Animal Intelligence
Many caterpillars of Prerts rape have, during this autumn, fed below my windows. On searching for suitable positions for passing into chrysalides, some eight or ten individuals, in their direct march upwards, encountered the plate-glass panes of my windows; on these they appeared to be unable to stand. Ac. cordingly in every case they made silken ladders, some of them five feet long, each ladder being formed of a single continuous thread, woven in elegant loops from side to side. . . . The reasoning, however, seems to be but narrow, for one ladder was constructed parallel to the window-frame for nearly three feet, on which secure footing could be had by simply diverting the track two inches.?
In this case it appears clear that we have to do with instinct, and not with reason. No doubt it is the congenital habit of these caterpillars to overcome impediments in this way; but the instinct is one of sufficient interest to. be here stated. A caterpillar described by Bonnet, which, from being confined: in a box, was unable to obtain a supply of the bark with which its ordinary instinct directs it to make its cocoon, substituted pieces of paper that were given to it, tied them together with silk, and constructed a very passable cocoon with them. In another instance the same naturalist having opened several cocoons’ of a moth (Voctura verbasci), which are composed of a mixture of grains of earth and silk, just after being finished, the larve did not repair the injury in the same manner. Some employed both earth and silk; others contented themselves with spinning a silken veil before the opening.®
The same authorities state, as result of their own observation, that the— Common cabbage caterpillar, which, when building web under stone or wooden surfaces, previously covers a space with a web to form a base for supporting its dependent pupa, when building a web beneath a muslin surface dispenses with this base altogether: it perceives that the woven texture of the muslin forms facilities for attaching the threads of the cocoon securely enough to support the weight of the cocoon without the neces- sity of making the usual square inch or so of basal support.!
The instincts of the larva of the Timea moth are thus described by Réaumur :— It feeds upon the elm, using the leaves both as food and clothing. To do this it only eats the parenchyma of the leaf, _ preserving the upper and under epidermal membranes, between which it then insinuates itself as it progressively devours the _ parenchyma. It, however, carefully avoids separating these _ membranes where they unite at the extreme edge of the leaf, which is designed to form ‘ one of the seams of its coat.’ The cavity when thus excavated between the two epidermal mem- branes is then lined with silk, made cylindrical in shape, cut off at the two ends and all along the side remote from the ‘ seam,’ and then the two epidermal membranes sewn together along the side where they have had to be cut in order to separate them from the tree. The larva now has a coat exactly fitting its body, and open at each end. By the one opening it feeds, and by the other discharges its excrement, ‘having on one side a nicely jointed seam—that which is commonly applied to its back— composed of the natural marginal junction of the membranes of the leaf.’
Réaumur cut off the edge of a newly finished coat, so as to expose the body of the larva at that point. The animal did not set.about making a new coat ab imitio, as we might expect that it would on the popular supposition that a train of instinctive actions is always as mechanical as the running down of a set of cog-wheels, and that wherever a novel element is introduced the machinery must be thrown out of gear, so that it cannot meet a new emergency of however simple a character, and must there- fore re-start the whole process over again from the be- ginning. In this case the larva sewed up the rent; and not only so, but ‘the scissors having cut off one of the projections intended to enter into the construction of
the triangular end of the case, it entirely changed the original plan, and made that end the head which had been first designed for the tail.’ he says, two generations of the Angoumois moth; the first. — appear in early summer, and lay their eggs upon the ears. of wheat in the fields; the second appear later in the summer, or in the autumn, and these lay their eggs upon. wheat in the granaries; from these eggs there comes the first generation of next year’s moths. This is a highly remarkable case—supposing the facts to be as Bonnet. states; for it seems that the early summer moths, although born in the granaries, immediately fly to the unreaped. fields to lay their eggs in the standing corn, while the autumn moths never attempt to leave the granaries, but lay their eggs upon the stored wheat.! Westwood says that—
A species of Tasmanian caterpillar (Noctua Ewingit) swarms. over the land in enormous companies, which regularly begin to. march at four o’clock in the morning, and as regularly halt at midday. Liparis chrysorrhaca, a kind of caterpillar, spins for the winter a common web, in which several hundred individuals. find a common shelter.” The larva of the ichneumon, while feeding upon its caterpillar host, spares the walls of the intestines until it is time for it to escape, when, the life of the caterpillar being no longer necessary to its development, it perforates these walls.?
The larvee Theda wsocrates live in a group of seven or eight. in the fruit of pomegranate. In consequence of their excava- tions within the fruit, the latter is apt to fall; and to prevent its doing so the larve throw out a thread of attachment where- with to secure the fruit to the branch, so that if the stalk withers, this thread serves to suspend the fruit.* . The caterpillar of the Bombyx moth, which is a native of France, exhibits very wonderful instincts. The larva is gre- garious in its habits, each society (family) consisting of perhaps.
600 or 800 individuals, When young they have no fixed habi- tation, but encamp sometimes in one place, and sometimes in another, under the shelter of their web ; but when they have attained two-thirds of their growth, they weave for themselves a common tent. About sunset the regiment leaves its quarters. . . . At their head is a chief, by whose movements their pro- cession is regulated. When he stops all stop, and proceed when he proceeds ; three or four of his immediate followers succeed in the same line, the head of the second touching the tail of the first ; then comes an equal series of pairs, next of threes, and so on, as far as fifteen or twenty, The whole procession moves regularly on ‘with an even pace, each file treading in the steps of those that precede it. If the leader, arriving at a particular point, pursues a different direction, all march to that point before they turn. !
The following additional facts concerning these remark- able habits may be quoted. I take them from the ac- count published by Mr. Davis in ‘Loudoun’s Magazine of Natural History : ’°— The caterpillars, he observed, were Bombyces, and were seen crossing a road in single file, each so close to its predecessor that the line was quite continuous, ‘moving like a living cord.’ The number of caterpillars was 154, and the length of the line 27 feet. When Mr. Davis removed one from the line the caterpillar immediately in front suddenly stood still, then the next, and next, and soon to the leader. Similarly, those behind the point of interruption successively halted. After a pause of a few moments, the first caterpillar behind the break in the line endeavoured to fill up the vacant space, and so recover con- tact or communication, which after a time it succeeded in doing, when the information that the line was again closed was passed forward in some way from caterpillar to caterpillar till it reached the leader, when the whole line was again put in motion. The individual which had been abstracted remained rolled up and motionless ; but on being placed near the moving column it immediately unrolled, and made every attempt to get readmitted into the procession, After many endeavours it succeeded, the one below falling into the rear of the interloper. On repeating the experiment by removing a caterpillar fifty from the head of the procession, Mr. Davis found that it took just thirty seconds by his watch for information of the fact to reach the leader. All the same results followed as in the previous
case. It was observable that the animals were guided neither by sight nor smell while endeavouring to close up the inter- rupted line; for the caterpillar next behind the interruption, on whom the duty of closing up devolved, ‘ turned right and left, and often in a wrong direction, when within half an inch of the one immediately before him; when he at last touched the ob- ject of his search, the fact was communicated again by signal ; and in thirty seconds the whole line wasin rapid march.’ This gentleman adds that the object of the march was the search for new pasture. The caterpillars feed on the Eucalyptus, and when they have completely stripped one tree of its leaves, they all con- gregate on the trunk, and proceed as described to another tree.
De Villiers! gives an account of his observations on the manner in which these caterpillars (Cnethocampiu pitzo- campa) are able to pass information, which does not quite agree with the above observation of Mr. Davis. For he says that, in a train of 600 caterpillars, interference by him in any part of the train was communicated through the whole series instantaneously—all the 600 caterpillars stopping immediately and with one consent like a single organism.
According “to Kirby and Spence there is a kind of caterpillar (Pieris crategi) which lives in little colonies of ten or twelve in common chambers lined with silk. In one part they make of the same material a little bag or pocket, which is used by the community or household as a water-closet. When full of excrement the caterpillars empty it by turning out the pellets with their feet.? Only two other instances of noteworthy intelligence as exhibited by larve have fallen within my reading. One of these is mentioned by Réaumur, who says that the larve of Hemerobius chrysops chase aphides, and having killed them, clothe themselves in their skins ; and the other case is the very remarkable one mentioned in his newly published work by W. MacLachlan, F.R.S., of caddis-worms adjusting the specific gravity of their tubes to suit that of the water in which they live, by attaching heavy or light material to them according as they require sinking or flotation.
the intelligence of which immeasurably surpasses that of the other sub-kingdoms, it is remarkable that these lowest ferior to some of the higher members of the lower groups. Neither in its instincts nor in general intelligence can any fish be compared with an ant or a bee—a fact which shows how slightly a psychological classification of animals ‘depends upon zoological affinity, or even morphological or- ganisation. For although a highly competent authority, namely Van Baer, has said that a bee is as highly organised an animal asa fish, though on a different type,' no one would
highly organised than a fish as its higher intelligence would require, supposing degrees of intelligence to stand in necessary relation to degree of organic development. And this consideration is not materially altered if, instead of regarding the whole organism, we look to the nervous system alone. There is no doubt that the cerebral hemi- spheres of a fish, although small as compared with these organs in the higher Vertebrata, are, bulk for bulk, enormous as compared with the cesophageal ganglia or ‘brain’ of an insect; while the disproportion becomes still greater if the cerebral hemispheres of a fish are com- pared with their supposed analogues in the brain of an ant, viz., the pedunculated and convoluted lobes which surmount the cephalic ganglion. But here the relative smallness of the ant as a whole must be taken into con-
sideration, and also the fact that its brain is relatively K much more massive as well as more highly organisedthan animals, except, perhaps, the octopus and his allies. There- — . fore, although the brain of a fish is formed upon a type — function far to eclipse all other types of nerve-centre, we — have to observe that in its lowest stage of evolution as — presented to science in the fishes, this type is functionally and parental feelings ; anger, jealousy, play, and curiosity. So far the class of emotions is the same as that with which we have met in ants, and corresponds with that which is
distinctive of the psychology of a child about four months _ old. I have not, however, any evidence of sympathy, which would be required to make the list of emotions. identical ; but sympathy may nevertheless be present. Fear and pugnacity are too apparent in fish to require special proof. The social or gregarious feelings are strongly shown by the numberless species which swim in shoals, the sexual feelings are proved by courtships, and the parental by those species which build nests and guard their young. Schneider saw several species of fish at the Naples Aquarium protecting their eggs. In one case the male mounted guard over a rock where the eggs were de- posited, and swam with open mouth against intruders. The following accounts of the nidification of certain species of fish show that the parental instincts are not unlike those which obtain in birds, and are comparable in point of strength with the same instincts as they occur in ants, bees, and spiders.
Agassiz remarks ! that while examining the marine products of the Sargasso Sea, Mr. Mansfield picked up and brought to him a round mass of sargassum, about the size of the two fists placed together. The whole consisted, to all appearance, of nothing but gulf-weed, the branches and leaves of which were, however, evidently knit together, and not merely balled into a roundish mass. The elastic threads which held the gulf-weed together were beaded at intervals, sometimes two or three beads being close together, or a branch of them hanging from the cluster of threads. This nest was full of eggs scattered through- out the mass, and not placed together in a cavity. It was evidently the work of the Chironectes. This rocking fish-cradle is carried along as an undying arbour, affording at the same time protection and afterwards food for its living freight. It is suggested that the fish must have used their peculiar pectoral fins when constructing this elaborate nest.
The well-known tinker or ten-spined stickleback (Gaster- osteus pungitius) is one of our indigenous fish which constructs a nest. On May 1, 1864, a male’ was placed in a well-estab- lished aquarium of moderate size, to which, after three days, two ripe females were added. Their presence at once roused him into activity, and he soon began to build a nest of bits of dirt and dead fibre, and of growing confervoid filaments, upon a jutting point of rock among some interlacing branches of Myriophyllum spicatum—all the time, however, frequently in- terrupting his labours to pay his addresses to the females. This was done in most vigorous fashion, he swimming, by a series of little jerks, near and about the female, even pushing against her with open mouth, but usually not biting. After a little coquetting she responds and follows him, swimming just above him as he leads the way to the nest. When there, the male commences to flirt—he seems unaware of its situation, will not swim to the right spot, and the female, after a few ineffectual attempts to find the proper passage into it, turns tail to swim away, but is then viciously pursued by the male. When he first courts the female, if she, not being ready, does not soon respond, he seems quickly to lose his temper, and, attacking her with great apparent fury, drives her to seek shelter in some crevice or dark corner. The coquetting of the male near the nest, which seems due to the fact that he really has not quite finished it, at length terminates by his pushing his head well into the entrance of the nest, while the female closely follows him, placing herself above him, and apparently much excited. As he withdraws she passes into the nest, and pushes quite
_ through it, after a very brief delay, during which she deposits her ova. The male now fertilises the eggs, and drives the female away toa safe distance; then, after patting down the nest, he proceeds in search of another female. The nest is built and the ova deposited in about twenty-four hours. The male continued — to watch it day and night, and during the light hours he also ~ continually added to the nest. , The marine fifteen-spined stickleback(Gasterosteus spinachia) affords another instance of nest-constructing fishes. The places selected for their nests are usually harbours, or some sheltered spots to where pure sea. water reaches. The fish either find growing, or even collect some of the softer kinds of green or red seaweed, and join them with so much of the coralline tufts (Janie) growing on the rock as will serve the purpose of afford- ing firmness to the structure, and constitute a pear-shaped mass five or six inches long, and about as stout as a man’s fist. A thread, which is elastic and resembles silk, is employed for the purpose of binding the materials together: under a magnifier _ it appears to consist of several strands connected by a gluey substance, which hardens by exposure to the water.! i _ M. Carbonnier, who has studied the habits of the Chinese — butterfly-fish (Zacropodus) in his private aquarium in Paris, where he had some in confinement, observed that the male constructs a nest of froth of considerable size, 15 to 18 centi-— metres horizontal diameter, and 10 to 12 high. He prepares — the bubbles in the air (which he sucks in and then expels), — strengthening them with mucous matter from his mouth, and brings them into the nest. Sometimes the buccal secretion ~ will fail him, whereupon he goes to the bottom in search of — confervee, which he sucks and bites for a little in order to stimu- late the act of secretion. The nest prepared, the female is in- duced toenter. Not less curious is the way in which the male
unable to carry them up in his mouth; instead of this, he first swallows an abundant supply of air, then descending, he places himself beneath the eggs, and suddenly, by a violent contraction of the muscles in the interior of his mouth and pharynx, he ex- hales the air which he had accumulated by the gills. This air, finely divided by the lamelle and fringes of the gills, escapes in the form of two jets of veritable gaseous powder, which envelopes the eggs and raises them to the surface. In this manceuvre the Macropodus entirely disappeared in a kind of air-mist, and when this had dissipated he reappeared with a
1 Quoted from Francis Day, F.L.S., ‘ Instincts and Emotions of Fish,’ Journ. Linn. Soc., vol. XV., pp. 36-7, where see for other cases of nest- building among fish. ; multitude of air-bubbles like little pearls clinging all over his body.! Again, in detailing Mr. Baker’s observations on the three-spined stickleback, published in the Philosophical Transactions, this author says :— ~ It has been remarked that after the deposition of the eggs the nest was opened more to the action of the water, and the vibratory motion of the body of the male fish, hovering over its surface, caused a current of water to be propelled across the surface of the ova, which action was repeated almost continu- ously. After about ten days the nest was destroyed and the materials removed ; and now were seen the minute fry flutter- ing upwards here and there, by a movement half swimming, half leaping, and then falling rapidly again upon or between the clear pebbles of the shingle bottom. This arose from their having the remainder of the yelk still attached to their body, which, acting as a weight, caused them to sink the moment the swimming effort had ceased. Around, across, and in every direction the male fish, as the guardian, continually moved. Now his labours .became more arduous, and his vigilance was taxed to the utmost extreme, for the other fish (two tench and a gold carp), some twenty times larger than himself, as soon as they perceived the young fry in motion, continuously used their utmost endeavours to snap them up. The courage of the little stickleback was now put to its severest test; but, nothing daunted, he drove them all off, seizing their fins and striking with all his strength at their heads and at their eyes. His care of the young brood when encumbered with the yelk was very extraordinary ; and as this was gradually absorbed and they gained strength, their attempts to swim carried them to a greater distance from the parent fish ; his vigilance, however, seemed everywhere, and if they rose by the action of their fins above a certain height from the shingle bottom, or flitted beyond a given distance from the nest, they were immediately seized in his mouth, brought back, and gently puffed or jetted into their place again.
The same care of the young, bringing them back to their nest up till about the sixth day after hatching, has been remarked by Dr. Ransom in the ten-spined stickleback (G. pungitius)." when the young of the pipe-fish are hatched out, the parents show them marked attachment, and that the M. Carbonnier has recorded how the male of the curiously grotesque telescope-fish, a variety of Carassius auratus (Linn.), acts as accoucheur to the female. Three males pursued one female which was heavy with spawn, and rolled her like a ball upon the ground for a distance of several metres, and continued this process without rest or relaxation for two days, until the exhausted female, who had been unable to recover her equili- brium for a moment, had at last evacuated all her ova.?
That adult fish are capable of feeling affection for one another would seem to be well established : thus Jesse relates breeding season, and that nothing could drive away the male from the spot at which he had perceived his partner slowly dis- appear, and whom he had followed to the edge of the water. Mr. Arderon‘* gave an account of how he tamed a dace, which would lie close to the glass watching its master; and subsequently how he kept two ruffs (Acerina cernua) in an aquarium, where they became very much attached to one another... He gave one away, when the other became so miser- able that it would not eat, and this continued for nearly three weeks, Fearing his remaining fish might die, he sent for its former companion, and on the two meeting they became quite happy again. Jesse gives a similar account of two gold carp.®
Anger is strikingly shown by many fish, and notori- ously by sticklebacks when their territory is invaded by a neighbour. These animals display a strange instinct of appropriating to themselves a certain part of the tank in which they may be confined, and furiously attacking any other stickleback which may presume to cross the imagi- nary frontier. Uunder such circumstances of provocation I have seen the whole animal change colour, and, darting at
Of course, here, as elsewhere, it is impossible to be sure how far apparent expression of an emotion is due to the presence of that mental state which we recognise as the emotion in ourselves ; but still the best guide we have to follow is that of apparent expression. Following this principle, we are also entitled to at- tribute to fish the emotions conducive to play; for nothing can well be more expressive of sportive glee than many of their movements. As for jealousy, the fights of many male fish for the possession of females constitutes evi- dence of emotion which would be called by this name in the higher animals. Schneider, in his recent work already often quoted, says that he has observed a male fish (Labrus) show jealousy only towards other individual males of his
of his female, but not objecting to the approach of fish of other species. | Curiosity is shown by the readiness, or even eagerness, with which fish will approach to examine any unfamiliar object. So much is this the case that fishermen, like hunters, sometimes trade upon this faculty:— And spear, about the low rocks damp Crept, and struck the fish which came To worship the delusive flame.' Stephenson, the engineer, on sinking lighted lanterns in the water, also found that fish were attracted to them.?
As curious instances of special instincts in fish we may notice the well-known habit of the angler (Lophius pis- cator), which conceals itself in mud and seaweed, while waving in the water certain filaments with which it is provided above its snout. Other fish, attracted by these moving objects, approach, and are thereupon seized by the 1 Shelley, Lines written in the Bay of Lerici. 2 See Smiles, Lives of Engineers, vol. iii., p. 69. angler. We must also allude to the Chelmon rostratus, which shoots its prey by means of a drop of water projected from the mouth with considerable force and unerring aim. The mark thus shot at is always some small object, such as a fly, at rest above the surface of the water, so that when suddenly hit it falls into the water.! This remark- able instinct can only, I think, have originated as a primordially intentional adjustment, and as such shows a high degree of intelligence on the part of these fishes’ an-. cestors. Moreover, the wonderful co-ordination of sight and muscular movements required to judge the distance, to make due allowance for refraction, and to aim correctly, shows that the existing representatives are not unworthy of their ancestors.
Several species of fish in different parts of the world. have the habit of quitting pools which are about to dry up, and taking excursions across country in search of more: abundant water. Eels have this habit, and perform their migrations by night. Dr. Hancock, in the ‘Zoological Journal,’ gives an account of a species of Doras, the indi- _ viduals of which are about a foot in length, and travel by night in large shoals, or ‘ droves,’ when thus searching for water. A strong serrated arm constitutes the first ray of the pectoral fin; and, using this as a kind of foot, the animal pushes itself forward by means of its tail, thus moving nearly as fast as a man can walk. Another migrating fish (Hydrargzra) was found by thousands in the fresh waters of Carolina by Bosc. It travels by leaps, and, according to Bosc, always directs itself towards the nearest water, although he purposely placed them so that they could not see it.
But perhaps the strangest among this class of habits is that of the climbing perch (Perca scandens), first dis- covered by Daldorff in Tranquebar; for this animal not only creeps over land, but even climbs the fan palm in search of certain Crustacea which form its food. In climb- ing it uses its open gill-covers as hands wherewith to: suspend itself, while it deflects its tail laterally upwards so: as to bring to bear upon the bark certain little spines with
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.