Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 1140 to 1169 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

1140

Coming now to cases more distinctly indicative of reason in the strict sense of the word, numberless ordi- nary acts performed by dogs indisputably show that they possess this faculty. Thus, for instance, Livingstone gives the following observation.' A dog tracking his master along a road came to a place where three roads diverged. Scenting along two of the roads and not finding the trail, he ran off on the third without waiting to smell. Here, therefore, is a true act of inference. If the trackis not on A or B,it must be on C, there being no other alternative.

1141

Again, it is not an unusual thing for intelligent dogs, who know that their masters do not wish to take them out, to leave the house and run a long distance in the direction in which they suppose their masters are about to go, in order that when they are there found the distance may be too great for their masters to return home for the purpose of shutting them up. I have myself known several terriers that would do this, and one of the in- stances I shall give im extenso (quoted from an account which I published at the time in ‘ Nature’); for I think it displays remarkably complex processes of far-seeing calculation :—

1142

The terrier in question followed a conveyance from the house in which I resided in the country, to a town ten miles distant. He only did this on one occasion, and about five months afterwards was taken by train to the same town as a present to some friends there. Shortly afterwards I called upon these friends in a different conveyance from the one which the dog had previously followed ; but the latter may have known that the two conveyances belonged to the same display of the recognition of a portrait by a dog. The portrait was

1143

one of myself, and the dog a half-bred setter and retreiver of my own. 1 Missionary Travels, chap. i. house. Anyhow, after I had put up the horses at an inn, I ‘spent the morning with the terrier and his new masters, and dn the afternoon was accompanied by them to the inn, I -Should have mentioned that the inn was the same as that at which the conveyance had been put up on the previous occa- -sion, five months before. Now, the dog evidently remembered this, and, reasoning from analogy, inferred that I was about to return. This is shown by the fact that he stole away from our party—although at what precise moment he did so I cannot ‘say, but it was certainly after we had arrived at the inn, for ‘subsequently we all remembered his having entered the coffee- room with us. Now, not only did he infer from a single pre- cedent that I was going home, and make up his mind to go with me, but he also further reasoned thus :—‘As my previous master lately sent me to town, it is probable that he does not want ‘me to return to the country; therefore, if I am to seize this ‘opportunity of resuming my poaching life, I must now steal a march upon the conveyance. But not only so, my former master may possibly pick me up and return with me to my proper owners ; therefore I must take care only to intercept the conveyance at a point sufficiently far without the town to make sure that he will not think it worth his while to go back with me.’

1144

Complicated as this train of reasoning is, it is the simplest one I can devise to account for the fact that slightly beyond the third milestone the terrier was await- ing me, lying right in the middle of the road with his face towards the town. I should add that the second two miles of the road were quite straight, so that I could easily have seen the dog if he had been merely running a comparatively short distance in front of the horses. Why this animal should never have returned to his former home on his own account I cannot suggest, but I think it was merely due to an excessive caution which he also mani- fested in other things. However, be the explanation of this what it may, as a fact he never did venture to come back upon his own account, although there never was a sub- sequent occasion upon which any of his former friends went to the town but the terrier was seen to return with them, having always found some way of escape from his intended imprisonment.

1145

gist,’ vol. vii., p. 2338) of his terrier, which, on starting a water-rat out of reeds into the running stream, would not plunge directly after it, knowing that the rat would beat him at swimming. But the moment the rat plunged, the dog ran four or five yards down the bank, and there waited till the water-rat, being carried down stream, appeared upon the surface, when he pounced upon it successfully. Cases of this kind might be multiplied indefinitely, and they appear to show a true faculty of reason or inferring.

1146

A friend of mine, a naturalist, and a very conscientious man, whose word can be implicitly trusted, gives the following, to which he was an eye-witness. His grandfather, then a very old but hale and hearty man, had a splendid Newfoundland. There was a narrow and precipitous road leading from the fields to the house. It was regarded as a very dangerous place. One day when the old gentleman was doing some work about the farm his horse became alarmed, and started off with the waggon along this causeway. The chances were that he would dash himself and the empty waggon to pieces. At once the dog seemed to take in the situation, although until that time he had been impassive. He started after the horse at full speed, over- took him, caught the bridle, and by his strength arrested the frightened creature until help could reach him. My friend gives many other stories of this fine dog, and thinks he had a decided sense of humour. I will repeat that both of these tales come to me well authenticated, and I could, by seeking permission, give names and places.

1147

Couch gives the following, which is worth quoting, as showing the intelligence of dogs in attacking unusual prey :— On the first discovery of the prey (crabs) a terrier runs in to seize it, and is immediately and severely bitten in the nose. But a sedate Newfoundland dog of my acquaintance proceeds more soberly in his work. He lays his paw on it to arrest it in its escape ; then tumbling it over he bares his teeth, and, seizing it with the mouth, throws the crab aloft. It falls upon the stones; the shell is cracked beyond redemption, and then the dainty dish is devoured at his leisure.!

1148

I myself know a large dog in Germany which used to kill snakes by dexterously tossing them in the air a great | tear it in pieces. This dog can never have been poisoned by the bite of a snake; but he seems to have had an its bite than other animals; for while he was bold in fighting with dogs, and did not then object to receiving his fair share of laceration, he was extremely careful never to begin to tear a snake till he had thoroughly bewildered it |

1149

The reasoning displayed by dogs may not always be of a high order, but little incidents, from being of constant — occurrence among all dogs, are the more important as showing the reasoning faculty to be general. to these animals. I shall therefore give a few cases to show the kind of eas that is of constant occurrence. Mr. Stone writes to me from Norbury Park concerning two of his dogs, one large and the other small. Both being in a room at the same time,

1150

one of them, the larger, had a bone, and when he had left it the smaller dog went to take it, the larger one growled, and the other retired to a corner. Shortly afterwards the larger dog went out, but the other did not appear to notice this, and at any rate did not move. A few minutes later the large dog was heard to bark out of doors; the little dog then, without a moment’s hesitation, went straight to the bone and took it. It thus appears quite evident that she reasoned—‘ That dog is barking out of doors, therefore he is not in this room, therefore it is safe for me to take the bone.’ The action was so rapid as to be clearly a consequence of the other dog’s barking.

1151

Again, Mr. John Le Conte, writing from the Uni- versity of California, tells me of a dog which used to hunt rabbits in an extensive pasture-ground where there was a hollow tree, which frequently served as a place of refuge for the rabbits when they were pressed :-— On one occasion a rabbit was ‘started,’ and all of the dogs, with the exception of ‘ Bonus,’ dashed off in full pursuit. We were astonished to observe that the sedate ‘ Bonus,’ fore- going the intense excitement of the chase, deliberately trotted by a short cut to a hollow oak trunk, and crouching at its base calmly awaited the advent of the fleeing rabbit. And he was not disappointed (they frequently escaped without being reduced to this extremity), for the pursuing dogs pressed the rabbit so hard that, after making a long detour, it made for the place of refuge. As it was about entering the hollow trunk, _ the crouching ‘ Bonus’ captured the astonished rodent.

1152

Similarly, Dr. Andrew Wilson, F.R.S.E., writes me as follows :— There is a shrubbery near the house, about 200 or 300 yards long, and running in the shape of a horseshoe. A small terrier used to start a rabbit nearly every morning, at the end of the shrubbery next the house, and hunt him through the whole length of it to the other end, where the rabbit escaped into an - old drain. The dog then appears to have come to the conclusion that the chord of a circle is shorter than its arc, for he raised the rabbit again, and instead of following him through the shrubbery as usual, he took the short cut to the drain, and was ready and in waiting on the rabbit when he arrived, and caught him. |

1153

I was watching the operations of a little Skye terrier on a wheatstack which was in the course of being thrashed, when suddenly a very large rat bounced off, just from under Fan’s nose. It darted into a pit of water about a dozen yards from the stack, and tried to escape. Fan, however, plunged after, and swam for some distance, but found she was being left be- hind. So she turned to the shore again and ran round to the other side of the pit, and was ready and caught it just on landing.

1154

I never saw anything more remarkable. If it was not rea- son, L do not know how it is possible that it could come much more closely to the exercise of that faculty. spent a winter in Alaska, he ‘had a good opportunity to study animal intelligence in the Eskimo dogs,’ and he reports it as ‘a fact of common occurrence,’ when the dogs are drawing sledges on the ice near the coast, that on coming to sinuosities in the coast-line, they spon- taneously leave the beaten track and strike out so as to ‘cut across the windings by going straight from point to point’ of land. This is frequently done even when the leading dog ‘could not see the whole winding of the beaten track; he seemed to reason that the route must lead around the headlands, and that he could economise travel by cutting across.’

1155

It will be remembered in connection with these dogs, that Mr. Darwin in the ‘ Descent of Man’ (p. 75) quotes Dr. Hayes, who, in his work on ‘The Open Polar Sea,’ ‘repeatedly remarks that his dogs, instead of continuing to draw the sledges in a compact body, diverged and separated when they came to thin ice, so that their weight might be more evenly [and widely |distributed. This was. the ice was becoming thin and dangerous.’ Mr, Darwin remarks, ‘ This instinct may possibly have arisen since the time, long ago, when dogs were first employed by the

1156

the parent stock of the Esquimaux dog, may have ac- quired an instinct, impelling them not to attack their prey in a close pack when on thin ice.’ One morning, soon after his usual time for starting, I saw the dog looking anxiously about, evidently afraid that my brother had gone without him. He looked into the room where we had breakfasted, but my brother was not there. He went up two or three stairs, and listened attentively. Then, to my astonishment, he came down, and going to the hat-stand in the hall, stood on his hind legs and sniffed at the great-coats. hanging there, undoubtedly trying to ascertain whether my brother’s coat was there or not.

1157

My cat had kittens, of which two were preserved, the rest being drowned. The dog tolerated the two kittens, but did not care about them with any friendship. When the kittens were a few weeks old, I—finding that I could get but one of them off my hands—determined to kill the other, and, as the quickest mode of death, to shoot it by a pistol close behind its head. The dog saw me do this in my garden, and in a few minutes after- wards she appeared with the other kitten dead in her mouth; she had killed it. If that was not reasoning I do not know what is.

1158

Mr. W. F. Hooper writes me of a Newfoundland dog that was in the habit of accompanying the nursemaid and baby belonging to its mistress. On one occasion a keen wind began to blow, and the nursemaid drew her shawl over the child :-— The nursemaid had not taken many steps towards home before her progress was barred by the dog, who placed himself in the centre of the path and growled whenever she advanced. She was much alarmed, and tried to coax the dog to move, but: Leo would not, and abated nothing of the hostile display. Half _ an hour passed, and the girl became nearly distracted. What - could be the matter with the dog? Was she to be a prisoner: all day? Would the animal fly at her throat? Was Leo suffer- ing from hydrophobia? ‘These and similar questions crossed the- girl’s mind. At length a suggestion of despair—it was nothing: more—occurred to her. She thought it might win the dog round to good humour if she showed it the baby ; so she removed the folds of her shawl and presented it at arm’s length to the- dog. The result was magical, and far in excess of all expecta- tion, for not only did the dog cease to growl, but he began to. gambol and caress, and removed himself from the path altogether, so that there was now a free course, and home was soon reached. The explanation of the whole affair is, when the nursemaid turned on her path thinking she had gone sufficiently far, the. dog missed sight of the baby, and believed it was gone. Under this impression the dog converted himself into a sentinel, with the resolve that not one step should be taken towards home. without the baby ; and faithfully did the animal keep watch and ward until the demonstration was given that the child had not been left behind, but was still in the nurse’s arms alive and well. I think this is an exhibition of intelligence worthy of being known to you.

1159

I extract the following instance from Col. Hutchinson’s ‘Dog-breaking.’ It is briefly alluded to in the ‘ Descent of Man.’ The observer and narrator is Mr. Colquhoun :— long shots across a pretty broad stream, I stopped a mallard with each barrel, but both were only wounded. I sent him across for the birds. He first attempted to bring them both, — but one always struggled out of his mouth: he then laid down to cross to me, the bird left fluttered into the water; he im- —

1160

mediately returned again, laid down the first on the shore and recovered the other. The first now fluttered away, but he instantly secured it, and, standing over them both, seemed to cogitate for a moment; then, although on any other occasion he never ruffles a feather, deliberately killed one, brought over ‘the other, and then returned for the dead bird. The following, communicated to me by Mr. Blood, isa closely analogous, and therefore confirmatory case. He was out shooting with a companion, and three wild ducks ‘were simultaneously dropped into a lake—one falling dead and the other two winged. Mr. Blood sent in his spaniel to retrieve, /

1161

and of course when the wounded birds saw her coming they swam out, so that she first reached the dead duck. She swam up to it, paused fora moment, and passing it went after the nearest wounded bird. Having caught this, she again hesitated, _and apparently after consideration she gave it a chop and let it go, quieted for the present. She then caught and brought to land the other wounded duck, and going back she again reached the dead bird ; but looking at the other and seeing that it was again moving, she went out and brought it in, and last of all brought the dead bird. The dog was a first-rate retriever and never injured game, so that it was an entirely new thing for her ‘to kill a bird.

1162

Can we conceive any human being reasoning more correctly than a dog did in the following instance ? Towards the evening of a long day’s snipe-shooting on Dartmoor, the party was walking down the bank of the Dart, when my retriever flushed -a widgeon which fell to my gun in the river, and of course ‘instantly dived, I said no word to the dog, He did not plunge into the river then, but galloped down stream some fifty or sixty yards, and then entered and dashed from side to side— it was about twenty or thirty feet wide—working up stream, and making a great commotion in the water until he came to the place where we stood. Then he landed and shook himself, and carefully hunted the near bank a considerable distance

1163

down, crossed to the opposite side, and diligently explored that bank. Two or three minutes elapsed, and the party was for moving on, when I called their attention to a sudden change in the dog’s demeanour. His ‘flag’ was now up and going from side to side in that energetic manner which, as every sportsman knows, betokéns a hot scent, I then knew that the bird was as safe as if it was already in my bag. Away through the heather went the waving tail, until twenty or thirty yards from the bank opposite to that on which we were standing there was a momentary scuffle; the bird just rose from the ground above the heather, the dog sprang into the air, caught it, came away at full gallop, dashed across the stream, and delivered it into my hands. Need I interpret all this for the experienced sportsman 4 The dog had learned from long experience in Australia and the narrow cafiadas in the La Plata that a wounded duck goes down stream ; if winged, his maimed wing sticks out and renders it impossible for him to go up, so he will invariably land and try to hide away from the bank. But if the dog enters at the place where the bird fell, the latter will go on with the stream for an indefinite distance, rising now and then for breath, and give infi- nite trouble. My dog had found out all this long since, and had proved the correctness of his knowledge times out of number, and by his actions had taught me the whole art and mystery of retrieving duck. His object, I say without a doubt, because I had numberless opportunities of observing it, was to fling the bird and force it to land by cutting it off lower down the stream. Then assuming, as his experience justified him, that the bird had landed, he hunted each bank in succession for the trail, which he knew must betray the fugitive.

1164

As showing in a higher, and therefore rarer degree, the: ratiocinative faculty in dogs, I may quote a brief ex- tract from my British Association lecture :— master to church on alternate Sundays. To do so he had to swim a channel about a mile wide; and before taking to the water he used to run about a mile to the north when the tide was flowing, and a nearly equal distance to the south when the tide was ebbing, ‘ almost invariably calculating his distance so well that he landed at the nearest point to the church.’ In his letter to me Dr. Rae continues: ‘ How the dog managed to calculate the strength of the spring and neap tides at their

1165

various rates of speed, and always to swim at the proper angle, is most surprising.’ As a confirmatory case, I may also quote an extract. from a letter sent me by Mr. Percival Fothergill. Writing of a retriever which he has, he says :— I have seen her spring overboard from our gangway 16 feet — from the water-line. The tides ran more than 5 knots, and she invariably came down to a little wharf abreast the ship, and — gazed intently for small pieces of stick or straw, and having thus ascertained the drift of the tide (did as you mention of another dog), ran up tide and swam off. The sentry on the ~ forecastle always kept a look-out for the dog, and threw over a line with a bowling knot, and she was hauled on board.

1166

But one day she was observed to wait an unusual time on the wharf ; no wood or straw gave her the required information. After waiting some time, she lay down on the planks, and dropped one paw into the water, and found by the feel which way the tide ran, got up, and ran up stream as usual. Mr. George Cook writes me that he recently had a pointer, which one morning, when the grass was covered with frost, dragged a mat out of his kennel, from which he had got loose, to the lawn beneath the house windows, where he was found lying upon the mat, which thus served to protect him from the frost. The distance over which he — had dragged the mat for this purpose was about 100 yards. Mr. Cook adds: ‘I have since frequently seen him bring this mat out of his kennel and lay it in the sunshine, shifting it if a shadow came upon the place where he had laid it.’

1167

The following is sent me by the Rey. F. J. Penky. He gives me the name of his friend the canon, but does not give me express permission to publish it. In quoting his account, therefore, I leave this name blank. He says :-— The following is an instance of sagacity—indeed, amount- ing to reason—in a dog, a French poodle that belonged to Colonel Pearson (not the lately beleaguered colonel at Ekowe, but a Colonel Pearson living some years ago at Lichfield). The circumstance happened toa friend of mine, Canon. ; rector of I have the story from his own lips, but I have no permission for his name to be used in any publication, should

1168

the story be thought worthy of it. My friend the canon, I may say, has no leanings. Being a guest at luncheon with the dog’s master, my friend fed the dog with pieces of beef. After luncheon the beef was taken into the larder. The dog did not think he had his fair share. What did he do? Now he had been taught to stand on his hind legs, put his paw on a lady’s wrist, and hand her into the dining-room. He adopted the same tactics with my friend the canon, stood on his hind legs, put his paw on his arm, and made for the door. To see what would follow, Canon suffered himself to be led; but the sagacious dog, instead of steering for the dining-room, led him in the direction of the larder, along a passage, down steps, &c., and did not halt till he brought him to the larder, and close to the shelf where the beef had been put. The dog had a small bit given him for his sagacity, and Canon returned to the drawing-room. But the dog was still not satisfied. He tried the same trick again, but this time fruitlessly. The canon was not going again with him to thelarder. What was Mori to do? And here comes the instance of reason in the poodle. Finding he could not prevail on the visitor to make a second excursion to the larder, he went out into the hall, took in his teeth Canon ’s hat from off the hall table, and carried it under the shelf in the larder, where the coveted beef lay out of his reach. There he was found with the hat, waiting for the owner of the hat, and expecting another savoury bit when he should come for his hat.

1169

Many anecdotes might be adduced of the cleverness which some dogs show in finding their way by train; but I shall give only three, and I select these, not only be- cause they all mutually corroborate one another, but like- wise because they all display such high intelligence on the Last year we spent our holidays at Llan Bedr, Merioneth- shire. Our host has a house in the above village, and another at Harlech, a town three miles distant. His favourite dog, Nero, is of Norwegian birth, and a highly intelligent animal. He is at liberty to pass his time at either of the houses owned by his master, and he occasionally walks from one to the other. More frequently, however, he goes to the railway station at Llan Bedr, gets into the train, and jumps out at Harlech. Being most probably unable to get out of the carriage, he was

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.