Animal Intelligence
Being unable to conceive at the time that this was such an act of atrocity on the part of the ameba as the sequel disclosed, and thinking that the young acineta might yet escape, or pass into some other form in the body of its host, I watched the ameba for some time afterwards, until the tale ended by the young acineta becoming divided into two parts, and thus in their respective digestive spaces ultimately becoming broken down and digested.! With regard to these remarkable observations it can only, I think, be said that although certainly very sug- gestive of something more than mechanical response to stimulation, they are not sufficiently so to justify us in ascribing to these lowest members of the zoological scale any rudiment of truly mental action. The subject, how-
ever, is here full of difficulty, and not the least so on account of the ameba not only having no nervous system, but no observable organs of any kind; so that, although we may suppose that the adaptive movements described by Mr. Carter were non-mental, it still remains wonderful that these movements should be exhibited by such apparently unorganised creatures, seeing that as to the remoteness of the end attained, no less than the complex refinement of the stimulus to which their adaptive response was due, the movements in question rival the most elaborate of non-mental adjustments else- where performed by the most highly organised of nervous systems.
Dr. Eimer attributes ‘ voluntary action ’ to the Medusa, and indeed draws a sharp distinction between what he considers their ‘ involuntary ’ and ‘ voluntary’ movements. In this distinction, however, I do not at all concur; for although I am well acquainted with the difference be- tween the active and slow rhythm upon which the dis- tinction is founded, I see no evidence whatever for supposing that the difference involves any psychological element. The active swimming is produced by stimu- lation, and is no doubt calculated to lead to the escape of the organism; but this fact certainly does not carry us beyond the ordinary possibilities of reflex action. And even when, as in some species is constantly the case, boyits of active swimming appear to arise spontaneously or without observable stimulation, the fact is to be at- © tributed to a liberation of overplus ganglionic energy, or to some unobservable stimulation ; it does not justify the supposition of any psychical element being con- cerned.!
M‘Crady gives an interesting account of a medusa which carries its larve on the inner sides of its bell- shaped body. The manubrium, or mobile digestive cavity 1 For an account of the natural movements of the Medusz and the effects of stimulation upon them, see Croonian Lecture in Phil. Trans. 1875, and also Phil. Trans. 1877 and 1879. of the animal, depends, as in the other Meduse, from the summit of the concave surface of the bell, like a clapper or tongue. Now M‘Crady observed this depending organ to be moved first to one side and then to the other side of the bell, in order to give suck to the larve on the sides of the bell—the larvee dipping their long noses into the nutrient fluids which that organ of the parent’s body contained. I cite this case, because if it occurred in one of the higher animals it would probably be called a case of instinct ; but as it occurs in so low an animal as a jelly-fish, it is unreasonable to suppose that intelligence can ever have played any part in originating the action. Therefore we may set it down as the uncompounded result of natural selection. _ Some species of meduse—notably Sarsia—seek the light, crowding into the path of a beam, and following it actively if moved. They derive advantage from so doing, because certain small crustacea on which they feed like- wise crowd into the light. The seeking of light by these medusz is therefore doubtless of the nature of a reflex action which has been developed by natural selection in order to bring the animals into contact with their prey. Paul Bert has found that Daphnia pulex seeks the light (especially the yellow ray), and Engelmann has observed the same fact with regard to certain protoplasmic organisms. But in none of these or other such cases is there any evidence of a psychical element being concerned in the process. Echinodermata.
Some of the natural movements of these animals, as also some of their movements under stimulation, are very suggestive of purpose; but I have satisfied myself that there is no adequate evidence of the animals being able to profit by individual experience, and therefore, in accordance with our canon, that there is no adequate evidence of their exhibiting truly mental phenomena. On the other hand, the study of reflex action in these organisms is full of interest—so much so that in my next work I shall take them as typical organisms in this connection.!
* See Croonian Lecture, 1881, in forthcoming issue of Phil. Trans. Mr. Darwin has now in the press a highly interesting work on the habits of earth-worms. It appears from his observations that the manner in which these animals draw down leaves, &c., into their burrows is strongly indicative of instinctive action, if not of intelligent purpose—seeing that they always lay hold of the part of the leaf (even though an exotic one) by the traction of which the leaf will offer least resistance to being drawn down. But as this work will so shortly be published, I shall not forestall any of the facts which it has to state, nor should I yet like to venture an opinion as to how far these facts, when considered altogether, would justify any inference to a truly mental element as existing in these animals.
Of the land leeches in Ceylon, Sir E. Tennent gives an account which likewise seems to bespeak intelligence as occurring in annelids. He says :— In moving, the land leeches have the power of planting one extremity on the earth and raising the other perpendicularly to watch for their victim. Such is their vigilance and instinct, - that on the approach of a passer-by to a spot which they infest, they may be seen amongst the grass and fallen leaves on the edge of a native path, poised erect, and preparing for their attack on man and horse. On descrying their prey they ad- vance rapidly by semicircular strides, fixing one end firmly and arching the other forwards, till by successive advances they can lay hold of the traveller’s foot, when they disengage themselves from the ground and ascend his dress in search of an aperture to enter. In these encounters the individuals in the rear of a party of travellers in the jungle invariably fare worst, as the leeches, once warned of their approach, congregate with sin- gular celerity.}
I sHALL treat of the Mollusca before the Articulata, because as a group their intelligence is not so high. Indeed, it is not to be expected that the class of animals wherein the ‘vegetative’ functions of nutri- tion and reproduction predominate so largely over the animal functions of sensation, locomotion, &c., should present any considerable degree of intelligence. Never- theless, in the only division of the group which has sense organs and powers of locomotion highly developed —viz., the Cephalopoda—we meet with large cephalic ganglia, and, it would appear, with no small develop- ment of intelligence. Taking, however, the sub-king- dom in ascending order, I shall first present all the trustworthy evidence that I have been able to collect, pointing to the highest level of intelligence that is at- tained by the lower members. The following is quoted from Mr. Darwin’s MS. :—
Even the headless oyster seems to profit from experience, for Dicquemase (‘Journal de Physique,’ vol. xxviii. p. 244) asserts that oysters taken from a depth never uncovered by the sea, open their shells, lose the water within, and perish; but oysters taken from the same place and depth, if kept in reser- voirs, where they are occasionally left uncovered for a short time, and are otherwise incommoded, learn to keep their shells shut, and then live for a much longer time when taken out of the water.! .
1 This fact is also stated by Bingley, Animal Biography, vol. iii. p. 454, and is now turned to practical account in the so-called ‘ Oyster- schools’ of France. The distance from the coast to Paris being too great for the newly dredged oysters to travel without opening their shells, they are first taught in the schools to bear a longer and longer exposure to the air without gaping, and when their education in this respect is completed they are sent on their journey to the metropolis, where they arrive with closed shells, and in a healthy condition.
Some evidence of intelligence seems to be displayed by the razor-fish. For the animals dislike salt, so that when this is sprinkled above their burrows in the sand, they come to the surface and quit their habitations. But if the animal is once seized when it comes to the surface and afterwards allowed to retire into its burrow, no amount of salt will force it again to come to the surface.!. With regard to snails, L. Agassiz writes: ‘ Quiconque a eu loccasion d’observer les amours des limacons, ne saurait mettre en doute la séduction déployée dans les mouvements et les allures qui préparent et accomplissent le double embrassement de ces hermaphrodites.’ ?
Again, Mr. Darwin’s MS. quotes from Mr. W. White * a curious exhibition of intelligence in a snail, which does not seem to have admitted of mal-observation. , This gentleman ‘fixed a land-shell mouth uppermost in a chink of rock; in a short time the snail protruded itself to its utmost length, and, attaching its foot vertically above, tried to pull the shell out in a straight line. Not succeeding, it rested for a few minutes and then stretched out its body on the right side and pulled its utmost, but failed. Resting again, it protruded its foot on the left side, pulled with its full force, and freed the shell. This exertion of force in three directions, which seems so geometrically suitable, must have been intentional.’
If it is objected that snail shells must frequently be liable to be impeded by obstacles, and therefore that this display of manceuvring on the part of their occupants is to be regarded as a reflex, I may remark that here again we have one of those incessantly recurring cases where it is difficult to draw the line between intelligence and non- intelligence. For, granting that the action is to a certain extent mechanical, we must still recognise that the animal while executing it must have remembered each of the two directions in which it had pulled ineffectually before it began to pull in the third direction; and it is improbable that snail shells are so frequently caught in positions from which a pull in only one direction will
release them, that natural selection would have developed a special instinct to try pulling successively in three directions at right angles to one another. The only other instance that I have met with of the apparent display of intelligence in snails is the remark- able one which Mr. Darwin gives in his ‘ Descent of Man,’ on the authority of Mr. Lonsdale. Although the inter- pretation which is assigned to the fact seems to me to go beyond anything that we should have reason to expect of snail intelligence, I cannot ignore a fact which stands upon the observation of so good an authority, and shall therefore quote it in Mr. Darwin’s words :— | These animals appear also susceptible of some degree of per-
manent attachment: an accurate observer, Mr. Lonsdale, in- forms me that he placed a pair of land-snails (Helix pomatia), one of which was weakly, into a small and ill-provided garden. After a short time the strong and healthy individual disap- peared, and was traced by its track of slime over a wall into an adjoining well-stocked garden. Mr. Lonsdale concluded that it had deserted its sickly mate; but after an absence of twenty- four hours it returned, and apparently communicated the result -of its successful exploration, for both then started along the same track, and disappeared over the wall.!
In this case the fact must be accepted, seeing that it stands on the authority of an accurate observer, and is of so definite a kind as not to admit of mistake. Conse- quently we are shut up to the alternative of supposing the return of the healthy snail to its mate a mere acci- dent, and their both going over the wall into the well- stocked garden another mere accident, or acquiescing in the interpretation which Mr. Darwin assigns. Now, if we look closely into the matter, the chances against the double accident in question are certainly so considerable as to render the former supposition almost impossible. On the other hand, there is evidence to prove, as I shall immediately show, that a not distantly allied animal is unquestionably able to remember a particular locality as its home, and habitually to return to this locality after feeding. Therefore, in view of this analogous and cor-
roborative case, the improbability of the snail remembering for twenty-four hours the position of its mate is very much reduced ; while the subsequent communication, if it took place, would only require to have been of the nature of ‘ follow me,’ which, as we shall repeatedly find, is a degree of communicative ability which many inyerte- brated animals possess. Therefore, in view of these con- siderations, I incline to Mr. Darwin’s opinion that the facts. can only be explained by supposing them due to intelli- gence on the part of the snails. Thus considered, these facts are no doubt very remarkable; for they would appear to indicate not merely accurate memory of direction and locality for twenty-four hours, but also no small degree of something akin to ‘permanent attachment,’ and sympa- thetic desire that another should share in the good things. which one has found.!
The case to which I have just alluded as proving beyond all doubt that some Gasteropoda are able to retain a very precise and accurate memory of locality, is that of the common limpet. | Mr. J. Clarke Hawkshaw publishes in the Journal of the Linnzan Society the following account of the habits in question :— The holes in the chalk in which the limpets are often to be .found are, I believe, excavated in a great measure by rasping from the lingual teeth, though I doubt whether the object is to form a cavity to shelter in, though the cavities, when formed, may be of use for that purpose. It must be of the greatest im- portance to a limpet that, in order that it may insure a firm adherence to the rock, its shell should fit the rock accurately ; when the shell does fit the rock accurately, a small amount of muscular contraction of the animal would cause the shell to ad- here so firmly to a smooth surface as to be practically im- moveable without fracture. As the shells cannot be adapted daily to different forms of surface, the limpets generally return to the same place of attachment. I am sure this is the case with many ; for I found shells perfectly adjusted to the uneven surfaces of flints, the growth of the shells being in some parts
1 The facts, however, in order to sustain such conclusions, of course require corroboration, and it is therefore to be regretted that Mr. Lons- dale did not experimentally repeat the conditions, distorted and indented to suit inequalities in the surface of the flints. ... I noticed signs that limpets prefer a hard, smooth surface to a pit in the chalk. On one surface of a large block, over all sides of which limpets were regularly and plentifully distri- buted, there were two flat fragments of a fossil shell about 3 inches by 4 inches, each embedded in the chalk. The chalk all round these fragments was free from limpets; but on the smooth surface of the pieces of shell they were packed as closely as they could be. I noticed another case, which almost amounts, to my mind, to a proof that they prefer a smooth surface to a hole. A limpet had formed a clearing on one of the sea-weed- covered blocks before referred to. In the midst of this clearing was a pedestal of flint rather more than one inch in diameter, standing up above the surface of the chalk; it projected so much that a tap from my hammer broke it off. On the top of the smooth fractured surface of this flint the occupant of the -clearing had taken up its abode. Theshell was closely adapted to the uneven surface, which it would only fit in one position. The cleared surface was in a hollow with several small natural cavities, where the limpet could have found a pit ready made to shelter in; yet it preferred, after each excursion, to climb up to the top of the flint, the most exposed point in all its domain.!
It appears certain from these observations, which to some extent were anticipated by those of Mr. F. C. Lukis,? that limpets, after every browsing excursion, return to one particular spot or home; and the precise memory of direction and locality implied by this fact seems to justify us in regarding these actions of the animal as of a nature unquestionably intelligent. Coming now to the cephalopoda, there is no doubt that if a larger sphere of opportunity permitted, adequate observation of these animals would prove them to be much the most intelligent members of the sub-kingdom. Unfortunately, however, this sphere of opportunity has hitherto been very limited. The following meagre ac- -count is all that I have been able to gather concerning the psychology of these interesting animals.
mistakable evidence of consciousness and intelligence.. This observer had an opportunity of watching them for a long time in the zoological station at Naples; and he says that they appeared to recognise their keeper after they had for some time received their food from him. Hollmann narrates that an octopus, which had had a struggle with a lobster, followed the latter into an adjacent: tank, to which it had been removed for safety, and there destroyed it. In order to do this the octopus had to climb up a vertical partition above the surface of the water and descend the other side.! According to
water, seeking to return to it when removed, even though they do not see it. But this probably arises from the sense of discomfort due to exposure of their skin to the air; and if we can call it an ‘idea,’ it is doubtless shared: by all other aquatic Mollusca when exposed to air. WirtHin the last ten or twelve years our information on the habits and intelligence of these insects has been so considerably extended, that in here rendering a condensed epitome of our knowledge in this most interesting branch of comparative psychology, it will be found that the chapter is constituted principally of a statement of observa- tions and experiments which have beenconducted during the short period named. The observers to whom we are mainly indebted for this large increase of our knowledge are Messrs. Bates, Belt, Miller, Moggridge, Lincecum, MacCook, and Sir John Lubbock. From the fact that these naturalists conducted their observations in different parts of the world and on widely different species of ants, it is not surprising that their results should present many points of difference ; for this only shows, as we might have ex- pected, that different species of ants differ considerably in habits and intelligence. Therefore, in now drawing all these numerous observations to a focus, I shall endeavour to show clearly their points of difference as well as their points of agreement; and in order that the facts to be considered may be arranged in some kind of order, I shall deal with them under the following heads :—Powers of special sense; Sense of direction; Powers of memory; Emotions; Powers of communication ; Habits general in sundry species ; Habits peculiar to certain species ; General intelligence of various species.
Taking first the sense of sight, Sir John Lubbock made a number of experiments on the influence of light coloured by passing through various tints of stained glass, with the following results. The ants which he observed greatly dislike the presence of light within their nests, hurrying about in search of the darkest corners when light is ad- mitted. The experiments showed that the dislike is much greater in the case of some colours than in that of others. Thus under a slip of red glass there were congregated on one occasion 890 ants, under green 544, under yellow 495, and under violet only 5. To our eyes the violet is as opaque as the red, more so than the green, and much more so than the yellow. Yet, as the numbers show, the ants had scarcely any tendency to congregate under it: there were nearly as many under the same area of the uncovered portion of the nest as under that shaded by the violet glass. It is curious that the coloured glasses appear to act on the ants in a graduated series, which corresponds with the order of their influence on a photographic plate. Ex- periments were therefore made to test whether it might not be the actinic rays that were so particularly distasteful to the ants; but with negative results. Placing violet glass above red produces the same effect as red glass alone. Obviously, therefore, the ants avoid the violet glass because they dislike the rays which it transmits, and do not prefer the other colours because they like the rays which they transmit. Sodium, barium, strontium, and lithium flames were also tried, but not with so much effect as the coloured glass.
It has just been observed that the relative dislike which Sir John Lubbock’s ants showed to lights of different colours seems to be determined by the position of the colour in the spectrum—there being a regular gradation of intole- rance shown from the red to the violet end. As these ants dislike light, the question suggests itself that the reason of their graduated intolerance to light of different colours may be due to their eyes not being so much affected by the rays of low as by those of high refrangibility. In this connection it would be interesting to ascertain whether ants of the genus Atta show a similarly graduated intole- rance to the light in different parts of the spectrum; for both Moggridge and MacCook record of this genus that it not only does not shun the light, but seeks it—coming to
the glass sides of their artificial nests to enjoy the light of a lamp. Possibly, therefore, the scale of preference to lights of different colours would be found in this genus to be the reverse of that which Sir John Lubbock has found in the case of the British species. As regards hearing, Sir John Lubbock found that sounds of various kinds do not produce any effect upon the insects. Tuning-forks and violin notes, shouting, whistling, &c., were all equally inefficient in producing the slightest influence upon the animals; and experiments with sensitive flames, microphone, telephone, &c., failed to yield any evidence of ants emitting sounds inaudible to human ears.
Lastly, as regards the sense of smell, Sir John Lubbock found that on bringing a camel’s-hair brush steeped in various strong scents near where ants were passing, “some went on without taking any notice, but others stopped, and evidently perceiving the smell, turned back. Soon, however, they returned, and passed the scented pencil. _ After doing this two or three times, they generally took no further notice of the scent. This experiment left no doubt on my mind.” In other cases the ants were observed to wave about and throw back their antennz when the scented pencil was brought near.
That ants track one another by scent was long ago mentioned by Huber, and also that they depend on this sense for their power of finding supplies which have been previously found by other ants. Huber proved their power of tracking a path previously pursued by their friends, by drawing his finger across the trail, so oblite- rating the scent at that point, and observing that when the ants arrived at that point they became confused and ran about in various difections till they again came upon the trail on the other side of the interrupted space, when they proceeded on their way as before. The more numerous and systematic experiments of Sir John Lubbock have fully corroborated Huber’s observations, so far as these points are concerned. Thus, to give only one or two of these experiments ; in the accompanying woodcut (Fig. 1) A is the nest, B a board, x fg slips of paper, h and m
similar slides of glass, on one of which, h, there was placed pupee, while the other, m, was left empty. Sir John Lub- A bock watched two particular (marked) ants proceeding from A to / and back again, carrying the pup on f to the nest A. Whenever an ant came out of A upon B he transposed the slips fand g. Therefore at sented to the ant of taking the unscented pathway leading to the full glass h, or the scented pathway leading to the empty glass. m. The two marked ants, knowing their ™ way, always took the right turn at the
angle; but the stranger ants, being guided. only by scent, for the most part took the wrong turn at the angle, so going to the empty glass m. For out of 150: stranger ants only 21 went, to h, while the remaining 129 went to m. Still the fact that all the stranger ants did not follow the erroneous scent-trail to m, may be taken to indicate that they are also assisted in finding treasure by the sense of sight, though in a lesser degree. Therefore Sir John Lubbock concludes that in finding treasure ‘they are guided in some cases by sight, while in others they track one another by scent.’
As further evidence showing how much more ants de- pend upon scent than upon sight in finding their way, the following experiment may be quoted. In the accompany- ing woodcut (Fig. 2) the line marked 1, 2, 3 represents. the edge of a paper bridge leading to the nest; A the top of a pencil which is standing perpendicularly upon a board, represented by the general black surface; B the top of the same pencil when moved a distance of a few inches from its first position A. On the top of this pencil were placed some pupe. Sir John Lub-- bock, after contriving this arrangement, marked an ant and put it upon the pupe on the top of the pencil. After she had made two journeys carrying pup from the pencil to the nest (the tracks she pursued being repre- sented by the two thick white lines), while she was in the nest he moved the pencil to its position at B. The thin
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.