Animal Intelligence
The following display of intelligence on the part of swallows is communicated to me by Mr. Charles Wilson. Two swallows were building a nest in the verandah of a f house in Victoria, but as their nest was resting partly on a bell- — wire, it was by this means twice pulled down. They then began afresh, making a tunnel through the lower part of the nest, through which the wire was able to act without doing ] tunnels. Being molested by sparrows which desired to take forcible possession of their nest, a pair of swallows modified the entrance of the latter, so that instead of opening by a simple hole under the eaves of a house, it was carried on in the form of a tunnel.
Linneus says that the martin, when it builds under the eaves of houses, sometimes is molested by sparrows taking ‘possession of the nest. The pair of martins to which the nest belongs are not strong enough to dislodge the in- vaders ; but they convoke their companions, some of whom guard the captives, whilst others bring clay, close up the entrance of the nest, and leave the sparrows to die miser- ably. This account has been to a large extent indepen- dently confirmed by Jesse, who seems not to have been acquainted with the statement of Linnzeus. He writes :—
Swallows seem to entertain the recollection of injury, and to resent it when an opportunity offers. A pair of swallows built their nest under the ledge of a house at Hampton Court. It was no sooner completed than a couple of sparrows drove them from it, notwithstanding the swallows kept up a good re- sistance, and even brought others to assist them. The intruders were left in peaceable possession of the nest, till the two old birds were obliged to quit it to provide food for their young. They had no sooner departed than several swallows came and broke down the nest; and I saw the young sparrows lying dead on the ground. As soon as the nest was demolished, the swallows began to rebuild it.!
A pair of swallows built their nest against one of the first- floor windows of an uninhabited house in Merrion Square, Dublin. A sparrow, however, took possession of it, and the swallows were repeatedly seen clinging to the nest, and en- -deavouring to gain an entrance to the abode they had erected with so much labour. All their efforts, however, were defeated by the sparrow, who never once quitted the nest. The perse- verance of the swallows was at length exhausted: they took flight, but shortly afterwards returned, accompanied by a number of their congeners, each of them having a piece of dirt in its bill. By this means they succeeded in stopping up the hole, and the intruder was immured in total darkness. Soon afterwards the nest was taken down and exhibited to several persons, with the dead sparrow in it. In this case there ap- pears to have been not only a reasoning faculty, but the birds
must have been possessed of the power of communicating their _ resentment and their wishes to their friends, without whose aid they could not thus have avenged the injury they had sus- ‘ tained.! That birds sometimes act in concert may also be _ gathered from the following observations recorded by Mr. Buck :— I have constantly seen a flock of pelicans, when on the feed, form a line across a lake, and drive the fish before them up its whole length, just as fishermen would with a net.?
The following is extracted from Sir E. Tennent’s _ * Natural History of Ceylon,’ and displays remarkable in- telligence on the part of the crows in that island :— One of these ingenious marauders, after vainly attitudi- nising in front of a chained watch-dog, that was lazily gnawing a bone, and after fruitlessly endeavouring to divert his attention by dancing before him, with head awry and eye askance, at length flew away for a moment, and returned bringing a com- panion which perched itself on a branch a few yards in the rear. The crow’s grimaces were now actively renewed, but with no better success, till its confederate, poising itself on its wings, descended with the utmost velocity, striking the dog upon the spine with all the force of its strong beak. The ruse was successful; the dog started with surprise and pain, but not quickly enough to seize his assailant, whilst the bone he had been gnawing was snatched away by the first crow the
instant his head was turned. Two well-authenticated instances of the recurrence of this device came within my knowledge at Colombo, and attest the sagacity and powers of communication and combination possessed by these astute and courageous birds. This account, which would be difficult of credence if narrated by a less competent author, is strikingly confirmed by an independent observation on the crows of Japan, which has recently been published by Miss Bird, in whose words I shall render it. She writes :—
In the inn garden I saw a dog eating a piece of carrion in the presence of several of these covetous birds. They evidently said a great deal to each other on the subject, and now and then one or two of them tried to pull the meat away from him, which he resented. At last a big strong crow succeeded in tearing off a piece, with which he returned to the pine where the others were congregated, and after much earnest speech - they all surrounded the dog, and the leading bird dexterously dropped the small piece of meat within reach of his mouth, when he immediately snapped at it, letting go the big piece unwisely for a second, on which two of the crows flew away with it to the pine, and with much fluttering and hilarity they all ate, or rather gorged it, the deceived dog looking vacant and bewildered for a moment, after which he sat under the tree and barked at them inanely. A gentleman told me that he saw a dog holding a piece of meat in like manner in the presence of three crows, which also vainly tried to tear it from him, and after a consultation they separated, two going as near as they dared to the meat, while the third gave the taila bite sharp enough to make the dog turn round with a squeak, on which the other villains seized the meat, and the three fed triumphantly upon it on the top of a wall.!
These two independent statements by competent ob- servers of such similar exhibitions of intelligence by crows, justifies us in accepting the fact, remarkaple though it be. As further corroboration, however, I shall quote still another independent and closely similar observation, which I find in a letter to me from Sir J. Clarke Jervoise, who says, while writing of rooks which he has observed in England :— A pheasant used to come very boldly and run off with large pieces of food, which he could only divide by shaking, and he was closely watched by the rooks for the pieces that flew out of his reach. He learned to run off into the shrubs, followed by the rooks, who pulled his tail to make him drop his food.
I shall next quote a highly interesting observation which seems to have been well made, and which displays remarkable intelligence on the part of the birds described. These are Turnstones, which, as their name implies, turn over stones, &c., in order to obtain as food the sundry small creatures concealed beneath. In this case the ob- server was Edward. Being concealed in a hollow, and unnoticed by the birds, he saw a pair trying to turn over the body of a stranded cod-fish, three and a half feet long, _ and buried in the sand to a depth of several inches. He thus describes what he saw :—
Having got fairly settled down in my pebbly observatory, I turned my undivided attention to the birds before me. They _ were boldly pushing at the fish with their bills, and then with their breasts. Their endeavours, however, were in vain: the _ object remained immovable. On this they both went round to the opposite side, and began to scrape away the sand from beneath the fish. After removing a considerable quantity, they again came back to the spot which they had left, and went once more to work with their bills and breasts, but with as little apparent success as formerly. Nothing daunted, however, they ran round asecond time to the other side, and recommenced their trenching operations with a seeming determination not to _ be baffled in their object, which evidently was to undermine the dead animal before them, in order that it might be the more easily overturned.
While they were thus employed, and after they had laboured in this manner at both sides alternately for nearly half an hour, they were joined by another of their own species, which came flying with rapidity from the neighbouring rocks. Its timely arrival was hailed with evident signs of joy. I was led to this conclusion from the gestures which they exhibited, and from a low but pleasant murmuring noise to which they gave utterance so soon as. the new-comer made his appearance. Of their feelings he seemed to be perfectly aware, and he made his reply to them in a similar strain. Their mutual congratulations being over, they all three set to work; and after labouring
vigorously for a few minutes in removing the sand, they came round to the other side, and putting their breasts simultaneously to the fish, they succeeded in raising it some inches from the — into its sandy bed, to the manifest disappointment of the three. © Resting, however, for a space, and without leaving their respective positions, which were a little apart the one from the other, they resolved, it appears, to give the work another trial. Lowering themselves, with their breasts pressed close to the
sand, they managed to push their bills underneath the fish, which they made to rise about the same height as before. — Afterwards, withdrawing their bills, but without losing the advantage which they had gained, they applied their breasts to. the object. This they did with such force, and to such purpose, slight declivity. It was followed to some distance by the birds. themselves before they could recover their bearing.! I shall now bring this chapter to a close by presenting all the evidence that I have been able to collect with regard to the punishment of malefactors among rooks.
Goldsmith, who used constantly to observe a rookery from his window, says that the selection of a site for the building of a nest is a matter of much anxious delibera- tion on the part of a young crow couple; the male and female ‘examining all the trees of a grove very atten- tively, and when they have fixed upon a branch that seems fit for their purpose, they continue to sit upon it, and observe it very sedulously for two or three days longer :’—
It often happens that the young couple have made choice of a place too near the mansion of an older pair, who do not. choose to be incommoded by such troublesome neighbours; a quarrel, therefore, instantly ensues, in which the old ones are always victorious. The young couple, thus expelled, are obliged. again to go through their fatigues—deliberating, examining, and choosing ; and, having taken care to keep their due distance, the nest begins again, and their industry deserves commen- dation. But their activity is often too great in the beginning ; they soon grow weary of bringing the materials of their nests from distant places, and they very early perceive that sticks may be provided nearer home, with less honesty indeed, but some degree of address. Away they go, therefore, to pilfer as. fast as they can, and, whenever they see a nest unguarded, they
take care to rob it of the very choicest sticks of which it is composed. But these thefts never go unpunished, and probably, upon complaint being made, there is a general punishment inflicted. I have seen eight or ten rooks come upon such occasions, and, setting upon the new nest of the young couple, all at once tear it to pieces in a moment. _ At length, however, the young pair find the necessity of going more regularly to work. While one flies to fetch the materials, the other sits upon the tree to guard it; and thus in the space of three or four days, with a skirmish now and then between, the pair have filled up a commodious nest, composed of sticks without, and of fibrous roots and long grass within. From the instant the female begins to lay, all hostilities are at an end; not one of the whole grove, that a little before treated her so rudely, will now venture to molest her, so that she brings forth her brood with perfect tranquillity. Such is the severity with which even native rooks are treated by each other ; butif a foreign rook should attempt to make himself a denizen of their society, he would meet with no favour, the whole grove would at once be up in arms against him, and expel him with- out mercy.
The wrong-doers being discovered, the punishment is ap- propriate to the offence; by the destruction of their dishonest work they are taught that they who build must find their own bricks or sticks, and not their neighbours’, and that if they wish to live in the enjoyment of the advantages of the social con- dition, they must endeavour to conform their actions to the principles of the rookery of which they have been made members. Itis not known what enormities led to the institution of another tribunal of the same kind, called the Crow Court, but ac- cording to Dr. Edmonson, in his ‘ View of the Shetland Islands,’ its proceedings are as authoritative and regular, andit is remark- able as occurring in a species (Corvus Cornice) so near akin totherook. The Crow Court is a sort of general assembling of birds who, in their usual habits, are accustomed to live in pairs, scattered at great distances from each other ; when they visit the south or west of England, as they do in severe winters, they are commonly solitary. In their summer haunts in the Shetland Islands, numbers meet together from different points on a particular hill or field; and on these occasions the assem- bly is not complete, and does not begin its business for a day or two, till, all the deputies having arrived, a general clamour
or croaking ensues, and the whole of the court, judges, barristers, — ushers, audience, and all, fall upon the two or three prisoners at the bar, and beat them till they kill them. When this is accomplished the court breaks up and quietly disperses. In the northern parts of Scotland (says Dr. Edmonson), and in the Faroe Islands, extraordinary meetings of crows are — occasionally known to occur. They collect in great numbers, as if they had all been summoned for the occasion; a few of the flock sit with drooping heads, and others seem as grave as judges, while others again are exceedingly active and noisy ; in the course of about one hour they disperse, and it is not un- common, after they have flown away, to find one or two left dead on the spot. These meetings will sometimes continue for a day or two before the object, whatever it may be, is completed. Crows continue to arrive from all quarters during the session. As soon as they have all arrived, a very general noise ensues ; and, shortly after, the whole fall upon one or two individuals, and put them to death. When the execution has been per- formed, they quietly disperse.
Similarly, the Bishop of Carlisle writes in the ‘ Nine- teenth Century’ for July 1881 :— 7 I have seen also a jackdaw in the midst of a congregation of rooks, apparently being tried for some misdemeanour. First Jack made a speech, which was answered by a general cawing of the rooks ; this subsiding, Jack again took up his parable, and the rooks in their turn replied in chorus. After a time the business, whatever it was, appeared to be settled satisfac- torily : if Jack was on his trial, as he seemed to be, he was honourably acquitted by acclamation ; for he went to his home in the towers of Ely Cathedral, and the rooks also went their way.
Lastly, Major-General Sir George Le Grand Jacob, K.C.S.L., C.B., writes to me that while sitting in a ve- randah in India, he saw three or four crows come and perch on a neighbouring house. They then cawed continuously with such peculiar sound and vigour as to attract his at- tention. His account proceeds :— Soon a gathering of crows from all quarters took place, until the roof of the guard-house was blackened by them. Thereupon a prodigious clatter ensued ; it was plain that a ‘ palaver’ was going forward. Some of its members, more eager than others, skipping about, I became much interested, and narrowly watched the proceedings, all within a dozen yards of me. After much cawing and clamour, the whole group suddenly rose into the air,
and kept circling round half a dozen of their fellows, one of whom had been clearly told off for punishment, for the five repeat- edly attacked it in quick succession, allowing no opportunity for their victim to escape, which he was trying to do, until they had cast him fluttering on the ground about thirty yards from my chair. Unfortunately I rushed forward to pick up the bird, prostrate but fluttering on the grass which was like a lawn before the building. 1 succeeded only in touching it, for it wriggled away from my grasp, and flew greatly crippled and close to the ground into the neighbouring bushes, where I lost sight of it. All the others, after circling round me and chattering, angrily as I thought, flew away, on my resuming my seat, in the direction taken by their victim.
[Since going to press I have seen, through the kindness of Mr. Seebohm, some specimens of cuckoo’s eggs coloured in imitation of those belonging to the birds in the nests of which they are laid. There can be no question about the imitation, and I add this note to mitigate the criticism which I have passed upon Professor Newton’s theory of the cause. For Mr. Seebohm has pointed out to me that the theory becomes more probable if we consider that a cuckoo reared in the nest of any particular bird is likely afterwaids to choose a similar nest for the deposition of its own eggs. Whether or not the memory of a bird would thus act could only, of course, be certainly proved by experiment; but in view of the possibility that it may, Professor Newton’s theory becomes more probable than it is if the selection of the appropriate nest is supposed to depend only on inheritance.
I must also add that Dr. Sclater has been kind enough to draw my attention to a remarkable description of a species of Bower-bird, published by Dr. Beccari in the Gardener's Chronicle for March 16, 1879, This species is called the Gardener Bower-bird (Amblyornis niornata), and inhabits New Guinea. The animal is about the size of a turtle-dove, and its bower—or rather hut—is built round the stem of a tree in the shape of a cone, with a space between the stem of the tree and the walls of the hut. The latter are composed of stems of an orchid with their ieaves on—this particular plant being chosen by the birds apparently because its leaves remain long fresh. But the most extra- ordinary structure is the garden, which is thus described by Dr. Beccari :—‘ Before the cottage there is a meadow of moss. This is brought to the spot and left free from grass, stones, or anything which would offend the eye. On this green turf flowers and fruits of pretty colour are placed, so as to form an elegant little garden. The greater part of the decoration is collected round the entrance to the nest, and it would appear that the husband offers these his daily gifts to his wife. The objects are very various, but always of a vivid colour. There were some fruits of a Garcinia like a small-sized apple. Others were the fruits of Gardencias of a deep yellow colour in the interior. I saw alsv small rosy fruits, probably of a Scitamineous plant, and beautiful rosy flowers of a new Vaccinium. There were also fungi and mottled insects placed on the turf. As soon as the objects are faded they are moved to the back of the hut.’ There is a fine-coloured plate of this bird in its garden, published in the Birds of New Guinea, by Mr. Gould, Part ix., 1879. ]
I sHALL devote this chapter to the psychology of all the Mammalia which present any features of psychological interest, with the exception of the rodents, the elephant, the dog and cat tribe among Carnivora, and the Primates —all of which I shall reserve for separate treatment. . In the ‘Transactions of the Linnean Society,’ Major Mitchell gives an interesting account of the structure reared by a small Australian marsupial (Conilurus con- structor ) for the purposes of defence against the dingo dog. It consists of a large pile of dry sticks and brushwood, ‘big enough to make two or three good cart-loads.’ Each stick and fragment is closely intertwined or woven with the rest, so that the whole forms a solid, compact mass. In the middle of this large structure is the nest of the animal.
The marsupials are as low in the scale of mammalian intelligence as they are in that of mammalian structure ; so that, except the above, I have met with no fact con- nected with the psychology of this group that is worth quoting, except, perhaps, the following, which appears to show deliberation and decision onthe part of the kangaroo. Jesse writes :— A gentleman who had resided for several years in New South Wales related the following circumstance, which he assured.me he had frequently witnessed while hunting the kan- garoo: it furnishes a strong proof of the affection of that animal for her young, even when her own life has been placed in the
most imminent danger. He informed me that, when a female kangaroo has been hard pressed by dogs, he has seen her, while she has been making her bounds, put her fore-paws into her pouch, take a young one from it, and then throw it as far on one side as she possibly could out of the way of the dogs. But for this maneuvre her own life and that of her young one would have been sacrificed. By getting rid of the latter she has frequently effected her escape, and probably returned after- wards to seek for her offspring.
| In 1811, says Mr. Scoresby, one of my harpooners struck a _ sucker, with the hope of leading to the capture of the mother. Presently she arose close to the ‘fast boat,’ and seizing the young one, dragged about 600 feet of line out of the boat with remarkable force and velocity. Again she rose to the surface, darted furiously to and fro, frequently stopped short or suddenly changed her direction, and gave every possible intimation of extreme agony. For a length of time she continued thus to act, though pursued closely by the boats; and, inspired with courage and resolution by her concern for her young, seemed regardless of the dangers which surrounded her. At length one of the
boats approached so near that a harpoon was hove at her; it: hit, but did not attach itself. A second harpoon was struck, but this also failed to penetrate ; but a third was more successful, and held. Still she did not attempt to escape, but allowed other boats to approach; so that in a few minutes three more harpoons were fastened, and in the course of an hour afterwards she was killed.! Mr. Saville Kent communicates an article to ‘Nature’ (vol. viii., p. 229) on ‘ Intellect of Porpoises.’ He says :—
The keeper in charge of these interesting animals is now in the habit of summoning them to their meals by the call of a whistle; his approaching footsteps, even, cause great excitement in their movements. . . . The curiosity attributed to these creatures, as illustrated by the experiences of Mr. Matthew Williams, receives ample confirmation from their habits and confinement. A new arrival is at once subjected to the most importunate attention, and, advancing from familiarity to con-
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.