Animal Intelligence
she occasionally Jaid her egg in another bird’s nest. If the old bird profited by this occasional habit through being able to migrate earlier, or through any other cause; or if the young were made more vigorous by advantage being taken of the mis- taken instinct of another species than when reared by their own mother, encumbered as she could hardly fail to be by having eggs and young at the same time;! then the old birds or the fostered young would gain an advantage.?
The instinct would seem to be a very old one, for there are two great changes of structure in the European cuckoo which are manifestly correlated with the instinct. Thus, the shape of the young bird’s back has already been noted ;, and not less remarkable than this is the small size of the egg from which the young bird is hatched. For the egg of the cuckoo is not any larger than that of the skylark, although an adult cuckoo is four times the size of an adult skylark. And ‘that the small size of the egg isa real case of adaptation (in order to deceive the small birds in whose nests it is laid), we may infer from the fact of the non-parasitic American cuckoo laying full-sized eggs.’ Yet, although the instinct in question is doubtless of high antiquity, there have been occasional instances observed in cuckoos of reversion to the ancestral instinct of nidifica- tion; for, according to Adolf Miller, ‘ the cuckoo occasion-
1 Allusion is here made to the fact that the cuckoo lays her eggs at intervals of two or three days, and therefore that if all were incubated by the mother, they would hatch out at different times—a state of things which actually obtains in the case of the American cuckoo, whose nest contains eggs and young at the same time. 2 It is worth while to observe, as bearing on this theory of the origin of this parasitic habit, that even non-parasitic birds occasionally deposit their eggs in nests of other birds. Thus, Professor A. Newton writes in his admirable essay on ‘ Birds ’ in the Encyclopedia Britannica, ‘ Cer- tain it is that some birds, whether by mistake or stupidity, do not un- frequently lay their eggs in the nests of others. It is within the know-
ledge of many that pheasants’ eggs and partridges’ eggs are often laid in the same nest; and it is within the knowledge of the writer that gulls’ eggs have been found in the nests of eider-ducks, and wice versa ; that a redstart and a pied flycatcher will lay their eggs in the same con-~ venient hole—the forest being rather deficient in such accommodation ; that an owl and a duck will resort to the same nest-hole, set up by the scheming woodman for his own advantage; and that the starling, which constantly dispossesses the green woodpecker, sometimes discovers that the rightful heir of the domicile has to be brought up by the intruding tenant.’
ally lays her eggs on the bare ground, sits on them, and feeds her young.’ : In ‘Nature’ for November 18, 1869, Professor A. Newton, F.R.S., has published an article on a somewhat obscure point connected with the instincts of the cuckoo. He says that Dr. Baldamus has satisfied him, by an exhibi- tion of sixteen specimens of cuckoos’ eggs found in the nests of different species of birds, ‘that the egg of the cuckoo is approximately coloured and marked like those of the bird in whose nest it is found,’ for the purpose, no doubt, of deceiving the foster-parents. Professor Newton adds, however :—
Having said this much, and believing as I do the Doctor to be partly justified in the carefully worded enunciation of what he calls a ‘law of nature,’ I must now declare that it is only ‘approximately,’ and by no means wniversally true that the cuckoo’s egg is coloured like those of the victims of her imposi- tion, &e. Still, when so great an authority as Professor Newton, _ expresses himself satisfied that there is a marked tendency to such imitation, which in some cases leads to extra- ordinary variations in the colouring of the cuckoo’s egg, the alleged fact becomes one which demands notice. The _ question, of course, immediately arises, How is it conceiv- able that the fact, if it is a fact, can be explained? We cannot imagine the cuckoo to be able consciously to colour her egg during its formation in order to imitate the eggs among which she is about to lay it; nor can we suppose that having laid an egg and observed its colouring, she then carries it to the nest of the bird whose eggs it most resembles. Professor Newton suggests another theory, which he seems to think sufficient, but which I confess seems to me little more satisfactory than the impossible _ theories just stated. He says :—
Only one explanation of the process can, to my mind, be _ offered. Every person who has studied the habits of birds with _ sufficient attention will be conversant with the tendency which _ certain of those habits have to become hereditary. Itis, I am sure, no violent hypothesis to suppose that there is a very _ reasonable probability of each cuckoo most commonly placing her eggs in the nest of the same bird, and of this habit being transmitted to her posterity. .
Now it will be seen that it requires but only an application to this case of the principle of ‘ natural selection,’ or ‘ survival of the fittest,’ to show that if my argument be sound, nothing can be more likely than that, in the course of time, that prin- ciple should operate so as to produce the facts asserted, the eggs which best imitated those of particular foster-parents having the best chance of duping the latter, and so of being hatched out.
Now, granting to this hypothesis the assumption that individual cuckoos have special predilections as to the species in whose nests they are to lay their eggs, and that some of these species require to be deceived by imitative colouring of the egg to prevent their tilting it out, there one cuckoo out of a hundred happens to lay eggs suffi- ciently: like those of the North African magpies (a species alluded to by Professor Newton) to deceive the latter into supposing the egg to be one of their own. This I cannot think is too small a proportion to assume, seeing that, ex hypothesi, the resemblance must be tolerably close, and that the egg of the magpie does not resemble the great majority of eggs of the cuckoo. . Now, in order to sustain the theory, we must suppose that the particular cuckoo which happens to have the peculiarity of laying eggs so closely resembling those of the magpie, must also happen to have the peculiarity of desiring to lay its eggs in the nest of a magpie. The conjunction of these two pecu- liarities would, I should think, at a moderate estimate reduce the chances of an approximately coloured egg being laid in the appropriate nest to at least one thousand to one. But supposing the happy accident to have taken place, we have next to suppose that the peculiarity of
stant for the same individual cuckoo, but is inherited by innumerable generations of her progeny; and, what is much more difficult to grant, that the fancy for laying eggs in the nest of a magpie is similarly inherited. I think, therefore, notwithstanding Professor Newton’s strong opinion upon the subject, that the ingenious hypothesis must be dismissed as too seriously encumbered by the difficulties which I have mentioned. We may with philo- sophical safety invoke the influence of natural selection to explain all cases of protective colouring when the modus operandi need only be supposed simple and direct; but in a case such as this the number and complexity of the conditions that would require to meet in order to give natural selection the possibility of entrance, seem to me much too considerable to admit of our entertaining the possibility of its action—at all events in the way that Professor Newton suggests. Therefore, if the facts are facts, I cannot see how they are to be explained.
Cuckoos are not the only birds which manifest the - parasitic habit of laying their eggs in other birds’ nests. Some species of Melothrus, a widely distinct genus of American birds, allied to our starlings, have parasitic habits like those of the cuckoo ; and the species present an interesting gradation in the perfectiun of their instincts. The sexes of Melothrus cadius are stated by an excellent observer, Mr. Hudson, sometimes to live promiscuously together in flocks and sometimes to pair. They either build a nest of their own, or seize on one belonging to some other bird, occasionally throwing out the nestlings of the stranger. They either lay their eggs in the nest thus appropriated, or oddly enough build one for them- selves on the top of it. They usually sit on their own eggs and rear their own young; but Mr. Hudson says it is probable that they are occasionally parasitic, for he has seen the young of this species feeding old birds of a distinct kind and clamouring to be fed by them. The parasitic habits of another species of Melothrus, the M. Canariensis, are much more highly developed than those of the last, but are still far from perfect. This bird, as far as it is known, invariably lays its eggs in the nests of strangers, but it is remarkable that several together sometimes commence to build an irregular untidy nest of their own, placed in singularly ill-adapted situations, as on the leaves of a large thistle. They must, however, as far as Mr. Hudson has ascer- tained, complete a nest for themselves. They often lay so many eggs, from fifteen to twenty, in the same foster-nest, that few or none can possibly be hatched. They have, moreover, the extra- ordinary habit of pecking holes in the eggs, whether of their own species or of their foster-parents, which they find in the appropriated nests. They drop also many eggs on the bare
ground, which are thus wasted. A third species, the M. precius — of North America, has acquired instincts as perfect as those of | the cuckoo, for it never lays more than an egg in a foster-nest, so that the young bird is securely reared. Mr. Hudson is a strong disbeliever in evolution, but he appears to have been so much struck by the imperfect instincts of the Melothrus Canari- ensis that he quotes my words, and asks, ‘Must we consider these habits not as especially endowed or created instincts, but as small consequences of one general law, namely transition ?’!
Such are all the facts and considerations which I have to present with reference to the curious instinct in ques- tion. It will be seen that—with one doubtful or not suffi- ciently investigated exception, viz., that of cuckoos adapt- ing the colour of their eggs to that of the eggs of the foster-parents—there is nothing connected with these instincts that presents any difficulty to the theory of evo- - lution. We may, perhaps, at first sight wonder why some counteracting instinct should not have been developed by the same agency in the birds which are liable to be thus - duped; but here we must remember that the deposition of a parasitic egg is, comparatively speaking, an exceed- ingly rare event, and therefore not one that is likely to _lead to the development of a special instinct to meet it.
Under this heading I shall here, as in the case of this heading elsewhere, string together all the instances which I have met with, and which I deem trustworthy, of the display of unusually high intelligence in the class, family, order, or species of animals under consideration—the ob- ject of this heading in all cases being that of supplying, by the facts mentioned beneath it, a general idea of the upper limit of intelligence which is distinctive of each group of animals.
That birds recognise their own images in mirrors as birds there can be no question. Houzeau, who records observations of his own in this connection with parrots,? adds that dogs are more difficult to deceive by mirrors in this way than birds, on account of their depending so much upon smell for their information. No doubt indi- vidual differences are to be met with in animals of both classes, and much depends on previous experience. Young dogs, or dogs which have never seen a mirror before, are not, as a rule, difficult to deceive, even though they have good noses. I myself had a setter with an excellent nose, who on many repeated occasions tried to fight his own image, till he found by experience that it was of no use. As to birds, I have seen canaries suppose their own images to be other canary birds, and also the reflection of a room to be another room—the birds flying against a large mirror and falling half stunned. I mention the latter circumstance because it afforded evidence of the superior intelligence of a linnet, which on the same occasion dashed itself against the mirror once, but never a second time, while the canaries did so repeatedly.
Mrs. Frankland, in ‘ Nature ’(xxi., p. 82), gives the fol- lowing account of a bullfinch paying more attention toa portrait of a bullfinch than to his own image in a mirror, which is certainly remarkable; and as the fact seems to have been observed repeatedly, it can scarcely be discredited : The following is a curious instance of discrimination which I have observed in my bullfinch. He is in the habit of coming out of his cage in my room in the morning. In this room there is a mirror with a marble slab before it, and also a very cleverly executed water-colour drawing of a hen bullfinch, life size. The first thing that my bullfinch does on leaving his cage is to fly to the picture (perching on a vase just below it) and pipe his tune in the most insinuating manner, accompanied with much bow- ing to the portrait of the hen bullfinch. After having duly paid his addresses to it, he generally spends some time on the marble slab in front of the looking-glass, but without showing the ‘slightest emotion at the sight of his own reflection, or courting it with a song. Whether this perfect coolness is due to the fact of the reflection being that of a cock bird, or whether (since he shows no desire to fight the reflected image) he is per- fectly well aware that he only sees himself, it is difficult to say.
That birds possess considerable powers of imagination, or forming mental pictures of absent objects, may be in- ferred from the fact of their pining for absent mates, parrots — calling for absent friends, &c. The same fact is further proved by birds dreaming, a faculty which has been noticed by Cuvier, Jerdon, Thompson, Bennet, Houzeau, Bechstein, Lindsay, and Darwin.! The facility with which birds lend themselves to the education of the show-man is certain evidence of consider-. able docility, or the power of forming novel associations. of ideas. Thus, according to Bingley,—
Some years ago the Sieur Roman exhibited in this country the wonderful performances of his birds. These were gold- finches, linnets, and canary birds. One appeared dead, and was » held up by the tail or claw without exhibiting any signs of life. A second stood on its head, with its claws in the air, &c., &c.? And many years ago there was exhibited a very puzzling automaton, which, although of very small size and quite isolated from any possibly mechanical connection with its designer, performed certain movements in any order that the fancy of the observers might dictate. The explana- tion turned out to be that within the mechanism of the figure there was a canary bird which had been taught to run in different directions at different words or tones of command, so by its weight starting the mechanism to perform the particular movement required.
The rapidity with which birds learn not to fly against newly erected telegraph wires, displays a large amount of observation and intelligence. The fact has been repeatedly observed. For instance, Mr. Holden says :-— About twelve years ago I was residing on the coast of county Antrim, at the time the telegraph wires were set up along that charming road which skirts the sea between Larne and Cushendall. During the winter months large flocks of starlings. always migrated over from Scotland, arriving in the early morn- ing. The first winter after the wires were stretched along the coast. I frequently found numbers of starlings lying dead or wounded on the road-side, they having evidently in their flight in the dusky morn struck against the telegraph wires, not
blown against them, as these accidents often occurred when there was but little wind. I found that the peasantry had come to the conclusion that these unusual deaths were due to the flash of the telegraph messages killing any starlings that happened to be perched on the wires when working. Strange to say that throughout the following and succeeding winters hardly a death occurred among the starlings on their arrival. It would thus appear that the birds were deeply impressed, and understood the cause of the fatal accidents among their fellow-travellers the previous year, and hence carefully avoided the telegraph wires ; not only so, but the young birds must also have acquired this knowledge and perpetuated it, a knowledge which they could not have acquired by experience or even instinct, unless the instinct was really inherited memory derived from the parents whose brains were first impressed by it.!
moorland. During the first season some of the grouse were injured by flying against the wires, but never in any succeeding season. Why the young birds should avoid them without having had individual experience may, I think, be explained by the consideration that in birds which fly in flocks or coveys, it is the older ones that lead the way. This explanation would not, of course, apply to birds which fly singly ; but I am not aware that any ob- servations have gone to show that the young of such birds avoid the wires.
I quote the following exhibition of intelligence in an eagle from Menault :-— The following account of the patience with which a golden eagle submitted to surgical treatment, and the care which it showed in the gradual use of the healing limb, must suggest the idea that something very near to prudence and reason existed in the bird. This eagle was caught in a fox-trap set in the forest of Fontainebleau, and its claw had been terribly torn. An operation was performed on the limb by the conservators of
the Zoological Gardens at Paris, which the noble bird bore with a rational patience. Though his head was left loose, he made: no attempts to interfere with the agonising extraction of the splinters, or to disturb the arrangements of the annoying band- ages. He seemed really to understand the nature of the services — rendered, and that they were for his good.! Speaking of the Urubu vultures, Mr. Bates says :— They assemble in great numbers in the villages about the — end of the wet season, and are then ravenous with hunger. My cook could not leave the open kitchen at the back of the house for a moment whilst the dinner was cooking, on account of — their thievish propensities. Some of them were always loitering © about, watching their opportunity, and the instant the kitchen was left unguarded, the bold marauders marched in and lifted — the lids of the saucepans with their beaks to rob them of their — contents, The boys of the village lie in wait, and shoot them — with bow and arrow; and vultures have consequently acquired such a dread of these weapons, that they may be often kept off by hanging a bow from the rafters of the kitchen.” Mrs. Lee, in her ‘ Anecdotes,’ says that one day her gardener was struck by the strange conduct of a robin, which the man had often fed. The bird fluttered about him in so strange a — manner—now coming close, then hurrying away, always in the same direction—that the gardener followed its retreating move- — ments. The robin stopped near a flower-pot, and fluttered over — it in great agitation. It was soon found that a nest had been formed in the pot, and contained several young. Close by was a snake, intent, doubtless, upon making a meal of the brood. |
The following appeared in the ‘ Gardener’s Chronicle’ for Aug. 3, 1878, under the initials‘T. G.’ I wrote to the © editor requesting him to supply me with the name of his correspondent, and also to state whether he knew him to be a trustworthy man. In reply the editor said that he — knew his correspondent to be trustworthy, and that his © name is Thomas Guring :— . About thirty years ago the small market town in which I reside was skirted by an open common, upon which a number ~ -of geese were kept by cottagers. The number of the birds was very great, . . . Our corn market at that. time was held in the street in front of the principal inn, and on the market day a — good deal of corn was scattered from sample bags by millers. — Somehow the geese found out about the spilling of corn, and they appear to have held a consultation upon the subject. . ..
‘From this time they never missed their opportunity, and the entry of the geese was always looked for and invariably took place. On the morning after the market, early, and always on the proper morning, fortnightly, in they came cackling and gobbling in merry mood, and they never came on the wrong day. The corn, of course, was the attraction, but in what manner did they mark the time? One might have supposed that their perceptions were awakened on the market day by the smell of corn, or perhaps by the noise of the market traffic; but my story is not yet finished, and its sequel is against this view. It happened one year that a day of national humiliation was kept, and the day appointed was that on which our market should have been held. The market was postponed, and the geese for once were bafiled. There was no corn to tickle their olfactory organs from afar, no traffic to appeal to their sense of hearing. I think our little town was as still as it usually is on Sundays. . . . The geese should have stopped away; but they knew their day, and came as usual... . I do not pretend to remember under what precise circumstances the habit of coming into the street was acquired. It may have been formed by degrees, and continued from year to year; but how the old _birds, who must have led the way, marked the time so as to come in regularly and fortnightly, on a particular day of the _ week, I am at a loss to conceive.
Livingstone’s ‘Expedition to the Zambesi, 1865,’ p. 209, gives a conclusive account of the bird called the _honey-guide, which leads persons to bees’ nests. ‘They are quite as anxious to lure the stranger to the bees’ hive as other birds are to draw him away from their own nests.’ The object of the bird is to obtain the pupx of the bees which are laid bare by the ravaging of the nest. The habits of this bird have long been known and described in books on popular natural history; but it is well that the facts have been observed by so trustworthy a man as Livingstone. He adds, ‘How is it that members of this - family have learned that all men, white and black, are fond of honey?*® We can only answer, by intelligent observa- _ tion in the first instance, passing into individual and hereditary habit, and so eventually into a fixed instinct. Brehm relates an instance of cautious sagacity in a _ pewit. He had placed some horsehair snares over its nest, but the bird seeing them, pushed them aside with
her bill. Next day he set them thickly round the nest ; but now the bird, instead of running as usual to the nest along the ground, alighted directly upon it. This shows a considerable appreciation of mechanical appa as. does also the following. At Ardglass, co. Down, Ireland, is a long tract of turf coming to the edge of the rocks overhanging the sea, where cattle and geese feed; at a barn on this tract there was a low enclosure, with a door fastening by a hook and staple to the side- post : when the hook was out of the staple, the door fell open by its own weight. I one day saw a goose with a large troop of goslings coming off the turf to this door, which was secured by the hook being in the staple. The goose waited for a minute or two, as if for the door to be opened, and then turned round as if to go away, but what she did was to make a rush at the door, and making a dart with her beak at the point of the hook | nearly threw it out of the staple ; she repeated this manceuvre, and succeeded at the third attempt, the door fell open, and the goose led her troop in with a sound of triumphant chuckling. How had the goose learned that the force of the rush was need- ful to give the hook a sufficient toss 1
Mrs. K. Addison sends me the following instance of the use of signs on the part of an intelligent jackdaw. The bird was eighteen months old, and lived in some bushes in Mrs. Addison’s garden. She writes :— I generally made a practice of filling a large basin which stands under the trees every morning for Jack’s bath. A few days ago I forgot this duty, and was reminded of the fact in a very singular manner. Another of my daily occupations is to open my dressing-room shutters about eleven o’clock of a morning, Now these said shuuters open almost on to the trees where Jack lives. The day I forgot his bath, when I opened the shutters I found my little friend waiting just outside them, as though he knew — that he should see me there ; and when he did he placed himself immediately in front of me, and then shook himself and spread — out his wings just as he always does in his bath. The action was so suggestive and so unmistakable, that I spoke just as I would have done toa child—‘ Oh yes, J ack, of course you shall have some water.’
The Central Prison at Agra is the roosting-place of great numbers of the common blue pigeon ; they fly out to the neigh- bouring country for food every morning, and return in the evening, when they drink at a tank just outside the prison walls. In this tank are a large number of fresh-water turtles, which lie in wait for the pigeons just under the surface of the water and at the edge of it. Any bird alighting to drink near one of these turtles has a good chance of having its head bitten off and eaten ; and the headless bodies of pigeons have been picked up near the water, showing the fate which has sometimes befallen the birds. The pigeons, however, are aware of the danger, and have hit on the following plan to escape it. A pigeon comes in from its long flight, and, as it nears the tank, instead of flying down at once to the water’s edge, will cross the tank at about twenty feet above its surface, and then fly back to the side from - which it came, apparently selecting for alighting a safe spot - which it had remarked as it flew over the bank ; but even when such a spot has been selected the bird will not alight at the edge of the water, but on the bank about a yard from the water, and will then run down quickly to the water, take two or three _ hurried gulps of it, and then fly off to repeat the same process at another part of the tank till its thirst is satisfied. I had _ often watched the birds doing this, and could not account for their strange mode of drinking till told by my friend the super- intendent of the prison, of the turtles which lay in ambush for the pigeons.
As a still more remarkable instance of the display of intelligence by a bird of this species, I shall quote the following observation of Commander R. H. Napier, also published in ‘ Nature’ (viii., p. 324) :— A number of them (pouters) were feeding on a few oats that had been accidentally let fall while fixing the nose-bag on a horse standing at bait. Having finished all the grain at hand, a large ‘pouter’ rose, and flapping its wings furiously, flew directly at the horse’s eyes, causing the animal to toss his head, and in doing so, of course shake out more corn. I saw this several times repeated—in fact, whenever the supply on hand had been exhausted. . . . Was not this something more than instinct ?
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.