Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 150 to 179 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

150

The facts also show that the yielding of the secretion to the ants is, as it were, a voluntary act on the part of the aphides, or, perhaps more correctly, that the instinct to. yield it has been developed in such a relation to the re- quirements of the ants, that the peculiar stimulation sup- plied by the antennz of the latter is necessary to start the act of secretion ; for in the absence of this particular stimu- lation the aphides will never excrete until compelled to do so by the superabundance of the accumulating secretion. The question, therefore, directly arises how, on evolutionary

151

principles, such a class of facts is to be met ; for it is cer- tainly difficult to understand the manner in which this instinct, so beneficial to the ants, can have arisen in the aphides, to which it does not appear, at first sight, to offer any advantages. Mr. Darwin meets the difficulty thus: * Although there is no evidence that any animal performs an action for the exclusive good of another species, yet each tries to take advantage of the instincts of others ;’ and ‘as the secretion is extremely viscid, it is no doubt a convenience to the aphides to have it removed; therefore probably they do not excrete solely for the good of the ants.’!

152

Some ants which keep aphides build covered ways, or _ tunnels, to the trees or shrubs where the aphides live. _ Forel saw a tunnel of this kind which was taken up a wall _-and down again on the other side, in order to secure a safe covered way from the nest to theaphides. Occasion- ally such covered ways, or tubes, are continued so as to enclose the stems of the plants on which the aphides live. ‘The latter are thus imprisoned by the walls of the tube, which, however, expand where they take on this additional function of stabling the aphides, so that these insects are really confined in tolerably large chambers. The doors of these chambers are too small to allow the aphides to escape, while large enough for the ants to pass in and out. Forel saw such a prison or stable shaped like a cocoon, and about a centimétre long, which was hanging on the branch of a tree, and contained aphides carefully tended by the ants. Huber records similar observations.

153

Sir John Lubbock has made an interesting addition to our knowledge respecting this habit as practised by a certain species of ant (Lasiws flavus), which departs in a very remarkable manner from the habit as practised by other species. He says: ‘ The ants took the greatest care of these eggs, carrying them off to the lower chambers with the utmost haste when the nest was disturbed.’ But the most interesting of Sir John Lubbock’s observations in this connection is new, and reveals an astonishing

154

amount of method shown by the ants in farming their aphides. He says :— | When my eggs hatched I naturally thought that the aphides — belonged to one of the species usually found on the roots of plants in the nests of Lasius flavus. To my surprise, however, — the young creatures made the best of their way out of the nest, — and, indeed, were sometimes brought out by the ants them- selves, In vain I tried them with roots of grass, &c.; they wandered uneasily about, and eventually died. Moreover, they

155

._ did not in any way resemble the subterranean species. In 1878 I again attempted to rear these young aphides ; but though I hatched a great many eggs, I did not succeed. This year, how- ever, I have been more fortunate. The eggs commenced to hatch the first week in March. Near one of my nests of Lasius flavus, in which I had placed some of the eggs in question, was a glass containing living specimens of several species of plants commonly found on or around ants’ nests. To this some of the young aphides were brought by the ants. Shortly after- wards I observed on a plant of daisy, in the axils of the leaves, some small aphides, very much resembling those from my nest, though we had not actually traced them continuously. They seemed thriving, and remained stationary on the daisy. More- over, whether they had sprung from the black eggs or not, the ants evidently valued them, for they built up a wall of earth round and over them. So things remained throughout the summer, but on October 9 I found that the aphides had laid some eggs exactly resembling those found in the ants’ nests; and on examining daisy plants from outside, I found on many of them similar aphides, and more or less of the same eggs.

156

i confess these observations surprised me very much, The statements of Huber have not, indeed, attracted so much notice as many of the other interesting facts which he has recorded ; because if aphides are kept by ants in their nests, it seems only natural that their eggs should also occur. The above case, however, is much more remarkable. Here are aphides, not living in the ants’ nests, but outside, on the leaf-stalks of plants. The eggs are laid early in October on the food-plant of the in- sect. They are of no direct use to the ants, yet they are not left where they are laid, where they would be exposed to the severity of the weather and to innumerable dangers, but brought into their nests by the ants, and tended by them with the ut- most care through the long winter months until the following March, when the young ones are brought out and again placed

157

on the young shoots of the daisy. This seems to me a most remarkable case of prudence. Our ants may not perhaps lay up food for the winter, but they do more, for they keep during six months the eggs which will enable them to procure food during the following summer. | The following, which is taken from Biichner’s ‘Geistesleben der Thiere’ is perhaps a still more striking performance of the same kind as that which Sir John Lubbock observed :— _ The author is debtor to Herr Nottebohm, Inspector of Build- ings at Karlsruhe, who related the following on May 24, 1876, under the title, ‘ Ants as Founders of Aphides’ Colonies : ’—‘ Of two equally strong young weeping ashes, which I planted in my garden at Kattowitz, in Upper Silesia, one succeeded well, and

158

- in about five or six years showed full foliage, while the other regularly every year was covered, when it began to bud, with millions of aphides, which destroyed the young leaves and sprouts, and thus completely delayed the development of the tree. As I perceived that the only reason for this was the action of the aphides, J determined to destroy them utterly. So in the March of the following year I took the trouble to clean and wash every bough, sprig,and bud before the bursting of the latter, with the greatest care, by means of a syringe. The result was that the tree developed perfectly healthy and vigor- ous leaves and young shoots, and remained quite free from the aphides until the end of May or the beginning of June. My joy was of short duration. One fine sunny morning I saw a surprising number of ants running quickly up and down the trunk of the tree; this aroused my attention, and led me to look more closely. To my great astonishment I then saw that many troops of ants were busied in carrying single aphides up the stem to the top, and that in this way many of the lower leaves had been planted with colonies of aphides. After some weeks the evil was as great as ever. The tree stood alone on the grass plot, and offered the only situation for an aphides’ colony for the countless ants there present. I had destroyed this colony ; but the ants replanted it by bringing new colonists from distant branches, and setting them on the young leaves.!

159

MacCook noticed, of the mound-making ants, that of the 1 Zoe. cit. p. 121. workers returning to the nest from the tree on which the milk- ing was going on, a far smaller number had distended abdomens than among those descending the tree itself. A closer investi- gation showed that at the roots of the trees, at the outlets of the subterranean galleries, a number of ants were assembled, which were fed by the returning ants after the fashion already described in feeding the larve, and which were distinguished by the observer as ‘pensioners.’ MacCook often observed the same fact later, among, with others, the already described Pennsylvanian wood-ant. Distinguished individuals in the body-guard of the queen were fed in like fashion. MacCook is inclined to think that the reason of this proceeding is to be found in the ‘division of labour’ so general in the ant repub- lic, and that the members of the community which are em- ployed in building and working within the nest, leave to the others the care of providing food for themselves as well as for the younger and helpless members ; they thus have a claim to receive from time to time a reciprocal toll of gratitude, and take it, as is shown very clearly, in a way demanded by the welfare of the community,!

160

Aphides are not the only insects which ants employ as cows, several other insects which yield sweet secretions being similarly utilised in various parts of the world. Thus, gall insects and cocci are kept in just the same way as aphides; but MacCook observed that where aphides and cocci are kept by the same ants, they are kept in separate chambers, or stalls. The same observer saw caterpillars of the genus Lycena kept by ants for the sake of a sweet secretion which they supply.

161

Habit of making Slaves.—This habit, or instinct, obtains among at least three species of ant, viz., Formica rufescens, F. sanguinea, and strongylognathus. It was originally observed by P. Huber in the first-named species, Here the species enslaved is F’. fusca, which is appropriately coloured black. The slave-making ants attack a nest of F. fusca in a body; there is a great fight with much slaughter, and, if victorious, the slave-makers carry off the pup of the vanquished nest in order to hatch them out as slaves. Mr. Darwin gives an account of a battle which he himself observed.”

162

When the pupz hatch out in the nest of their captors, the young slaves begin their life of work, and seem to regard their master’s home as their own; for they never attempt to escape, and they fight no less keenly than their masters in defence of the nest. F. sanguimea content themselves with fewer slaves than do F. rufescens; and the work that devolves upon the slaves differs according to the species which has enslaved them. In the nests of F. sanguinea the comparatively few captives are kept as household slaves; they never either enter or leave the nest, and so are never seen unless the nest is opened. They are then very conspicuous from the contrast which their black colour and small size present to the red colour and much larger size of F. rufescens. As the slaves are by this species kept strictly indoors, all the outdoor work of foraging, slave-capturing, &c., is performed by the masters ; and when for any reason a nest has to migrate, the masters carry their slaves in their jaws. J. rufescens, on the other hand, assigns a much larger share of labour to the slaves, which, as we have already seen, are present in much larger numbers to take it. In this species the males and fertile females do no work of any kind; and the workers, or sterile females, though most energetic in capturing slaves, do no other kind of work. Therefore the whole community is absolutely dependent upon its slaves. The masters are not able to make their own nests or to feed their own larve. When they migrate, it is the slaves that determine the migration, and, reversing the order of things that obtains in F. sanguimea, carry their masters in their jaws. Huber shut up thirty masters without a slave and with abundance of their favourite food, and also with their own larve and pupe as a stimulus to work; but they could not feed even themselves, and many died of hunger.

163

He then introduced a single slave, and she at once set to work, fed the surviving masters, attended to the larvee, and made some cells. ~ In order to confirm this observation, Lespés placed a piece of sugar near a nest of slave-makers. It was soon found by one of the slaves, which gorged itself and re- turned to the nest. Other slaves then came out and did likewise. Then some of the masters came out, and, by pulling the legs of the feeding slaves, reminded them that they were neglecting their duty. The slaves then imme- diately began to serve their masters with the sugar. Forel also has contirmed all these observations of Huber. Indeed, in the case of ’. rufescens, the structure of the animal is such as to render self-feeding physically impossible. Its long and narrow jaws, adapted to pierce the head of an enemy, do not admit of being used for feeding, unless liquid food is poured into them by the mouth of a slave. This fact shows of how ancient an origin the instinct of slave-making must be; it has altered in an important manner a structure which could not have been so altered prior to the establishment of the instinct in question.

164

Mr. Darwin thus sums up the differences in the offices of the slaves in the nests of F’. sanguinea and F. rufescens respectively :— The latter does not build its own nest, does not determine its own migrations, does not collect food for itself or for its fellows, and cannot even feed itself ; itis‘absolutely dependent on its nu- merous slaves. ormica sanguinea, on the other hand, possesses much fewer slaves, and in the early part of the summer extremely few ; the masters determine when and where a new nest shall be formed, and when they migrate, the masters carry the slaves. Both in Switzerland and England the slaves seem to have the exclusive care of the larve, and the masters alone go on slave- making expeditions. In Switzerland the slaves and masters work together, making and bringing materials for the nest; both, but chiefly the slaves, tend and milk, as it may be called, their aphides ; and thus both collect food for the community. In England the masters alone usually leave the nest to collect building materials and food for themselves, their slaves and larve. So that the masters in this country receive much less service from their slaves than they do in Switzerland.

165

Mr. Darwin further observes that ‘this difference in the usual habits of the masters and slaves in the two countries probably depends merely on the slaves being captured in greater numbers in Switzerland than in Eng- land ;’ and records that he has observed in a community of the English species having an unusually large stock of slaves that ‘a few slaves mingled with their masters leaving the nest, and marched along the same road to a tall Scotch fir tree, twenty-five yards distant, which they ascended together, probably in search of aphides or cocci.’ And, according to Huber, the principal office of the slaves in Switzerland is to search for aphides.

166

Mr. Darwin also made the following observation :— ‘ Desiring to ascertain whether F. sanguimea could dis- tinguish the pupe of F. fusca, which they habitually make into slaves, and which are an unwarlike species, from F. flava, which they rarely capture, and never without a severe fight,’ he found ‘it was evident that they did at once distinguish them ;’ for while ‘they eagerly and instantly seized the pupze of F. fusca, they were much terrified when they came across the pupe, or even the earth from the nest, of F. flava, and quickly ran away; but in about a quarter of an hour, shortly after the little yellow ants had crawled away (from their nest having been disturbed by Mr. Darwin), they took heart and carried off the pupe.’

167

Concerning the origin of this remarkable instinct, Mr. Darwin writes :— As ants which are not slave-makers will, as I have seen, carry off pup of other species if scattered near their nests, it is possible that such pupz originally stored as food might be- come developed, and the foreign ants thus unintentionally reared would then follow their proper instincts, and do what work they could. Iftheir presence proved useful to the species which had seized them—if it were more advantageous to the spe- cies to capture workers than to procreate them—the habit of collecting pups, originally for food, might by natural selection be strengthened and rendered permanent for the very different purpose of raising slaves. When the instinct was once acquired, if carried out to a much less extent even than in our British F’. sanguinea, which, as we have seen, is less aided by its slaves than the same species in Switzerland, natural selection might increase and modify the instinct, always supposing such modifi- cation to be of use to the species, until an ant was found as abjectly dependent on its slave as is the Yormica rufescens.

168

Ants do not appear to be the only animals of which ants make slaves; for there seems to be at least one case in which these wonderful insects enslave insects of another species, which therefore may be said to stand to the ants in the relation of beasts of burden. The case to which I allude is one that is recorded in Perty’s ‘ Intellectual Life of Animals’ (2nd ed. p. 329), and is as follows :— According to Audubon certain leaf-bugs are used as slaves by the ants in the Brazilian forests, When these ants want to bring home the leaves which they have bitten off the trees, they do it by means of a column of these bugs, which go in

169

pairs, kept in order on either side by accompanying ants. They - compel stragglers to re-enter the ranks, and laggards to keep up by biting them. After the work is done the bugs are shut up within the colony and scantily fed. Wars.—On the wars of ants a great deal might be said, as the facts of interest in this connection are very nume- rous; but for the sake of brevity I shall confine myself to giving only a somewhat meagre account. One great cause of war is the plundering of ants’ nests by the slave-making species. Observers all agree that this plundering is effected by a united march of the whole army composing a nest of the slave-making species, directed against some particular nest of the species which they enslave. According to Lespés and Forel, single scouts or small companies are first sent out from the nest to ex- plore in various directions for a suitable nest to attack. These scouts afterwards serve as guides to the marauding excursion. Forel saw several of these scouts of the species F. rufescens or Amazon carefully inspecting a nest of F. fusca which they had found, investigating especially the entrances. These are purposely made difficult to find by their architects, and it not unfrequently happens that after all precautions and inspections on the part of the invaders, an expedition fails on account of not finding the city gates.

170

When the scouts have been successful in discovering a suitable nest to plunder, and have completed their stra- tegical investigations of the locality to their satisfaction, they return straight to their own nest or fortress. Forel has then seen them walking about on the surface of their nest for a long time, as if in consultation, or making up after which hosts of warriors streamed out of the entrances, and ran about tapping each other with their heads and antenne. They then formed into column and set out to pillage the nest of the slave ants. The following is the account which Lespés gives of such expeditions :—

171

They only take place towards the end of the summer and in autumn. At this time the winged members of the slave species (Ff. fusca and J. cunicularia) have left the nest, and the Amazons will not take the trouble to bring back useless con-. sumers. When the sky is clear our robbers leave their town in the afternoon at about three or four o’clock. At first no order is perceptible in their movements, but when they are all gathered together they form a regular column, which then moves forward quickly, and each day in a different direction. They march closely pressed together, and the foremost always appear

172

moment overtaken by others, so that the head of the column is continually growing. They are in fact seeking the traces of the ants which they propose to plunder, and it is scent that guides them, They snuff over the ground like hounds following the track of a wild animal, and when they have found it they plunge headlong forward, and the whole column rushes on be- hind. The smallest armies I saw consisted of several hundred individuals, but I have also seen some four times as large. They then form columns which may be five métres long, and as much as fifty centimétres wide. After a march, which often lasts a full hour, the column arrives at the nest of the slave species. The /. cwniculariw, which are the strongest, offer keen opposition, but without much result. The Amazons soon penetrate within the nest, to come out again a moment later, while the assailed ants at the same time rush out in masses. During the whole time attention is directed solely to the larvee and pups, which the Amazons steal while the others try to save as many as possible. They know very well that the Ama- zons cannot climb, so they fly with their precious burdens to the surrounding bushes or plants, whereto their enemies cannot follow them. ‘They then pursue the retreating robbers and try to take away from them as much of their booty as possible. But the latter do not trouble themselves much about them, and hasten on home. On their return they do not follow the short- est road, but exactly the one by which they came, finding their way back by smell. Arrived at their nest, they immediately

173

hand over their booty to the slaves, and trouble themselves no more about it. A few days afterwards the stolen pup or nymphe emerge, without memory of their childhood, and imme- diately and without compulsion take part in all tasks. From time to time the army makes a short halt, partly to let the rearguard close up, partly because different opinions arise as to the direction of the host, or because the place at which they are is unknown to them. Forel several times saw the army completely lose its way—an incident only once ob- served by Huber. Forel puts the number of warriors in such an army at from one hundred to more than two thousand. Its speed is on an average a métre per minute, but varies much according to circumstances, and is naturally least when return- ing laden with booty. If the distance be very great, such bodily fatigue may at last be felt that the whole attack on the hostile nest is given up, and a retreat is begun; Forel once saw this happen after they had passed over a distance of two hun- dred and forty yards. Sometimes it seems as though, on coming within sight of the hostile nest, a kind of discouragement took possession of them, and prevented their making the attack. If the nest cannot at once be found, the whole army halts, and - some divisions are sent forward to search for it, and these are gradually seen returning towards the centre. Forel also saw such an army only searching the first day, advancing zigzag, and with frequent halts, whereas on the following day it went forward to its aim swiftly and without delay, having found out the road. It seems that a single ant, even if it knows the way and the place, is not able alone to lead a large army, but that a considerable number must be employed in this duty. Mistakes as to the road occur with special ease during the return journey, because the several ants are laden with booty and cannot readily understand each other. Individual ants are then seen to wander about in every direction often for a long time, until they at last reach a spot known to them, and then advance swiftly to their goal. Many never come back at all.

174

These mistakes easily occur when the robbers which have passed into a hostile nest do not come out again at the same holes whereby they entered, but by others at some distance—for instance, by a subterranean canal, Coming out thus in astrange neighbourhood, they do not know which way to take, and only some chance to find the right road during their aimless wanderings about, and recognise and follow it by smell. On the other hand, such mistakes scarcely ever happen to individuals in an unladen train, kept in good array. Other species of ants (7. fusca, rufa, sanguinea) know better how to manage under such circumstances than do the Amazons. The laden ones lay down their loads, first find where ‘they are, and only take them up again after they have found their way. If the booty seized in the nest first attacked is too large to be all taken at once, the robbers return once, or oftener, so as to complete their work..... The ants, as already said, have no regular leaders nor chiefs, yet it is certain that in each expedition, alteration of road, or other change, the decision during that event comes from a small knot of individuals, which have previously come to an understanding, and carry the rest and the undecided along with them. These do not always follow immediately, but only after they have received several taps on the head from the members of the ‘ring.’ The pro- cession does not advance until the leaders have convinced them- selves by their own eyesight that the main part of the army is following.

175

One day Forel saw some Amazons on the surface of a nest of the J. fusca seeking and sounding in all directions, without being able to find the entrance. At last one of them found a very little hole, hardly as large as a pin’s head, through which the robbers penetrated. .But since, owing to the smallness of the hole, the invasion went on slowly, the search was continued, and an entrance was found further off, through which the Amazon army gradually disappeared. All was quiet. About five minutes later Forel saw a booty-laden column emerge from each hole. Not a single ant was without a load. The two columns united outside and retreated together.

176

A. marauding excursion of the Amazons against the JF. rufibarbis, a sub-species of the J. fusca, or small black ants, took place as follows :—The vanguard of the robber army found that it had reached the neighbourhood of the hostile nest’ more quickly than it had expected; for it halted suddenly and de- eidedly, and sent a number of messengers which brought up the main body and the rearguard with incredible speed. In less than thirty seconds the whole army had closed up, and hurled itself in a mass on the dome of the hostile nest. This was the more necessary as the rujibarbes during the short halt had dis- covered the approach of the enemy, and had utilised the time to cover the dome with defenders. An indescribable struggle followed, but the superior numbers of the Amazons overcame, and they penetrated into the nest, while the defenders poured

177

by thousands out of the same holes, with their larve and pups — in their jaws, and escaped to the nearest plants and bushes, running over the heaps of their assailants. These looked on the matter as hopeless, and began to retreat. But the ruf- barbes, furious at their proceedings, pursued them, and en- deavoured to get away from them the few pupz they had ob- tained, by trying to seize the Amazons’ legs and to snatch away the pups. The Amazon lets its jaws slip slowly along the captive pupa, as far as the head of its opponent, and pierces it, if it does not, as generally happens, draw back. But it often manages to seize the pupa at the instant at which the Amazon lets it go and flies with it. This is managed yet more easily when a comrade holds the robber by the legs, and compels it to: loose its prey in order to guard itself against its assailant. Sometimes the robbers seize empty cocoons and carry them away, but they leave them on the road when they have dis- covered their mistake. In the above case the strength of the rufibarbes proved at last so great that the rearguard of ‘the re- treating army was seriously | pressed, and was obliged to give up: its booty. A number of the Amazons also were overpowered and killed, but not without the rufibarbes also losing many people. None the less did some individuals, as though despe- rate, rush into the thickest hosts of the enemy, penetrated again into the nest, and carried off several pupz by sheer au- dacity and skill. Most of them left their prey to go to the help of their comrades when assailed by the rufibarbes. Ten minutes after the commencement of the retreat all the Amazons had left the nest, and, being swifter than their opponents, they were only pursued for about halfway back. Their attack had failed on account of a short delay !

178

On another occasion observed by Forel, in which several fertile Amazons also took part and killed many enemies, the nest was thoroughly ravished, but the retreat was also in this case very much disturbed and harassed by the superior numbers of the enemy. There were many slain on both sides. That in spite of the above-mentioned unanimity different opinions among the members of an expedition sometimes hinder its conduct, the following observation seems to show :—An advancing column divided after it had gone about ten yards from the nest. Half turned back, while the other half went on, but after some time hesitated and also turned back. Arrived at home, it found those which had formerly turned back putting themselves in motion in a new direction. The newly returned followed them, and the reunited army, after various wheelings, halts, &c., at

179

_ last turned home again by a long way round. The whole busi- ‘ ness looked like a promenade. But apparently different parties had different nests in view, while others were entirely against the expedition. Yet perhaps it was only a march for exercise. Outer obstacles do not, as a rule, hinder the Amazons when _ they are once on the march. Forel saw them wade through some shallow water, although many were drowned in it, and _ then march over a dusty high road, although the wind blew half of them away. As they returned, booty-laden, neither wind, nor dust, nor water could make ‘them lay down their _ prey. They only got back with great trouble, and turned back _ again to bring fresh booty, although many lost their lives.

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.