Animal Intelligence
A curious aberration of the nest-building instinct is sometimes shown by certain birds—particularly the com- mon wren—which consists in building a supernumerary nest. That is to say, after one nest is completed, another is begun and finished before the eggs are laid, and the first nest is not used, though sometimes it is used in pre- ference to the second. _~ times display in the choice of a site, and also the deter- mination of certain birds to return to the same site in successive years, I may allude to the case published by Bingley, of a pair of swallows which built their nest upon the wings and body of a dead owl, which was hanging from the rafters of a barn, and so loosely as to sway about with every gust of wind. The owl with the nest upon, it was placed as a curiosity in the museum of Sir Ashton Lever, and he directed that a shell should be hung ywpon the rafters in the place which had been previously oc- cupied by the dead owl. Next year the swallows re- turned and constructed their new nest in the cavity of the shell.?
The following is quoted from Thompson’s ‘ Passions of Animals,’ p. 205 :— The sociable grosbeak of Africa is one of the few instances of birds living in community and uniting in constructing one huge nest for the whole society. L. Valiant’s account has been: fully confirmed by other travellers. He says : ‘I observed on the: way a tree with an enormous nest of these birds, which I have called republicans; and as soon as I arrived at my camp I de- spatched a few men with a waggon to bring it to me, that I might open and examine the hive. When it arrived, I cut it in pieces with a hatchet, and saw that the chief portion of the structure consisted of a mass of Boshman’s grass, without any mixture, but so compact and firmly basketed together as to be impene- trable to the rain. This is the commencement of the structure, and each bird builds its particular nest under this canopy. But.
the nests are formed only beneath the eaves, the upper surface- } remaining void, without, however, being useless ; for as it has a projecting rim, and is a little inclined, it serves to let the water run off, and preserves each little dwelling from the rain. Fi to yourself a huge irregular sloping roof, all the eaves of whale are covered with nests, crowded one against another, and you will have a tolerably accurate idea of these singular edifices. Each individual nest is three or four inches in diameter, which
is sufficient for the bird; but, as they are all in contact with one another around the eaves, they appear to the eye to form but one building, and are distinguishable from each other only by a little external aperture which serves as an entrance to the nest;. and even this is sometimes common to three different nests, one of which is situated at the bottom and the other two at the sides. This large nest, which was one of the most considerable I had anywhere seen in the course of my journey, contained 320 inhabited cells, which, supposing a male and female to each,
would form a society of 640 individuals; but as these birds are- The following is quoted from Couch (‘ Illustrations of Instinct,’ p. 227 et seq.) :— Mr. Waterton says there is a peculiarity in the nidification. notice. At the time it lays its first egg the nest which it has prepared is of very moderate size; but as incubation proceeds. we see it increase vastly in height and breadth. Every soft material, such as pieces of grass and fragments of sedges, is laid hold of by the sitting swan as they float within her reach, and are added to the nest. This work of accumulation is performed’
by her during the entire period of incubation, be the weather wet or dry, settled or unsettled ; and it is perfectly astonishing to see with what assiduity she plies her work of aggrandisement. to a nest already sufficient in strength and size to answer every end. My swans generally form their nest on an island quite: above the reach of a flood; and still the sitting bird never ap- pears satisfied with the quantity of materials which are provided for her nest. I once gave her two huge bundles of oaten straw, and she performed her work of apparent supererogation by apply- ing the whole of it to her nest, already very large, and not exposed to destruction had the weather become ever so rainy.
It is probable that this disposition to accumulation, in its general bearing, has reference to heat rather than the flood ; but that the wild swan has a foresight regarding danger, and a quick perception as to the means of securing safety, appears from an instance mentioned by Captain Parry, in his Northern voyage. When everything was deeply involved in ice, the voyagers were obliged to pay much attention to discern whether they were: travelling over water or land; but some birds, which formed their nest at no great distance from the ships, were under no mistake in so important a matter; and when the thaw took place it was seen that the nest was situated on an islarid in the lake.
The following cases are likewise taken from Couch (Joe. cit., p. 225) :— This swan was eighteen or nineteen years old, had brought up many broods, and was highly valued by the neighbours, She exhibited, some eight or nine years past, one of the most remarkable powers of instinct ever recorded. She was sitting on four or five eggs, and was observed to be very busy in collect- ing weeds, grasses, &c., to raise her nest; a farming man was ordered to take down half a load of haulm, with which she most industriously raised her nest and the eggs two feet and a half ; that very night there came down a tremendous fall of rain, which flooded all the malt-shops and did great damage. Man made no preparation, the bird did; instinct prevailed over reason. Her eggs were above, and only just above, the water.
During the early part of the summer of 1835, a pair of water-hens built their nest by the margin of the ornamental pond at Bell’s Hill, a piece of water of considerable extent, and ordinarily fed by a spring from the height above, but into which the contents of another large pond can occasionally be admitted. This was done while the female was sitting; and as the nest. had been built when the water level stood low, the sudden influx of this large body of water from the second pond caused a rise — of several inches, so as to threaten the speedy immersion and —
consequent destruction of the eggs. This the birds seem to have been aware of, and immediately took precautions against so imminent a danger; for when the gardener, upon whose veracity I can safely rely, seeing the sudden rise of the water, © went to look after the nest, expecting to find it covered and the — eggs destroyed, or at least forsaken by the hen, he observed, — whilst at a distance, both birds busily engaged about the brink ~ where the nest was placed; and when near enough he clearly — perceived that they were adding, with all possible despatch, fresh — materials to raise the fabric beyond the level of the increased — contents of the pond; and that the eggs had by some means ~ been removed from the nest by the .birds, and were then de- — posited upon the grass about a foot or more from the margin of —
the water. He watched them for some time, and saw the nest rapidly increase in height ; but I regret to add that he did not remain long enough, fearing he might create alarm, to witness the interesting act of replacing the eggs which must have been effected shortly after; for, upon his return in less than an hour, he found the hen quietly sitting upon them in the newly raised nest. Ina few days afterwards the young were hatched, and, as usual, soon quitted the nest and took to the water with their parents. The nest was shown to mein situ shortly after, and I could then plainly discern the formation of the new with the older part of the fabric. —
We must not conclude these remarks on nidification without alluding to Mr. Wallace’s chapters on the ‘ Philo- sophy of Birds’ Nests,’ in his work on ‘ Natural Selection. This writer is inclined to suppose that birds do not build their nests distinctive of their various species by the teach- ings of hereditary instinct, but by the young birds intelli- gently observing the construction of the nests in which tion when in the following season they have occasion to build nests of their own. With reference to this theory it is only needful to say that it is antecedently improbable, and not well substantiated by facts. It is antecedently improbable because, when any habit has been continued for a number of generations—especially when the habit is of a peculiar and detailed character—the probability is
much reason to anticipate that the nest of the little crus- tacean Podocerus, or the cell of the hive-bee, is constructed by a process of conscious imitation, as that this is the case with the nests of birds: And this theory is not well sub- stantiated by facts because, if the theory were true, we should expect considerable differences to be usually pre- sented by nests of the same species. Unless the con- struction of the nest of any given species were regulated by a common instinct, numberless: idiosyncratic peculi- _ arities would necessarily require to arise, and there would only be a very general uniformity of type presented by the nests of the same species.
A more valuable contribution to the ‘ Philosophy of Birds’ Nests’ is furnished by this able naturalist when he _ directs attention to a certain general correlation between _ the form of the nest and the colour of the female. For, on reviewing the birds of the world, he certainly makes _ good the proposition that, as a general rule, liable however _ to frequent exceptions, dull-coloured females sit on open nests, while those that are conspicuously coloured sit in _ domed nests. But Mr. Darwin, in a careful review of all the evidence, clearly shows that this interesting fact is to be attributed, not, as Mr. Wallace supposed, to the colour of the female having been determined through natural selection by the form of the nest, but to the reverse process of the form of the nest having been determined by the. colour of the female.}
Another general fact of interest connected with nidifica- tion must not be omitted. This is that the instincts of nidification, although not so variable as the theory of Mr. _ Wallace would require, are nevertheless highly plastic. The falcon, which usually builds on a cliff, has been known to lay its eggs on the ground in a marsh; the golden eagle sometimes builds in trees or on the ground ; while the heron varies its site between trees, cliffs, and open fen.? Again, Audubon, in his ‘ Ornithological Bio- graphy,’ gives many cases of conspicuous local variations in the nests of the same species in the northern and
southern United States; and, as Mr. Wallace truly ob— 4 serves,— ’ Many facts have already been given which show that birds — do adapt their nests to the situations in which they place them; — and the adoption of eaves, chimneys, and boxes by swallows, wrens, and many other birds, shows that they are always ready to take advantage of changed conditions. Itis probable, there- — fore, that a permanent change of climate would cause many — birds to modify the form or materials of their abode, so as better |
In America the change of habits in this respect under- — gone by the house-swallow has been accomplished within — the last three hundred years. Closely connected, if not identical, with this fact is — another, namely, that in some species which have been © watched closely for a sufficient length of time, a steady im- — provement in the construction of nests has been observed. — Thus C. G. Leroy, who filled the post of Ranger of Ver-— sailles about a century ago, and therefore had abundant opportunities of studying the habits of animals, wrote an essay on ‘The Intelligence and Perfectibility of Animals — from a Philosophical Point of View.’ In this essay he has anticipated the American observer Wilson in noticing — that the nests of young birds are distinctly inferior to those of older ones, both as regards their situation and — construction. As we have here independent testimony — of two good observers to a fact which in itself is not im- © probable, I think we may conclude that the nest-making — instinct admits of being supplemented, at any rate in ~ some birds, by the experience and intelligence of the — individual. M. Pouchet has also recorded that he has found a decided improvement to have taken place in the ~ nests of the swallows at Rouen during his own lifetime ; — and this accords with the anticipation of Leroy thatif our — observation extended over a sufficient length of time, and — in a manner sufficiently close, we should find that the ac- cumulation of intelligent improvements by individuals of — successive generations would begin to tell upon the in- —
herited instinct, so that all the nests in a given locality would attain to a higher grade of excellence. Leroy also says that when swallows are hatched out too late to migrate with the older birds, the instinct of migration is not sufficiently imperative to induce them to undertake the journey by themselves. ‘ They perish, the victims of their ignorance, and of the tardy birth which made them unable to follow their parents.’ Perhaps the strangest of the special instincts mani- fested by birds is that of the cuckoo laying its eggs in the nests of other birds. As the subject is an important one from several points of view, I shall consider it at some
question is not practised by all species of the genus— the American cuckoo, for instance, being well known to stinct as the European. The first observer of the habit practised by the European cuckoo was the illustrious Jenner, who published his account in the ‘ Philosophical The cuckoo makes choice of the nests of a great variety of small birds. I have known its eggs entrusted to the care of the hedge-sparrow, water-wagtail, titlark, yellowhammer, green lin- net, and winchat. Among these it generally selects the three former, but shows a much greater partiality to the hedge-sparrow than to any of the rest; therefore, for the purpose of avoiding confusion, this bird only, in the following account, will be con- sidered as the foster-parent of the cuckoo, except in instances which are particularly specified.
When the hedge-sparrow has sat her usual time, and disen- gaged the young cuckoo and some of her own offspring from the shell,? her own young ones, and any of her eggs that remain unhatched, are soon turned out, the young cuckoo remaining 1 Phil. Trans., vol. \xxviii., p. 221 et seq. 2 The young cuckoo is generally hatched first. possessor of the nest, and sole object of her future care. The — young birds are not previously killed, nor are the eggs de- — molished, but all are left to perish together, either entangled about the bush which contains the nest, or lying on the ground under it.
On June 18, 1787, I examined the nest of a hedge-sparrow, which then contained a cuckoo’s and three hedge-sparrow’s eggs. On inspecting it the day following, I found the bird had hatched, but that the nest now contained a young cuckoo and only one young hedge-sparrow. The nest was placed so near the extremity of a hedge, that I could distinctly see what was going forward in it; and, to my astonishment, saw the young cuckoo, though so newly hatched, in the act of turning out the young hedge- sparrow.
The mode of accomplishing this was very curious. The little animal, with the assistance of its rump and wings, contrived to get the bird upon its back, and making a ledgment for the burden by elevating its elbows, clambered backward with it up the side of the nest till it reached the top, when, resting for a moment, it threw off its load with a jerk, and quite disengaged — it from the nest. It remained in this situation a short time, feeling about with the extremities of its wings, as if to be con- vinced whether this business was properly executed, and then dropped into the nest again. With these (the extremities of its wings) I have often seen it examine, as it were, an egg and nest- ling before it began its operations ; and the sensibility which these parts appeared to possess seemed sufficiently to compensate the want of sight, which as yet it was destitute of. I afterwards. put in an egg, and this by asimilar process was conveyed to the edge of the nest and thrown out. These experiments I have since repeated several times in different nests, and have always found the young cuckoo disposed to act in the same manner. In climbing up the nest it sometimes drops its burden, and thus is foiled in its endeavours ; but after a little respite the work is resumed, and goes on almost incessantly till it is effected. It is wonderful to see the extraordinary exertions of the young cuckoo, when it is two or three days old, if a bird be put into the nest with it that is too weighty for it to lift out. In this state it seems ever restless and uneasy. But this disposition for turning out its companions begins to decline from the time it is two or three till it is about twelve days old, when, as far as I have hitherto seen, it ceases.
Indeed, the disposition for throwing out the egg appears to cease a few days sooner; for I have frequently seen the young cuckoo, after it had been hatched nine or ten days, remove a nestling that had been placed in the nest with it, when it suffered an egg, put there at the same time, to remain unmolested. The singularity of its shape is well adapted to these purposes; for, different from other newly hatched’ birds, its back from the scapule downwards is very broad, with a considerable depression in the middle. This depression seems formed by nature for the design of giving a more secure lodg- ment to the egg of the hedge-sparrow, or its young one, when the young cuckoo is employed in removing either of them from the nest. When it is about twelve days old this cavity is quite. filled up, and then the back assumes the shape of nestling birds in general. . . . The circumstance of the young cuckoo being destined by nature to throw out the young hedge-sparrows: seems to account for the parent cuckoo dropping her egg in the nests of birds so small as those I have particularised. If
she were to do this in the nest of a bird which produced a large egg, and consequently a large nestling, the young cuckoo would probably find an insurmountable difficulty in solely pos- sessing the nest, as its exertions would be unequal to the labour of turning out the young birds. (I have known a case in which a hedge-sparrow sat upon a cuckoo’s egg and one of her in size that the young cuckoo had not powers sufficient to lift it out of the nest till it was two days old, by which time it had grown very considerably. This egg was probably laid by the- cuckoo several days after the hedge-sparrow had begun to sit ;
and even in this case it appears that its presence had created the disturbance before alluded to, as all the hedge-sparrow’s eggs had, gone except one.) ... June 27, 1787.—Two cuckoos and a hedge-sparrow were hatched in the same nest this morn- ing; one hedge-sparrow’s egg remained unhatched. In a few hours after, a contest began between the cuckoos for the pos- session of the nest, which continued undetermined till the next afternoon ; when one of them, which was somewhat superior in size, turned out the other, together with the young hedge-
_ sparrow and the unhatchedegg. This contest was very remark- able. The combatants alternately appeared to have the advan- _ tage, as each carried the other several times nearly to the top _ weight of its burden; till at length, after various efforts, the the cuckoo? May they not be owing to the following circum-— stances,—the short residence this bird is allowed to make in the country where ‘it is destined to propagate its species, and the call that nature has upon it, during that short residence, to produce a numerous progeny? The cuckoo’s first appearance here is about the middle of April, commonly on the 17th, Its egg is not ready for incubation till some weeks after its arrival, seldom before the middle of May. <A fortnight is taken up by — the sitting bird in hatching the egg. The young bird generally continues three weeks in the nest before it flies, and the foster- parents feed it more than five weeks after this period ; so that, if a cuckoo should be ready with an egg much sooner than the time pointed out, not a single nestling, even one of the earliest, would be fit to provide for itself before its parent would be in- stinetively directed to seek a new residence, and be thus com-— pelled to abandon its young one; for old cuckoos take their final leave of this country the first week in July.
Had nature allowed the cuckoo to have stayed here as long as some other migrating birds, which produce a single set of - young ones (as the swift or nightingale, for example), and had allowed her to have reared as large a number as any bird is capable of bringing up at one time, there might not have been sufficient to have answered her purpose; but by sending the cuckoo from one nest to another, she is reduced to the same state as the bird whose nest we daily rob of an egg, in which case the stimulus for incubation is suspended,
A writer in ‘ Nature’ (vol. v., p. 383; and vol. ix., p. 123), to whom Mr. Darwin refers in the latest edition of ‘The Origin of Species’ as an observer that Mr. Gould has found trustworthy, precisely confirms, from observations of his own, the above description of Jenner. So far, therefore, as the observations are common I shall not quote his statements; but the following additional matter is worth rendering :— But what struck me most was this: the cuckoo was per- fectly naked, without a vestige of a feather or even a hint of future feathers; its eyes were not yet opened, and its neck seemed too weak to support the weight of its head. The pipits (in whose nest the young cuckoo was parasitic) had well- developed quills on the wings and back, and had bright eyes partially open ; yet they seemed quite helpless under the mani- pulations of the cuckoo, which looked a much less developed
creature. The cuckoo’s legs, however, seemed very muscular, and it appeared to feel about with its wings, which were abso- lutely featherless, as with hands—the ‘spurious wing’ (unusually large in proportion) looking like a spread-out thumb. The most singular thing of all was the direct purpose with which the blind dittle monster made for the open side of the nest, the only part where it could throw its burden down the bank. [The latter remark has reference to the position of the nest below a heather bush, on the declivity of a low abrupt bank, where the only chance of dislodging the young birds was to eject them over the side of the nest remote from its support upon the bank.] As ‘the young cuckoo was blind, it must have known the part of the nest to choose by feeling from the inside that that part was ‘unsupported.
| Such being the facts, we have next to ask how they _are to be explained on the principles of evolution. At first sight it seems that although the habit saves the bird which practises it much time and trouble, and so is clearly of benefit to the individual, it is not so clear how the in- _ stinct is of benefit to the species; for as cuckoos are not social birds, and therefore cannot in any way depend on - mutual co-operation, it is difficult to see that this saving of time and trouble to the individual can be of any use to the species. But Jenner seems to have hit the right cause in the concluding part of the above quotation. If _ it is an advantage that the cuckoo should migrate early, it clearly becomes an advantage, in order to admit of this, _ that the habit should be formed of leaving her eggs for other birds to incubate. At any rate, we have here a suffi- ciently probable explanation of the raison @étre of this _ curious instinct ; and whether it is the true reason or the only reason, we are justified in setting down the instinct to the creating influence of natural selection. | Mr. Darwin, in his ‘ Origin of Species,’ has some in- _ teresting remarks to make on this subject. First, he is informed by Dr. Merrell that the American cuckoo, _ although as a rule following the ordinary custom of birds _ in incubating her own eggs, nevertheless occasionally de- posits them in the nests of other birds. Now let us suppose that the ancient progenitor of our Euro- _ pean cuckoo had the habits of the American cuckoo, and that
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.