Animal Intelligence
into the water, is ‘in part to be rid of them, and partly, perhaps, with a view to effecting a possible cure; forI — have seen one ant carry another down the twig which formed their path to the surface of the water, and, after ‘dipping it in for a minute, carry it laboriously up again, -and lay it in the sun to dry and recover.’ But that some species of ants display marked signs -of what we may call sympathy even towards healthy com- panions in distress, is proved by the following observation of Mr. Belt. He writes :'—
One day, watching a small column of these ants (ie. Eciton humata), I placed a little stone on one of them to se- -cure it. The next that approached, as soon as it discovered its ‘situation, ran backwards in an agitated manner, and soon com- municated the intelligence to the others. They rushed to the rescue ; some bit at the stone and tried to move it, others seized the prisoner by the legs and tugged with such force that I ‘thought the legs would be pulled off, but they persevered until they got the captive free. I next covered one up with a piece -of clay, leaving only the ends of its antenne projecting. It was soon discovered by its fellows, which set to work immediately, and by biting off pieces of the clay soon liberated it. Another time I found a very few of them passing along at intervals. I confined one of these under a piece of clay at a little distance ‘from the line, with his head projecting. Several ants passed it, but at last one discovered it and tried to pull it out, but could not. It immediately set off at a great rate, and I thought it had deserted its comrade, but it had only gone for assistance, ‘for in a short time about a dozen ants came hurrying up, evi- dently fully informed of the circumstances of the case, for they made directly for their imprisoned comrade and soon set him ‘free. I do not see how this action could be instinctive. It was sympathetic help, such as man only among the higher mam- malia shows. The excitement and ardour with which they carried on their unflagging exertions for the rescue of their comrade could not have been greater if they had been human ‘beings.
This observation seems unequivocal as proving fellow- feeling and sympathy, so far as we can trace any analogy ‘between the emotions of the higher animals and those of insects. That insects with such highly organised social habits, and depending so greatly on the principles of co- operation, should manifest emotions or instincts of an inci- piently altruistic character, is no more than we should antecedently expect on the general principle of survival of the fittest. Our only surprise should be that these emotions, or instincts, should appear to be so feebly de- veloped in some species of ants, and, as we shall subse- quently see, also of bees. But it may be worth while in this connection to point out that the valuable observation of Mr. Belt above quoted refers to the species of ant which, as we shall subsequently find, presents the most highly organised instincts of co-operation that are to be met with among ants, and therefore the greatest dependence of the welfare of the individual on that of the community. And the same remark is applicable to our native species, F’. san- guinea, which the Rev. W. W. F. White has repeatedly seen rescuing buried companions very much in the manner described by Mr. Belt; and he does not appear to be ac- quainted with Mr. Belt’s observations. He figures one case in which he saw three ants co-operating to dig out a buried comrade.
Huber, Kirby and Spence, Dugardin, Burmeister, Franklin, and other observers have all expressed them- selves as more or less strongly of the opinion that members of the same community of ants, and other social Hymen- optera, are able to communicate information to one another by some system of language or signs. The facts, however, on which their opinion rests have not been stated with that degree of caution and detail which the accept- ance of the conclusion requires. Thus, Kirby and Spence give only one instance of supposed communication between ants,” and even this one is inconclusive, as the facts de- scribed admit of being explained by supposing that the ants simply tracked one another by scent; while Huber
merely deals in general statements as to ‘contact of antenne,’ without narrating any particulars of his observa- tions. Therefore, until within the last few years there was really no sufficient evidence to sustain the general opinion that ants are able to communicate with one another; but the observations which I shall now detail must be regarded as fully substantiating that general opinion by facts as abundant and conclusive as the most critical among us can desire. I shall first narrate in his own words the more important of Sir John Lubbock’s experiments in this connection :—
I took three tapes, each about 2 feet 6 inches long, and arranged them parallel to one another and about 6 inches apart. An end of each I attached to one of the nests (7. niger), and at the other end I placed a glass. In the glass at the end of one tape I placed a considerable number (300 to 600) of larve. In the second I put two or three larve only, in the third none at all. The object of the last was to see whether many ants would come to the glasses under such circumstances by mere accident, and I may at once say that scarcely any did so. I then took two ants, and placed one of them to the glass with many larve, the other to that with two or three. Each of them took a larva and carried it to the nest, returning for another, and so on. After each journey I put another larva in the glass with only two or three larvz, to replace that which had been removed. Now, if several ants came under the above circumstances as a mere matter of accident, or accom- panying one another by chance, or if they simply saw the larvee which were being brought, and consequently concluded that they might themselves find a larva in the same place, then the numbers going to the two glasses ought to be approximately equal. In each case the number of journeys made by the ants would be nearly the same ; consequently, if it was a matter of scent, the two glasses would be in the same position. It would be impossible for an ant, seeing another in the act of bringing a larva, to judge for itself whether there were few or many left behind. On the other hand, if the strangers were brought, then it would be curious to see whether more were brought to the glass with many larve than to that which only contained two or three. I should also mention that every stranger was imprisoned until the end of the experiment.
471 hours the ants which had access to a glass containing numerous larve brought 257 friends to their assistance ; while during an interval 54 hours longer those which visited the glass with only two or three larvee brought only 82 friends; and, as already mentioned, no single ant came to the glass which contained no larve. Now, as all the glasses were exposed to similar conditions, and as the roads to the first two must, in the first instance at all events, have been equally scented by the passage of ants over them, these results look very conclusive as proving some power of definite communication, not only that larve are to be found, but even where the largest store is to be met with. | .
One case of apparent communication struck me very much. I had had an ant (/. niger) under observation one day, during which she was occupied in carrying off larve to her nest. At night I imprisoned her in a small bottle ; in the morning I let her out at 6.15, when she immediately resumed her occupation. Having to go to London, I imprisoned her again at 9 o’clock. When I returned at 4.40 I put ner again to the larve. She examined them carefully, and went home without taking one. At this time no other ants were out of the nest. In less than a minute she came out again with eight friends, and the little heap made straight for the heap of larve. When they had gone two-thirds of the way I again imprisoned the marked ant; the others hesitated a few minutes, and then with curious quick- ness returned home. At 5.15 1 put her again to the larve. She again went home without a larva, but after only a few seconds’ stay in the nest, came out with no less than thirteen friends. They all went towards the larve, but when they had got about two-thirds of the way, although the marked ant had on the previous day passed over the ground about 150 times, and though she had just gone straight from the larve to the nest, she seemed to have forgotten her way, and considered ; and after she had wandered about for half an hour, I put her to the larve. Now, in this case, the twenty-one ants must have been brought out by my marked one, for they came exactly with her, and there were no other antsout. Moreover, it would seem that they must have been told, because (which is very curious in itself) she did not in either case bring a larva, and
consequently it cannot have been the mere sight of a larva which had induced them to follow her. Further experiments proved, as we might have ex- pected, that although an ant is able to communicate to her friends in the nest that she has found treasure some- where outside, she is not able to describe to them its pre- cise locality. Thus, having exposed larvee and placed an ant upon them as before, Sir John watched every time she came out of the nest with friends to assist her, but instead of allowing her to pilot the way, he took her up and carried her to the larvae, allowing her to return with a larva upon her own feet. Under these circumstances the friends, although evidently coming out with the intention of finding some treasure, were never able to find it; but wandered about in various directions for a while, and then returned to the nest. Thus, during two hours she brought out in her successive journeys altogether no less than 120 ants, of which number only 5 in their unguided wanderings happened to find the sought-for treasure. This result seems to prove, as we might have expected, that the communication is of the nature of some sign amounting to no more than a ‘follow me.’ Other experi- ments confirmed this result, and also brought out the fact that ‘some species act much more in association than others—Formica fusca, for instance, much less than Lasius niger.” Thus Sir John Lubbock placed some honey before a marked specimen of the former species; but although she visited and revisited the honey during an entire day, she brought out no friends to share it; and although in her journeys to and from the nest she happened to pass and repass many other individuals, they took no notice of each other.
The obvious objection to these experiments, that an ant observing a friend bringing home food or a pupa might infer, without being told, that by accompanying the friend on the return journey she ‘ might participate in the good things,’ has been partly met by the fact already stated, viz., that there is so very marked a difference in the result if, on experimenting on two ants, one had access to a large treasure and the other only to asmall one. But
to put this matter beyond question, Sir John Lubbock tried the experiment of pinning down a dead fly, so that the ant which found it was unable, with all her tugging, to move it towards the nest. At length she went back to the nest for assistance, and returned accompanied by seven friends. So great was her excitement, however, that she outran these friends, ‘who seemed to have come out reluctantly, as if they had been asleep, and were only half awake ;’ and they failed to find the fly, slowly meandering about for twenty minutes. After again tug- ging for a time at the fly, the first ant returned a second time to the nest for assistance, and in less than a minute came out with eight friends. They were even less energetic than the first party, and having lost sight of their guide in the same manner as happened before, they all returned to the nest. Meanwhile several of the first party, which had all the while been meandering about, found the fly, and proceeded to dismember it, carrying the trophy to the nest, and calling out more friends in the ordinary way. This experiment was repeated several times and on differ- ent species, always with the same result. Now, as Sir John remarks, ‘ the two cases (7.¢e. those in which the ant brought out friends to her assistance even when she had no booty to show) surely indicate a distinct power of com- munication. . . . It isimpossible to doubt that the friends were brought out by the first ant; and as she returned empty-handed to the nest, the others cannot have been induced to follow her by merely observing her proceedings. I conclude, therefore, that they possess the power of re- questing their friends to come and help them.’
In order to ascertain whether the signs which com- municating ants make to one another are made by means of sound, Sir John Lubbock placed near a nest of Lasius flavus six small upright pillars of wood about 14 inch high, and on one of these he put a drop of honey. ‘I then put three ants to the honey, and when each had sufficiently fed, I imprisoned her, and put another ; thus always keep- ing three ants at the honey, but not allowing them to go home. If, then, they could summon their friends by sound, there ought soon to be many ants at the honey.’
The result showed that the ants were not able thus to call to one another from a distance. As additional proof of the general fact that at all events some ants have the power of communicating infor- mation to one another, it will be enough here to quote an exceedingly interesting observation of the distinguished geologist Hague. The quotations are taken from his letters written to Mr. Darwin, and published in Nature : — On the mantelshelf of our sitting-room my wife has the habit of keeping fresh flowers. A vase stands at each end, and near the middle a small tumbler, usually filled with violets. Some time ago I noticed a pile of very small red ants on the wall above the left-hand vase, passing upward and downward be- tween the mantelshelf and a small hole near the ceiling, at a point where a picture nail had been driven. The ants, when first observed, were not very numerous, but gradually increased in number, until on some days the little creatures formed an almost unbroken procession, issuing from the hole at the nail, descending the wall, climbing the vase directly below the nail, satisfying their desire for wateror perfume, and then returning. The other vase and tumbler were not visited at that time.
As I was just then recovering from a long illness it hap- pened that I was confined to the house, and spent my days in the room where the operations of these insects attracted my atten- tion. Their presence caused me some annoyance, but I knew of no effective means of getting rid of them. For several days in succession I frequently brushed the ants in great numbers from the wall down to the floor; but as they were not killed the re- sult was that they soon formed a colony in the wall at the base of the mantel, ascending thence to the shelf, so that before long the vase was attacked from above and below.
forty, on the shelf at the foot of the vase. Thinking to kill them, I struck them lightly with the end of my finger, killing some and disabling the rest. The effect of this was immediate and unexpected. As soon as those ants which were approach- ing arrived near to where their fellows lay dead and suffering, they turned and fled with all possible haste. In half an hour the wall above the mantelshelf was cleared of ants. continued to ascend until reaching the lower bevelled edge of the shelf, at which point the more timid individuals, although unable to see the vase, somehow became aware of trouble, and turned about without further investigation, while the more daring advanced hesitatingly just to the upper edge of the shelf, when, extending their antenne and stretching their necks, they seemed to peep cautiously over the edge until beholding their suffering companions, when they too turned and followed the others, expressing by their behaviour great excitement and terror. An hour or two later, the path or trail leading from the lower colony to the vase was almost entirely free from ants.
I killed one or two ants on their path, striking them with my finger, but leaving no visible trace. The effect of this was that as soon as an ant ascending towards the shelf reached the spot where one had been killed, it gave signs immediately of great disturbance, and returned directly at the highest possible ‘speed. oA curious and invariable feature of their behaviour was that when such an ant, returning in fright, met another ap- proaching, the two would always communicate, but each would pursue its own way, the second ant continuing its journey to the spot where the first had turned about, and then following that example.
For some days after this there were no ants visible on the wall, either above or below the shelf. Then a few ants from the lower colony began to reappear, but instead of visiting the vase which had been the scene of the disaster, they avoided it altogether, and following the lower front edge of the shelf to the tumbler standing near the middle, made their attack upon that. I repeated the same experiment here with precisely the same result. Killing or maiming a few of the ants and leaving their bodies about the base of the tum- bler, the others on approaching, and even before arriving at the upper surface of the shelf where their mutilated companions were visible, gave signs of intense emotion, some running away immediately, and others advancing to where they could survey the field and then hastening away precipitately.
Occasionally an ant would. advance towards the tumbler until it found itself among the dead and dying; then it seemed to lose all self-possession, running hither and thither, making ‘wide circuits about the scene of the trouble, stopping at times and elevating the antenne with a movement suggestive of wringing them in despair, and finally taking flight. After this another interval of several days passed, during which no ants appeared. Now, three months later, the lower colony has been entirely abandoned. Occasionally, however, especially when fresh and fragrant violets have been placed on the shelf, a few ‘ prospectors’ descend from the upper nail-hole, rarely, almost never, approaching the vase from which they were first driven away, but seeking to satisfy their desire at the tumbler. To turn back these stragglers and keep them out of sight for a number of days, sometimes for a fortnight, it is sufficient to kill one or two ants on the trail which they follow descending the wall. This I have recently done as high up as I can reach, three or four feet above the mantel. The moment this spot is reached, an ant turns abruptly and makes for home, and in a little while there is not an ant visible on the wall.
In a subsequent volume of ‘Nature’ (viii. p. 244), Mr. Darwin publishes another letter which he received from Mr. Hague upon the same subject. It seems that Mr. Mog- gridge suggested to Mr. Darwin that, as he and others had drawn across their path, the observation of Mr. Hague might really resolve itself into a dislike on the part of the ants to cross a line over which a finger had been drawn, and have nothing to do with intelligent terror inspired by the sight of their slaughtered companions. The following is Mr. Hague’s reply to Mr. Darwin’s request for further experiments to test this point :—
Acting on Mr. M ’s suggestion, I first tried making simple finger-marks on their path (the mantel is of marble), and found just the results which he describes in his note as observed by himself at Mentone, that is, no marked symptoms of fear, but a dislike to the spot, and an effort to avoid it by going around it, or by turning back and only crossing it again after an interval of time. I then killed several ants on the path, using a smooth stone or piece of ivory, instead of my finger, to crush them. In this case the ants approaching all turned back as before, and with much greater exhibition of fear than when the simple finger-mark was made. This I did repeatedly. The final re- sult was the same as obtained last winter. They persisted in coming for a week or two, during which I continued to kill them, and then they disappeared, and we have seen none since. It would appear from this that while the taint of the hand is sufficient to turn them back, the killing of their fellows with a stone or other material produces the effect described in my first
note. This was made clear to me at that time; from the be- haviour of the ants the first day I killed any, for on that occa- sion some of them approaching the vase from below, on reaching the upper edge of the mantel, peeped over, and drew back on seeing what had happened about the vase, then turned away a little, and after a moment tried again at another and another point along the edge, with the same result in the end. More- over, those that found themselves among the dead and dying went from one writhing ant to another in great haste and ex- citement, exhibiting the signs of fright which I described.
_ I hardly hope that any will return again, but if they do, and give me an opportunity, I shall endeavour to act further on Mr. M ’s suggestion. | With this quotation I shall conclude the present division _of the chapter; for, looking to all the other observations previously mentioned, there can be no question concern- ing the general fact that ants have the power of commu- nicating with one another. And under subsequent head- ings abundant additional evidence on this point will be found implicated with the other facts detailed.
Swarming.—The precise facts with regara to the swarming of ants are not yet certainly established. As regards some of the facts, however, there is no doubt. The winged males and females first quit the nest in enor- mous numbers, and choose some fine afternoon in July or August for their wedding flight. The entrances to the nest are widened by the workers and increased in -number, and there is a great commotion on the sur- face of the nest. The swarm takes place as a thick cloud of all the male and female insects, rising together to a considerable height. The flight continues for several hours, usually circling round some tree or tower, and it is during the flight that fertilisation is effected. After it is effected, the swarm returns to the ground, when the males perish, either from falling a prey, in their shelterless condition, to birds or spiders, or, on account of not being able to feed themselves, from starvation. ‘The workers, or neuter ants, of their own
colony have lost all interest in them from the moment of — their return, and trouble themselves no more about them, for they well know that the males have now fulfilled their — vocation.’ The great majority of the fertilised females — share the same fate as the males. But a small proportion find concealment in holes, which they either dig for them- selves, or happen to find ready made, and there found a new colony. The first thing they do is to pull off their now useless wings, by scratching and twisting them, one ~ after the other, with the clawed ends of their feet. They © then lay their eggs, and become the queens of new © colonies.
Forel says that no fertilised female ever returns to her original home; but that the workers keep back a certain number of females which are fertilised before the swarming takes place; in this case the workers pull off the wings of the fertilised females. The majority of observers, how- — ever, maintain that some of the females composing the swarm return to their native home to become mothers where they had been children. Probably both statements are correct. A writer in the ‘Groniger Deekblad’ for June 16, 1877, observes that, looking to the injurious effects of in-breeding, the facts as related by Forel are less probable than those related by other observers, and that, if they actually occur, the females fertilised before flight are probably kept by the ants as a sort of ‘reserve corps to which the workers resort only in case of need, and if they fail to secure any returning queens.’
Nursing.—The eggs will not develop into larve un- less nursed. The nursing is effected by licking the surface of the eggs, which under the influence of this process increase in size, or grow. In about a fortnight, during which time the workers carry the eggs from higher to lower levels of the nest, and vice versa, according to the circumstances of heat, moisture, &c., the larve are hatched out, and require no less careful nursing than the eggs. The workers feed them by placing mouths together and re- gurgitating food stored up in the crop or proventriculus into the intestinal tract of the young. The latter show their hunger by ‘stretching out their little brown heads.’
Great care is also taken by the workers in cleaning the larvee, as well as in carrying them up and down the chambers of the nest for warmth or shelter. When fully grown the larve spin cocoons, and are then pup, or the ‘ants’ eggs’ of bird-fanciers. These require no food, but still need incessant attention with reference to warmth, moisture, and cleanliness. When the time arrives for their emergence as perfect insects, the workers assist them to get out of their larval cases by biting through the walls of the latter. It is noticeable that in doing this the workers do not keep to any exact time, but free them sometimes earlier and sometimes later, in accordance with their rate of development. ‘The little ‘animal when freed from its chrysalis is still covered with a thin skin, like a little shirt, which has to be pulled off.
how the young creature is then washed, brushed, and fed, we are involuntarily reminded of the nursing of human babies. The empty cases, or cocoons, are carried outside the nest, and may be seen heaped together there for along time. Some species carry them far away from the nest, or turn them into building materials for the dwelling.’ ! Education.—The young ant does not appear to come into the world with a full instinctive knowledge of all its duties as a member of a social community. Itis led about the nest, and ‘trained to a knowledge of domestic duties, especially in the case of the larve.’ Later on the young ants are taught to distinguish between’ friends and. foes. When an ants’ nest is attacked by foreign ants, the young ones never join in the fight, but confine themselves to removing the pup; and that the knowledge of hereditary enemies is not wholly instinctive in ants is proved by the following experiment, which we owe to Forel. He put young ants belonging to three different species into a glass case with pupz of six other species—all the species being naturally hostile to one another. The young ants did not quarrel, but worked together to tend the pupe. When the latter hatched out, an artificial colony was formed of
a number of naturally hostile species all living together after the manner of the ‘ happy families’ of the showmen. Habit of keeping Aphides.—It is well known that various species of ants keep aphides, as men keep milch cows, to supply a nutritious secretion. Huber first ob- served this fact, and noticed that the ants collected the eggs of the aphides and treated them exactly as they treated their own, guarding and tending them with the utmost care. When these eggs hatch out the aphides are usually kept and fed by the ants, to whom they yield a sweet honey-like fluid, which they eject from the abdomen upon being stroked on this region by the antenne of the ants. Mr. Darwin, who has watched the latter process,. observes with regard to it,—
I removed all the ants from a group of about a dozen aphides on a dock plant, and prevented their attendance during several hours. After this interval, I felt sure that the aphides would. want to excrete. I watched them for some time through a lens, but not one excreted ; I then tickled them with a hair in the same manner, as well as I could, as the ants do with their antennz ; but not one excreted. Afterwards I allowed an ant to visit them, and it immediately seemed, by its eager way of running about, to be well aware what a rich flock it had dis- covered ; it then began to play with its antennz on the abdo- men, first of one aphis and then of another ; and each, as soon as it felt the antenne, immediately lifted up its abdomen and exereted a limpid drop of sweet juice, which was eagerly de- voured by the ant. Even quite young aphides behaved in this manner, showing that the action was instinctive, and not the result of experience.
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.