Animal Intelligence
knowledge of the increased dimensions to which the animal will grow under the influence of this food. Only one queen is required for a single hive; but the bees always raise several, so that if any mishap should occur to one, other larvee may be ready to fall back upon. Besides honey and bee-bread two other substances are found in beehives. These are propolis and beeswax. The former is a kind of sticky resin collected for the most part from coniferous trees. This is used as mortar in building, &e. It adheres so strongly to the legs of the bee which has gathered it, that it can only be detached by the help of comrades. For this purpose the loaded bee presents her legs to her fellow-workers, who clean it off with their jaws, and while it is still ductile, apply it round the inside of the hive. According to Huber, who made this observation, the propolis is applied also to the insides of the cells. The workers first planed the surfaces _ with their mandibles, and one of them then pulled out a thread of propolis from the heap deposited by the carrier bees, severed it by a sudden throwing back of the head, and returned with it to the cell which it had previously been planing. It then laid the thread between the two walls which it had planed; but, proving too long, a portion of the thread was bitten off. The properly measured portion was then forced into the angle of the cell by the fore-feet and mandibles. The thread, now converted into a narrow ribbon, was next found to be too broad. It was therefore gnawed down to the proper width. Other bees then com- pleted the work which this one had begun, till all the walls of the cells were framed with bands of propolis. The ob- ject ofthe propolis here seems to be that of giving strength
to the cells. The wax is a secretion which proceeds from between the segments of the abdomen. Having ingested a large meal of honey, the bees hang ina thick cluster from the top of their hive in order to secrete the wax. When it begins to exude, the bees, assisted by their companions, rub it off into heaps, and when a sufficient quantity of the material has been thus collected, the work begins of build- ing the cells. As the cells are used both for storing food and
rearing young, I shall consider them later on. Now we haye to pass to the labours incidental to propagation. All the eggs are laid by one queen, who requires during this season a large amount of nourishment, so much, indeed, that ten or twelve working bees (7.e. sterile females) are set apart as her feeders. Leaving the ‘royal cell,’ she walks over the nursery-combs attended by a retinue of workers, and drops a single egg into each open cell. It is a highly remarkable fact that the queen is able to control the sex of the eggs which she lays, and only deposits drone or male eggs in the drone cells, and worker or female eggs in the worker cells—the cells pre- pared for the reception of drone larve being larger than those required for the worker larve. Young queens lay more worker eggs than old queens, and when a queen, from increasing age or any other cause, lays too large a proportion of drone eggs, she is expelled from the com- munity or put to death. It is remarkable, also, under these circumstances, that the queen herself seems to know that she has become useless, for she loses her propensity to attack other queens, and so does not run the risk of making the hive virtually queenless, There is now no doubt at all that the determining cause of an egg turn- ing out male or female is that which Dzierzon has shown, namely, the absence or presence of fertilisation—unferti- lised eggs always developing into males, and fertilised ones into females. The manner, therefore, in which a. queen controls the sex of her eggs must depend on some power that she has of controlling their fertilisation.
The eggs hatch out into larvee, which require constant. attention from the workers, who feed them with the chyle or bee-bread already mentioned. In three weeks from the time that the egg is deposited, the white worm-like — larva has passed through its last metamorphosis. When it has emancipated itself its nurses assemble round it to wash and caress it, as well as to supply it with food. They then clean out the cell which it has left. When so large a number of the larve hatch out as to overcrowd the hive, it is the function of the queen to lead forth aswarm. Meanwhile several larval queens have been
in course of development, and matters are so arranged by the foresight of the bees, that one or more young queens are ready to emerge at a time when otherwise the hive would be left queenless. But the young queen or queens, although perfectly formed, must not escape from their royal prison-houses until the swarm has fairly taken place ; the worker bees will even strengthen the coverings of these prison-houses if, owing to bad weather or other causes, swarming is delayed. The prisoner queens, which are fed through a small hole in the roof of their cells, now continually give vent to a plaintive cry, called by the bee-keepers ‘ piping,’ and this is answered by the mother queen. The tones of the piping vary. The reason why the young queens are kept such close prisoners till after the departure of the mother queen with her swarm, is simply that the mother queen would destroy all the younger ones, could she get the chance, by stinging them. The workers, therefore, never allow the old queen to approach the prisons of the younger ones. They establish a guard all round these prisons or royal cells, and beat off the old queen whenever she endeavours to approach. But if the swarming season is over, or anything should prevent a further swarm from being sent out, the worker bees offer no further resistance to the jealousy of the mother queen, but allow her in cold blood to sting to death all the young queens in their nursery prisons. As soon as the old queen leaves with a swarm, the young queens are liberated in succession, but at intervals of a few days; for if they were all: liberated at once they would fall upon and destroy one another. Each young queen as it is liberated goes off with another swarm, and those which remain unliberated are as carefully guarded from the liberated sister queen as they were previously guarded from the mother queen. When the .
season is too late for swarming the remaining young queens are liberated simultaneously, and are then allowed to fight to the death, the survivor being received as sovereign. The bees, far from seeking to prevent these battles, appear to excite the combatants against each other, surrounding and m2 bringing them back to the charge when they are disposed to recede from each other ; and when either of the queens shows a — disposition to approach her antagonist, all the bees forming the cluster instantly give way to allow her full liberty of attack. The first use which the conquering queen makes of her victory is to secure herself against fresh dangers by destroying all her future rivals in the royal cells ; while the other bees, which are spectators of the carnage, share in the spoil, greedily devouring any food which may be found at the bottom of the cells, and even sucking the fluid from the abdomen of the pupx before they toss out the carcasses.}
Similarly, when a strange queen is put into a hive already provided with a queen— A circle of bees instinctively crowd around the invader, not, however, to attack her—for a worker never assaults a queen— but to respectfully prevent her escape, in order that a combat may take place between her and their reigning monarch. The lawful possessor then advances towards the part of the comb where the invader has established herself, the attendant workers clear a space for the encounter, and, without interfering, wait the result. A fearful encounter then ensues, in which one is stung to death, the survivor mounting the throne. Although the workers of a de facto monarch will not fight for her defence, yet, if they perceive a strange queen attempting to enter the hive, they will surround her, and hold her until she is. starved to death ; ‘but such is their respect for royalty that they never attempt to sting her.?
All these facts display a wonderful amount of ap- parently sagacious purpose on the part of the workers, although they may not seem to reflect much credit on the intelligence of the queens. But in this connection we must remember the observation of F. Huber, who saw two queens, which were the only ones left in the hive, engaged in mortal combat; and when’ an opportunity arose for each to sting the other simultaneously, they simultaneously released each other’s grasp, as if in horror of a situation that might have ended in leaving the hive queenless. This, then, is the calamity to avert which all
1 Art. ‘Bees,’ Hncycl. Brit. 2 Dr. Kemp, Indications of Instinct. the instincts both of workers and queens are directed. And that these instincts are controlled by intelligence is suggested, if not proved, by the adaptations which they show to special circumstances. Thus, for instance, F. Huber smoked a hive so that the queen and older bees effected their escape, and took up their quarters a short distance away. ‘The bees which remained behind set about constructing three royal cells for the purpose of rearing a new queen. Huber now carried back the old queen and ensconced her in the hive. Immediately the bees set about carrying away all the food from the royal cells, in order to prevent the larvee contained therein from developing into queens. Again, if a strange queen is pre- sented to a hive already provided with one, the workers do not wait for their own queen to destroy the pretender, but themselves sting or smother her todeath. When, on the other hand, a queen is presented to a hive which is with- out one, the bees adopt her, although it is often necessary for the bee-master to protect her for a day or two ina trellis cage, until her subjects have become acquainted with her. When a hive is queenless, the bees stop all work, become restless, and make a dull complaining noise. This, however, is only the case if there is likewise a total absence of royal pup, and of ordinary pupz under three days of age—i.e. the age during which it is possible to rear an ordinary larva into a queen.
As soon as the queen has been fertilised, and the services of the drones therefore no longer required, the worker bees fall upon their unfortunate and defenceless brothers. to kill them, either by direct stinging or by throwing them out of the hive to perish in the cold. The drones’ cells are then torn down, and any remaining drone eggs or pup destroyed. Generally all the drones—which may number more than a thousand—are slaughtered in the course of-a single day. Evidently the object of this massacre is that of getting rid of useless mouths; but there is a more difficult question as to why these useless ‘mouths ever came into existence. It has been suggested that the enormous disproportion between the present number of males and the single fertile female refers to
a time before the social instincts became so complex or consolidated, and when, therefore, bees lived in lesser communities. Probably this is the explanation, although I think we might still have expected that before this period in their evolution had arrived bees might have de- veloped a compensating instinct, either not to allow the queen to lay so many drone eggs, or else to massacre the drones while still in the larval state. But here we must re- member that among the wasps the males do work (chiefly domestic work, for which they are fed by their foraging sisters); so it is possible that in the hive-bee the drones were originally useful members of the community, and that they have lost their primitively useful instincts. But whatever the explanation, it is very curious that here, among the animals which are justly regarded as exhibiting the highest perfection of instinct, we meet with perhaps the most flagrant instance in the animal kingdom of instinct unperfected. It is the more remarkable that the drone-killing instinct should not have been better de- veloped in the direction of killing the drones at the most profitable time—namely, in their larval or oval state— from the fact that in many respects it seems to have been advanced to a high degree of discriminative refinement. Thus, to quote Biichner,—
That the massacre of the drones is not performed entirely from an instinctive impulse, but in full consciousness of the object to be gained,is proved by the circumstance that it is carried out the more completely and mercilessly the more fer- tile the queen shows herself to be. But in cases where this fertility is subject to serious doubt, or when the queen has been fertilised too late or not at all, and therefore only lays drones’ eggs, or when the queen is barren, and new queens, to be fer- tilised later, have to be brought up from working-bee larve, then all or some of the drones are left alive, in the clear pre- vision that their services will be required later. . . . This wise calculation of consequences is further exemplified in that some- times the massacre of the drones takes place before the time for swarming, as, for instance, when long-continued unfavourable weather succeeds a favourable beginning of spring, and makes the bees anxious for their own welfare. If, however, the weather breaks, and work again becomes possible, so that the
bees take courage anew, they then bring up new drones, and prepare them in time for the swarming. This killing of drones is distinguished from the regular drone massacre by the fact that the bees then only kill the developed drones, and leave the drone larvee, save when absolute hunger compels their destruc- tion. Not less can it be regarded as a prudent calculation of circumstances when the bees of a hive, brought from our tempe-. rate climate to a more southern country, where the time of col- lecting lasts longer, do not kill the drones in August, as usual, but at a later period, suitable to the new conditions
But the philosophy of drone-killing is, I think, even more difficult in the case of the wasps than in that of the bees. For, unlike the bees, whose communities live from year to year, the wasps all perish at the end of autumn, with the exception of a very few fertilised females. As this season of universal calamity approaches, the workers destroy all the larval grubs—a proceeding which, in the opinion of some writers, strikingly exemplifies the bene- ficence of the Deity! Now, it does not appear to me easy to understand how the presence of such an instinct in this case is to be explained. For, on the one hand, the indi- vidual females which are destined to live through the winter cannot be conspicuously benefited by this slaughter of grubs; and, on the other hand, the rest of the com- munity is so soon about to perish, that one fails to see of what advantage it can be to it to get rid of the grubs. If the whole human race, with the exception of a few women, were to perish periodically once in a thousand years, the race would profit nothing by destroying, a few months before the end of each millennium, all sick persons, lunatics, and other ‘useless mouths.’ I have not seen this difficulty with regard to the massacring instinct in wasps mentioned before, and I only mention it now in order to draw atten- tion to the fact that there seems to be a more puzzling problem presented here than in the case of the analogous instinct as exhibited by bees. The only solution which has suggested itself to my mind is the possibility that in earlier times, or in other climates, wasps may have re- sembled bees in living through the winter, and that the grub-slaying instinct is in them a survival of one which
was then, as in the case of the bees now, a clearly beneficial instinct. ) For some days before swarming begins, there is a great excitement and buzzing in the hive, the temperature of which rises from 92° to 104°. Scouts having been pre- viously sent out to explore for suitable quarters wherein to plant the new colony, these now act as guides. The swarm leaves the hive with their queen. The bees which remain behind busy themselves in rearing out the pup, which soon arriving at maturity, also quit the hive in successive swarms. According to Bichner, ‘ secondary swarms with young queens send out no, scouts, but fly at random through the air. They clearly lack the experience and prudence of the older bees.’ And, regarding the behaviour of the scouts sent out by primary swarms, this author says :—
M. de Fraviére had the opportunity of observing the manner in which such an examination is carried on, and with what pru- — dence and accuracy. He placed an empty beehive, made in a new style,-in front of his house, so that he could exactly watch from his own window what went on inside and out without disturb- ance to himself or to the bees. A single bee came and examined the building, flying all round it and touching it. It then let itself down on the board, and walked carefully and thoroughly over the interior, touching it continually with its antennz so as. to subject it on all sides to a thorough investigation. The result of its examination must have been satisfactory, for after it had gone away it returned accompanied by a crowd of some fifty friends, which now together went through the same pro- cess as their guide. This new trial must also have had a good — result, for soon a whole swarm came, evidently from a distant. spot, and took possession. Still more remarkable is the behaviour of the scouts when they take possession of a satis- factory hive or box for an imminent or approaching swarm. Although it is not yet inhabited they regard it as their property, watch it and guard it against stranger bees or other assailants, and busy themselves earnestly in the most careful cleansing of it, so far as this cleansing is impossible to the setter up of the hive. Such a taking possession sometimes occurs eight days before the entrance of the swarm.
war is plunder; and facts now well substantiated by numberless observers concerning ‘robber-bees’ indicate a large measure of intelligence. These aim at lessening their labour in collecting honey by plundering the store of other hives. The robberies may be conducted singly o1 in concert. When the thieving propensity is developed only in individual cases, the thieves cannot rely on force in plundering a foreign state, and so resort to cautious stealth. ‘They show by their whole behaviour—creeping into the hive with careful vigilance—that they are per- fectly conscious of their bad conduct; whereas the workers belonging to the hive fly in quickly and openly, and in full consciousness of their right.’ If such solitary burglars. are successful in obtaining plunder, their bad example leads other members of their own community to imitate them; thus it is that the whole bee-nation may de- _ velop marauding habits, and when they do this they act
in concert to rob by force. In this case an army of bees _ precipitates itself upon the foreign hive, a battle ensues,. and if successful in overcoming resistance, the invaders first of all search out the queen-bee and put her to death, whereby they disorganise their enemies and plunder the hive with ease. It is observed that when this policy is once successful, the spirit of aggrandisement is encouraged, so that the robber-bees ‘ find more pleasure in robbery than in their own work, and become at last formidable robber-. states.’ When an invaded hive is fairly overcome by the invaders killing the queen, the owners of the hive, finding that all is lost, not only abandon further resistance, but very often reverse their policy and join the ranks of their conquerors. They assist in the tearing down of their cells, and in the conveyance of the honey to the hive of their invaders. ‘When the assailed hive is emptied, the next ones are attacked, and if no effective resistance is offered, are robbed in similar fashion, so that in this way a whole bee-stand may be gradually destroyed.’ Siebold observed the same facts in the case of wasps. (Polistes gallica). If, however, the battle turns in favour
happens that the plundered hive offers no resistance at all, owing to the robbers having visited the same flowers as the robbed, and so probably (having much the same smell) not being recognised as belonging to a different com- munity. The thieves, when they find such to be the case, may become so bold as to stop the bees that are returning to the hive with their loads, of which they deprive them at the entrance of the hive. This is done by a process which one observer, Weygandt,' calls ‘milking,’ and it ‘seems that the milking bee attains the double advantage of securing the honey from the milked one and disarming suspicion of the other bees by contracting its smell and entering the hive loaded, into which it is admitted with- out opposition to continue its plunder.
Sometimes robber-bees attack their victims in the fields at a distance from the hives. This sort of high- way robbery is generally conducted by a gang of four or five robber-bees which set upon a single honest bee, — “hold him by the legs, and pinch him until he unfolds his tongue, which is sucked in succession by his assailants, who then suffer him to depart in peace.’ It is strange that hive-bees of dishonest tempera- ments seem able to coax or wheedle humble-bees into the voluntary yielding of honey. ‘ Humble-bees have been known to permit hive-bees to take the whole honey that they have collected, and to go on gathering more, and handing it over, for three weeks, although they refuse to part with it, or seek refuge in flight, when wasps make similar overtures.’ ?
Besides theft and plunder, there are other causes of warfare among bees, which, however, are only apparent in their effects. Thus, for some undiscernible reason, duels are not infrequent, which generally end in the death of one or both combatants. At other times, equally without apparent reason, civil war breaks out in a hive, which is sometimes attended with much slaughter. Architecture.—Coming now to the construction of the cells and combs, there is no doubt that here we meet with
the most astonishing products of instinct that are pre- sented in the animal kingdom. A great deal has been written on the practical exhibition of high mathematical principles which bees display in constructing their combs in the form that secures the utmost capacity for storage of honey with the smallest expenditure of building material. The shortest and clearest statement of the subject that I have met with is the following, which has been given by Dr. Reid :—
There are only three possible figures of the cells which can make them all equal and similar, without any useless interstices. These are the equilateral triangle, the square, and the regular hexagon. Mathematicians know that there is not a fourth way _ possible in which a plane may be cut into little spaces that _ shall be equal, similar, and regular, without useless spaces. Of the three figures, the hexagon is the most proper for convenience ‘and strength. Bees, as if they knew this, make their cells regular hexagons.
. Again, it has been demonstrated that, by making the bottoms _ of the cells to consist of three planes meeting in a point, there _ isa saving of material and labour in no way inconsiderable. The bees, as if acquainted with these principles of solid geometry, follow them most accurately. Itis a curious mathe- matical problem, at what precise angle the three planes which compose the bottom of a cell ought to meet, in order to make _ the greatest possible saving, or the least expense of material and labour. This is one of the problems which belong to the higher parts of mathematics. It has accordingly been resolved by some mathematicians, particularly by the ingenious Maclaurin, by a fluctionary calculation, which is to be found in the Transac- tions of the Royal Society of London. He has determined precisely the angle required, and he found, by the most exact mensuration the subject would admit, that it is the very angle _ in which the three planes in the bottom of the cell of a honey- - comb do actually meet.}
Marvellous as these facts undoubtedly are, they may now be regarded as having been satisfactorily explained. Long ago Buffon sought to account for the hexagonal form of the cells by an hypothesis of mutual pressure. _ Supposing the bees to have a tendency to build tubular cells, if a greater number of bees were to build in a given space than could admit of all the parallel tubes being completed, tubes with flat sides and sharp angles might result, and if the mutual pressure were exactly equal in all directions, these sides and angles would assume the form of hexagons. This hypothesis of Buffon was sustained by such physical analogies as the blowing of a crowd of soap- bubbles in a cup, the swelling of moistened peas in a con- fined space, &e. The hypothesis, however, as thus pre- sented was clearly inadequate; for no reason is assigned why the mutual pressure, even if conceded to exist, should always be so exactly equal in all directions as to convert all the cylinders into perfect hexagons—even the ana- logy of the soap-bubbles and the moistened peas failing, as pointed out by Brougham and others, to sustain it, seeing that as a matter of fact bubbles and peas under circumstances of mutual pressure do not assume the form of hexagons, but, on the contrary, forms which are con- spicuously irregular. Moreover, the hypothesis fails to. * account for the particular prismatic shape presented by the cell base. Therefore it is not surprising that this. hypothesis should have gained but small acceptance. Kirby and Spence dispose of it thus: —*He (Buffon) gravely tells us that the boasted hexagonal cells of the bee are produced by the reciprocal pressure of the cylindrical bodies of these insects against each other!!?! The double note of admiration here may be taken to express the feelings with which this hypothesis of Buffon was re- garded by all the more sober-minded naturalists. Yet it turns out to have been not very wide of the mark.
As is often the case with the gropings of a great mind, the idea contains the true principle of the explanation, although it fails as an explanation from not being in a position to take sufficient cognizance of all the facts. Safer it is for lesser minds to restrain their notes of exclamation while considering the theories of a greater; however crude or absurd the latter may appear, the place of their birth renders it not impossible that some day they may prove to have been prophetic of truth revealed by fuller know 1 Introd. Ent., ii, p. 465. .
ledge. Usually in such cases the final explanation is eventually reached by the working of a yet greater mind, Mr. Waterhouse pointed out ‘ that the form of the cell stands in close relation to the presence of adjoining cells.’ Starting from this fact, Mr. Darwin says,— Let us look to the great principle of gradation, and see whether Nature does not reveal to us her method of work. At one end of a short series we have humble-bees, which use their old cocoons to hold honey, sometimes adding to them short
tubes of wax, and likewise making separate and very irregular rounded cells of wax. At the other end of the series we have _ the cells of the hive-bee, placed in a double layer. . . . In the _ series between the extreme perfection of the cells of the hive- bee and the simplicity of those of the humble-bee we have the cells of the Mexican Melipona domestica, carefully described and figured by Pierre Huber. . . . It forms a nearly regular waxen comb of cylindrical cells, in which the young are hatched, and, in addition, some large cells of wax for holding honey. These latter cells are nearly spherical and of nearly equal sizes, and are aggregated into an irregular mass. But the important thing to notice is, that these cells are always made at that degree of nearness to each other that they would have intersected or broken into each other if the spheres had been completed ; but this is never permitted, the bees building perfectly flat cells of wax between the spheres which thus tend to intersect. Hence each cell consists of an outer spherical portion ; and of two, three, or more flat surfaces, according as the cell adjoins two, three, or more other cells. When one cell rests on three other cells, which, from the spheres being nearly of the same size, is very frequently and necessarily the case, the three flat surfaces are united into a pyramid; and this pyramid, as Huber has remarked, is manifestly a gross imitation of the three-sided pyramidal base of the cell of the hive-bee. . . .
Reflecting on this case, it occurred to me that if the Meli- - pona had made its spheres at some given distance from each other, and had made them of equal sizes, and had arranged them symmetrically in a double layer, the resulting structure would have been as perfect as the comb of the hive-bee. Accordingly I wrote to Prof. Miller of Cambridge, and ‘this geometer has kindly read over the following statement, drawn up from his; information, and tells me that it is strictly correct.
This statement having fully borne out his theory, Mr. Darwin continues :— Hence we may safely conclude that, if we could slightly modify the instincts already possessed by the Melipona, and in themselves not very wonderful, this bee would make a structure as wonderfully perfect as that of the hive-bee. We must sup- pose the Melipona to have the power of forming her cells truly spherical, and of equal sizes; and this would not be very sur- prising, seeing that she already does so to a certain extent, and seeing what perfectly cylindrical burrows many insects make in wood, apparently by turning round on a fixed point. Wemust suppose the Melipona to arrange her cells in level layers, as she already does her cylindrical cells; and we must further suppose: —and this is the greatest difticulty— that she can somehow judge- accurately at what distance to stand from her fellow-labourers when several are making their spheres; but she is already so far able to judge of distance that she always describes her spheres so as to intersect to a certain extent; and then she unites the points of intersection by perfectly flat surfaces. By such modifications of instinct, which in themselves are not very wonderful—hardly more wonderful than those which guide a. bird to make its nest,—I believe that the hive-bee has acquired through natural selection her inimitable architectural powers.!
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.