Animal Intelligence
white line represents the course then pursued by the ant in its endeavours to find the pencil, which was shifted only a few inches from A to B, That. is, ‘the ants on their journey to the shifted object travelled very often back- wards and forwards and round the spot where the coveted object first stood. Then they, would retrace their steps towards the nest, wander hither and thither from side to side between the nest and the point A, and only after very repeated efforts around the original site of the larve reach, as it were, accidentally the object desired at B.’ Therefore the ants were clearly not guided by the sight of the pencil.
The same thing is well shown by another form of experiment. ‘Some food was placed at.the point a (Figs. 3 and 4) on a board measuring 20 inches by 12 inches, and so arranged that the ants in going straight from it to the nest would reach the board at the point 5, and after passing under the paper a tunnel ¢, would proceed between five pairs of Il wooden bricks, each 3 t inches in length and 1} i inches in height. When they got to know their way they went quite straight along the line de
Fig. 3. to a. The board was then twisted as shown in Fig. 4. ‘ The bricks and tunnel being arranged exactlyin the same direction as be- fore, but the board Fig. 4. , a, they walked exactly along the old path to e.’ Keeping the board steady, but moving the brick pathway 4 the board where the food V4 was next placed (Fig. 5), 4 | had the effect of making y 4 the ant first go to the old 4 position of the food at a, whence it veered to a new position, which we may call w The bricks’ and food were then moved to- wards the right-hand corner of the board—+.e. over a dis- tance of 8 inches (Fig. 6). The ant now first went to a,
then to #, and not finding the food at either place, set to work to look for it at random, and was only successful after twenty-five minutes’ wandering. ar ash And, as evidence how \ - much more dependence N they place upon scent in \ finding their way than ‘N upon any other of their \ faculties, it is desirable to N quote yet one further ex- |/ a 7 periment, which is of great es interest as showing that en when their sense of smell is made to contradict their sense of direction, they follow the former, notwithstanding, as we shall presently see, the wonderful accuracy of the information which is supplied to them by the latter. ‘If, when F’. niger were carrying off larve placed in a cup on a piece of board, I turned the board round so that the side which had been turned towards the nest was away from it, and vice versa, the ants always returned over the same track on the board, and, in consequence, directly away from home. If I moved my board to the other side of my artificial nest, the result was the same. Evidently they followed the road, not the direction.’
There can be little doubt that ants have a sense cf taste, as they are so well able to distinguish sugary sub- stances; and it is unquestionable that in their antenne they possess highly elaborated organs of touch. As evidence of the accuracy and importance of the sense of direction in the Hymenoptera, we must here adduce Sir John Lubbock’s highly interesting experiments on ants—leaving his experiments in this connection on bees and wasps to be considered in the next chapter. He first accustomed some ants (Lasiws niger) to go to and fro to food over a wooden bridge. When they had got quite accustomed to the way, he watched when an ant was upon a bridge which could be rotated, and while she
was passing along it, he turned it round, so that end b was at c,andcat b. ‘In most cases the ant immediately turned round also; but even if she went on to 0 or ¢, as the case might be, as soon as she came to the end of the bridge she turned round.’ Next, between the nest and the food he placed a hat-box twelve inches in diameter and seven inches high, cutting two small holes, so that the ants in passing from the nest to the food had to pass in at one hole and out at the other. The box was fixed upon a central pivot, so as to admit of being rotated easily without much friction or disturbance. When the ants had well learnt their way, the box was turned half round as
ant turned too, thus retaining her direction.’ Lastly, Sir John took a disk of white paper, which he placed in the stead of the hat-box between the nest and the food. When an ant was on the disk making towards the food, he gently drew the disk to the other side of the food, so that the ant was conveyed by the moving surface in the same direction as that in which she was going, but beyond the point to which she intended to go. Under these circumstances ‘ the ant did not turn round, but went on’ to the further edge of the disk, when she seemed ‘a good deal surprised at finding where she was.’
These experiments seem to show that the mysterious ‘sense of direction,’ and consequent faculty of ‘ homing,’ are in ants, at all events, due to a process of registering, and, where desirable,immediately counteracting any change of direction, even when such change is gently made by a wholly closed chamber in which the animal is moving, and not by any muscular movements of the animal itself. And the fact that drawing the moving surface along in the same direction of advance as that which the insect is pursuing does not affect the movements of the latter, seems conclusively to show that the power of registration has reference only to lateral movements of the travelling surface; it has no reference to variations in the velocity of advance along the line in which the animal is pro- gressing.'
1 While this MS. is passing through the press Sir John Lubbock has Little need here be said to prove that ants display some powers of memory; for many of the observations and experiments already detailed constitute a sufficient demon- stration of the statement that they do. Thus, for instance, the general fact that whenever an ant finds her way toa store of food or larvee, she will return toit again and again jn a more or less direct line from her nest, constitutes ample proof that the ant remembers the way to the store. It is of considerable interest, however, to note that the nature of this insect-memory appears to be, as far as it goes, precisely identical with that of memory in general. ‘Thus, a new fact becomes impressed upon their memory by repetition, and the impression is liable to become
effaced by lapse of time. More evidence on both these - features of insect-memory will be adduced when we come to treat of the intelligence of bees; but meanwhile it is enough to refer to the fact that in his experiments on ants, Sir John Lubbock found it necessary to teach the insects by a repetition of several lessons their way to treasure, if that way was long or unusual. With regard to the duration of memory, it does not appear that any experiments have been made; but the following observation by Mr. Belt on this point in the case of the leaf-cutting ant may here be stated. In June 1859 he found his garden invaded by these ants, and following up their paths he found their nest about a hundred yards
vead another paper before the Linnean Society, which contains some important additional matter concerning the sense of direction in ants. It seems that in the experiment above described, the hat-box was not provided with a cover or lid, ¢.e. was not a ‘closed chamber,’ and that Sir John now finds the ants to take their bearings from the ‘direction in which they observe the light to fall upon them. . For in .the experiment with the uncovered hat-box, if the source of light (candle) is moved round together with the rotating table which sup- ports the box, the ants continue their way without making compen- sating changes in their direction of advance. The same thing happens if the hat-box is covered, so as to make of it a dark chamber. Direction of light being the source of their information that their ground is being moved, we can understand why they do not know that it is being moved when it is moved in the direction of their advance, as in the experiment with the paper slip.
distant. He poured down their burrows a pint of common brown carbolic acid, mixed with four buckets of water.. The marauding parties were at once drawn off from the garden to meet the danger at home, and the whole formi- carium was disorganised, the ants running up and down again in the utmost perplexity. Next day he found them busily employed bringing up the ant-food from the old burrows, and carrying it to newly formed ones a few yards distant. These, however, turned out to be only intended as temporary repositories; for in a few days both the old and the new burrows were entirely deserted, so that he: supposed all the ants to have died. Subsequently, how- ever, he found that they had migrated toa new site, about two hundred yards from the old one, and there established themselves in a new nest. Twelve months later the ants: again invaded his garden, and again he treated them to a strong dose of carbolic acid. The ants,as on the previous. occasion, were at once withdrawn from the garden, and two days afterwards he found ‘all the survivors at work on one track that led directly to the old nest of the year before, where they were busily employed in making fresh exca- vations. Many were bringing along pieces of ant-food ’ from the nest most recently deluged with carbolic acid to that which had been similarly deluged a year before, and~ from which all the carbolic acid had long ago disappeared. ‘Others carried the undeveloped white pupz and larve. It was a wholesale and entire migration;’ and the next day the nest down which he had last poured the carbolic acid was entirely deserted. Mr. Belt adds: ‘I afterwards found that when much disturbed, and many of the ants destroyed, the survivors migrate to a new locality. I do not doubt that some of the leading minds in this formicarium recol- lected the nest of the year before, and directed the migration to it.’ |
Now, I do not insist that the facts necessarily point to. this conclusion ; for it may have been that the leaders of the migration simply stumbled upon the old and vacant nest by accident, and finding it already prepared as a nest,, forthwith proceeded to transfer the food and pupe to it.: Still, as the two nests were separated from one another by so considerable a distance, this hypothesis does not seem probable, and the only other one open to us is that the ants remembered the site of their former home for a period of twelve months. And this conclusion is rendered less improbable from a statement of Karl Vogt in his. ‘Thierstaaten,’ to the effect that for several successive years ants from a certain nest used to go through certain inhabited streets to a chemist’s shop 600 métres distant, in order to obtain access to a vessel filled with syrup. As it cannot be supposed that this vessel was found in suc- cessive working seasons by as many successive accidents, it can only be concluded that the ants remembered the syrup store from season to season.
I shall now pass on to consider a class of highly re- markable facts, perhaps the most remarkable of the many remarkable facts connected with ant psychology. It has been known since the observations of Huber that all the ants of the same nest or community recognise one another as friends, while an ant introduced from another nest, even though it be an ant of the same species, is known at once to be a foreigner, and is usually maltreated or put to death. Huber found that when he removed an ant from a nest and kept it away from its companions for a period of four months it was still recog- nised as a friend, and caressed by its previous fellow- citizens after the manner in which ants show friendship, viz., by stroking antenne. Sir John Lubbock, after re- peating and fully confirming these observations, extended them as follows. He first tried keeping the separated ant away from the nest for a still longer period than four months, and found that even after a separation of more than a year the animal was recognised as before. He re- peated this experiment a number of times, and always with the same invariable difference between the recep- tion accorded to a foreigner and a native—no matter, apparently, how long the native had been absent.
Considering the enormous number of ants that go to make a nest, it seems astonishing enough that they should be all personally known to one another, and still more astonishing that they should be able to recognise members ing that the facts could only be explained, either by all ‘the ants in the same nest having a peculiar smell, or by all the members of the same community having a par- ticular pass-word or gesture-sign, Sir John Lubbock, with the view of testing this theory, separated some ants ‘from a nest while still in the condition of pups, and, when they emerged from that state as perfect insects, transferred them back to the nest from which they had been taken as pups. Of course in this case the ants in the nest could never have seen those which had been removed, for a larval ant is as unlike the mature insect as a grub is unlike a beetle; neither can it be supposed that a larva, hatched out away from the nest, should retain, when a perfect insect, any smell belonging to its parent nest—more especially as it had been hatched out by ants in another nest;! nor, lastly, is it reasonable to imagine that the animal, while still a larval grub, can have been taught any gesture-signal used as a pass-word by the matured animals. Yet, although all these possible hypo-' theses seem to be thus fully excluded by the conditions of the experiment, the result showed unequivocally that the ants recognised their transformed larvee as native-born | members of their community.
Lastly, Sir John Lubbock tried the experiment of going still further back in the life-history of the ants before separating them from the nest. For in September he divided a nest into two halves, each having 4 queen. At this season there were neither larve nor eggs. The following April both the queens began to lay eggs, and in August—i.e. nearly a year after the original partitioning of the nest—he took some of the ants newly hatched from the pup in one division, and placed them in the other division, and vice versd. In all cases these ants were re- ceived by the members of the other half of the divided nest as friends, although if a stranger were introduced into either half it was invariably killed. Yet the ants which
1 It is to be noted that although ants will attack stranger ants introduced from other nests, they will carefully tend prranaet larvee ‘similarly introduced. were thus so certainly recognised by their kindred ants as friends had never, even in the state of an egg, been present in that division of the nest before. On this highly remarkable fact Sir John Lubbock says :— These observations seem to me conclusive as far as they go, _and they are very surprising. In my experiments of last year, though the results were similar, still the ants experimented with had been brought up in the nest, and were only removed after they had become pupe. It might therefore be argued that the ants, having nursed them as larve, recognised them when they came to maturity ; and though this would certainly _ be-in the highest degree improbable, it could not be said to be impossible. In the present case, however, the old ants had ab- _ solutely never seen the young ones until the moment when, _ some days after arriving at maturity, they were introduced into the nest.; and yet in all ten cases they were undoubtedly recog- nised as belonging to the community. ) It seems to me, therefore, to be established by these experi- _ ments that the recognition of ants is not personal and indi- vidual ; that their harmony is not dueto the fact that each ant is individually acquainted with every other member of the community.
At the same time, the fact that they recognise their friends even when intoxicated, and that they know the young born in their own nest even when they have been brought out of the chrysalis by strangers, seems to indicate that the recognition is not effected by means of any sign or pass-word. We must, therefore, conclude with reference to this subject that the mode whereby recognition is undoubtedly effected is as yet. wholly unintelligible; and I have introduced these facts under the heading of memory only
because this heading is not more inappropriate than any other that could be devised for their reception. It ought here to be added also that the power of thus recognising members of their community is not con- fined by the limits of blood-relationship, for in an experi- ment made by Forel it was shown that Amazon ants recognised their own slaves almost instantaneously after ‘an absence of four months. Under this heading I may also adduce the evidence as to enormous masses, or, as we might say, a whole nation of ants recognising each other as belonging to the same
nationality. New nests often spring up as offshoots from the older ones, and thus a nation of towns gradually spreads to an immense circumference around the original centre. Forel describes a colony of F. exsecta which comprised more than two hundred nests, and covered a space of nearly two hundred square métres. ‘All the members of such a colony, even those from the further- most nest, recognise each other and admit no stranger.’ Similarly, MacCook describes an ‘ant town’ in the Alleghany Mountains of North America (‘ Trans. Amer. Entom. Soc.,’ Nov. 1877) which was inhabited by F. exsec- toides. It consists of 1,600 to 1,700 nests, which rise in cones to a height of from two to five feet. The ground below is riddled in every direction with subterranean passages of communication. The inhabitants are all on the most friendly terms, so that if any one nest is injured it is repaired by their united forces.
It remains to be added in connection with this subject. that the recognition is not automatically invariable, but when ‘ants are removed from a nest in the pupa state, tended by strangers, and then restored, some at least of their relatives are certainly puzzled, and in many cases doubt their claims to consanguinity. I say some, because while strangers under the circumstances would have been immediately attacked, these ants were in every case amicably received by the majority of the colony, and it was sometimes several hours before they came across one who did not recognise them.’
It may also be added that Lasiws flavus behaves towards strangers quite differently and much more hos- pitably than is the case with L. niger. The stranger shows no alarm, but, on the contrary, will voluntarily enter the strange nest, and she is there received with kindness ; although from the attention she excites, and the numerous communications which take place between her and her new friends, Sir John was ‘ satisfied that they knew she was not one of themselves. . . . Very different is the behaviour of Z. niger under similar circumstances, I tried the same experiment with them. There was no communications with the antenne, there was no cleaning,
but every ant which the stranger approached flew at her like a little tigress. I tried this experiment four times ; The pugnacity, valour, and rapacity of ants are too well and generally known to require the narration of special instances of their display. With regard to the tenderer emotions, however, there is a difference of opi- nion among observers. Before the researches of Sir John Lubbock it was the prevalent view that these insects dis- play marked signs of affection towards one another, both by caressing movements of their antenne, and by showing solicitude for friends in distress. Sir John, however, has found that the species of ants on which he has experi- mented are apparently deficient both in feelings of affection and of sympathy—or, at least, that such feelings are in these species much less strongly developed than the sterner passions.
He tried burying some specimens of Lasius niger beneath an ant-road ; but none of the ants traversing the road made any attempt to release their imprisoned com- panions. He tried the same experiment with the same result on various other species. Even when the friends in difficulty are actually in sight, it by no means follows that their companions will assist them. Of this, he says, he could give almost any number of instances. Thus, when ants are entangled in honey, their companions devote themselves to the honey, and entirely neglect their friends in distress; and when partly drowned, their friends take no notice. When chloroformed or intoxicated their own companions either do not heed them, or else “seem somewhat puzzled at finding their intoxicated fellow-creatures in such a condition, take them up, and carry them about for a time in a somewhat aimless manner.’
show that chloroformed ants were treated as dead, 7. removed to the edge of the parade-board and dropped over into the surrounding moat of water; while intoxicated ‘ants were generally carried into the nest, if they were ants belonging to that community; if not, they were thrown overboard. This care shown towards intoxicated friends. appears to indicate a dim sense of sympathy towards ~ afflicted individuals; but that this emotion or instinct does not in the case of these species extend to healthy individuals in distress seems to be proved, not only by the ‘experiments of | burying alngady; described, but also by the following :—» |
On Sept. 2, theréfore, I ote two ants from one of my nests of 2. fusca into a bottle, the end of which was tied up with muslin as described, and laid it down close to the nest. In a second botile I put two ants from another nest of the same species, The ants which were at liberty took no notice of the bottle containing their imprisoned friends, The strangers in the other bottle, on the contrary, excited them considerably. The whole day one, two, or more ants stood sentry, as it were, over the bottle, In the evening no less than twelve were collected round it, a larger number than usually came out of the nest at any one time. The whole of the next two days, in the same way, there were more or less ants round the bottle containing the strangers; while, as far as we could see, no notice whatever was taken of the friends. On the 9th the ants had eaten through the muslin, and effected an entrance. We did not. chance to be on the spot at the moment; but as I found two ants lying dead, one in the bottle and one just outside, I think there can be no doubt that the strangers were put to death. The friends throughout were quite neglected.
Sept. 21.—I then repeated the experiment, putting three. ants from another nest in a bottle as before. The same scene was repeated. The friends were neglected. On the other hand, some of the ants were always watching over the bottle containing the strangers, and biting at the muslin which pro- tected them. The next morning at 6 a.m. I found five ants. thus occupied. One had caught hold of the ieg of one of the strangers, which had unwarily been allowed to protrude through the meshes of the muslin, They worked and watched, though not, as far as I could see, with any system, till 7.30 in the evening, when they effected an entrance, and immediately at- tacked the strangers.
Sept. 24.—I repeated the same experiment with the same nest. Again the ants came and sat over the bottle containing: the strangers, while no notice was taken of the friends. The next morning again, when I got up, I found five ants. round the bottle containing the strangers, none near the friends.. As in the former case, one of the ants had seized a stranger by the leg, and was trying to drag her through the muslin, All day the ants clustered round the bottle, and bit perseveringly,
though not systematically, at the muslin. The same thing hap- pened all the following day. On repeating these experiments with another species (viz., Formica rufescens) the ants took no notice of either bottle, and showed no sign either of affection or hatred. Oneis almost tempted to surmise that the spirit of these ants is broken by slavery [7.e. by the habit of keeping slaves]. But the experi- ‘ments on 7. fusca seem to show that in these curious insects hatred is a stronger passion than affection,
We must not, however, too readily assent to this general conclusion, that ants as a whole are deficient in the tenderer emotions; for although the case is doubtless so with the species which Sir John examined, it appears to be certainly otherwise with other species, as we shall presently see. But first it may be well to point out that even the hard-hearted species with which Sir John had to _ do seem not altogether devoid of sympathy with sick or mutilated friends, although they appear to be so towards healthy friends in distress. Thus the care shown to intoxicated friends seems to indicate, if not, as already observed, a dim sense of sympathy, at least an instinct to preserve the life of an ailing citizen for the future benefit of the community. Sir John also quotes some observa- tions of Latreille showing that ants display sympathy with mutilated companions; and, lastly, mentions an instance which he has himself observed of the same thing. A spe- cimen of F. fusca congenitally destitute of antennze was attacked and injured by an ant of another species. When separated by Sir John, another ant of her own species eame by. ‘She examined the poor sufferer carefully, then picked her up tenderly, and carried her away into the nest. It would have been difficult for any one who witnessed this scene to have denied to this ant the pos- session of humane feelings.’ Moggridge is also of opinion that the habit of throwing sick and apparently dead ants
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.