Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 600 to 629 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

600

_ wards by straightening the tail, while it closes the gill- covers not to prevent progress,and soon. Sir E. Tennent, however, without disputing the evidence that these fish do climb trees, says,— A great number of species of fish perform migrations. In relation to intelligence, the most interesting of these is the migration of salmon, which annually leave the sea to spawn in rivers, though there is some doubt whether the same individuals spawn every year. There is no doubt, however, that the same individuals frequently, though not invariably, revisit the same rivers for their successive spawnings. This fact may be due either to the remem- brance of locality, similar to that which is unquestionably manifested by birds, or to the salmon not swimming far along the coast during other seasons of the year, and there- fore in the spawning season when seeking a river happen- ing to hit upon the same one. The latter hypothesis is one which Mr. Herbert Spencer tells me he is inclined to adopt, and, being a salmon-fisher, he has paid attention to the subject. He informs me of an observation by a friend of his own, who sawa salmon, when about to spawn, swim- ming along the coast-line, and all round a boathouse, apparently seeking any stream that it might first en- counter.

601

The distances up rivers to which salmon will swim in the spawning season is no less surprising than the energy with which they perform the feat, and the determination with which they overcome all obstacles. They reach Bohemia by the Elbe, Switzerland by the Rhine, and,. which is much more wonderful, the Cordilleras of America: by the Maragnon. They employ only three months in ascending to the sources of the Maragnon (a journey of 3,000 miles), the current of which is remarkably rapid, which is at the rate of nearly forty

602

miles a day ; ina smooth stream or lake their progress would increase in a fourfold ratio. Their tail isa very powerful organ, and its muscles have wonderful energy ; by placing it in their mouths they make of it a very elastic spring, for letting it go with violence they raise themselves in the air to the height of from twelve to fifteen feet, and so clear the cataract that impedes their course: if they fail in their first attempt, they continue their efforts till they have accomplished it.!

603

General Intelligence. With reference to the general intelligence of fish, wariness in waters which are much fished. This shows no small degree of intelligence, for the caution is proved to be the result of observation by the fact that young trout under such circumstances are less wary than old ones. Moreover, many fish will abandon old haunts when much disturbed. Again, according to Kirby, the carp thrusts itself into the mud in order that the net may pass over it, or, if the bottom be stony, makes great leaps to clear it.

604

At the Andaman Islands fish are captured by the convicts by means of weirs fixed across the openings of creeks. After existing a week or so, it is observed that captures invariably cease; and it is believed that such is due to barnacles, &c., clustering on to the wood of which they are composed. It does not seem improbable that the fish have learned to avoid a loca- lity out of terror at those which enter but do not again return.? Lacepéde’ relates that some fish, which had been kept for many years in a basin of the Tuileries, would come when called by their names. Probably it was the sound of the voice and not the articulate words to which they responded ; for Lacepéde also relates that in many parts of Germany trout, carp, and tench were summoned to their food by the sound of a bell; and the same thing has been recorded of various fish in various localities, notably by Sir Joseph Banks, who used to collect his fish by sound- ‘ing a bell.*

605

4 For sundry other similar cases see Mr. Day’s excellent paper already quoted. In ‘Nature’ (vol. xi., p. 48) Mr. Mitchell gives the following instance of intelligence on the part of a small perch. Having one day disturbed its nest full of young fry, Mr. Mitchell next day went to look for the nest; ‘but we searched in vain for the fish and her young. At length, a few yards further up stream, we discovered the parent guarding her fry with jealous care in a cavity scooped out of the coarse sand. . . . This is the first and only instance that has come under my notice of a fish watching over her young, and conveying them, when threatened with danger, to some other place.’

606

In ‘ Nature’ (December 19, 1878) there is also pub- _ lished a communication which was made by Mr. J. Faraday to the Manchester Anglers’ Association, concerning a skate which he observed in the aquarium of that town :— A morsel of food thrown into the tank fell directly in an angle formed by the glass front and the bottom. The skate, a large example, made several vain attempts to seize the food, owing to its mouth being on the underside of its head and the food being close to the glass. He lay quite still for a while as though thinking, then suddenly raised himself into a slanting posture, the head inclined upwards, and the under surface of the body towards the food, when he waved his broad expanse of fins, thus creating an upward current or wave in the water, _ which lifted the food from its position and carried it straight to his mouth.

607

It will be observed, however, that this observation is practically worthless, from the observer having neglected to repeat the conditions in order to show that the move- ments of the fish were not, in their adaptation to these circumstances, purely accidental. Therefore I should not have alluded to this observation, had I not found that it has been quoted by several writers as a remarkable display of intelligence on the part of the fish. I must not take leave of this class without making some allusion to the alleged habits of the so-called ¢ pilot- fish,’ and also to those of ‘ thresher’ and ‘ sword-fish.’ I class these widely different habits together because they are alike in being dubious; different observers give differ- ent accounts, and therefore, until more information is

608

forthcoming, we must suspend our judgment with regard to the habits in question. The following describes what these habits are believed by many observers to be. Captain Richards, R.N., says that he saw a blue shark following a bait which was thrown out to him from the ship. The shark, which was attended by four pilot-fish, repeatedly approached the bait; but every time he did so one of the latter rushed in and prevented him. After a siderable distance, he turned back again, swam quickly after the vessel, and before the pilot-fish could overtake him, seized the bait and was caught. While hoisting him on board, one of the pilots was seen to cling to his side until above water, when it dropped off. All the pilots

609

friend, ‘with every apparent mark of anxiety and distress.” Colonel Smith fully corroborates this observation; but Mr. Geoffrey, on the other hand, saw a pilot-fish take great pains to bring a shark to the bait.? Probably the truth is that the pilot-fish attend the shark in order to obtain the crumbs that fall from his feasts, and that the cases in which they appear to prevent his taking the bait are without any psychological significance. can be said is that the statements, although antecedently improbable, are sufficient in number not to be ignored. Mr. Day appears to accept the evidence as adequate, and gives the following cases :—

610

following interesting narrative :—One morning during a calm, when near the Hebrides, all hands were called up at 2 a.m. to witness a battle between several of the fish called threshers or fox-sharks (Alopecias vulpes), and some sword-fish on one side, ' and an enormous whale on the other. It was in the middle of the summer ; and the weather being clear, and the fish close to the vessel, we had a fine opportunity of witnessing the contest. As soon as the whale’s back appeared above the water, the

611

threshers springing several yards into the air descended with great violence upon the object of their rancour, and inflicted upon him the most severe slaps with their long tails, the sounds of which resembled the reports of muskets fired at a distance. The sword-fish in their turn attacked the distressed whale, stab- bing from below: and thus beset on all sides and wounded, when the poor creature appeared, the water around him was dyed with blood. In this manner they continued tormenting and wounding him for many hours, until we lost sight of him ; and I have no doubt they in the end completed his destruction. The master of a fishing-boat has recently observed that the thresher-shark serves out the whales, the sea sometimes being all blood. One whale, attacked by these fish, once took refuge under his vessel, where it lay an hour and a half without moving a fin. He also remarked having seen the threshers jump out of the water as high as the mast-head and down upon the whale, while the sword fish was wounding him from beneath the two sorts of fish evidently acting in concert.

612

On the intelligence of frogs and toads very little has to be said. Frogs seem to have definite ideas of locality; for several of my correspondents inform me that they have known cases in which these animals, after having been removed for a distance of 200 or 300 yards from their habitual haunts, returned to them again and again. This, however, may I think perhaps be due to these haunts having a moistness which the animals are able to perceive at a great distance. But be this as it may, certainly the distance at which frogs are able to perceive moisture is surprising. Thus, for instance, Warden gives a case in which a pond containing a number of frogs dried up, and the frogs thereupon made straight for the nearest water, although this was at a distance of eight kilometres.!

613

A curious special instinct is met with in the toad Bufo obstetricans, from which it derives its name; for the male here performs the function of an accoucheur to the female, by severing from her body the gelatinous cord by which the ova are attached. Another special instinct or habit manifested by toads is described by M. Duchemin in a paper before the Academy of Sciences at Paris.2 The habit consists in the killing of carp by squatting on the head of the fish and forcing the fore-feet into its eyes. Probably this habit arises from sexual excitement on the part of the toads.

614

I have one case, communicated to me by a corre- spondent, of a frog which learnt to know her voice, and to come when called. As fish will sometimes do the same I used to open the gate in the railings round the pond, and call out ‘Tommy’ (the name I had given it), and the frog would jump out from the bushes, dive into the water, and swim across to me—get on my hand sometimes. When I called ‘Tommy,’ it would nearly always come, whatever the time of day, though it was only fed after breakfast ; but it seemed quite

615

A very similar case is recorded by Mr. Pennent! of a toad which was domesticated for thirty-six years, and knew all his friends. There is no doubt that frogs are able to appreciate coming changes of weather, and to adapt their movements in anticipation of them; but these facts show delicate sensibility rather than remarkable intelligence. The following observation of Edward, the Scottish naturalist, however, shows considerable powers of observa- tion on the part of frogs. After describing the great noise made by a number of frogs on a moonlight night, he says :—

616

Presently, when the whole of the vocalists had reached their highest notes, they became hushed in aninstant. Iwas amazed at this, and began to wonder at the sudden termination of the concert. But, looking about, I observed a brown owl drop down, with the silence of death, on to the top of a low dyke close by the orchestra.” Like the other cold-blooded Vertebrata, the reptiles are characterised by a sluggishness and low development of mental power which is to some extent proverbial. Never- theless, that some members of the class present vivid emotions is not to be questioned. Thus, to quote from Thompson :—

617

The common guana (Lacerta iguana) is naturally extremely gentle and harmless. Its appearance, however, is much against it, especially when agitated by fear or anger. Its eyes then seem on fire; it hisses like a serpent, swells out the pouch under its throat, lashes about its long tail, erects the scales on its back, and extending its wide jaws, holds its head, covered over with tubercles, in a menacing attitude. The male, during the spring of the year, exhibits great attachment towards the female. Throwing aside his usual gentleness of character, he defends her even with fury, attacking with undaunted courage every animal that seems inclined to injure her; and at this time, though his bite is by no means poisonous, he fastens so firmly, that it is necessary either to kill him or to beat him with great violence on the nose, in order to make him quit his hold.’

618

Several species of snake incubate their eggs and show parental affection for their young when they are hatched out; but neither in these nor in any other of their emotions do the reptiles appear to rise much above the level of fish. The case, however, which I shall after- wards quote, of the tame snakes kept by Mr. and Mrs. Mann, seems to show a somewhat higher degree of emo- tional development than could be pointed to as occurring in any lower Vertebrata. Moreover, according to Pliny, so much affection subsists between the male and female asp, that when the one is killed the other seeks to avenge its death; and this statement is so far confirmed—or rather, its origin explained—by Sir Emerson Tennent that he says when a cobra is killed, its mate is often found on the same spot a day or two afterwards.

619

Passing on to the general intelligence of reptiles, we shall find that this also, although low as compared with the intelligence of birds and mammals, is conspicuously higher than that of fish or batrachians. Taking first the case of special instincts, Mr. W. F. Barrett, in a letter to Mr, Darwin, bearing the date May 6, 1873, and contained among the MSS. already alluded to, gives an account of cutting open with a penknife the egg of an alligator just about to hatch. The young animal, although blind, ‘instantly laid hold of the finger, and attempted to bite.’ Similarly, Dr. Davy, in his * Ac- count of Ceylon,’ gives an interesting observation of his own on a young crocodile, which he cut out of the 88,

620

and which, as soon as it escaped, started off in a direct dine for a neighbouring stream. Dr. Davy placed his stick before it to try to make the little animal deviate from its course; but it stoutly resisted the opposition, and raised itself into a posture of offence, just as an older animal would have done. Humboldt made exactly the same observation with regard to young turtles, and he remarks that as the young normally quit the egg at night, they cannot see the water which they seek, and must therefore be guided to it by discerning the direction in which the air is most humid. He adds that experiments were made which consisted in putting the newly hatched animals into bags, carrying them to some distance from the shore, and liberating them with their tails turned towards the water. It was in- variably found that the young animals immediately faced round, and took without hesitation the shortest way to the water.

621

Searcely less remarkable than the instincts of the young turtles are those of the old ones. Their watchful timidity at the time of laying their eggs is thus described by Bates :— Great precautions are obliged to be taken to avoid disturb- ing the sensitive turtles, who, previous to crawling ashore to lay, assemble in great shoals off the sand-bank. The men during this time take care not to show themselves, and warn off any fisherman who wishes to pass near the place. Their fires are made in a deep hollow near the borders of the forest, so that the

622

shallow waters where the animals are congregated, or the sight of a man or a fire on the sand-bank, would prevent the turtles from leaving the water that night to lay their eggs; and if the causes of alarm were repeated once or twice they would forsake the praia for some other quieter place. ... I rose from my hammock by daylight, shivering with cold—a praia, on account of the great radiation of heat in the night from the sand, being towards the dawn the coldest place that can be found in this climate. Cardozo and the men were already up watching the turtles. The sentinelshad erected for this purpose a stage about ‘fifty feet high, on a tall tree near their station, the ascent to which was by a roughly made ladder of woody lianas. They are ena- bled, by observing the turtles from this watch-tower, to ascertain Ss

623

the date of successive deposits of eggs, and thus guide the com- mandante in fixing the time for the general invitation to the Ega people. The turtles lay their eggs by night, leaving the water, when nothing disturbs them, in vast crowds, and crawl- ing to the central and highest part of the praia. These places. are, of course, the last to go under water when, in unusually wet seasons, the river rises before the eggs are hatched by the heat of the sand. One could almost believe, from this, that the- animals used forethought in choosing a place; but it is simply one of those many instances in animals where unconscious. habit has the same resuit as conscious prevision. The hours. between midnight and dawn are the busiest. The turtles ex- cavate with their broad webbed paws deep holes in the fine: sand ; the first comer, in each case, making a pit about three feet deep, laying its eggs (about 120 in number) and covering them with sand; the next making its deposit at the top of that. of its predecessor, and so on until every pit is full. The whole ~ body of turtles frequenting a praia does not finish laying in less than fourteen or fifteen days, even when there is no interrup- tion. When all have done, the area (called by the Brazilians. taboleiro) over which they have excavated is distinguishable from the rest of the praia only by signs of the sand having been a little disturbed.!

624

These little incidents show the timidity and cowardice (? prudence and caution) of the alligator. He never attacks man when his intended victim is on his guard; but he is cunning enough to know when this may be done with impunity. Of this we had proof a few days afterwards, d&c.? But a most singular instance of attachment between two. animals, whose natures and habits were most opposite, was re- lated to me by a person on whose veracity I can place the great- est reliance. He had resided for nine years in the American States, where he superintended the execution of some extensive works for the American Government. One of these works con- sisted in the erection of a beacon in a swamp in one of the rivers,

625

2 Ibid. The astonishing facts relating to the migration of turtles in the laying season will be treated under the general heading ‘ Migra- tion’ in my forthcoming work. where he caught a young alligator. This animal he made so perfectly tame that it followed him about the house like a dog, scrambling up the stairs after him, and showing much affection and docility. Its great favourite, however, was a cat, and the friendship was mutual. When the cat was reposing herself before the fire (this was at New York), the alligator would lay himself down, place his head upon the cat, and in this attitude go tosleep. If the cat was absent the alligator was restless ; _ but he always appeared happy when the cat was near him. The only instance in which he showed any ferocity was in attacking a fox, which was tied up in the yard. Probably, however, the _ “x resented some playful advances which the other had made, and thus called forth the anger of the alligator. In attacking the fox he did not make use of his mouth, but beat him with so _ much severity with his tail, that, had not the chain which con- fined the fox broken, he would probably have killed him. The alligator was fed on raw flesh, and sometimes with milk, for which he showed a great fondness. In cold weather he was shut up in a box, with wool in it; but, having been forgotten one frosty night, he was found dead in the morning. This is not, I believe, a solitary instance of amphibia becoming tame, and showing a fondness for those who have been kind to them. Blumenbach mentions that crocodiles have been tamed; and two instances have occurred under my own observation of toads knowing their benefactors, and coming to meet them with con- _ siderable alacrity.

626

With regard to the higher intelligence of Fao I may quote the following instances. Three or four different correspondents tell me of cases . which they have themselves observed, of snakes and _ tortoises unmistakably distinguishing persons. In one of these cases the tortoise would come to the call of the favoured person, and when it came would manifest its affection by tapping the boot of this person with its mouth; ‘but it would not answer anyone else.’ A separation of some weeks did not affect the memory of this tortoise for his friend.!

627

1 The tortoise which has gained such immortal celebrity by having fallen under the observation of the author of the Natural History of Selborne, likewise distinguished persons in this way. For ‘ whenever the good old lady came in sight, who had waited on it for more than thirty years, it always hobbled with awkward alacrity towards its benefactress, whilst to strangers it was altogether inattentive.’ The following interesting observation on the intelli- gence of snakes shows, not only that these animals are well able to distinguish persons, and that they remember their friends for a period of at least six weeks, but also that they possess an intensity of amiable emotion scarcely to be expected in this class. Clearly the snakes in question were not only perfectly tame, but entertained a remark- able affection for those who tended and petted them. The facts were communicated to me by Mr. Walter Severn, the ‘well-known artist, who was a friend of Mr.and Mrs. Mann, the gentleman and his wife to whom the snakes belonged. Mr. and Mrs. Mann having got into trouble with their neighbours on account of the fear and dislike which their pets occasioned, legal proceedings were instituted, and so the matter came before the public. Mr. Severn then wrote a letter to the Zimes, in order to show that the animals were harmless: From this letter the following is an extract :-—

628

T happen to know the gentleman and lady against whom a complaint has been made because of the snakes they keep, and I should like to give a short account of my first visit to them, Mr. M., after we had talked for a little time, asked if I had any fear of snakes; and after a timid ‘No, not very,’ from me, he produced out of a cupboard a large boa-constrictor, a python, and several small snakes, which at once made themselves at home on the writing-table among pens, ink, and books. I was at first a good deal startled, especially when the two large snakes coiled round and round my friend, and began to notice me with their bright eyes and forked tongues; but soon finding how tame they were, I ceased to feel frightened. After a short time Mr. M. expressed a wish to call Mrs. M., and left me with the boa deposited on an arm-chair. I felt a little queer when the animal began gradually to come near, but the entrance of my host and hostess, followed by two charming little children, put me at my ease again. After the first interchange of civilities, she and the children went at once to the boa, and, calling it by the most endearing names, allowed it to twine itself most grace- fully round about them. I sat talking for a long time, lost in wonder at the picture before me. Two beautiful little girls with their charming mother sat before me with a boa-constrictor (as thick round as a small tree) twining playfully round the lady’s waist and neck, and forming a kind of turban round her

629

head, expecting to be petted and made much of like a kitten. The children over and over again took its head in their hands and kissed its mouth, pushing aside its forked tongue in doing so. The animal seemed much pleased, but kept turning its head continually towards me with a curious gaze, until I allowed it to nestle its head for a moment up my sleeve. Nothing could be prettier than to see this splendid serpent coiled all round Mrs. M. while she moved about the room, and when she stood to pour out our coffee. He seemed to adjust his weight so nicely, and every coil with its beautiful marking was relieved by the black velvet dress of the lady. It was long before I could make up my mind to end the visit, and I returned soon after with a friend (a distinguished M.P.'), to see my snake- taming acquaintance again... .

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.