Animal Intelligence
to shoot tigers as they came to drink at a large lake (I forget — the district), skirted by a dense jungle, when about midnight water’s edge. Then it stopped and sniffed the air in the direc- tion of the jungle, as if suspecting the presence of an enemy; — apparently satisfied, however, it began to drink, and continued to do so for a most inordinate length of time. When literally — swollen with water it turned to go into the jungle, but was met on its extreme margin by a jackal, which, with a sharp
startled, and ran along the shore for some distance, when it again attempted to enter the jungle, but was again met and driven back in the same manner. The night being calm, my friend could hear this process being repeated time after time— the yelps becoming successively fainter and fainter in the dis- tance, until they became wholly inaudible. The stratagem thus employed was sufficiently evident. The lake having a long narrow shore intervening between it and the jungle, the jackals formed themselves in line along it while concealed within the extreme edge of the cover, and waited until the deer was water- logged. Their prey, being thus rendered heavy and _short- winded, would fall an easy victim if induced to run sufficiently far, z.¢., if prevented from entering the jungle. It was, of course, impossible to estimate the number of jackals engaged in this hunt, for it is not impossible that as soon as one had done duty at one place, it outran the deer to await it in another.
A native servant who accompanied my friend told him that this was a stratagem habitually employed by the jackals in that place, and that they hunted in sufficient numbers ‘to leave nothing but the bones.’ As it is a stratagem which could only be effectual under the peculiar local conditions described, it must appear that this example of collective instinct is due to ‘separate expression,’ and not to ‘ inherited habit.’ Cases of collective instinct are not of unfrequent occurrence among dogs. For the accuracy of the two following I can vouch, . A small Skye and a large mongrel were in the habit of hunting hares and rabbits upon their own account, the small dog having a good nose, and the larger one great fleetness. These qualities they combined in the most advantageous manner, the terrier driving the cover towards his fleet-footed companion which was waiting for it outside.
The second case is remarkable for a display of sly sagacity. A friend of mine in Ross-shire had a small terrier and a large Newfoundland. One day a shepherd called upon him to say that his dogs had been worrying sheep the night before. The gentleman said there must be some mistake, as the Newfound- land had not been unchained. A few days afterwards the shepherd again called with the same complaint, vehemently asserting that he was positive as to the identity of the dogs. Consequently the owner set one watch upon the kennel and another outside the sheep enclosure, directing them (in con- sequence of what the shepherd had told him) not to interfere with the action of the dogs. After this had been done several nights in succession, the small dog was observed to come at daydawn to the place where the large one was chained; the latter immediately slipped his collar, and the two animals made straight for the sheep. Upon arriving at the enclosure the Newfoundland concealed himself behind a hedge, while the terrier drove the sheep towards his ambush, and the fate of one of them was quickly sealed. When their breakfast was finished the dogs returned home, and the larger one, thrusting his head into his collar, lay down again as though nothing had happened. Why this animal should have chosen to hunt by stratagem prey which it could easily run down, I cannot suggest; but there can be little doubt that so wise a dog must have had some good reason.
A similar instance of the display of collective instinct is thus narrated by M. Dureau de la Malle :— I had at one time two sporting dogs, the one an excellent pointer with a very smooth skin, and of remarkable beauty and intelligence ; the other was a spaniel with long and thick hair, but which had not been taught to point, but only coursed in the woods like a harrier. My chdteaw is situated on a level spot of ground, opposite to copse wood filled with hares and
rabbits. When sitting at my window, I have observed these two dogs, which were at large in the yard, approach and make signs to each other, and first glancing at me, as if to see if I offered any obstacle to their wishes, step away very gently, then quicken their pace when they were at a little distance from my sight, and finally dart off at full speed when they thought I could neither see them nor order them back, Surprised at this mysterious manceuvre, I followed them, and witnessed a sin- gular sight. The pointer, who seemed to be the leader of the enterprise, had sent the spaniel out to beat the bushes, and give tongue at the opposite extremity of the bushwood. As to himself, he made with slow steps the circuit of the wood by following it along the border, and I observed him stop before a passage much frequented by rabbits, and there point. I con- tinued at a distance to observe how the intrigue was going to end. At length I heard the spaniel, which had started a hare, drive it with much tongue towards the place where its com- panion was lying in ambush, and the moment that the hare came out of the passage to gain the fields, the latter darted upon it and brought it to me with an air of triumph. I have seen these two dogs repeat this same manceuvre more than a hundred times; and this conformity has convinced me that it was not accidental, but the result of a concerted agreement and combined plan of operations understood beforehand.
Again, among Mr. Darwin’s MSS., I find a letter from Mr. H. Reeks (1871), which says that the wolves of New- foundland adopt exactly the same stratagem for the cap- ture of deer in winter as that which is adopted by the hunters. That is to say, some of the pack secrete them- selves in one or more of the leeward deer-paths in the forest or ‘ belting,’ while one or two wolves make a circuit round the herd of deer to’ windward. The herd invariably retreats by one of its accustomed runs, and $ it rarely happens... . that the wolves do not manage by this stratagem to secure a doe or young stag.’ And Leroy, in his book on Animal Intelligence, narrates closely similar facts of the wolves of Europe as having fallen within his own observation.
THE intelligence of the dog is of special, and indeed of unique interest from an evolutionary point of view, in that from time out of record this animal has been domes- ticated on account of the high level of its natural intelli- gence ; and by persistent contact with man, coupled with training and breeding, its natural intelligence has been greatly changed. In the result we see, not only a general modification in the way of dependent companionship and docility, so unlike the fierce and self-reliant disposition of all wild species of the genus; but also a number of special modifications, peculiar to certain breeds, which all have obvious reference to the requirements of man. The whole psychological character of the dog may therefore be said to have been moulded by human agency with refer- ence to human requirements, so that now it is not more true that man has in a sense created the structure of the bull-dog and greyhound, than that he has implanted the instincts of the watch-dog and pointer. The definite proof which we thus have afforded of the transforming and creating influence exerted upon the mental character and instincts of species by long and persistent training, coupled with artificial selection, furnishes the strongest possible corroboration of the theory which assigns psycho- logical development in general to the joint operation of individual experience coupled with natural selection. For thousands of years man has here been virtually, though unconsciously, performing what evolutionists may re- gard as a gigantic experiment upon the potency of in- dividual experience accumulated by heredity; and now there stands before us this most wonderful monument of
his labours—the culmination of his experiment in the transformed psychology of the dog. In my next work I shall treat of this subject with the fulness that it deserves—especially in its relation to the origin of instincts and the development of the moral sense; but to enter upon this topic at present would ~ demand more space than can be allowed. To do full justice to the psychology of the dog a separate treatise would be required. Here I can only trace a sketch, :
As regards memory, one or two instances will suffice. Mr. Darwin writes: ‘I had a dog who was savage and averse to all strangers, and I purposely tried his memory after an absence of five years and two days. I went near the stable where he lived, and shouted to him in my old manner ; he showed no joy, but instantly followed me out walking, and obeyed me, as if I had parted with him only an hour before.’ ! It is not only persons or places that dogs remember for long periods. I had a setter in the country, which one year I took up with me to town for a few months. While in town he was never allowed to go out without a collar on which was engraved my address. A ring upon this collar made a clinking sound, and the setter soon learnt to associate the approach of this sound with the prospect of a walk. Three years afterwards I again took this setter up to town. He remembered every nook and corner of my house in town, and also his way about the streets, and _ the first time that I brought his collar, slightly clinking — as before, he showed by his demonstrations of joy that he well remembered the sound with all its old associations, although he had not heard this sound for three years.
The emotional life of the dog is highly developed— more highly, indeed, than that of any other animal. His gregarious instincts, united with his high intelligence and constant companionship with man, give to this animal a psychological basis for the construction of emotional cha- tacter, having a more massive as well as more complex consistency than that which is presented even in the case of the monkey, which, as we shall afterwards see, attains to a remarkably high level in this respect.
Pride, sense of dignity, and self-respect are very con- spicuously exhibited by well-treated dogs. As with man, so with the friend of man, it is only those whose lines of fortune have fallen in pleasant places, and whose feelings may therefore be said to have profited by the refining influences of culture, that display in any conspicuous mea- sure the emotions in question. ‘Uurs of low degree,’ and even many dogs of better social position, have never enjoyed those conditions essential to moral refinement, which alone can, engender a true sense of self-respect and dignity. A “low-life’ dog may not like to have his tail pulled, any more than a gutter child may like to have his ears boxed ; but here it is physical pain rather than wounded pride that causes the smart. Among ‘ high-life’ dogs, however, the case is different. Here wounded sensibilities and loss of esteem are capable of producing much keener suffering than is mere physical pain; so that among such dogs a whipping produces quite a different and a much more lasting effect than in the case of their rougher brethren, who, as soon as it is over, give themselves a shake and think no moreabout it. As evidence of the delicacy of feeling to which dogs of aristocratic estate may attain, I shall give one or two among many instances that I could render.
A reproachful word or look from any of his friends would make a Skye terrier that I owned miserable for a whole day. Ifwe had ever ventured to strike him I ‘do not know what would have happened, for his sentiments were quite abreast of the age with respect to moral repug- nance to the use of the lash. Thus, for instance, at one time when all his own friends were out of town, he was taken for a walk every day in the park by my brother, to whose care he had been entrusted. He enjoyed his walks very much, and was wholly dependent upon my brother
for obtaining them. Nevertheless, one day while he was. amusing himself with another dog in the park, my brother,. in order to persuade him to follow, struck him with a glove. The terrier looked up at his face with an astonished and indignant gaze, deliberately turned round, and trotted home. Next day he went out with my brother as before, but after he had gone a short distance he looked up at his. face significantly, and again trotted home with a dignified air. After thus making bis protest in the strongest way he could, the dog ever afterwards refused to accompany him.
This terrier habitually exhibited a strong repugnance- to corporal punishment, even when inflicted upon others. Thus, whenever or wherever he saw a man striking a dog, - whether in the house or outside, near at hand or at a dis= tance, he used to rush in to interfere, snarling and snap- ping in a most threatening way. Again, when driving with me in adog-cart, he always used to hold the sleeve of my coat every time I touched the horse with the whip. As bearing upon this sensitiveness of feeling produced in dogs by habitually kind treatment, I shall here give an extract from the letter of one of. my correspondents (Mrs.. E. Picton). It relates to a Skye terrier which had a biti aversion to being washed :—
In process of time this aversion increased so much that all the servants I had refused to perform the ablutions, being in terror of doing so from the ferocity the animal evinced on such occasions. I myself did not choose to undertake the office, for though the animal was passionately attached to me, such was: his horror of the operation, that even I was not safe. Threats, beating, and starving were all of no avail ; he still persisted in his obstinacy. At length I hit upon a new device. Leaving him perfectly free, and not curtailing his liberty in any way, L let him know, by taking no notice of him, that he had offended me. He was usually the companion of my walks, but now L refused to let him accompany me. When I returned home I took no notice of his demonstrative welcome, and when he came- looking up at me for caresses when I was engaged either in reading or needlework, I deliberately turned my head aside. This state of things continued for about a week or ten days, and the poor animal looked wretched and forlorn. There was.
evidently a conflict going on within him, which told visibly on his outward appearance. At length one morning he crept quietly up to me, and gave me a look which said as plainly as any spoken words could have done, ‘I can stand it no longer ; I submit.’ And submit he did quite quietly and patiently to one of the roughest ablutions it had ever been his lot to expe- rience ; for by this time he sorely needed it. After it was over he bounded to me with a joyous bark and wag of his tail, saying unmistakably, ‘I know all isrightnow.’ He took his place by my side as his right when I went for my walk, and retained from that time his usually glad and joyous expression of coun- tenance. When the period for the next ablution came round the old spirit of obstinacy resumed its sway for a while, but a single look at my averted countenance was sufficient for him, and he again submitted without a murmur. Must there not have been something akin to the reasoning faculty in the breast of an animal who could thus for ten days carry on such a. struggle 4
This strong effect of silent coldness shows that the loss. of affectionate regard caused the terrier more suffering than beating, starving, or even the hated bath ; and as many analogous cases might be quoted, I have no hesitation in adducing this one as typical of the craving for affec- tionate regard which is manifested by sensitive dogs. In this connection I may point out the remarkable change which has been produced in the domestic dog as compared with wild dogs, with reference to the enduring of pain. A wolf or a fox will sustain the severest kinds of physical suffering without giving utterance to a sound, while a dog will scream when any one accidentally treads upon its toes. This contrast is strikingly analogous to that which obtains between savage and civilised man: the North American Indian, and even the Hindoo, will endure without a moan an amount of physical pain—or at least bodily injury—which would produce vehement ex- pressions of suffering from a European. And doubtless. the explanation is in both cases the same—namely, that refinement of life engenders refinement of nervous organi- sation, which renders nervous lesions more intolerable.
As evidence of the idea of caste in a dog, I shall quote only one instance, although many others might be- given: this also may be taken as typical. I extract it from St. John’s ‘Wild Sports of the Highlands,’ where, speaking of his retriever, this very good observer states : ‘He struck up an acquaintance with a ratcatcher and his eur, thoroughly entering into their way of business ; but friends, and denied all acquaintance with them in the most comical manner.’ !
Dogs likewise display in a high degree the feelings of emulation and jealousy. I once had a terrier which took great pains, and manifested paternal delight, in teaching his puppy to hunt rabbits. But in time the puppy out- grew his father in strength and fleetness, so that in the to be gradually distanced. His whole demeanour then changed, and every time that he found his son drawing away from him he used in desperation to seize the reced- ing tail of the youngster. Although the son was now much stronger than the father, he never used to resent this exercise of paternal authority, even though the rabbit were close under his nose.
' Of jealousy in dogs innumerable instances might be given, but I shall merely quote one from my bulky cor- respondence on this head. It is sent me by Mr. A. Oldham :— He had grown old, and having some affection in his legs which made walking difficult to him, he had sunk into a very stagnant sort of life, when a Scotch terrier was brought to live with us, and treated with much favour. All Charlie’s old vigour revived upon the advent of this rival. He exhibited agonies of jealousy, and has since spent his life in following, watching, and imitating him. He insists on doing everything that Jack does. Although he had previously given up walking, he now makes a point of going out whenever Jack does so. Several times he has started with us, but finding that Jack was not of the party, has turned back and quietly gone home. In the same way,
1 So many cases are on record of large dogs (especially of the New- foundland breed) throwing troublesome curs into the water, and again rescuing them if they show danger of drowning, that we can scarcely fail to accept them as true. Such cases exhibit a wonderful play of human-like emoticns. although before he ate nothing but meat, he now eats any food that is also given to Jack; and if Jack is caressed he watches _-for some time, and then bursts out whining and barking. I have -seen the same rage manifested by a fine cockatoo at the sight of his mistress carrying on her wrist and stroking affectionately a little green parrot. Such jealousy seems to me a very advanced emotion, as it has passed beyond the stage when it may be sup- posed to be caused by a fear of other animals monopolising material benefits which they desire for themselves; it is ex- -cited solely by seeing affection or attention bestowed by those they love upon other animals. The actions in which Charlie ‘tries to participate—such as walking far, plunging into cold water after sticks, &c.—are in themselves extremely disagree- able to him, and he performs them only that he may obtain a share in the companionship and notice bestowed upon Jack.
Akin to jealousy is the sense of justice. If a master is not equal in his ways towards his dogs, the dogs are ‘very apt to discover the injustice and to resent it accord- ‘ingly. The well-known observation of the great Arago ‘may be taken as a typical one in this connection. Having been detained by a storm at a country inn, and having -ordered a chicken for his dinner, Arago was warming himself by the kitchen fire, when he saw the innkeeper put the fowl -on the spit and attempt to seize a turnspit dog lying in the kitchen. The brute, however, refused to enter the wheel, got under a table, and showed fight. On Arago -asking what could be the meaning of such conduct, the host replied that the dog had some excuse, that it was not his turn but his comrade’s, who did not happen to be ‘in the kitchen. Accordingly, the other turnspit was sent ‘for, and he entered the spit very willingly, and turned away. When the fowl was half roasted Arago took him out, and the other dog, no longer smarting under the sense of injustice, now took his turn without any opposi- tion, and completed the roasting of the fowl.
Deceitfulness is another trait in canine character of which numberless instances might be given; but here, again, it seems unnecessary to quote more than one or two cases as illustrative of the general fact. Another of my correspondents, after giving several examples of the ‘display of hypocrisy of a King Charles spaniel, proeeeds :— He showed the same deliberate design of deceiving on other occasions. Having hurt his foot he became lame for a time, during which he received more pity and attention than usual. For months after he had recovered, whenever he was harshly spoken to, he commenced hobbling about the room as if lame and suffering pain from his foot. He only gave up the practice when he gradually perceived that it was unsuccessful.
The following instance, which I observed myself, I regard as more remarkable. It has already been pub- lished in ‘ Nature ’ (vol. xii., p. 66), from which I quote it: window-panes, and if ridiculed when unsuccessful was evidently. much annoyed. On one occasion, in order to see what he would do, I purposely laughed immoderately every time he failed. _ It so happened that he did so several times in succes- sion—partly, I believe, in consequence of my laughing—and eventually he became so distressed that he positively pretended to catch the fly, going through all the appropriate actions with his lips and tongue, and afterwards rubbing the ground with his neck as if to kill the victim: he then looked up at me with a triumphant air of success. So well was the whole process simulated that I should have been quite deceived, had I not seen that the fly was still upon the window. Accordingly I drew his attention to this fact, as well as to the absence of any- thing upon the floor ; and when he saw that his hypocrisy had been detected he slunk away under some furniture, evidently very much ashamed of himself.
This allusion to the marked effects of ridicule upon a dog leads to a consideration of the next emotion with which I feel certain that some dogs are to be accredited. I mean the emotion of the ludicrous. This same terrier used, when in good humour, to perform several tricks, which I know to have been self-taught, and which clearly had the object of exciting laughter. For instance, while lying on his side and violently grinning, he would hold one leg in his mouth. Under such circumstances, nothing pleased him so much as having his joke duly appreciated, while if no notice was taken of him he would become sulky. On the other hand, nothing dis- pleased him so much as being laughed at when he did
¢lusively proved than by the fact of his behaviour in pretending to catch the fly. Mr. Darwin observes: ‘ Dogs show what may be fairly called a sense of humour, as dis- tinct from mere play; if a bit of stick or other such ob- ject be thrown to one, he will often carry it away for a short distance ; and then squatting down with it on the ground close before him, will wait until his master comes close to take it away. The dog will seize it and rush away in triumph, repeating the same manceuvre, and evidently enjoying the practical joke.’ :
I have very definite evidence of the fact that dogs are able to communicate to one another simple ideas. The communication is always effected by gesture or tones of barking, and the ideas are always of such a simple nature as that of a mere ‘follow me.’ According to my own observations, the dogs must be above the average of canine intelligence, and the gesture they invariably em- ploy is a contact of heads, with a motion between a rub and a butt. It is quite different from anything that occurs in play, and is always followed by a definite course of action. I must add, however, that although the in- formation thus conveyed is always definite, I have never known a case in which it was complex—anything like asking or telling the way, which several writers have said that dogs can do, being, I believe, quite out of the question. One example will suffice. A Skye terrier (not quite pure) was asleep in the room where I was, while his son lay upon a wall which separates the lawn from the high road. The young dog, when alone, would never attack a strange one, but was a keen fighter when in company with his father. Upon the present occasion a large mongrel passed along the road, and shortly afterwards the old dog awoke and went sleepily downstairs. When he arrived upon the door-step his son ran up to him and
made the sign just described. His whole manner im- mediately altered to that of high animation. Clearing the wall together, the two animals ran down the road as. terriers only can when pursuing an enemy. I watched them for a mile and a half, within which distance their | speed never abated, although the object of their pursuit had not from the first been in sight. It is almost superfluous to give cases illustrating the well-known fact that dogs communicate their desires and ideas to man; but as the subject of the communication by signs will afterwards be found of importance in con- nection with the philosophy of communication by words, I shall here give a few examples of dogs communicating by signs with man, which for my purpose will be the more valuable the less they are recognised as unusual.
Lieutenant-Gen. Sir John H. Lefroy, C.B., K.C.M.G., F.R.S., writes me that he has a terrier which it is the duty of his wife’s maid to wash and feed. ‘It was her habit after calling her mistress in the morning to go out and milk a goat which was tethered near the house, and give “Button” the milk. One morning, being rather earlier than usual, instead of going out at once she took up some needlework and began to occupy herself. The dog endeavoured in every possible way to attract her attention and draw her forth, and at last pushed aside the curtain of a closet, and never having been taught to fetch or carry, took between his teeth the cup she habitually used, and brought it to her feet. I inquired into every circumstance strictly on the spot, and was shown where he found the cup.’
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.