Animal Intelligence
This interesting, and indeed surprising observation of Leuckart’s is, in turn, a corroboration of an almost identical one made more than a century ago by Cardinal Fleury, and communicated by him to Réaumur, who published it in his ‘l’Histoire des Insectes’ (1734). The Cardinal smeared the trunk of a tree with birdlime in order to prevent the ants from ascending it; but the insects overcame the obstacle by making a road of earth, small stones, &c., as in the case just mentioned. In
a bridge across a vessel of water surrounding the bottom of an orange-tree tub. They did so by conveying a number of little pieces of wood, the choice of which material instead of earth or stones, as in the previous case, seems to betoken no small knowledge of practical engineer- ing. Biichner, after quoting these cases, proceeds to say (loc. cit., p. 120),— The ants behaved in yet more ingenious fashion under the - following very similar circumstances. Herr G. Theuerkauf, the painter (Wasserthorstr. 49, Berlin), writes to the author, November 18, 1875: ‘A maple tree standing on the ground of the manufacturer, Vollbaum, of Elbing (now of Dantzic),. swarmed with aphides and ants. In order to check the mis- ehief, the proprietor smeared about a foot width of the ground round the tree with tar. The first ants who wanted to cross naturally stuck fast. But what did the next? They turned back to the tree and carried down aphides, which they stuck down on the tar one after another until they had made a bridge over which they could cross the tarring without danger. The above- named merchant, Vollbaum, is the guarantor of this story, which I received from his own mouth on the very spot whereat it occurred,
Biichner also gives the following case on the authority of Karl Vogt (loc. cit., p. 128). An apiary of a friend was. invaded by ants :-— To make this impossible for the future, the four legs of the beehive-stand were put into small, shallow bowls filled with water, as is often done with food in ant-infested places. The ants soon found a way out of this, or rather a way into their beloved honey, and that over an iron staple with which the stand was attached to a neighbouring wall. The staple was removed, but the ants did not allow themselves to be defeated. They climbed into some linden trees standing near, the branches. of which hung over the stand, and then dropped upon it from the branches, doing just the same as their comrades do with respect to food surrounded by water, when they drop upon it. from the ceiling of the room. In order to make this impos- sible, the boughs were cut away. But once more the ants were found in the stand, and closer investigation showed that one of the bowls was dried up, and that a crowd of ants had gathered in it. But they found themselves puzzled how to go on with their robbery, for the leg did not, by chance, rest on the bottom of the bowl, but was about half an inch from it.. The ants were seen rapidly touching each other with their antenne, or carrying on a consultation, until at last a rather
larger ant came forward and put an end to the difficulty. It rose to its full height on its hind legs, and struggled until at last it seized a rather projecting splinter of the wooden leg, and managed to take hold of it. As soon as this was done other ants ran on to it, strengthened the hold by clinging, and so made. a little living bridge, ovér which the others could easily pass. The same author publishes the following very remark- able observation, quoted from a letter to him by Dr. Ellen- dorf :— .
It is a hard matter to protect any eatables from these creatures, let the custody be ever so close. The legs of cup- : boards and tables in or on which eatables are kept are placed in vessels of water. I myself did this, but I none the less found thousands of ants in the cupboard next morning. It wasa puzzle to me how they crossed the water, but the puzzle was soon solved ; for I found a straw in one of the saucers, which - lay obliquely across the edge of the pan and touched the leg of the press: this they had used for a bridge. Hundreds were drowned in the water, apparently because disorder had reigned at first, those coming down with booty meeting those going up. But now there was perfect order; the descending stream used one side of the straw, the ascending the other. I now pushed the straw about an inch away from the cupboard leg; a terrible confusion arose. In a moment the leg immediately over the water was covered with hundreds of ants, feeling for the bridge in every direction with their antennz, running back again and coming in ever larger swarms, as though they had communicated to their comrades within the cupboard the fearful misfortune that had taken place. Meanwhile the new-comers continued to run along the straw, and not finding the leg of the cupboard the greatest perplexity arose. They hurried round the edge of the pan, and soon found out where the fault lay. With united forces they quickly pulled and pushed at the straw, until it again came into contact with the wood, and the communication was again restored.
This observation is strikingly, though unconsciously, confirmed by a recent writer in the Leiswre Hour (1880, pp. 718-19), who having been much troubled by small red ants in the tropics swarming over his provisions, placed the latter in a meat-safe detached from the wall and standing on four legs, each of which was placed in a little tin vessel containing water. Eight or ten days afterwards. he found his provisions in the safe swarming with ants as before, and on investigating their mode of access to them found—
going and coming from the outer door to a height of four feet on my wall, and corresponding with that of the safe ; and look- ing between it and the wall, I discovered the secret—the bridge which these persevering little insects had made. It consisted of a broken bit of straw, which rested with one end on a mud buttress fixed to the wall, and the other on the overhanging or projecting top of the safe, which came within an inch and a half of the wall. So they must have carried the straw up from the floor, and resting their end of it on the support they had pre- pared, let it fall until its other end reached the safe, and then crossed and completed the structure, for it was fastened at both ends with the mortar composed of their saliva and fine earth. Ruthlessly I destroyed the bridge, and moving the safe farther from the wall, managed to prevent their inroads for that season at least. Since then I have frequently seen short bridges, com- posed entirely of the concrete or mortar which the white ants use to cover up their workings, extending from a damp earthen wall to anything not more than three-quarters of an inch from it.
I shall relate two more instances of the use of a reasoning faculty in these ants. I oncesaw a wide column trying to pass along a crumbling, nearly perpendicular slope. They would have got very slowly over it, and many of them would have fallen, but a number having secured their hold, and reaching to each other, remained stationary, and over them the main column passed. Another time they were crossing a watercourse along a small branch, not thicker than a goose-quill. They widened this natural bridge to three times its width by a number of ants clinging to it and to each other on each side, over which the column passed three or four deep; whereas excepting for this expedient they would have had to pass over in single file, and treble the time would have been consumed. Can it be contended that such insects are not able to determine by reasoning powers which is the best way of doing a thing ?
Another observer, writing from the same part of the world to Biichner, gives a still more wonderful account of the ingenuity of Ecitons in crossing water. This observer : is Herr H. Kreplin, of Heidemihl (Station Ducherom), _*who lived for nearly twenty years in South America as an engineer, and had often the opportunity of seeing the driver ants in the forests there.’ He writes to Biichner, each other, stronger ants are to be seen, distinguishable from
the others by their foxy colour and very thick heads with gigantic mandibles. These ‘thickheads’ play the same ré/e in the ant-state for which they are cast in cultured communities. They look after the order of the march, and allow none to turn either to the right or left, The least confusion in the regularity _ of the march makes them turn round and put things straight _ again. While the procession of the brown workers streams on unceasingly with a swarming motion, the ‘ officers,’ as the natives call these thickheads, run constantly backwards and
forwards, ready to take the command on meeting any difficulty. The crossing of streams by these creatures is the most interest- ing point. Ifthe watercourse be narrow,.the thickheads soon 7 find trees, the branches of which meet on the bank on either side, and after ashort halt the column set themselves in motion over these bridges, rearranging themselves in the narrow train with marvellous quickness on reaching the further side. But if no natural bridge be available for the passage, they travel along the bank of the river until they arrive at a flat sandy shore. Each ant now seizes a bit of dry wood, pulls it into the water, and mounts thereupon. The hinder rows push the front
- ones even further out, holding on to the wood with their feet and to their comrades with their jaws. In a short time the water is covered with ants,and when the raft has grown too large to be held together by the small creatures’ strength, a part breaks itself off and begins the journey across, while the ants left on the bank busily pull their bits of wood into the water, and work at enlarging the ferry-boat until it again breaks. This is repeated as long as an ant remains on shore. I had often heard described this method of crossing rivers, but in the year 1859 I had the opportunity of seeing it for myself.
- Africa exhibit precisely similar devices for the bridging of. streams, namely, by forming a chain of individuals over which the others pass. By means of similar chains they also let themselves down from trees. It must be observed, independently made and separately recorded, serve to cor- roborate one another so strongly that we can entertain no reasonable doubt concerning the wonderful facts which they convey. I shall now bring these numerous instances to a close with a quotation from Mr. Belt, which reveals in the most unequivocal manner surprising powers of observation and rational action on the part of the leaf-cutting ants of South America, whose general habits we have already con- sidered :-—
A nest was made near one of our tramways, and to get to the trees the ants had to cross the rails, over which the waggons. were continually passing and repassing. Every time they came along a number of ants were crushed to death. They perse- vered in crossing for some time, but at last set to work and tunnelled underneath each rail. One day, when the waggons were not running, I stopped up the tunnels with stones; but although great numbers carrying leaves were thus cut off from the nest, they would not cross the rails, but set to work making fresh tunnels underneath them.
The foregoing facts concerning the intelligence of ants fully justifies Mr. Darwin’s observation that ‘the brain of an ant is one of the most marvellous atoms of matter in the world, perhaps more so than the brain of a man.’ It may therefore be interesting in this particular case to depart from the lines otherwise laid down through- out the present work, and to devote a short section to the anatomy and physiology of this nerve-centre with its ap- pended organs of sense.
The brain of an ant, then, is proportionally larger than that of any other insect. (See Titus Graber, ‘ Insects,’ vol. i. p. 255.) In structure, also, the brain of an ant is in advance of that of other insects, its nearest analogue being the brain of a bee. The superiority of development is particularly remarkable with reference to the ‘stalked bodies’ of Dujardin; and these are largest in neuter workers, which are. the most intelligent members of the - community. |
| __ _ Injury of the brain causes, as in higher animals, _ tetanic spasms and involuntary reflex movements, followed $ by stupefaction. _ An ant, whose brain has been perforated by the pointed _ mandibles of an amazon, remains as though nailed to its place ; a shudder runs from time to time through its body, and one of _ its legs is lifted at regular intervals. It occasionally makes a short and quick step, as though driven by an unseen spring, _ but, like that of an automaton, aimless and objectless. If it is pulled, it makes a movement of avoidance, but falls back into its stupefied condition as soon as it is released. It is no longer apable of action consciously directed to a given object; it neither tries to escape, nor to attack, nor to go back to its home, nor to rejoin its companions, nor to walk away ; it feels neither heat nor cold, it knows neither fear nor desire for food. It is merely an automatic and reflex machine, and is exactly similar to one of those pigeons from which Flourens removed _ the hemispheres of the cerebrum. Just in the same way behaves _ the body of an ant from which the head has been taken away. In the numerous fights between amazons and other ants, count- less cases have been observed of slight injury to the brain, which have caused the most remarkable phenomena. Many of the wounded were seized with a mad rage, and flung them- selves at every one that came in their way, whether friend or foe. Others assumed an appearance of indifference, and walked serenely about in the midst of the fighting. Others exhibited a sudden failure of strength; but they still recognised their enemies, approached them, and tried to bite them in cold blood, in a way quite foreign to the behaviour of healthy ants. They were also often observed to run round and round ina circle, the motion resembling the manége, or riding-school action of mammals, when one of the crura cerebri has been removed.
Tf an ant is cut in half through the thorax, so that the great nerve ganglia of the pro-thorax remain untouched, the behaviour of the head shows that intelligence also remains untouched. Ants mutilated in this way try to go forwards with their two remaining legs, and beg with their antenne for their com- panions’ aid. If one of these latter lets itself be stopped, then we observe a lively interchange of thanks and sympathy ex- ' pressed by the actively moving antenne. Forel placed near to
each other two such mutilated bodies of the /. rufibarbis. They conversed with each other in the above-described way, and ap- peared each to beg for help. But when he put in some simi- larly mutilated ants of a hostile species, /. sanguinea, the picture was changed; war broke out between these cripples just in the same way and with the same fury as between per- fect ants.! The antennz appear to be the most important of the sense-organs, as their removal produces an extraordinary disturbance in the intelligence of the animal. An ant so mutilated can no longer find its way or recognise com- panions, and therefore is unable to distinguish between friends and foes. It is also unable to find food, ceases to engage in any labour, and loses all its regard for larvee,. remaining permanently quiet and almost motionless. A somewhat similar disturbance, or rather destruction, of the mental faculties is observable as a result of the same mutilation in the case of bees.?
1 Biichner, Geistesleben der Thiere, English translation, p: 49, 2 While this work is passing through the press, an interesting Essay has been published by Mr. MacCook on the Honey-making Ant. I am not here able to refer to this Essay at greater length, but have done so in a review in Wature (March 2, 1882.)—G, J. R. as the one on ants, we shall consider first— Powers of Special Sense. Bees and wasps have much greater powers of sight than ants. They not only perceive objects at a greater distance, but are also able to distinguish their colours. This was proved by Sir John Lubbock, who placed honey on slips of paper similarly formed, but of different colours ; when a bee had repeatedly visited a slip of one colour (A), he transposed the slips during the absence of the bee; on its return the insect did not fly to slip B, although this now occupied the position which had been previously occupied by slip A, but again visited slip A, although this now occu- pied the position which had been previously occupied by slip B. Therefore, as these experiments were again and again repeated both on bees and wasps with uniform re- sults, there can be no question that the insects by their first visits to slip A established an association between the colour of A and the honey upon it, such that, when they again returned and found B in the place of A, they were guided by their memory of the colour rather than by their memory of the position. It was thus shown that the insects could distinguish green, red, yellow, and blue. These experiments also brought out the further fact that both bees and wasps exhibit a marked preference for some colours over others. Thus, in a series of black, white, yellow, orange, green, blue, and red slips, two or three bees paid twenty-one visits to the orange and yellow, and only four to all the other slips. The slips were then moved,
after which, out of thirty-two visits, twenty-two were to the orange and yellow. Another colour to which a similar preference is shown is blue. As regards scent, Sir John found that on putting a few ‘drops of eau de Cologne at the entrance of a beehive, ‘immediately a number (about 15) came out to see what ‘was the matter.’ Other scents had a similar effect ; but on repetition several times the bees became accustomed As in ants, so in bees, Sir John’s experiments failed to yield any evidence of a sense of hearing. But in this connec- tion we must not forget the well-known fact, first observed by Huber, that the queen bee will answer by a certain sound the peculiar piping ofa pupa queen ; and again, by making a certain cry or humming noise, will strike consternation suddenly on all the bees in the hive—these remaining for a long time motionless as if stupefied.
The following are Sir John Lubbock’s observations upon this subject in the case of bees and wasps :— Every one has heard of a ‘bee-line.’ It would be no less | correct to speak of a wasp-line. On August 6 I marked a ' wasp, the nest of which was round the corner of the house, so that her direct way home was not out at the window by which she had entered, but in the opposite direction, across the room to a window which wasclosed. I watched her for some hours, during which time she constantly went to the wrong window, and lost much time in buzzing about at it. For ten consecutive days this wasp paid numerous visits, coming in at the open window, and always .trying, though always unsuccessfully, to return to her nest in the ‘wasp-line’ of the closed window— buzzing about that window for hours at a time, though eventually on finding it closed she returned and went round through the open window by which she always entered.
This observation shows how strong must be the instinct in a wasp to take the shortest way home, and how much the insect depends upon its sense of direction in so doing. It also shows how long a time it requires to learn by indi- vidual experience the properties of a previously unknown substance such as glass. But to this latter point we shall presently have occasion to return. Next we must adduce evidence to show that in way- finding the ‘sense of direction’ in bees appears to be largely supplemented by observation of particular objects.
Sir John Lubbock observes: ‘I never found bees to return if brought any considerable distance at once. By taking them, however, some twenty yards each time they came to the honey, I at length trained them to come to my room;’ that is to say, bees require to learn their way little by little before they can return to a store of honey which they may have been fortunate enough to find ; their general sense of direction is not in itself a sufficient guide. This, at least, is the case where, as in the experi- ments in question, the bees are carried from the hive to the store of honey (here a distance of less than 200 yards): possibly if they had found the honey by them- selves flying towards it, and so probably taking note of objects by the way, one journey might have proved suffi- cient to teach them the way. But, whether or not this would have been the case, the fact that when carried they required also to be taught the way piece by piece, is con- clusive proof that their sense of direction alone is not sufficient to enable them to traverse a route of 200 yards a second time.
The same result is brought out by other experiments conducted on a different plan, though not apparently with this object. ‘My room is square, with two windows on the south-west side, where the hive was placed, and one on the south-east.’ Besides the ordinary entrance from outside, the hive had a small postern door opening into the room. At 6.50 a bee came out through the little postern door. After she had fed, she evidently did not know her way home ; so I put her back.
At 10,15 she came out a third time; and again I had to put her back. At 10.55 she came out again, and still did not remember the door. Though I was satisfied that she really wished to return, and was not voluntarily remaining outside ; still, to make the matter clear, I turned her out of a side window into the garden, when she at once returned to the hive. At 11.15 she came out again; and again I had to show her the way back. At 11.20 she came out again; and again I had to show her the way back (this makes five times); when, however,—
At 11.30 she came out again after feeding, she returned straight to the hive. At 11.40 she came out, fed, and returned straight to the hive. At 11.50 she came out, fed, and returned straight to the hive ; she then stayed in for some time. At 12.30 she came out again, but seemed to have forgotten the way back ; after some time, however, she found the door and went in. Again :—August 24 at 7.20 a bee came through the post- ern: I fed her ; and though she was not frightened or disturbed, when she had finished her meal she flew tothe window and had evidently lost her way; so at 8 o'clock I in pity put her back myself.
August 29.—A bee came out to the honey at 10.10; at 10.12 she flew to the window, and remained buzzing about till 11.12, when, being satisfied that she could not find her way, I put her in. Nay, even those who seemed to know the postern, if taken near the other window, flew to it, and seemed to have lost themselves. This cost me a great many bees. Those which got into my room by accident continually died on the floor near the window. These observations show that even when a bee is not carried from the hive to the honey, but herself fles to it, her sense of direction is not alone sufficient to enable her to find the way back to the hive—or, rather, to the unac- customed entrance to the hive from which she had come out. Probably if the side window had been open, the bee would have returned to the hive round the eorner of the house, and through the entrance to which she was most accustomed. But as it was she had to learn, by five or
six journeys, the way between the postern entrance and the food. But the following observation on a wasp is in this con- nection the most conclusive. A marked wasp visited honey exposed in the room before mentioned. ‘The next morning she came— At 7.25, and fed till 7.28, when she began flying about the room and even into the next; so I thought it well to put her out of the window, when she flew straight away to her nest. My room, as already mentioned, had windows on two sides; and the nest was in the. direction of a closed window, so that the wasp had to go out of her way in going out through the open one.
At 7.45 she came back. I had moved the glass containing the honey about two yards; and though it stood conspi- cuously, the wasp seemed to have much difficulty in finding it. Again she flew to the window in the direction of her nest, and I had to put her out, which At 8.15 she returned to the honey almost straight. 8.21, she seems obvious from this that wasps have a sense of direction, and do not find their way merely by sight. At 8.50 back to honey, and 8.54 again to wrong window; but . finding it closed, she took two or three turns round the room, and then flew out through the open window.
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.