Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 420 to 449 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

420

Mr. Darwin next tested this theory by the experiment. of introducing into beehives plates of wax, and observing that the bees worked upon these plates just.as the theory required. That is to say, they made their cells by ex- cavating a number of little circular pits at equal distances. from one another, so that by the time the pits had ac- quired the width of an ordinary cell, the sides of the pits. intersected. As soon as this occurred the bees ceased to. excavate, and instead began to build up flat walls of wax on the lines of intersection. Other experiments with very thin plates of vermilion-coloured wax showed that the bees all worked at about the same rate, and on opposite sides of the plates, so that the common bottoms of any ~ two opposite pits were flat. These flat bottoms ‘were situated, as far as the eye could judge, exactly along the planes of imaginary intersection between the basins on the opposite sides of the ridge of wax;’ so that if the

421

site basins being deepened (and widened) into cells, the mutual intersection of adjacent as well as opposite bottoms would have given rise, as in the first experiment with the thick plate of wax, to the pyramidal bottoms. Experi- ments with the vermilion wax also showed, as Huber had _ previously stated, that a number of individual bees work Invariably found that the colour was most delicately diffused by the bees—as delicately as a painter could have done it with his brush—by atoms of the coloured wax having been taken

422

from the spot on which it had been placed, and worked into the The work of construction seems to be a sort of balance struck between many bees, all instinctively standing at the same relative distance from each other, all trying to sweep equal spheres, and then building up, or leaving ungnawed, the This theory, while serving as a full and simple expla- nation of all the facts, has, as we have seen, been so fully substantiated by observation and experiment, that it de- serves to be regarded as raised to the rank of a completed demonstration. It differs from the theory of Buffon in two important particulars: it embraces all the facts, and supplies a cause adequate to explain them. This cause is natural selection, which converts the random ‘pressure’ in Buffon’s theory into a precisely regulated principle. Random pressure alone could never produce the beautifully symmetrical form of the hexagonal cell with the pyramidal bottom ; but it could and must have produced the intersection of cylindrical cells among pos- sibly many extinct species of bees, such as the Melipona. Whenever this intersection occurred in crowded nests, it must clearly have been of great benefit in securing economy of precious wax; for in every case where a flat wall of partition between two adjacent cells did duty

423

instead of a double cylindrical wall of separate cells, there ‘wax should have been saved. Thus we can see how natural selection would have worked towards the develop- ing of an instinct to excavate cells near enough together to produce intersection; and once begun, there is no reason why this instinct should not have been perfected by the same agency, till we meet with its ideal perfection in the hive-bee. For as Mr. Darwin observes,— With respect to the formation of wax, it is known that bees are often hard pressed to get sufficient nectar; and I am informed by Mr. Tegetmeier that it has been experimentally proved that from twelve to fifteen pounds of dry sugar are con- ‘sumed by a hive of bees for the secretion of a pound of wax; so that a prodigious quantity of fluid nectar must be collected and consumed by the bees in a hive for the secretion of the wax necessary for the construction of their combs. Moreover, many bees have to remain idle for many days during the process of secretion. . . . Hence it would continually be more and more advantageous to our humble-bees if they were to make their cells more and more regular, nearer together, and aggregated into a mass, like the cells of Melipona; for in this case a large of the bounding surface of each cell would serve to bound the adjoining cell, and much labour and wax would be saved. Again, from the same cause, it would be advantageous to the Melipona if she were to make her cells closer together, and more regular in every way than at present; for then, as we have seen, the spherical surfaces would wholly disappear and be replaced by plane surfaces; and the Melipona would make a comb as perfect as that of the hive-bee. Beyond this stage of perfection in architecture, natural selection could not lead; for the comb of ‘the hive-bee, as far as we can see, is absolutely perfect in economising labour and wax.

424

The problem, then, as to the origin and perfection of the cell-making instinct appears thus to have been fully and finally solved. I shall now adduce a few facts to show that while the general instinct of building hexagonal cells has doubtless been acquired by natural selection in the way just explained, it is nevertheless an instinct not wholly of a blind or mechanical kind, but is constantly under the control of intelligent purpose. Thus Mr. Darwin — observes,—

425

It was really curious to note in cases of difficulty, as when two pieces of comb met at an angle, how often the bees would pul] down and rebuild in different ways the same cell, some- times recurring to a shape which they had at first rejected.! Again, Huber saw a bee building upon the wax which had already been put together by her comrades, But she did not arrange it properly, or in a way to continue the design of her predecessors, so that her building made an undesirable corner with theirs. ‘ Another bee perceived it, pulled down the bad work before our eyes, and gave it to the first in the requisite order, so that it might exactly follow the original direction.’ Similarly, to quote Biichner,—

426

All the cells have not the same shape, as would be the case if the bees in building worked according to a perfectly instinctive and unchangeable plan. There are very manifold changes and irregularities. Almost in every comb irregular and unfinished cells are to be found, especially where the several divisions of a comb come together. The small architects do not begin their comb from a single centre, but begin building from many differ- ent points, so as to progress as rapidly as possible, and so that the greatest number may work simultaneously ; they therefore build from above downwards, in the shape of flat truncated cones or hanging pyramids, and these several portions are after- wards united together during the winter building. At these lines of junction it is impossible to avoid irregular cells between the pressed together or unnaturally lengthened ones. The same is true more or less of the passage cells, which are made to unite the large cells of the so-called drone wax with the smaller ones of the working bees, and which are generally placed in two or three rows. The cells also which they usually build from the combs to the glass walls of their hives, in order to hold them up, show somewhat irregular forms. Finally, in places where special conditions of the situation do not other- wise permit, it may be observed that the bees, far from clinging obstinately to their plan, very well understand how to accom- modate themselves to circumstancces not only in cell-building, but also in making their combs. F. Huber tried to mislead their instinct, or rather to put to the proof their reason and cleverness in every possible way, but they always emerged tri- umphant from the ordeal. For instance, he put bees in a hive

427

the floor and roof of which were made of glass, that is of a body which the bees use very unwillingly for the attachment of their combs, on account of its smoothness. Thus the possibility of building as usual from above downwards, and also from below — upwards, was taken away from them ; they had no point of sup- port save the perpendicular walls of their dwelling. They thereupon built on one of these walls a regular stratum of cells, from which, building sideways, they tried to carry the comb to the opposite side of the hive. To prevent this Huber covered that side also with glass. But what way out of the difficulty was found by the clever insects? Instead of building further in the projected direction, they bent the comb round at the extreme point, and carried it at a right angle towards one of the inner sides of the hive which was not covered with glass, and there fastened it. The form and dimensions of the cells must necessarily have been altered thereby, and the arrange- ment of their work at the angle must have been quite different from the usual, They made the cells of the convex side so much broader than those of the concave that they had a diameter two or three times as great, and yet they managed to join them properly with the others. They also did not wait to bend the comb until they came to the glass itself, but recog- nised the difficulty beforehand,! which had heen interposed by Huber while they were building with a view to overcome the first difficulty.

428

The Mason-Bee.—This insect closes the roof of its larval cell with a kind of mortar, which sets as hard as stone. A little hole, closed only with soft mud, is, how- ever, left in one part of the roof as a door of exit for the matured insect. It is said that when a mason-bee finds an old and deserted nest, it saves itself the trouble of making a new one—utilising the ready-made nest after having well cleaned it. Ini Algiers the mason-bees have been observed in this way to utilise empty snail-shells. According to Blanchard, some individuals avoid the labour of making their own nests or houses for their young, by possessing themselves of their neighbours’ houses either by craft or by force. ‘Does the mason-bee act like a machine,’ says E. Menault, ‘when it directs its work ac-

429

cording to circumstances, possesses itself of old nests, cleanses and improves them, and thereby shows that it can fully appreciate the immediate position ? Can one believe that no kind of reflection is here necessary ?’ The Tapestry-Bee.—The so-called tapestry-bee digs holes for her larvee three or four inches deep in the earth, and lines the walls and floor of the chamber with petals of the poppy laid perfectly smooth. Several layers of petals are used, and when the eggs are introduced the chamber is closed by drawing all the leaves together at the top. Loose earth is then piled over the whole structure in order to conceal it. The so-called rose-bee (Megachile centun- cularis) displays very similar habits.!

430

The Carpenter-Bee.—This was first observed and de- scribed by Réaumur.? It makes a long cylindrical tube in the wood of beams, palings, &c. This it divides into a number of successive chambers by partitions made of agglutinated saw-dust built across the tube at right angles to its axis. In each chamber there is deposited a single egg, together with a store of pollen for the nourish- ment of the future larva. The larve hatch out in suc- cession and in the order of their age—z.e. the dates at which they were deposited. To provide for this, the bee bores a hole from the lower cell to the exterior, so that each larva, when ready to escape from its chamber, finds an open way from the tube. The larve have to cut their own way out through the walls of their respective chambers, and itis remarkable that they always cut through the wall that faces the tubular passage left by the parent; they never bore their way out in the opposite direction, which, were they to do so, would entail the destruction of all the other and immature larve.

431

The Carding-Bee.—This insect surrounds its nest with a layer of wax, and then with a thick covering of moss. For this purpose a number of bees co-operate, and in order to save time each bee does not find and carry its own moss, but, with a division of labour similar to that which we have already noticed in the case of certain ants, a row of bees is formed, and the bits of moss passed from one to another along the line. There is a long passage to the nest, through which the moss has to be passed, and it is said that at the mouth of the tunnel a guard is stationed to drive away ants or other intruders.

432

Wasps.—These usually construct their nests of wood- dust, which they scrape off the weather-worn surfaces of boards, palings, &c., and work into a kind of paper with their saliva. If they happen to find any real paper, they perceive that it so much resembles the product of their own manufacture that they utilise it forthwith. The wasps do not require any special cells or chambers for the storage of honey, as they do not lay up any supply for the winter. The cells which they construct are therefore used exclusively for the rearing of larve. In form these cells are sometimes cylindrical or globular, but more usually hexagonal, like those of the hive-bee. Although the mode of building is different from that employed by the bees, there can be little doubt that if it were as care- fully investigated Mr. Darwin’s theory of transition from the cylindrical to the hexagonal form would be found to apply here also, seeing that both forms so frequently occur in the same nest. |

433

The Mason-Wasp.—The habits of this insect are de- scribed by Mr. Bates. Itconstructs its nest of clay. Each pellet that the insect brings it lays on the top of its nest- wall, and then spreads it out with its jaws, and treads it smooth with its feet. The nest, which is suspended on the branch of a tree, is then stocked with spiders and insects paralysed by stinging. The victims, not being wholly deprived of life, keep fresh until required as food of the developing larvee.

434

The Butcher- Wasps.—These also paralyse their prey in a similar manner, and for a similar purpose. Fabre removed from a so-called sphex-wasp a killed grass- hopper, which it was conveying to its nest and had momentarily laid down at the mouth of the burrow—as these insects always do on returning with prey, in order to see that nothing has intruded into the burrow during their absence. Fabre carried the dead or paralysed grasshopper to a considerable distance from the hole. On coming out the insect searched about until it found its prey. It then again carried it to the mouth of its burrow, and again laid it.down while it once more went in to see that all was right at home. Again Fabre removed the grasshopper, and so on for forty times in suecession—the sphex never omitting to go through its fixed routine of examining the interior of its burrow every time that it brought the prey to its mouth.

435

Mr. Mivart, in his ‘ Lessons from Nature,’ points to the instinct of this animal in the stinging of the ganglion of its prey as one that cannot be explained on Mr. Darwin’s theory concerning the origin of instincts. In my next work, which will have to deal with this theory, I shall consider Mr. Mivart’s difficulty, and also the difficulty first pointed out by Mr. Darwin himself as to why neuter insects, separated as they appear to be from the possi- bility of communicating by heredity any instinctive acquirements of the individual to the species, should present any instincts at all.

436

Beginning with Sir John Lubbock’s observations on this head, I shall first quote his statements with regard to way-finding :—- I have found, he says, that some bees are much more intel- ligent in this respect than others. A bee which I had fed several times, and which had flown about in the room, found its way out of the glass ina quarter of an hour, and when put in a second time came out at once. Another bee, when I closed the postern door, used to come round to the honey through an .- open window.

437

Bees seem to me much less clever in finding things than I had expected. One day (April 14, 1872), when a number of them were very busy on some barberries, I put a saucer with some honey between two bunches of flowers; these were re- peatedly visited, and were so close that there was hardly room for the saucer betweeen them, yet from 9.30 to 3.30 not a single bee took any notice of the honey. At 3.30 I put some honey on one of the bunches of flowers, and it was eagerly sucked by the bees; two kept continually returning till past five in the evening.

438

One day when I came home in the afternoon I found that at least a hundred bees had got into my room through the pos- tern and were on the window, yet not one was attracted by an open jar of honey which stood in a shady corner about 3 feet 6 inches from the window. One day (29th April, 1872) I placed a saucer of honey close to some forget-me-nots, on which bees were numerous and busy ; yet from 10 a.m. till 6 only one bee went to the honey. I put some honey in a hollow in the garden wall opposite the hives at 10.30 (this wall is about five feet high and four feet from the hives); yet the bees did not find it during the whole day.

439

On the 30th March, 1873, a fine sunshiny day, when the bees were very active, I placed a glass containing honey at 9 in the morning on the wall in front of the hives ; but not a single bee went to the honey the whole day. On April 20 I tried the same experiment, with the same result. September 19.—At 9.30 I placed some honey in a glass about four feet from and just in front of the hive; but during the whole day not a bee observed it. As it then occurred to me that it might be suggested that there was something about this honey which rendered it unat- tractive to the bees, on a following day I placed it again on the top of the wall for three hours, during which not a single bee came, and then moved it close to the alighting-board of the hive. It remained unnoticed for a quarter of an hour, when two bees observed it; and others soon followed in considerable numbers, . . . On the whole, wasps seem to me more clever in finding their way than bees. I tried wasps with the glass mentioned on p. 124 [%.e. the bell-jar], but they had no diffi- culty in finding their way out.

440

We shall now conclude this résumé of Sir John- Lubbock’s observations by quoting two other passages bearing on the general intelligence of bees and wasps :— The following fact struck me as rather remarkable. The wasp already mentioned at the foot of p. 135 one day smeared her wings with syrup, so that she could not fly. When this happened to a bee, it was only necessary to carry her to the alighting-board, when she was soon cleaned by her comrades. But I did not know where this wasp’s nest was, and therefore

441

-could not pursue a similar course with her. At first, then, I was afraid that she was doomed. I thought, however, that I would wash her, fully expecting, indeed, to terrify her so much that -she would not return again. I therefore caught her, put her in a bottle half full of water, and shook her up well till the honey was washed off. I then transferred her to a dry bottle and put her in the sun. When she was dry I let her out, and she at once flew to her nest. To my surprise, in thirteen minutes she returned, as if nothing had happened, and continued her visits ‘to the honey all the afternoon.

442

This experiment interested me so much that I repeated it with another marked wasp, this time, however, keeping the wasp in the water till she was quite motionless and insensible. When taken out of the water she soon recovered; I fed her ; ‘she went quietly away to her nest as usual, and returned after ‘the usual absence. The next morning this wasp was the first to visit the honey. for more than a few days; but I kept a specimen of Polistes Gallica for no less than nine months.

443

This is the wasp which has already been alluded to under the heading ‘Memory ;’ but it is evident that the individual experiences incidental to its domestication. The remaining passages that deserve quotation are the It is sometimes said of bees that those of one hive all know one another, and immediately recognise and attack any intruder from another hive. At first sight this certainly implies a great -deal of intelligence, It is, however, possible that the bees of

444

particular hives have a particular smell. Thus Langshaft, in his interesting ‘ Treatise on the Honey-Bee,’ says: ‘ Members of -different colonies appear to recognise their hive companions by the sense of smell; and I believe that if colonies are sprinkled with scented syrup, they may generally be safely mixed. More- -over, a bee returning to its own hive with a load of treasure is a very different creature from a hungry marauder; and it is ‘said that a bee, if laden with honey, is allowed to enter any

445

hive with impunity.’ Mr. Langshaft continues, ‘There is an air of roguery about a thieving bee which, to the expert, is as characteristic as are the motions of a pickpocket to a skilfub policeman. Its sneaking look, and nervous, guilty agitation, once seen, can never be mistaken.’ It is, at any rate, natural that a bee which enters a wrong hive by accident should be much surprised and alarmed, and would thus probably betray herself. On the whole, then, I do not attach much importance to: their recognition of one another as an indication of intelligence.

446

Since their extreme eagerness for honey may be attributed rather to their anxiety for the common weal than to their desire for personal gratification, it cannot fairly be imputed as greedi- ness ; still the following scene, one which most of us have wit- nessed, is incompatible surely with much intelligence. The sad fate of their unfortunate companions does not in the least deter others who approach the tempting lure from madly alighting on the bodies of the dying and dead, to share the same miserable- end. No one can understand the extent of their infatuation until he has seen a confectioner’s shop assailed by myriads of hungry bees. I have seen thousands strained out from the syrup in which they had perished; thousands more alighting even upon the boiling sweets, the floor covered and windows darkened with bees, some crawling, others flying, and others still, so completely besmeared as to be able neither to crawl nor fly, not one in ten able to carry home its ill-gotten spoils, and yet the air filled with new hosts of thoughtless comers.

447

Passing on now to the statements of other observers,. Huber first noticed the remarkable fact that when bee- hives are attacked by the death’s-head moth the bees close the entrance of their hive with wax and propolis to keep out the marauder. The barricade, which is built immediately behind the gateway, completely stops it up —only a small hole being left large enough to admit a bee, and therefore of course too small to admit the moth. Huber specially states that it was not until the beehives had been repeatedly attacked and robbed by the death’s- head moth, that the bees closed the entrance of their hive: with wax and propolis. Pure instinct would have induced the bees to provide against the first attack. Huber also observed that a wall built in 1804 against the death’s-- head hawk-moth was destroyed in 1805. In the latter year there were no death’s-head moths, nor were any seen during the following. But in the autumn of 1807 a large number again appeared, and the bees at once protected

448

themselves against their enemies. The bulwark was de- stroyed again in 1808. Again, Huber (loc. cit., tom. ii., p. 280) gives a case of apparent exercise of reason, or power of inference from a particular case to other and general cases. A piece of comb fell down and was fixed in its new position by wax. The bees then strengthened the attachments of all the other combs, clearly because they inferred that they too might be in danger of falling. This is a very remarkable case, and leads Huber to exclaim, ‘I admit that I was unable to avoid a feeling of astonishment in the presence of a fact from which the purest reason seemed to shine out.’

449

A closely similar, and therefore corroborative case of an even more remarkable kind is thus narrated in Watson’s ‘Reasoning Power of Animals’ (p. 448) :— _ Dr. Brown, in his book on the bee, gives another illustration: _ of the reasoning power of bees, observed by a friend of his. A centre comb in a hive, being overburdened with honey, had parted from its fastenings, and was pressing against another comb, so as to prevent the passage of the bees between them.

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.