Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 360 to 389 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

360

At 9.24 back to the honey; and 9.27 away, first, however, paying a visit to the wrong window, but without alighting. first to wrong window. . She was away therefore 9 minutes. ie bys 9.53 away, this time straight.,, 11 &ec., &e., the way being now clearly well learnt. But that the sense of direction is of much service to indicated by the following observation thus narrated, on the authority of the authors themselves, by Messrs. Kirb and Spence :— |

361

In vain, during my stay at St. Nicholas, I sallied out at every outlet to try to gain some idea of the extent and form of the town. ‘Trees, trees, trees, still met me, and intercepted the view inevery direction ; and I defy any inhabitant bee of this rural metropolis, after once quitting its hive, ever to gain a glimpse of it again until nearly perpendicularly over it. The bees, therefore, .... must be led to their abodes by instinct, &e., The observation, however, is not so conclusive as its authors suppose; for there is nothing to show that the bees did not take note of particular objects on their ac- customed routes, and so learn these routes by stages. It would be worth while in this connection to try the effect of hooding the eyes of a bee, or, if this were deemed too disturbing an experiment, removing the hive bodily to a distance from its accustomed site, and observing whether the bees start away boldly as before for long flights, or learn their new routes by stages.

362

Mr. John Topham, of Marlborough House, Torquay, writing to ‘ Nature,’ ! says :— On October 29, 1873, I removed a hive of bees in my garden, after it was quite dark, for a distance of 12 yards from the place in which it had stood for several months; and between its original situation and the new one there was a bushy evergreen tree, so that all sight of its former place was obstructed to a person looking from the new situation of the hive. Notwithstanding this change, the bees every day flew to the locality where they formerly lived, and continued flying around the site of what had been their home until, as night came on, they many of them sank upon the grass exhausted and chilled by the cold. Numbers, however, returned alive to their new position, after having looked in vain for their hive in its old place. At night I picked the exhausted bees up, and having restored warmth to them (by leaving them for a time on my coat-sleeve), I returned them to their companions.

363

Here was an illustration that the faculty of memory was superior to that of observation ; but that was not all. Nearly every bee which I picked up during the 23 days through whieh this effort of memory lasted was an old one, as was easily de- duced from observing the worn edges of the wings; showing that whilst the young insects were quick in receiving new im- pressions and in correcting errors, the nervous system of the old bees continued acting in the direction which early habit had effected. Sotrue it is that ‘one touch of nature makes the whole world kin.’

364

A closely similar observation has been told me by a friend, Mr. George Turner. He found that when he removed a beehive only a yard or two from its accus- tomed site, the bees, on returning home, flew in swarms around the latter, and for a long time were unable to find the hive. And several other similar cases might be adduced. Lastly, Thompson says :— It is highly remarkable that they [bees] know their hive more from its locality than from its appearance, for if it be re- moved during their absence and a similar one be substituted, they enter the strange one. If the position of a hive be changed, the bees for the first day take no distant flight till they have thoroughly scrutinised every object in its neighbourhood.'

365

On the other hand, the writer of the article on ‘ Bees’ in the ‘ Encyclopedia Britannica’ says that in certain parts of France it is the habit of bee-keepers to place a number of hives upon a boat, which, in charge of a man, floats slowly down a river. The bees are thus continuously changing their pasture-ground, and yet do not lose their locomotive hives. It may be here worth while to add, parenthetically, as the only authentic observation with which I am acquainted concerning the distance that bees are accustomed to forage, the following statement of Prof. Hugh Blackburn. Writing from Glasgow University to ‘ Nature,’! he says that bees are found in a certain peach-house every spring at the time of blossom, although, so far as he can ascer- tain, the beehives nearest to the peach-house in question are his own, and these are at a distance of ten miles,

366

On the whole, then, and in the absence of further experiments, we must conclude it to be probable that the sense of direction with which hymenopterous insects are, as shown by some of Sir John Lubbock’s experiments, un- questionably endowed, is of no small use to them in find- ing their way from home to food and vice versa ; although it appears certain, from other of his experiments, that this sense of direction is not in all cases a sufficient guide, and therefore requires to be supplemented by the definite observation of landmarks.

367

But the most conclusive evidence on this latter point is afforded by a highly interesting observation of Mr. Bates on the sand-wasps at Santurem, which may here be suitably introduced, as the insects are not distantly allied. He describes these animals as always taking a few turns in the air round the hole they had made in the sand before leaving to seek for flies in the forest, apparently in order to mark well the position of the burrow, so that on their return they might find it without difficulty. This observation has been since confirmed in a striking manner by Mr. Belt, who found that the sand-wasp takes the most precise bearings of an object the position of which she desires to remember. This observation is so interesting that it deserves to be rendered wm extenso :—

368

A specimen of Polistes carnifex (i.e. the sand-wasp noticed by Mr. Bates) was hunting about for caterpillars in my garden. I found one about an inch long, and held it out towards it on the point of a stick. It seized it immediately, and commenced biting it from head to tail, soon reducing the soft body to a mass of pulp. It rolled up about one-half of it into a ball, and pre- pared to carry it off. Being at the time amidst a thick mass of a fine-leaved climbing plant, it proceeded, before flying away, to take note of the place where it was leaving the other half. To do this, it hovered in front of it for a few seconds, then took small circles in front of it, then larger ones round the whole plant. I thought it had gone, but it returned again, and had another look at the opening in the dense foliage down which the other half of the caterpillar lay. It then flew away, but must have left its burden for distribution with its comrades at the nest, for it returned in less than two minutes, and making one circle around the bush, descended to the opening, alighted on a leaf, and ran inside. The green remnant of the cater- pillar was lying on another leaf inside, but not connected with the one on which the wasp alighted, so that in running in it missed it, and soon got hopelessly lost in the thick foliage. Coming out again, it took another circle, and pounced down on the same spot again, as soon as it came opposite to it. Three small seed-pods, which here grew close together, formed the marks that I had myself taken to note the place, and these the wasp seemed also to have taken as its guide, for it flew directly down to them, and ran inside; but the small leaf on which the fragment of caterpillar lay not being directly connected with any on the outside, it again missed it, and again got far away from the object of its search. It then flew out again, and the ‘same process was repeated again and again. Always when in circling round it came in sight of the seed-pods down it pounced. alighted near them, and recommenced its quest on foot. I was surprised at its perseverance, and thought it would have given up the search; but not so, it returned at least half-a-dozen times, and seemed to get angry, hurrying about with buzzing wings.

369

At last it stumbled across its prey, seized it eagerly, and as there was nothing more to come back for, flew straight off to its nest, without taking any further note of the locality. Such an action is not the result of blind instinct, but of a thinking mind; and it is wonderful to see an insect so differ- ently constructed using a mental process similar to that of man. We may here first allude to an observation of Sir John Lubbock already quoted in another connexion (see p-. 147). It is here evident that the wasp, after find- ing the store of honey in the room, and after finding the window closed in the ‘ wasp-line ’ direction to its nest,

370

required three repeated lessons from Sir John before she learnt that the window on the other side of the room, and away from the direction of her nest, afforded no obstacle to her exit. Having learnt this, the fourth time she came she again flew to the closed window as before, and then, as if but dimly remembering that there was another opening somewhere that offered no such mysterious resistance to her passage, ‘she took two or three turns. round the room, and then flew out through the open window.’ Having now taken the bearings of all the room upon her own wings, and having again found the difference between the two windows in respect of resistance, although in all other respects so much alike, the next time she came she made in the first instance as it were an experi- mental flight towards the closed window, but clearly had the alternative of going to the open one in her memory; for on finding the window closed as before, she did not alight, but flew straight from the closed to the open window. The same thing happened once again, but now, with the distinction between the two windows thus fully learnt, and with it the perception that in this case ‘the short- est cut was the longest way round,’ she never again flew to: the closed window ; in the forty successive visits which she paid through the remainder of that day, and the hundred visits or so which she made during the two following days, she seems to have uniformly flown to the open window. As evidence of forgetfulness, it will be enough to refer to the case of another wasp which, under precisely similar circumstances to those just detailed, learnt her way out of the open window one day, having made fifty passages. through it in five hours. Yet Sir John remarks,—

371

It struck me as curious that on the following day this wasp. seemed by no means so sure of her way, but over and over again went to the closed window. It is further of interest to note, as showing the simi- larity of the memory displayed by these insects with that of the higber animals, that there are considerable indi- vidual differences to be found in the degree of ag In this respect they certainly differ considerably. Some of the bees which came out of the little postern door (already de- scribed) were able to find their way back after it had been shown to them a few times. Others were much more stupid ; thus one bee came out on the 9th, 10th, llth, 12th, 14th, 15th, 16th, 17th, 18th, and 19th, and came to the honey; but though I repeatedly put her back through the postern, she was never able to find her way for herself.

372

I often found that if bees which were brought to honey did not return at once, still they would do so a day or two after- wards., For instance, on July 11, 1874, a hot thundery day, and when the bees were much out of humour, I brought twelve bees to some honey ; only one came back, and that one _ only twice ; but on the following day several of them returned. This latter observation is important, as proving that bees can remember for at least a whole day the locality where they have found honey only once before, and that they so far think about their past experiences as to return to that locality when foraging.

373

As the association of ideas by contiguity is the prin- ciple which forms the basis of all psychology, it is de- sirable to consider still more attentively this the earliest manifestation that we have of it in the memory of the Hymenoptera. That it is not exercised with exclusive reference to locality is proved by the following observation of Sir John Lubbock :— I kept a specimen of Polistes Gallica for no less than nine months.! ... I had no difficulty in inducing her to feed on my hand; but at first she was shy and nervous. She kept her sting in constant readiness. . . . Gradually she became quite used to me, and when I took her on my hand apparently ex- pected to be fed. She even allowed me to stroke her without any appearance of fear, and for some months I never saw her sting.

374

One other observation which goes to prove that other things besides locality are noted and remembered by bees may here be quoted. Sir John placed a bee in a bell jar, the closed end of which he held towards a window. The bee buzzed about at that end trying to 1 «Three months’ in the Journal of the Linnzan Society, but Sir John Lubbock informs me that this is a misprint, make for the open air. He then showed her the way out of the open end of the jar, and after having thus learnt it, she was able to find the way out herself. This seems to show that the bee, like the wasp on the closed window- ‘pane, was able to appreciate and to remember the differ- ence between the quality of glass as resisting and air as permeable, although to her sense of vision the difference must have been very slight. In other words, the bee must have remembered that by first flying away from the window, round the edge of the jar, and then towards the window, she could surmount the transparent obstacle; and this implies a somewhat different act of memory from that of associating a particular object—such as honey— with a particular locality. It is noteworthy that a fly under similar circumstances did not require to be taught to find its way out of the jar, but spontaneously found its own way out. This, however, may be explained by the fact that flies do not always direct their flight towards windows, and therefore the escape of this one was probably not due to any act of intelligence.

375

While upon the subject of memory in the Hymenoptera, it is indispensable that we should again refer to the ob- servation of Messrs. Belt and Bates already alluded to on pages 150-51. For it is from that observation rendered evident that these sand-wasps took definite pains, as it were, to teach themselves the localities to which they desired to return. Mr. Bates further observed that after thus taking a careful mental note of the place, they would return to it without a moment’s hesitation after an absence of an hour. The observation of Mr. Belt, already quoted im extenso, proves that these mental notes may be taken with the utmost minuteness, so that even in the most intricate places the insect, on its return, is perfectly con- fident that it has not made a mistake.

376

With regard to the duration of memory, Stickney relates a case in which some bees took possession of a hollow place beneath a roof, and having been then re- moved into a hive, continued for several years to return and oceupy the same hole with their successive swarms.! Similarly Huber relates an observation of his own showing the duration of memory in bees. One autumn he put some honey in a window, which the bees visited in large numbers. During the winter the honey was taken away and the shutters shut. When they were again opened in the spring the bees returned, although there was no honey in the window.

377

from analogous facts, also extends at least over a period of many months. Sir John Lubbock’s experiments on this head go to show that the social sympathies of bees are even less de- veloped than he found them to be in certain species of ants. Thus he says :— I have already mentioned with reference to the attachment which bees have been said to show for one another, that though I have repeatedly seen them lick a bee which had smeared her- self in honey, I never observed them show the slightest atten- tion to any of their comrades who had been drowned in water. Far, indeed, from having been able to discover any evidence of affection among them, they appear to be thoroughly callous and utterly indifferent to one another. As already mentioned, it was necessary for me occasionally to kill a bee; but I never found that the others took the slightest notice. Thus on the 11th of October I crushed a bee close to one which was feeding —in fact, so close that their wings touched; yet the survivor took no notice whatever of the death of her sister, but went on feeding with every appearance of composure and enjoymeuit, just as if nothing had happened. When the pressure was re- moved, she remained by the side of the corpse without the slightest appearance of apprehension, sorrow, or recognition. It was, of course, impossible for her to understand my reason for killing her companion ; yet neither did she feel the slightest emotion at her sister’s death, nor did she show any alarm lest the same fate should befall her also. In a second case exactly the same occurred. Again, I have several times, while a bee has been feeding, held a second bee by the leg close to her ; the prisoner, of course, struggled to escape, and buzzed as loudly as she could; yet the selfish eater took no notice whatever. So

378

far, therefore, from being at all affectionate, I doubt whether bees are in the least fond of one another. Réaumur, however (‘ Insects,’ vol. v., p. 265), nar- rates a case in which a hive-bee was partly drowned and so rendered insensible; the others in the hive carefully licked and otherwise tended her till she recovered. This. seems to show that bees, like ants, are more apt to have their sympathies aroused by the sight of ailing or injured companions than by that of healthy companions in distress ; but Sir John Lubbock’s observations above quoted go to prove that even in this case display of sympathy is cer-. tainly not the rule.

379

Huber says that when one wasp finds a store of honey ‘it returns to its nest, and brings off in a short time a hundred other wasps;’ and this statement is confirmed by Dujardin, who witnessed a somewhat similar perform- ance in the case of bees—the individual which first found a concealed store informing other individuals of the fact, and so on till numberless individuals had found it. Lubbock have not tended to confirm these observations with regard to bees and wasps, we must not too readily allow his negative results to discredit these positive observations. —moore especially as we have seen that his later experi- ments have fully confirmed the opinion of these previous authors with respect to ants. His experiments on bees and wasps consisted in exposing honey in a hidden situa- tion, marking a bee or wasp that came to it, and observing whether it afterwards brought any companions to share the booty. He found that although the same insect would return over and over again, strangers came so rarely that their visits could only be attributed to acci- dental and independent discovery. Only if the honey were in an exposed situation, where the insects could see one another feeding, would one follow the other to the food.

380

the conclusion to which these experiments in themselves might lead, because the very able observer F. Miiller states an observation of his own which must be considered as alone sufficient to prove that bees are able to com- municate information to one another :— Once (he says!) I assisted at a curious contest, which took place between the queen and the other bees in one of my hives, which throws some light on the intellectual faculties of these animals, A set of forty-seven cells have been filled, eight on a newly completed comb, thirty-five on the following, and four around the first cell of a new comb. When the queen had laid eggs in all the cells of the two older combs she went several times round their circumference (as she always does, in order to ascertain whether she has not forgotten any cell), and then pre- pared to retreat into the lower part of the breeding-room. But as she had overlooked the four cells of the new comb, the workers ran impatiently from this part to the queen, pushing her, in an odd manner, with their heads, as they did also other workers they met with. In consequence the queen began again to go around on the two older combs; but as she did not find any cell wanting an egg she tried to descend, but everywhere she was pushed back by the workers. This contest lasted for a rather long while, till the queen escaped without having com- pleted her work. Thus the workers knew how to advise the queen that something was as yet to be done, but they knew not how to show her where it had to be done.

381

Again, Mr. Josiah Emery, writing to ‘ Nature,’? with reference to Sir John Lubbock’s experiments, says that the faculty of communication which bees possess is so well and generally known to the ‘ bee-hunters’ of America, that the recognised method of finding a bees’ nest is to act upon the faculty in question :— Going to a field or wood at a distance from tame bees, with their box of honey they gather up from the flowers and imprison one or more bees, and after they have become sufii- ciently gorged, let them out to return to their home with their easily gotten load. Waiting patiently a longer or shorter time, according to the distance of the bee-tree, the hunter scarcely ever fails to see the bee or bees return accompanied with other bees, which are in like manner imprisoned till they in turn are

382

filled, when one or more are let out at places distant from each other, and the direction in each case in which the bee flies noted, and thus, by a kind of triangulation, the position of the bee-tree proximately ascertained. Those who have stored honey in their houses understand very well how important it is to prevent a single bee from dis- covering its location. Such discovery is sure to be followed by a general onslaught from the hive unless all means of access is prevented. It is possible that our American are more intelli- gent than European bees, but hardly probable; and I certainly shall not ask an Englishman to admit it. Those in America who are in the habit of playing first, second, and third fiddle to instinct will probably attribute this seeming intelligence to that principle.

383

According to De Fraviére, bees have a number of differ- ent notes or tones which they emit from the stigmata of the thorax and abdomen, and by which they communicate information. He says :— As soon as a bee arrives with important news, it is at once surrounded, emits two or three shrill notes, and taps a com- rade with its long, flexible, and very slender feelers, or antennz. The friend passes on the news in similar fashion, and the intel- ligence soon traverses the whole hive. If it is of an agreeable kind —if, for instance, it concerns the discovery of a store of sugar or of honey, or of a flowering meadow—all remains orderly. But, on the other hand, great excitement arises if the news presages some threatened danger, or if strange animals are threatening invasion of the hive. It seems that such intel- ligence is conveyed first to the queen, as the most important person in the state.

384

This account, which is quoted from Biichner, nv doubt bears indications of imaginative colouring; but if the observation as to the emission of sounds is correct— and, as we shall see, this point is well confirmed by other observers—it is most likely concerned in communicating by tone a general idea of good or harm: probably in the former case it acts as a sign, ‘ follow me ;’ and inthe latter - asa signal of danger. Buchner further says that, accord- ing to Landois, if a saucer of honey is placed before a hive, a few bees come out, which emit a cry of tut, tut, tut. This note is rather shrill, and resembles the cry of

385

an attacked bee. Hereupon a large number of bees come: out of the hive to collect the offered honey. The best way to observe the power of communication pos- sessed by bees by means of their interchange of touches, is to. take away the queen from a hive. In a little time, about an hour afterwards, the sad event will be noticed by a small part of the community, and these will stop working and run hastily about over the comb. But this only concerns part of the hive,,. and the side of a single comb. The excited bees, however, soon leave the little circle in which they at first revolved, and when they meet their comrades they cross their antenne and lightly touch the others withthem. The bees which have received some impression from this touch now become uneasy in their turn, and convey their uneasiness and distress in the same way to the other parts of the dwelling. The disorder increases rapidly, spreads to the other side of the comb, and at last to all the. people. Then arises the general confusion before described.

386

Huber tested this communication by the antenne by a striking experiment. He divided a hive into two quite sepa- rate parts by a partition wall, whereupon great excitement arose in the division in which there was no queen, and this was only quieted when some workers began to build royal cells. He then divided a hive in similar fashion by a trellis, through which the bees could pass their feelers. In this case all re-. mained quiet, and no attempt was made to build royal cells : the queen could also be clearly seen crossing her antenne with the workers on the other side of the trellis.

387

Apparently the feelers are also connected with the exceed- ingly fine scent of the bees, which enables them, wonderful as. it may seem, to distinguish friend and foe, and to recognise: the members of their own hive among the thousands and thousands of bees swarming around, and to drive back from the entrance stranger or robber bees. The bee-masters, therefore, when they want two separate colonies or the members of them to unite in one hive, sprinkle water over the bees, or stupefy them with some fumigating substance, so as to make them to a. certain extent insensible to smell, in order to attain their object. It is always possible to unite colonies by making the bees smell of some strong-smelling stuff, such as musk.!

388

Lastly, under the present heading I shall quote one- other observation, for which I am also indebted to: 1 Loe. cit. Biichner’s very admirable collection of facts relating to the psychology of Hymenoptera :— Herr L. Brofft relates, in ‘der Zoologische Garten’ (X VIIT. Year, No. 1, p. 67), that a poor and a rich hive stood next each other, on his father’s bee-stand, and the latter suddenly lost its queen. Before the owner had come to a decision thereupon the bees of the two hives came to a mutual understanding as to the condition of their two states. The dwellers in the queenless hive, with their stores of provisions, went over into the less populous or poorer hive, after they had assured themselves, by many influential deputations, as to the state of the interior of the poor hive, and, as appeared, especially as to the presence of an egg-laying queen !

389

The active life of bees is divided between collecting food and rearing young. We shall therefore consider these two functions separately. | The food collected consists of two kinds, honey (which, although stored in the ‘ crop’ for the purpose of carriage from the flowers to the cells, appears to be but the con- densed nectar of flowers) and so-called ‘ bee-bread.’ This consists of the pollen of flowers, which is worked into a kind of paste by the bees and stored in their cells till it is re- quired to serve as food for their larve. It is then partly digested by the nurses with honey, so that a sort of chyle is formed. It is observable that in each flight the ‘ carrier bees’ collect only one kind of pollen, so that it is possible for the ‘ house bees’ (which, by the way, are the younger bees left at home to discharge domestic duties with only a small proportion of older ones, left probably to direct the more inexperienced young) to sort it for storage in different cells. In the result there are several different kinds of bee-bread, some being more stimulating or nu- tritious than others. The most nutritious has the effect, when given to any female larva, of developing that larva into a queen or fertile female. This fact is well known to the bees, who only feed a small number of larve in this manner, and the larve which they select so to feed they place in larger or ‘royal’ cells, with an obvious fore-

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.