Animal Intelligence
T shall feel obliged if you will record in ‘ Nature’ a fact with reference to the common black scorpion of Southern India, which was observed by me some years ago in Madras. One morning a servant brought to me a large specimen of this scorpion, which, having stayed out too long in its nocturnal rambles, had apparently got bewildered at daybreak, and been unable to find its way home. To keep it safe the creature was at once put into a glazed entomological case. Having a few leisure minutes in the course of the forenoon I thought I would see how my prisoner was getting on, and to have a better view of it the case was placed in a window in the rays of the hot. sun. The light and heat seemed to irritate it very much, and this recalled to my mind a story which I had read somewhere that a scorpion, on being surrounded with fire, had committed suicide. I hesitated about subjecting my pet to such a terrible. ordeal, but taking a common botanical lens, I focussed the rays of the sun on its back. The moment this was done it began to run hurriedly about the case, hissing and spitting in a very fierce way. This experiment was repeated some four or five times with like results, but on trying it once again, the scorpion turned up its tail and plunged the sting, quick as lightning, into its own back. The infliction of the wound was followed by a sudden escape of fluid, and a friend standing by me called out, ‘See, it has stung itself: it is dead ;’ and sure enough in less. than half a minute life was quite extinct. JI have written this brief note to show (1) that animals may commit suicide; (2) that the poison of certain animals may be destructive to them- selves.
The following corroborative evidence on the subject was then supplied by Dr. Allen Thomson, F.R.S. (‘ Nature,’ vol. xx., p. 577) :— Doubts having been expressed at various times, even by learned naturalists, as to the reality of the suicide or self-de- struction of the scorpion by means of its own poison, and these doubts having been again stated in ‘ Nature,’ vol. xx., p. 553, by Mr. B. F. Hutchinson, of Peshawur, as the result of his own observations, I think it may be useful to give an articulate account of the phenomenon as it has been related to me by an eye-witness, which removes all possible doubt as toits occurrence under certain circumstances.
While residing many years ago, during the summer months, at the baths of Sulla in Italy, in a somewhat damp locality, my informant together with the rest of the family was much annoyed by the frequent intrusion of smail black scorpions into. the house, and their being secreted among the bedclothes, in shoes, and other articles of dress. It thus became necessary to ‘be constantly on the watch for these troublesome creatures, and ‘to take means for their removal and destruction. Having been informed by the natives of the place that the scorpion would destroy itself if exposed te a sudden light, my informant and her friends soon became adepts in catching the scorpions and — disposing of them in the manner suggested. ‘This consisted in confining the animal underan inverted drinking-glass or tumbler, below which a card was inserted when the capture was made, and ‘then, waiting till dark, suddenly bringing the light of a candle near to the glass in which the animal was confined. No sooner was this done than the scorpion invariably showed signs -of great excitement, running round and round the interior of the tumbler with reckless velocity for a number of times. This state having lasted for a minute or more, the animal suddenly became quiet, and turning its tail on the hinder part of its body over its back, brought its recurved sting down upon the middle of the head, and piercing it forcibly, in a few seconds became quite motionless, and in fact quite dead. This observa- tion was repeated very frequently ; in truth, it was adopted as the best plan of getting rid of the animals. The young people were in the habit of handling the scorpions with impunity im- mediately after they were so killed, and of preserving many of them as curiosities.
In this narrative the following circumstances are worthy of attention :— (1) The effect of light in producing the excitement amount- ing to despair, which causes the animal to commit self-destruc- tion ; (2) The suddenness of the operation of the poison, which is probably inserted by the penctane of the head into the upper cerebral ganglion; and (3) The completeness of the fatal Symptoms at once in- duced. I am aware that the phenomena now described have been observed by others, and they-appear to have been familiarly known to the inhabitants of the district in which the animals are found. Sufficient confirmation of the facts is also to be found in the narratives of ‘G. Biddie’ and ‘ M. L.’ contained in ‘ Nature,’ vol. ix., pp. 29-47, and it will be observed that the circumstances leading the animal to self-destruction in these in- stances were somewhat similar to those narrated by my inform- ant. It is abundantly clear, therefore, that the view taken
by Mr. Hutchinson, viz., that the ‘popular idea regarding _ scorpionic suicide is a delusion based on an impossibility,’ is _ wholly untenable; indeed, the recurved direction of the sting, which he refers to as creating the impossibility of the animal destroying itself, actually facilitates the operation of inflicting the wound. I suppose Mr. Hutchinson, arguing from the ana- logy of bees or wasps, imagined that the sting would be bent forwards upon the body, whereas the wound of the scorpion is invariably inflicted by a recurvation of the tail over the back of the animal.
It will be perceived that these observations were not made by Dr. Allen Thomson himself, and that there are certain inherent discrepancies in the account which he has published—such, for instance, as the reason given for _ trying and repeating the experiment, the method being’ _ clearly a cumbersome one to employ if the only object were that of ‘disposing of’ the animals. Nevertheless, as Dr. Thomson is a high authority, and as I learn from him that he is satisfied regarding the capability and vera~ _ city of his informant, I have not felt justified in suppress- ing his evidence. Still I think that so remarkable a fact _ unquestionably demands further corroboration before we should be justified in accepting it unreservedly. For if it is a fact, it stands as a unique case of an instinct detrimental alike to the individual and to the species.
THE Hymenoptera being so much the most intelligent order, not merely of insects, but of Invertebrata, and the Arachnida having been now considered, very little space need be occupied with the remaining classes of the Articu- lata. Sir John Lubbock, in his first paper on Bees and Wasps, quotes the following case from Kirby and Spence, with the remarks which I append :-— The first of these anecdotes refers to a beetle (Ateuchus pilu- larius) which, having made for the reception of its eggs a pellet of dung too heavy for it to move, repaired toan adjoining heap, and soon returned with three of his companions, ‘All four now applied their united strength to the pellet, and at length suc- ceeded in pushing it out; which being done, the three assistant. beetles left the spot and returned to their own quarters.’ This observation rests on the authority of an anonymous German artist ; and though we are assured that he was a ‘man of strict veracity,’ I am not aware that any similar fact has been re- corded by any other observer.
I have attentively admired their industry, and their mutual assisting of each other in rolling these globular balls from the place where they made them, to that of their interment, which is usually a distance of some yards, more or less. This they perform back foremost, by raising their hind parts and pushing away the ball with their hind feet. Two or three of them are sometimes engaged in trundling one ball, which from meeting with impediments, on account of the unevenness of the ground, is sometimes deserted by them. It is, however, attempted by others with success, unless it happen to roll into some deep hollow or ditch, where they are accustomed to leave it; but
they continue their work by rolling off the next ball that comes in their way. None of them seem to know their own balls, but an equal care for the whole appears to affect all the community. They form these pellets while the dung remains moist, and leave them to harden in the sun before they attempt to roll them. In their rolling of them from place to place, both they and the balls may frequently be seen tumbling about over the little eminenees that are in their way. They are not, however, easily discouraged, and by repeating their attempts usually surmount the difficulties.!
Biichner speaks of the fact that dung-beetles co-operate in their work as one that is well established, but gives no authorities or references.? <A friend of my own, however, informs me that she has witnessed the fact; and in view of analogous observations made on other species of Coleop- observations I may here append. Herr Gollitz writes to Biichner thus :— Last summer, in the month of July, I was one day in my field, and found there a mound of fresh earth like a molehill, on which a striped black and red beetle, with long legs, and about the size of a hornet, was busy taking away the earth from a hole that led like a pit into the mound, and levelling the place. After I had watched this beetle for some time, I noticed a second beetle of the same kind, which brought a little lump of earth from the interior to the opening of the hole, and then disappeared again in the mound ; every four or five minutes a pellet came out of the hole, and was carried away by the first- named beetle. After I had watched these proceedings for about half an hour, the beetle which had been working underground came out and ran to its comrade. Both put their heads together, and clearly held a conversation, for immediately afterwards they changed work. The one which had been working outside went into the mound, the other took the outside labour, and all went on vigorously. I watched the affair still for a little longer, and went away with the notion that these insects could understand each other just like men. Klingelhéffer, of Darmstadt (in Brehm, oc. cit., ix., p. 86), says :—A golden running beetle came to a cockchafer lying on its back in the garden, intending to eat it, but was unable to master it; it ran to the next bush, and
returned with a friend, whereupon the two overpowered the cockchafer, and pulled it off to their hiding-place. Similarly, there is no doubt that the burying beetl (Nicrophorus) co-operate. Several of them unite together to bury under the ground, as food and shelter for their young, some dead animal, such as a mouse, a toad, a mole, a bird, &e. The burial is performed because the corpse, if left above ground, would either dry up, or grow rotten, or be eaten by other animals. In all these cases the young would perish, whereas the dead body lying in the earth and withdrawn from the outer air lasts very well. The burying beetles go to work in a very well-considered fashion, for they scrape away the earth lying under the body, so that it sinks of itself deeper and deeper. When it is deep enough down, it is covered over from above. If the situation is stony, the beetles with united forces and great efforts drag the corpse to some place more suitable for burying. They work so diligently that a mouse, for instance, is buried within three hours. But they often work on for days, so as to bury the body as deeply as possible. From large carcasses, such as those of horses, sheep, &c., they only bury pieces as large as they can manage.}
Lastly, Clarville gives a case of a burying beetle which wanted to carry away a dead mouse, but, finding it too heavy for its unaided strength, went off, like the beetles previously mentioned, and brought four others to its as- sistance.” A friend of Gleditsch fastened a dead toad, which he desired to dry, upon the top of an upright stick. The burying beetles were attracted by the smell, and finding that they could not reach the toad, they undermined the stick, so causing it to fall with the toad, which was then _ buried safe out of harm’s way.® , A converse exemplification of beetle-intelligence is given by G. Berkeley. He saw a beetle carrying a dead spider up a heath plant, and hanging it upon a twig of the heath in so secure a position, that when the insect had left it Mr. Berkeley found that a sharp shake of the heather ' would not bring the dead spider down. As the burying
beetle preserves its treasure by hiding it out of sight below ground, so this beetle no doubt secured the same end but by other means; ‘ seeing,’ as Mr. Berkeley observes, ‘ that if it did not hang up its prey, it might fall into the hands of other hunters, it took all possible pains to find out the best store-room for it.’ The above instances of beetle-intelligence lead me to credit the following, which has been communicated to me by Dr. Garraway, of Faversham. On a bank of moss in the Black Forest he saw a beetle alight with a caterpillar which it was carrying, and proceed to excavate a cylindrical hole in the peat, about an inch and a half deep, into which, when completed, it dropped the caterpillar, and then flew away through the pines. ‘I was struck,’ says my corre- spondent, ‘ with the creature’s folly in leaving the whole uncovered, as every curious wayfaring insect would doubt- less be tempted to enter therein. However, in about a minute the beetle returned, this time carrying a small pebble, of which there were none in the immediate vicinity, and having carefully fitted this into the aperture, fled away into space.’
I must devote a short division of this chapter to the earwig. M. Geer describes a regular process of incubation as practised by the mother insect. He placed one with her eggs in a box, and scattered the eggs on the floor of the latter. The earwig, however, carried them one by one into a certain part of the box, and then remained con- stantly sitting upon the heap without ever quitting it for a moment. When the eggs were hatched, the young ear- wigs kept close to their mother, following her about every- where, and often running under her abdomen, just as chickens run under a hen.!
A young lady, who objects to her name being published, informs me that her two younger sisters (children) are in the habit of feeding every morning with sugar an earwig, which they call ‘Tom,’ and which crawls up a certain curtain regularly every day at the same hour, with the apparent expectation of getting its breakfast. This re- sembles analogous instances which have been mentioned in the case of spiders. The gad-fly, whose eggs are hatched out in the intes- tines of the horse, exhibits a singular refinement of instinct in depositing them upon those parts of the horse which the animal is most likely to lick. For, according to Bingley and other writers, ‘the inside of the knee is the part on which these flies principally deposit their eggs; and next to this they fix them upon the sides, and the back part of the shoulder; but almost always in places liable to be licked by the tongue.’ The female fly deposits her eggs while on the wing, or at least scarcely appears to settle when she extends her ovidepositor to touch the horse. She lays only a single egg at a time—flying away a short distance after having deposited one in order to prepare another, and so on.
The following anecdote, which I quote from Jesse, seems to indicate no small degree of intelligence on the part of the common house-fly—intelligence, for instance, the same both in kind and degree as that which was dis- played by Sir John Lubbock’s pet wasp already mentioned : Slingsby, the celebrated opera dancer, resided in the large house in Cross-deep, Twickenham, next to Sir Wathen Waller’s, looking down the river. He was fond of the study of natural history, and particularly of insects, and he once tried to tame some house-flies, and preserve them in a state of activity through the winter. For this purpose, quite at the latter end of autumn, and when they were becoming almost helpless, he selected four from off his breakfast-table, put them upon a large handful of cotton, and placed it in one corner of the window nearest the fireplace. Not long afterwards the weather became so cold that all flies disappeared except these four, which constantly left their bed of cotton at his breakfast-time, came and fed at the table, and then returned to their home. This continued for a short time, when three of them became lifeless in their shelter, and only one came down. ‘This one Slingsby had trained to feed upon his thumb-nail, by placing on it some moist sugar mixed with a little butter. Although there had been at intervals several days of sharp frost, the fly never missed taking his daily meal in this way till after Christmas, when, his kind
preserver having invited a friend to dine and sleep at his house, the fly, the next morning, perched upon the thumb of the visitor, who, being ignorant that it was a pet of his host’s, clapped his hand upon it, and thus put an end to Mr. Slingsby’s -experiment.! There is no doubt that these are an intelligent group of animals, although I have been able to collect but wonderfully little information upon the subject. Mr. Moseley, F.R.S., in his very interesting work, ‘ Notes by a Naturalist on the Challenger, says (p. 70) :—
In the tropics one becomes accustomed to watch the habits ‘of various species of crabs, which there live so commonly an ‘aérial life. The more I have seen of them, the more have I been A rock crab (Grapsus stringosus) was very abundant, run- ning about all over the rocks, and making off into clefts on one’s approach, I was astonished at the keen and long sight of this erab. I noticed some made off at full speed to their hiding- places at the instant that my head showed above a rock fifty yards distant.
At Still Bay, 0 on the sandy beach of which a heavy surf was breaking, I encountered a sand crab (Leypoda ippeus), which --was walking about, and got between it and its hole in the dry sand above the beach. The crab was a large one, at least three inches in breadth of its carapace. . . . With its curious column- like eyes erect, the crab bolted down towards the surf as the only escape, and as it saw a great wave rushing up the shelving shore, dug itself tight into the sand, and held on to prevent the undertide from carrying it into the sea. As soon as the wave had retreated, it made off full speed for the shore. I gave chase, and whenever a wave approached, the crab repeated the maneuvre. I once touched it with my hand whilst it was buried and blinded by the sandy water, but the surf compelled me to retreat, and I could not snatch hold of it for fear of its powerful claws. At last I chased it, hard pressed, into the surf in a hurry, and being unable to get proper hold in time, it was washed into the sea. The crab evidently dreaded going into the sea. . . . They soon die when kept a short time be- neath the water,
The land crabs of the West Indies and North America descend from their mountain home in May and June, to deposit their spawn in the sea. They travel in such swarms ~~ that the roads and woods are covered with them. They migrate in a straight line, and rather than allow them- selves to be deflected from it, ‘they scale the houses, and surmount every other obstacle that lies in their way’ (Kirby). They travel chiefly by night, and when they arrive at the sea-shore they ‘bathe three or four different times,’ and then ‘commit their eggs to the waves.’ They | return to the mountains by the same route, but only the most vigorous survive the double journey.
Prof. Alex. Agassiz details some interesting observations on the behaviour of young hermit crabs reared by himself ‘from very young stages,’ when first presented with shells of mollusks. ‘A number of shells, some of them empty, others with the animal living, were placed in a glass dish with the young crabs. Scarcely had the shells reached the bottom before the crabs made a rush for the shells, turned them round and round, invariably at the mouth, and soon a couple of the crabs decided to venture in, which they did with remarkable alacrity.’ The crabs which obtained for their share the shells still inhabited. by living mollusks, ‘remained riding round upon the mouth of their future dwelling, and, on the death of the mollusk, which generally occurred soon after in captivity, commenced at once to tear out the animal, and havi eaten him, proceeded to take its place within the shell.’
There is a species of small crustacean (Podocerus capillatus) described by Mr. Bates, which builds a nest to contain its eggs. The nest is in the form of a hollow cone, built upon seaweed, and composed of fine thread- like material closely interlaced. ‘These nests,’ says Mr.. Bates, ‘ are evidently used asa place of refuge and security, in which the parent protects and keeps her brood of young until they are old enough to be independent of the mother’s care.’ |
Dr. Erasmus Darwin tells us, on the authority of a friend on whose competency as an observer he relied, that the common crab during the moulting season stations as sentinel an unmoulted or hard-shelled individual, to. prevent marine enemies from injuring moulted individuals in their unprotected state. While thus mounting guard the hard-shelled crab is much more courageous than at other times, when he has only his own safety to consider. But these observations require to be corroborated.
buried the rest beneath a heap of shingle, on which he ‘mounted guard.’ ‘ Five times within two hours was the . fish unearthed, and as often did the lobster shovel the gravel over it with his huge claws, each time ascending the pile and turning his bold defensive front to his com- anions.’ A trustworthy naturalist, Mr. Gardner, whilst watching a shore-crab (Gelasimus) making its burrow, threw some shells towards the hole. One rolled in, and three other shells re- mained within a few inches of the mouth. In about five minutes the crab brought out the shell which had fallen in, and carried it away to the distance of a foot ; it then saw the three other shells lying near, and evidently thinking that they might likewise roll in, carried them to the spot where it had laid the- first. It would, I think, be difficult to distinguish this act. from one performed by man by the aid of reason.
Mr. Darwin also alludes to the curious instinctive habits of the large shore-crab (Birgus latro), which feeds on fallen cocoa-nuts ‘ by tearing off the husk fibre by fibre ; and it always begins at that end where the three eye-like depressions are situated. It then breaks through one of these eyes by hammering with its heavy front pincers, and turning round, extracts the albuminous core with its narrow posterior pincers.’ Remarkable cases occur of commensalism between certain crabs and sea-anemones, and they betoken much. intelligence. Thus Professor Mobius says in his ‘ Beitrige zur Meeresfauna der Insel Mauritius’ (1880) that there are two crabs belonging to different genera which have
the habit of firmly grasping a sea-anemone in each claw and carrying them about, presumably to secure some benefit to themselves. The more familiar case of the species of anemone which lives on the shells tenanted by hermit crabs is of special interest to us on account of a remarkable observation published by Mr. Gosse, F.R.S. (Zoologist, June, 1859). He found that on his detaching the anemone (Adamsia) from the shell, the hermit crab always took it up in its claws and held it against the shell ‘for the space of ten minutes at a time, until fairly attached by a good strong base.’ It was said by the late Dr. Robert Ball that when the common Sagartia para-
its vicinity, the anemone will leave the stone and attach itself to the hermit’s shell (Critic, March 24, 1860). I shall now allude to some of the more interesting facts touching the psychology of insects when in their immature or larval state. This is an interesting topic from the point of view which we occupy as evolutionists, because a caterpillar is really a locomotive and self-feeding embryo, whose entire mental constitution is destined to undergo a metamorphosis no less complete and profound than that which is also destined to take place in its corporeal struc- ture. Yet although the caterpillar has an embryo psy- chology, its instincts and even intelligence often seem to be higher or more elaborated than is the case with the imago form. Where such is the case the explanation of course must be that it is of more importance to the species that the larval form should be in a certain measure in- telligent than that the imago form should be so. Every larva is a potential imago, or breeding individual; there- fore its life is of no less value to the species during its larval than during its adult existence; and if certain instincts or grades of intelligence are of more use to it during the former than during the latter period, of course natural selection would determine the unusual event which we seem here in some cases to see—namely, that the
embryo should stand on a higher level of psychological development than the adult. I may most fitly begin under this heading with the remarkable instincts of the so-called ‘ant-lion,’ which is the larva of a neuropterous insect, the common Myrmeleon (M. formicarium). I quote the following account of its habits from Thompson’s ‘ Passions of Animals’ (p. 258) :— The devices of the ant-lion are still more extraordinary if possible. He forms, with astonishing labour and perseverance, a pit in the shape of a funnel, in a dry sandy soil, under some old wall or other spot protected from the wind. His pit being finished, he buries himself among the sand at the bottom, leaving only his horns visible, and thus waits patiently for his prey. Whenanant or any other small insect happensto walk on the edge of the hollow, it forces down some of the particles of sand, which gives the ant-lion notice ofits presence. He immediately throws up the sand which covers his head to overwhelm the ant, and with its returning force brings it to the bottom. This he continues to do till the insect is overcome and falls between his horns. Every endeavour to escape, when once the incau- tious ant has stepped within the verge of the pit, is vain, for in all its attempts to climb the side the deceptive sand slips from under its feet, and every struggle precipitates it still lower. When within reach its enemy plunges the points of its jaws into its body, and having sucked out all its juices, throws out the empty skin to some distance.
According to Bingley, if the ant-lion, while excavating its pitfall,— Comes to a stone of some moderate size, it does not desert the work on this account, but goes on, intending to remove that im- pediment the last. "When the pit is finished, it crawls back- ward up the side of the place where the stone is; and, getting its tail under it, takes great pains and time to get it on a true poise, and then begins to crawl backward with it up the edge to the top of the pit, to get it out of the way. It is a common thing to see an ant-lion labouring in this manner at a stone four times as big as its own body; and as it can only move backwards, and the poise is difficult to keep, especially up a slope of such crumbling matter as sand, which moulders away from under its feet, and necessarily alters the position of its body, the stone very frequently rolls down, when near the verge, quite to the bottom. In this case the animal attacks it again
in the same way, and is often not discouraged by five or six miscarriages, but continues its struggle so long that it at length gets over the verge of the place. When it has done this, it does not leave it there, lest it should roll in again ; but is always at the pains of pushing it further on, till it has removed it to a necessary distance from the edge of the pit.! Passing on now to the intelligence of caterpillars, Mr. G. B. Buckton, F.R.S., writing from Haslemere, says :—
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.