising from his prolonged companionship with man, and at the same time intensify the emotions of self- reliance, rapacity, &c., we should get the emotional character now presented by the wolves and jackals. It is interesting to note that this genetic similarity of emotional character extends to what may be termed idiosyncratic details in cases where it has not been interfered with by human agency. Thus the peculiar, weird, and unaccountable class of emotions which cause wolves to bay at the moon has been propagated unchanged to our domestic dogs.

1055

The intelligence of the fox is proverbial; but as I have not received many original observations on this head, I shall merely refer to some of the best authen- ticated observations already published, and shall begin with the instance narrated by Mr. St. John in his § Wild Sports of the Highlands ’:— When living in Ross-shire I went out one morning in July, before daybreak, to endeavour to shoot a stag, which had been complained of very much by an adjoining farmer, as having done great damage to his crops. Just after it was daylight I saw a large fox coming quietly along the edge of the plantation

1056

in which I was concealed ;-he looked with great care over the turf wall into the field, and seemed to long to get hold of some hares that were feeding in it, but apparently knew that he had no chance of catching one by dint of running ; after considering a short time he seemed to have formed his plans, and having examined the different gaps in the wall by which the hares might be supposed to go in and out, he fixed upon the one that seemed the most frequented, and laid himself down close to it in an attitude like a cat watching a mouse. Cunning as he was, | he was too intent on his own hunting to be aware that I was within twenty yards of him with a loaded rifle, and able to watch every movement that he made. I was much amazed to see the fellow so completely outwitted, and kept my rifle ready to shoot him if he found me out and attempted to escape. In the mean- time I watched all his plans. He first with great silence and are scraped a small hollow in the ground, throwing up the _ sand as a kind of screen between his hiding-place and the hares’ mews; every now and then, however, he stopped to listen, and sometimes to take a most cautious look into the field; when he had done this he laid himself down in a convenient position for Springing upon his prey, and remained perfectly motionless with the exception of an occasional reconnoitre of the feeding hares. - When the sun began to rise, they came one by one from the field to the cover of the plantation; three had already come in without passing by his ambush; one of them came within twenty yards of him, but he made no movement beyond crouch- ing still more closely to the ground.

1057

Presently two came directly towards him ; though he did not venture to look up, I saw by an involuntary motion of his ears that those quick organs had already warned him of their approach: the two hares came through the gap together, and the fox, springing with the quickness of lightning, caught one and killed her immediately ; he then lifted up his booty and was carrying it off like a retriever, when my rifle-ball stopped his course by -passing through his back-bone, and I went up and despatched him.

1058

Numberless instances are on record showing the remark- _ able cunning of foxes in procuring bait from traps without _ allowing themselves to be caught. These cases are so - numerous, and all display so much the same quality of intelligence, that it is impossible to doubt so great a - concurrence of testimony. I shall only give two or three _ Specific cases, to show the kind of intelligence that is in question. It will be observed that it is much the same as that which is displayed under similar’ circumstances by rats and wolverines, in which animals we have already

1059

played must justly be deemed to be of a very remarkable order. For, inasmuch as traps are not things to be met with in nature, hereditary experience cannot be supposed to have played any part in the formation of special instincts to avoid the dangers arising from traps, and therefore the astonishing devices by which these dangers: are avoided can only be attributed to observation, coupled with intelligent investigation of a remarkably high cha- racter.

1060

I extract the following from Couch’s ‘Illustrations of Instinct ’ (p. 175) :— Whenever a cat is tempted by the bait, and caught in a fox- trap, Reynard isat hand to devour the bait and the cat too, and fearlessly approaches an instrument which the fox must know cannot then do it any harm. Let us compare with this bold- ness the incredible caution with which the animal proceeds. when tempted by the bait in a set trap. Dietrich aus dem Winkell had once the good fortune of observing, on a winter evening, a fox which for many preceding days had been allured with loop baits, and as often as it ate one it sat comfortably

1061

down, wagging its brush. The nearer it approached the trap, — the longer did it hesitate to take the baits, and the oftener did it — the trap it squatted down, and eyed the bait for ten minutes at — least ; whereupon it ran three or four times round the trap, then it stretched out one of its fore-paws after the bait, but did — not touch it; again a pause, during which the fox stared im- movably at the bait. At last, as if in despair, the animal made a rush and was caught by the neck. (Mag. Nat. Hist., N.S., —

1062

Some years since, while hunting in Northern Michigan, I © tried with the aid of a professional trapper to entrap a fox who — made nightly visits to a spot where the entrails of a deer had gested itself to us we were unsuccessful, and, what seemed very — singular, we always found the trap sprung. My companion insisted that the animal dug beneath it, and putting his paw beneath the jaw, pushed down the pan with safety to himself; but though the appearance seemed to confirm it, I could hardly credit his explanation. This year, in another locality of the same region, an old and experienced trapper assured me of its correctness, and said in confirmation that he had several times caught them, after they had made two or three successful attempts to spring the trap, by the simple expedient of setting it upside down, when of course the act of undermining and touch- ing the pan would bring the paw within the grasp of the jaws.

1063

In connection with traps, my friend Dr. Rae has communicated to me a highly remarkable instance of the display of reason on the part of the Arctic foxes. I have previously published the facts: in my lecture before the British Association in 1879, and therefore shall here quote Desiring to obtain some Arctic foxes, Dr. Rae set various kinds of traps; but as the foxes knew these traps from previous experience, he was unsuccessful. Accordingly he set a kind of trap with which the foxes in that part of the country were not acquainted. This consisted of a loaded gun set upon a stand pointing at the bait. A string connected the trigger of the gun with the bait, so that when the fox seized the bait he discharged the gun, and thus committed suicide. In this arrangement the gun was separated from the bait by a distance of about 30 yards, and the string which connected the trigger with the bait was concealed throughout nearly its whole distance in the snow. The gun-trap thus set was successful in killing one fox, but never in killing a second; for the foxes afterwards adopted either of two devices whereby to secure the bait without injur- ‘ing themselves. One of these devices was to bite through the string at its exposed part near the trigger, and the other device was to burrow up to the bait through the snow at right angles to the line of fire, so that, although in this way they discharged the gun, they escaped with perhaps only a pellet or two in the nose. Now both of these devices exhibited a wonderful degree of what I think must fairly be called power of reasoning. I have carefully interrogated Dr. Rae on all the circumstances of the case, and he tells me that in that part of the world traps are never set with strings; so that there can have been no special association in the foxes’ minds between strings and traps. Moreover, after the death of fox No.-1, the track on

1064

the snow showed that fox No. 2, notwithstanding the temp-— tation offered by the bait, had expended a great deal of scientific observation on the gun before he undertook to sever the cord. — Lastly, with regard to burrowing at right angles to the line of — fire, Dr. Rae justly deemed this so extraordinary a circumstance, — that he repeated the experiment a number of times, in order to © satisfy himself that the direction of the burrowing was really to — be attributed to thought, and not to chance.!

1065

1 T have requested Dr. Rae to write out all the particulars of these remarkable observations, and the following is the response which he — has kindly made :—‘ When trapping foxes in Hudson’s Bay it sometimes. happens that certain of these acute animals, probably from having seen their companions caught, studiously avoid the ordinary steel and wooden traps, however carefully set. The trapper then sets one or more guns in a peculiar manner, having a line 15 or 20 yards long uniting the trigger with a bait, on taking hold of which the fox sets the gun off, — and commits suicide. The double object of the bait being placed so ~ near the gun is that the fox may be certainly killed—not wounded only—and that the head alone should be hit, and the body not riddled all over with shot, which would spoil the skin. It is also necessary to mention that four or five inches of slack line must be allowed for contraction of the line by change from a dry to a moist atmosphere, which otherwise would cause so great a strain on the trigger that the gun would be discharged without the bait being touched. So as to — conceal as far as possible all connection between bait and gun, that part of the line next the bait is carefully hid under the snow.

1066

‘When the fox takes the bait, he will have lifted it five inches (the length of the slack line) from its normal position before the gun goes off ; consequently, instead of pointing the gun at the bait, it is aimed fully eight or nine inches higher, at the probable position of the brain of the animal when the gun is discharged. : ‘For reasons which scarcely require explanation, foxes very gene- rally go about in pairs (long before the snow disappears), not necessarily always close together, because they have a better chance of finding food if separated some distance from each other.

1067

‘ After one or more foxes have been shot, the trapper on visiting his. guns perhaps finds that a fox has first cut the line connecting the bait with the gun, and then gone up and eaten the bait; or, if the gun has: been set on a drift bank of snow, he or she has scraped a trench ten or twelve inches deep up to the bait, taken hold of it whilst lying in the trench, set the gun off, and then trotted coolly away with the food (taken, one may say, from the gun’s mouth) safe and uninjured, as is. clearly evinced by there being no mark of blood on the tracks,

1068

‘In pulling the bait whilst in the trench, the fox would drag it five inches, or the length of the slack line, downwards, and therefore his. head and nose would be completely out of harm’s way, both because of the snow protection, and also these parts of his body being twelve or thirteen inches below the line of aim, ; ‘In the cases seen by myself, and by a friend of greater experience,. the trench was always scraped at right angles, or nearly so, to the line: of fire of the gun. This at first sight may appear erroneous, but on:

1069

Dr. Rae also informs me with regard to wolves, that ‘they have been frequently known to take the bait from a gun without injury to themselves, by first cutting the line of communication between the two.’! He adds :— I may also mention what I have been told, although I have never had an opportunity of seeing it, that wolves watch the fishermen who set lines in deep water for trout, through holes in the ice on Lake Superior, and very soon after the man has left, the wolf goes up to the place, takes hold of the stick which is placed across the hole and attached to the line, trots off with it along the ice until the bait is brought to the surface, then returns and eats the bait and the fish, if any happens to be on the hook. The trout of Lake Superior are very large, and the baits are of a size in proportion.

1070

Mr. Murray Browne, Inspector of the Local Govern- ment Board, writes to me from Whitehall as follows :— I once, at the Devil’s Glen, Wicklow, found a fox fast in a trap by the foot. We did not like to touch him, but got sticks and poked at the trap till we got it open. The process took ten minutes or a quarter-hour. When first we came up the fox strained to get free, and looked frightfully savage ; but we had not poked at the trap more than a very short time before the whole expression of his face changed, he lay perfectly quiet (though we must at times have hurt him); and when at last we had got the trap completely off his foot, he still lay quiet,

1071

reflection it really is not so, for if the trench is to be a shelter one— thinking, as the fox must have done, that the gun or something coming from it was the danger to be protected from or guarded against—it must be made across the line of fire, for if scratched in the direction of fire it would afford little or no protection or concealment, and the reasoning power or intelligence of the fox would be at fault. ‘My belief is that one of these knowing foxes had seen his or her companion shot, or found it dead shortly after it had been killed, and not unnaturally attributed the cause of the mishap to the only strange thing it saw near, namely, the gun.

1072

‘It was evident that in all cases they had studied the situation care- fully, as was sufficiently shown by their tracks in the snow, which indicated their extremely cautious approach when either the string- cutting or trench-making dodge was resorted to, in attempting to obtain the coveted bait without injury to themselves.’ 1 It will be remembered that, from evidence previously detailed, both the wolverine or glutton and certain deer have been shown capable of similarly obviating the danger of gun-traps.

1073

and looked calmly at us, as if he knew we were friends. In fact, we had some little difficulty in getting him to move away, which he did readily enough when he chose. Was not this a case of reason and good sense overpowering natural instinct ¢ Couch says (‘Illustrations of Instinct,’ p. 178): ‘Derham quotes Olaus in his account of Norway as having himself witnessed the fact of a fox dropping his tail among the rocks on the sea-shore to catch the erabs below, and hauling up and devouring such as laid hold of it.’

1074

Under the present heading I must not omit to refer to an interesting class of instincts which are manifested by those species of the genus Canis, whose custom it is to hunt in packs, The instincts to which I refer are those which lead to a combination among different members of the same pack for the capture of prey by stratagem. These instincts, which no doubt arose and are now maintained by intelligent adaptation to the requirements of the chase, I shall call ‘collective instincts... Thus Sir E. Tennent writes :—

1075

At dusk, and after nightfall, a pack of jackals, having watched a hare or a small deer take refuge in one of these retreats, immediately surrounded it on all sides; and having stationed a few to watch the path by which the game entered, the leader commences the attack by raising the ery peculiar to their race, and which resembles the sound ‘okkay’ loudly and rapidly repeated. The whole party then rush into the jungle ~ and drive out the victim, which generally falls into the ambush previously laid to entrap it.

1076

A native gentleman, who had favourable opportunities of . observing the movements of these animals, informed me that when a jackal has brought down his game and killed it, his first impulse is to hide it in the nearest jungle, whence he issues with an air of easy indifference to observe whether anything more powerful than himself may be at hand, from which he might encounter the risk of being despoiled of his capture. If the coast be clear he returns to the concealed carcass and carries it away, followed by his companions, But if a man be in sight, or any other animal to be avoided, my informant has seen the jackal seize a cocoa-nut husk in his mouth, or any similar sub- stance, and fly at full speed, asif eager to carry off his pretended

1077

prize, returning for the real booty at some more convenient - season.! Again, Jesse records the following display of the same instinct by the fox, as having been communicated to him by a friend on whose veracity he could rely :— Part of this rocky ground was on the side of a very high hill, which was not accessible for a sportsman, and from which both hares and foxes took their way in the evening to the plain below. There were two channels or gullies made by the rains, leading from these rocks to the lower ground. Near one of these channels, the sportsman in question, and his attendant, stationed themselves one evening in hopes of being able to shoot some hares. They had not been there long, when they observed a fox coming down the gully, and followed by another. After playing together for a little time, one of the foxes con- cealed himself under a large stone or rock, which was at the bottom of the channel, and the other returned to the rocks. He soon, however, came back, chasing a hare before him. As the hare was passing the stone where the first fox had concealed himself, he tried to seize her by a sudden spring, but missed his aim. The chasing fox then came up, and finding that his ex- _ pected prey had escaped, through the want of skill in his associate, he fell upon him, and they both fought with so much animosity, that the parties who had been watching their pro- ceedings came up and destroyed them both.

1078

Similarly, Mr. E. C. Buck records (‘ Nature,’ viii., 303) the following interesting observation made by his friend Mr. Elliot, B.C.S., Secretary to Government, N.W.P. :— He saw two wolves standing together, and shortly after noticing them was surprised to see one of them lie down in a watched the latter, which deliberately went to the far side of a herd of antelopes standing in the plain, and drove them, as a Sheep-dog would a flock of sheep, to the very spot where his companion lay in ambush. As the antelopes crossed the ditch, the concealed wolf jumped up as in the former case, seized a doe, and was joined by his colleague.

1079

Mr. Buck draws attention to another closely similar display of collective instinct of wolves in the same district observed by a ‘writer of one of the books on Brydon, C.B. (the ‘last man’ of the Afghan expedition of 1841), whom I knew intimately for several years, and ing letter ( Nature,’ vol. vili., p. 302), the following instance of ‘collective instinct’ exhibited by an animal closely allied to the wolf, viz., the Indian jackal, deserves to be recorded. It was ~ communicated to me by a gentleman (since deceased) on whose: —

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.