Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 1110 to 1139 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

1110

Similarly I select the following case from a great number of others that I might quote, because it is so closely analogous to the above. It is communicated to me by Mr. A. H. Baines :— There is a drinking-trough for him in my sitting-room : if at any time it happens to be without water when he goes to drink, he scratches the dish with his fore-paws in order to call attention to his wants, and this is done in an authoritative way, which generally has the desired effect. Another Pomeranian— a member of the same family—when quite young used to soak

1111

hard biscuits in water till soft enough to eat. She would carry the biscuit in her mouth to the drinking-trough, drop it in and leave it there for a few minutes, and then fish it out with her paw. One more instance of the communication of ideas by gestures will no doubt be deemed sufficient. It is one of a kind which has many analogies in the literature of canine intelligence. Dr. Beattie relates this case of canine sagacity, of which the scene was a place near Aberdeen. The Dee being frozen, a gentleman named Irvine was crossing the ice, which gave way with him about the middle of the river. _ Having a gun, he was able to keep himself from sinking by placing it across the opening. ‘The dog made many fruitless efforts to save his master, and then ran to a neighbouring village, where he saw a man, and with the most significant gestures pulled him by the coat, and prevailed on him to follow. The man arrived on the spot in time to save the gentleman’s life.’

1112

Numberless other instances of the same kind might be given, and they display a high degree of intelligence. Even the idea of saving life implies in itself no small amount of intelligence; but in such cases as these we have added the idea of going for help, communicating news of a disaster, and leading the way to its occurrence. Having thus as briefly as possible considered the emotional and the more ordinary intellectual faculties of the dog, I shall pass on to the statement of cases showing the higher and more exceptional developments of canine sagacity.

1113

Were the purpose of this work that of accumulating anecdotes of animal intelligence, this would be the place to let loose a flood of facts, which might all be well attested, relating to the high intelligence of dogs. But as my aim is rather that of suppressing anecdotes, except in so far as facts are required to prove the presence in animals of the sundry psychological faculties which I believe the different classes to present, I shall here, as elsewhere, follow the method of not multiplying anecdotes further than seems necessary fully to demonstrate the

1114

order that any who read these pages for the sake of the — anecdotes which they necessarily present may not be | disappointed by meeting with cases already known to ~ them, I shall draw my material mainly from the facts — communicated to me by private correspondents, alluding As showing the high general intelligence of the dog, ; I shall first begin with the collie. It is certain that many of these dogs can be trusted to gather and drive sheep without supervision. It is enough on this head to refer to the well-known anecdotes of the poet Hogg in his * Shepherd’s Calendar,’ concerning his dog ¢ Sirrah.’

1115

Williams, in his book on ‘ Dogs and their Ways,’ says (p. 124) that a friend of his had a collie which, whenever his master said the words ‘Cast, cast,’ would run off to seek any sheep that might be cast, and on finding it would at once assist it to rise. He also knew of another dog (p. 102), which would perform the same office even in the absence of his master, going the round of the fields and pastures by himself to right all the sheep that he found to be cast.’

1116

me an account of a sheep-dog belonging to a friend of his (Mr. Mitchell, of Inverness-shire) which strayed to a neigh- bouring farm, and took up his residence with the farmer. On the second night after the dog arrived at the farm the farmer ‘took the dog down to the meadow to see if the cattle were all right. To his dismay he found that 1 For many other instamces of sheep-dog sagacity, see Watson, Reasoning Power of Animals, under ‘ Shepherd’s Dog.’

1117

the fence between his meadow and his neighbour’s had got broken down, and that the whole of his neighbour’s cattle had cattle were driven back into their proper meadow, and the fence put into temporary repair. The neat night, at the same hour, the gentleman started off to look after the cattle. The dog, however, was not to be seen. On arriv- ment to find that the dog had preceded him! His astonishment soon changed into delighted approbation when he found the dog sitting on the broken fence between the two meadows, and daring the cattle from either side to cross. The cattle had during the interval between the first and second visits broken down the fence, and had got mixed up with each other. The dog had quietly gone off on his own account to see if all was right, and finding a similar accident to the one the previous

1118

cattle to their proper meadow, and had mounted guard over the broken fence as I have already indicated.’ Colonel Hamilton Smith says that the cattle-dogs of Cuba and Terra Firma are very wise in managing cattle, but require to display different tactics from the cattle-dogs of Europe :— When vessels with live stock arrive at any of the West India harbours, these animals, some of which are nearly as large as mastiffs, are wonderfully efficient in assisting to land the cargo. The oxen are hoisted out with a sling passing round the base of their horns ; and when an ox, thus suspended by the head, is lowered, and allowed to fall into the water, so that it may swim to land, men sometimes swim by the side of it and guide it, but they have often dogs of this breed which will perform the service equally well; for, catching the per- plexed animal by the ears, one on each side, they will force it

1119

__ to swim in the direction of the landing-place, and instantly let _go their hold when they feel it touch the ground, as the ox will then naturally walk out of the water by itself.! neously shown in the following case. It is communicated to me by a correspondent, Mr. A. H. Browning. This. gentleman was looking at a litter of young pigs in their sty, and when he went away the door of the sty was in- advertently left unfastened. The pigs all escaped into his garden. My correspondent then proceeds :—

1120

My attention was called to my dog appearing in a great state of excitement, mot barking (he seldom barks), but whining and performing all sorts of antics (in a human subject I should have said ‘ gesticulating’). The herdmen and myself returned to. the sty ; we caught but one pig, and put him back; no sooner had we done so than the dog ran after each pig in succession,. brought him back to the sty by the ear, and then went after another, until the whole number were again housed.

1121

In Lord Brougham’s ‘Dialogues on Instinct’ (iii.) there is narrated the story told to the author by Lord Truro of a dog that used to worry sheep at night. The animal quietly submitted to be tied up in the evening, but when everybody was asleep he used to slip his collar,. worry the sheep, and, returning before dawn, again get. into his collar to avoid suspicion. I allude to this re- markable display of sagacity because I am myself able fully to corroborate it by precisely similar cases. A friend of mine (the late Mr. Sutherland Murray) had a dog which was always kept tied up at night, but nevertheless the neighbouring farmers complained of having detected: him as the culprit when watching to find what dog it was. — that committed nightly slaughter among their sheep. My friend, therefore, set a watch upon his dog, and found that when all was still he slipped his collar, and after being absent for some hours, returned and slipped his: head in again.

1122

A precisely similar case is given further back, and others are communicated to me by two correspondents (Mr. Goodbehere, of Birmingham, and Mr, Richard Wil- liams, of Buffalo). The latter says :— And here let me ask if you are aware of the cunning and sagacity of these sheep-killing dogs, that they never kill sheep. on the farm to which they belong, or in the immediate vicinity, but often go miles away; that they always return before day- light, and before doing so wash themselves in some stream to get rid of the blood.

1123

In Germany I knew a large dog that was-very fond of grapes, and at night used to slip his collar in order to satisfy his propensity; and it was not for some time that the thief was suspected, owing to his returning before daylight and appearing innocently chained up in his kennel. A closely similar case is recorded in Mr. Duncan’s book on ‘Instinct’ of a dog belonging to the Rev. Mr. Taylor, of Colton. The only difference is that the delin- quent dog slipped and afterwards readjusted a muzzle

1124

In connection with sly sagacity I may also give an- other story contained in my correspondence, although in this case I am specially requested by my correspondent not to publish his name. I can, therefore, only say that he occupies a high position in the Church, and that the dog (a retriever) was his own property :— The dog was lying one evening before the kitchen fire where the cook had prepared a turkey for roasting. She left the kitchen for a few moments, when the dog immediately carried away the turkey and placed it in the cleft of a tree close to the house, but which was well concealed by the surrounding laurels. So rapid were his movements that he returned to his post before the cook had come back, and stretching himself before the fire, looked ‘ as innocent as a child unborn.’ Unfortunately for him, however, a man who was in the habit of taking him to shoot, saw him carrying away his prize and watched his pro- gress. On coming into the kitchen the man found the dog in his old place pretending to be asleep. Diver’s conduct was all along dictated by a desire to conceal his theft, and if he were a man I should have said that he intended, in case of inquiry, _ to prove an alibi.

1125

Mr. W. H. Bodley writes me of a retriever dog that _ belonged to him :— _ size was kept, and on one occasion they fought. Having been chastised for this, on future occasions when they quarrelled | they used to swim over a river of some breadth, where they a@2 could not be interfered with, and fight out their quarrel on the — other side. What seems to me noteworthy in this conduct is the self-restraint manifested under the influence of passion, and the mutual understanding to defer the fight till they could pro- secute it unmolested ; like two duellists crossing the Channel to fight in France.

1126

It is, of course, a well-known thing that dogs may easily be taught the use of coin for buying buns, &c. In the ‘Scottish Naturalist’ for April, 1881, Mr. Japp vouches for the fact that a collie which he knew was in the habit of purchasing cakes with coppers without ever having been taught the use of coin for such purposes. This fact, however, of a dog spontaneously divining the use of money requires corroboration, although it is certain that many dogs have an instinctive idea of giving peace-offerings, and the step from this to the idea of barter may not be large. Thus, to give only two — illustrations, Mr. Badcock writes to me that a friend of his — had a dog which one day had a quarrel with a companion dog, so that they parted at variance. ‘On the next day the friend appeared with a biscuit, which he presented as a peace-offering.’ Again, Mr. Thomas D. Smeaton writes to me of his dog that he ‘has an amusing practice when — he is restored to favour after some slight offence, of im- mediately picking up and carrying anything that is — handiest, stone, stick, paper: it is a deliberate effort to please, a sort of good-will offering, a shaking hands over — the past.’

1127

I am indebted for the following to Mr. Goodbehere, of — Birmingham ; it may be taken as typical of many similar cases :— My friend (Mr. James Canning, of Birmingham) was ac- — quainted with a small mongrel dog who on being presented with a penny or a halfpenny would run with it in his mouth to — a baker’s, jump on to the top of the half-door leading into the shop, and ring the bell behind the door until the baker came for- — ward and gave him a bun or a biscuit in exchange for the coi. — The dog-would accept any small biscuit for a halfpenny, but no- thing less than a bun would satisfy him for a penny. On one occasion the baker (being annoyed at the dog’s too frequent — visits), after receiving the ahs refused to give the dog any- ~

1128

thing in exchange, and on every future occasion the latter (who | declined being taken in a second time) would put the coin ou the floor, and not permit the baker to pick it up until he had re- ceived its equivalent. | My dog is a broken-haired rabbit-coursing dog, and is very intelligent. I took him one day to an exhibition of pictures and _ objects of interest, among which were statues and a bust of Sir Walter Scott. It was-a local exhibition, and as there was

1129

| jewellery, some one had to sit up all night with it as guard. I volunteered, and as we were looking about and sitting on a stand of flowers, my dog suddenly began to bark, and made as if he had found some one hiding. On looking round I found that it was the bust of Sir Walter Scott standing among the flowers, and in which he evidently recognised sufficient like- ness to a human being to think the supposed man had no business there at so late an hour.

1130

I adduce this instance because it serves as a sort of in- troduction to the more remarkable faculty which I cannot have the least doubt is manifested by some dogs—the faculty, namely, of recognising portraits as representing persons, or possibly of mistaking portraits for persons. A Dandie-Dinmont terrier, after the death of his mistress, was playing with some children in a room into which was brought a photograph (large) of her that he had never previously seen. It was placed upon the floor leaning against the wall, In the words of my informant, who witnessed it, the dog, when

1131

he suddenly caught sight of the picture, crouched ana trembled all over, his whole body quivering. Then he crept along the floor till he reached it, and, seating himself before it, began to bark loudly, as if he would say, ‘ Why don’t you speak to me?’ The picture was moved to other parts of the room, and he fol- lowed, seating himself before it and repeating his barking. Mr. Charles W. Peach also gives an account in ‘ Nature’ (vol. xx., p. 196) of a large dog recognising his portrait :— When it (the portrait) was brought to my house, my old dog was present with the family at the unveiling ; nothing was said to him, nor invitation given to him to notice it. We saw that ‘his gaze was steadily fixed on it, and he soon became excited and

1132

whined, and tried to lick and scratch it, and was so much taken — up with it that we—although so well knowing his intelligence— were all quite surprised—in fact, could scarcely believe that he should know it was my likeness. We, however, had sufficient proof after it was hung up in our parlour. The room was rather low, and under the picture stood a chair : the door was left open, without any thought about the dog; he, however, soon found it — out, when a low whining and scratching was heard by the ©

1133

family, and on search being made, he was in the chair trying to get at the picture. After this I put it up higher, so as to prevent its being injured by him. This did not prevent him from paying attention to it, for whenever I was away from home, whether for a short or a long time—sometimes for several days —he spent most of his time gazing on it, and as it appeared to give him comfort the door was always left open for him. When I was long away he made a low whining, as if to draw attention to it. This lasted for years—in fact, as long as he lived.

1134

From this account it appears that when in the first instance the dog’s attention was drawn to the picture it was on the floor in the line of the dog’s sight ; the behaviour of the animal then and subsequently was too marked and peculiar to admit of mistake. Another correspondent in ‘ Nature’ (vol. xx., p. 220), alluding to the previous letter, writes :— Having read Mr. Peach’s letter on ‘ Intellect in Brutes,’ as shown by the sagacity he witnessed in his dog, I have been asked to send a similar anecdote, which I have often told to friends. Many years ago’my husband had his portrait taken by J. Phillips, R.A., and subsequently went to India, leaving the portrait in London to be finished and framed. When it was sent home, about two years after it was taken, it was placed on the floor against the sofa, preparatory to being hung on the wall, We had then a very handsome black-and-tan setter, which was a great pet in the house. As soon as the dog came into the room he recognised his master, though he had not seen him for two years, and went up to the picture and licked the face. When this anecdote was told to Phillips, he said it was the highest compliment that had ever been paid him.

1135

Similarly, in the same periodical (vol. xx., p. 220), Mr. Henry Clark writes :— Some years ago a fine arts exhibition was held at Derby. A portrait of a Derby artist (Wright) was thus signalised :—‘ The artist’s pet dog distinguished this from a lot of pictures upon the floor of the studio by licking the face of the portrait.’ Again, I learn from Dr. Samuel Wilks, F.R.S., that a friend of his, whom I shall call Mrs. E., has aterrier which recognised her portrait. ‘The portrait is now (1881) hang- ing in the Royal Academy. When it first arrived home the dog barked at it, as it did at strangers; but after a day or two, when Mrs. E. opened the door to show the portrait to some friends, the dog went straight to the picture and licked the hand. The picture is a three- quarter length portrait of a lady with the hand at the bottom of the picture.’

1136

Lastly, my sister, whois a very conscientious and accu- rate observer, witnessed a most unmistakable recognition of portraits as representative of persons on the part of a small but intelligent terrier of her own. At my request she committed the facts to writing shortly after they occurred. The following is her statement of them :— I have a small terrier who attained the age of eight months without ever having seen a large picture. One day three nearly life-sized portraits were placed in my room during his absence. Two were hung up, and one left standing against the wall on the floor awaiting the arrival of apicture-rod. When the dog entered the room he appeared much alarmed by the sight of the pictures, barking in a terrified manner first at one and then at another. That is to say, instead of attacking them in an aggres- sive way with tail erect, as he would have done on thus encoun- tering a strange person, he barked violently and incessantly atsome distance from the paintings, with tail down and body elongated, sometimes bolting under the chairs and sofas in the extremity of his fear, and continuing barking from there. Thinking it might be merely the presence of strange objects in the room which excited him, I covered the faces of the portraits with cloths and turned the face of the one on the floor to the wall. The dog soon after emerged from his hiding-place, and having looked intently at the covered pictures and examined the back of the frame on the ground, became quite quiet and contented. I then uncovered one of the pictures, when he immediately flew at it, barking in the same frightened manner as before. I then re-covered that one and took the cover off another. The dog left the covered one and rushed at the one which was exposed. I then turned the face of the one on the floor to the room, and he

1137

flew at that with increased fierceness, This I did many times, covering and uncovering each picture alternately, always with the same result. It was only when all three paintings were uncovered at the same time, and he saw one looking at him in whatever direction he turned, that he became utterly terrified. He continued in this state for nearly an hour, at the end of which time, although evidently very nervous and apt to start, he ceased to bark. After that day he never took any more notice: of the pictures during the three months he remained in the house. He was then absent from the house for seven months. On his return he went with me into the room where the por- traits were hung, immediately on his arrival. He was evidently again much startled on first seeing them, for he rushed at one, barking as he had done on the first occasion, but he only gave three or four barks when he ran back to me with the same apologetic manner as he has when he has barked at a well- known friend by mistake.

1138

It will have been observed that in all these cases the portraits, when first recognised as bearing resemblance to human beings, were placed on the floor, or in the ordinary condition to the success of the recognition. That it cer- tainly was so in the case of my sister’s terrier was strikingly proved on a subsequent occasion, when she took the animal into a picture-shop where there were a number of portraits hanging round the walls, and also one of Car- lyle standing on the floor. The terrier did not heed those upon the walls, but barked excitedly at the one upon the ‘floor. This case was further interesting from the fact. that there were a number of purchasers in the shop who were, of course, strangers to the terrier ; yet he took no. notice of them, although so much excited by the picture. This shows that the pictorial illusion was not so complete. as to make the animal suppose the portrait to be a real person ; it was only sufficiently so to make it feel a sense of bewildered uncertainty at the kind of life-in-death appearance of the motionless representation.

1139

If, notwithstanding all this body of mutually corrobo-. rative cases, it is still thought incredible that dogs should. be able to recognise pictorial representations,! we should. 1 Since my MS, went to press I have myself met with a striking- do well to remember that this grade of mental evolution is reached very early in the psychical development of the human child. In my next work I shall adduce evidence to show that children of one year, or even less, are able to distinguish pictures as representations of particular objects, and will point at the proper pictures when asked to show these objects.

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.