Animal Intelligence
fence, and roll over on his back, with four legs in the air, by another beast perform this feat; and although it must have been ; often done in the presence of a number of cows, not one of them ever imitated it, though they would all have unquestionably followed the bull through an opening in the fence, or by the slip-rails. Mr. G. 8. Erb, writing from Salt Lake City, gives me an interesting account of the sagacity displayed by the wild deer of the United States in avoiding gun-traps, which, except for the cutting of the string, to which the teeth of the animal are not so well adapted, is strikingly similar to the sagacity which we shall see to be displayed in this respect by sundry species of Carnivora. He says :—
My method was this: I would fell or cut down a maple tree, the top of which they are very partial to; and as the ground was invariably covered with snow to the depth of 12 inches, food was scarce, and the deer would come and browse, probably from hearing the tree fall. I would place a loaded gun 20 feet from the top of the tree at which it was pointing ; I would attach a line the size of an ordinary fish-line to a lever that pressed against the trigger ; the other end of the line I would fasten to the tree-top. By this means the deer could not pass between the tree and the gun without getting shot, or at least shot at ; but I never succeeded in killing one when my line was as large as a fish-line, ¢.¢. about one-sixteenth of an inch in thick-
ness. Commencing at the body of the tree on one side, the deer would eat all the tops to within 12 inches of the line, and then - go around the gun and eat all on the other side, never touching the line. I tried this at least sixty times, always with the same result. Then I took a black linen thread, and had no diffi- culty in killing them, as it was so small and black that they could not distinguish it. There can be no doubt that pigs exhibit a degree of intelligence which falls short only of that of the most intelligent Carnivora. The tricks taught the so-called ‘learned pigs’ would alone suffice to show this; while the marvellous skill with which swine sometimes open latches and fastenings of gates, &., is only equalled by that of the cat. The following account of pigs in their wild state shows that they manifest the same kind of sagacious co-operation in facing an enemy as that which we have just seen to be manifested by the bison and the buffalo, although here it seems to be displayed in a manner still more organised :—
Wild swine associate in herds and defend themselves in com- mon. Green relates that in the wilds of Vermont a person fell in with a large herd in a state of extraordinary restlessness ; they had formed a circle with their heads outwards, and the young ones placed in the middle. A wolf was using every artifice to snap one, and on his return he found the herd scattered, but the wolf was dead and completely ripped up. Schmarda recounts an almost similar encounter between a herd of tame swine and a wolf, which he witnessed on the military positions of Croatia. He says that the swine, seeing two wolves, formed themselves into a wedge, and approached the wolves slowly, grunting and erecting their bristles. One wolf fled, but the other leaped on to the trunk of a tree. Assoon as the swine reached it they surrounded it with one accord, when, suddenly and instan- taneously, as the wolf attempted to leap over them, they got him down and destroyed him in a moment.!
In Bingley’s ‘ Memoirs of British Quadrupeds’ (page 452) there is an account drawn up at his request by Sir Henry Mildmay, concerning the docility of the pig. The Toomer brothers were King’s keepers in the New Forest, and they conceived the idea of training a sow to point game. This they succeeded in doing within a fort- night, and in a few more weeks it also learnt to retrieve. Her scent was exceedingly good, and she stood well at par- tridges, black game, pheasants, snipes, and rabbits, but never pointed hares. She was more useful than a dog, and afterwards became the property of Sir Henry Mild- may. According to Youatt,' Colonel Thornton also had a sow similarly trained. The same author says that a sow belonging to Mr. Craven had a litter of pigs, one of which, when old enough, was taken and roasted, then a second and a third. These were necessarily taken when the mother returned in the evening from the woods for supper. But the next time she came she was alone, and, ‘as her owners were anxious to know what was become of her brood, she was watched on the following evening, and observed driving back her pigs at the extremity of the wood, with much earnest grunting, while she went off to the house, leaving them to wait for her return. It was evident that she had noticed the diminution of her family, and had adopted this method to save those that re- mained.’ ?
Mr. Stephen Harding sends me the following as an observation of his own :— On the 15th ult. (Nov. 1879) I saw an intelligent sow pig about twelve months old, running in an orchard, going toa young apple tree and shaking it, pricking up her ears at the same time, as if to listen to hear the apples fall. She then picked the apples up and ate them. After they were all down she shook the tree again and listened, but as there were no more to fall she went away.
The proverbial indifference to dirt attributed to the pig seems scarcely to be justified; the worst that can be said is that the animal prefers cool mud to dry heat, and the filth which swine often exhibit in their sty is the fault of the farmers rather than of the animals. Or, to quote from Thompson’s ‘ Passions,’— A washed sow in the hot season of our temperate climate, and in almost every season of such a climate as that of Pales- tine, ‘returns to her wallowing in the mire’ simply because she feels scorched, and blistered, and sickened under the ardent
sunshine ; and hence, when she receives from man the aid which is due to her as a domesticated animal, she demands not dirt all the year through, nor any day at all, but shade in summer, shelter in winter, and a clean, dry bed in every season. Mr. Bates says of bats: ‘ The fact of their sucking the blood of persons sleeping is now well established; but it is only a few persons who are subject to this bloodletting. . .. I am inclined to think many different kinds of bats have this propensity’ (‘ Nat. on Amaz.,’ p. 91). The particular species of bat, however, which has been most universally accredited with this habit, viz., the vam- pire, is perfectly harmless.
Mr. G. Clark (‘A Brief Notice of the Fauna of Mauritius’) gives an account of the intelligence dis- played by a tame bat (Pteropus vulgaris). As soon as its master came into the room, it welcomed him with cries ; and if not at once taken up to be petted, it climbed up his dress, rubbed its head against him, and licked his hands. If Mr. Clark took anything in his hand, the bat would care- fully examine it by sight and smell, and when he sat down the bat would hang upon the back of his chair, following all his movements with its eyes.
I shall here run together a few facts relating to the intelligence of carnivorous animals other than those to be considered in subsequent chapters. Seals.—In their wild state these animals have not much opportunity for the display of intelligence; but when tamed it is seen that the latter is considerable. They are then affectionate animals, liking to be petted, and showing attachment to their homes. The most remarkable species of the order from a psychological point of view are the so-called Pinnipeds, whose habits during the breeding season are so peculiar that I think it is worth while to quote the best account that has hitherto
been published on the subject. This is the elaborate -work of Mr. Joel Asaph Allen : ! — From the time of the first arrivals in May up to the Ist of June, as late as the middle of this month if the weather be clear, is an interval in which everything seems quiet ; very few seals are added to the pioneers. By the Ist of June, however, or thereabouts, the foggy, humid weather of summer sets in, and with it the bull-seals come up by hundreds and thousands, and locate themselves in advantageous positions for the reception of the females, which are from three weeks to a month later, as a rule. The labour of locating and maintaining a position in the rookery is really a serious business for those bulls which come in last, and for those that occupy the water-line, frequently resulting in death from severe wounds in combat sustained. It appears to be a well-understood principle among the able-bodied bulls that each one shall remain undisturbed on his ground, which is usually about ten feet square, provided he is strong enough to hold it against all comers; for the crowding in of fresh bulls often causes the removal of those who, though equally able- bodied at first, have exhausted themselves by fighting earlier, and are driven by the fresher animals back further and higher up on the rookery. Some of these bulls show wonderful strength and courage. I have marked one veteran, who was among the first to take up his position, and that one on the water-line, when at least fifty or sixty desperate battles were fought victoriously by him with nearly as many different seals who coveted his position; and when the fighting season was over (after the cows have mostly all hauled up) I saw him covered with scars and gashes, raw and bloody, an eye gouged out, but holding it bravely over his harem of fifteen or twenty cows, all huddled together on the same spot he had first chosen.
The fighting is mostly or entirely done with the mouth, the opponents seizing each other with the teeth and clenching the jaws; nothing but sheer strength can shake them loose, and that effort almost always leaves an ugly wound, the sharp canines tearing out deep gutters in the skin and blubber, or shredding the flippers into ribbon-strips. They usually approach each other with averted heads and a great many false passes before either one or the other takes the initiative by gripping ; the heads are darted out and back as quick as flash, their hoarse roaring and shrill piping whistle never ceases, while their fat
1 History of the North American Pinnipeds. The quotations are bodies writhe and swell withexertion and rage, fur flying in air and blood streaming down—all combined make a picture fierce and savage enough, and, from its great novelty, exceedingly strange at first sight. In these battles the parties are always distinct, the offensive and the defensive ; if the latter proves the weaker he withdraws from the position occupied, and is never followed by his conqueror, who complacently throws up one of his hind flippers, fans himself, as it were, to cool himself from the heat of the conflict, uttering a peculiar chuckle of satisfac- tion and contempt, with a sharp eye open for the next covetous bull or ‘ sea-catch ’ (native name for the bulls on the rookeries, especially those which are able to maintain their position).
All the bulls, from the very first, that have been able to hold their positions have not left them for an instant, night or day; nor do they do so until the end of the rutting season, which subsides entirely between the lst and 10th of August, beginning shortly after the coming of the cows in June. Of necessity, therefore, this causes them to fast, to abstain entirely from food of any kind, or water for at least three months; and a few of them stay four months before going into the water for the first time after hauling up in May. This alone is remarkable enough, but it is simply wonderful when we come to associate the condition with unceasing activity, restlessness, and duty de- volved upon the bulls as heads and fathers of large families. They do not stagnate like bears in caves; it is evidently accomplished or due to the absorption of their own fat, with which they are so liberally supplied when they take their posi- tions on the breeding-ground, and which gradually diminishes while they remain on it.
They are noticed and received by the bulls on the water-line station with much attention; they are alternately coaxed and urged up on the rocks, and are immediately under the most jealous supervision ; but owing to the covetous and ambitious nature of the bulls which occupy the stations reaching some way back from the water-line, the little cows have a rough-and- tumble time of it when they begin to arrive in small numbers at first ; for no sooner is the pretty animal fairly established on the station of bull No. 1 who has installed her there, than he perhaps sees another one of her style down in the water from which she has just come, and in obedience to his polygamous feeling, he devotes himself anew to coaxing the later arrival in the same winning manner so successful in her case, when bull
No. 2, seeing bull No. 1 off his guard, reaches out his. long strong neck, and picks the unhappy but passive creature up by the scruff of hers, just as a cat does a kitten, and deposits her on his seraglio-ground; then bulls Nos. 3, 4, 5, and so on in the vicinity, seeing this high-handed operation, all assaik one another, and especially bull No. 2, and have a tremen- | dous fight perhaps for half a minute or so; and during this. commotion the cow is generally moved or moves farther back from the water two or three stations more, where, when all gets. quiet, she usually remains in peace. Her late lord and master, not having the exposure to such diverting temptation as had her first, gives her such care that she not only is unable to leave did she wish, but no other bull can seize upon her. This is only one instance of the many different trials and tribulations which both parties on the rookery subject themselves to before the harems are filled. Far back, fifteen or twenty stations deep from the water-line sometimes, but generally not more than, on an average, ten or fifteen, the cows crowd in at the close of the season for arriving, July 10 to 14, and then they are able to go about pretty much as they please, for the bulls have become greatly enfeebled by this constant fighting and excite- ment during the past two months, and are quite content with even only one or two partners.
I have found it difficult to ascertain the average number of cows to one bull on the rookery, but I think it will be nearly correct to assign to each male from twelve to fifteen females occupying the stations nearest the water, those back in the rear from five to nine. I have counted forty-five cows all under the charge of one bull, which had them penned up on a flat table- rock near Kestaire Point ; the bull was enabled to do this quite easily, as there was but one way to go to or come from this seraglio, and on this path the old Turk took his stand and guarded it well. At the rear of all these rookeries there is. always a large number of able-bodied bulls, who wait patiently, but in vain, for families, most of them having had to fight as. desperately for the privilege of being there as any of their more fortunately located neighbours, who are nearer the water than themselves; but the cows do not like to be in any outside position, when they are not in close company lying most quiet and contentin the largest harems; and these large families pack the surface of the ground so thickly that there is hardly moving or turning room until the females cease to come up from the sea ; but the inaction on the part of the bulls in the rear during the:
rutting season only serves to qualify them to move into the places. vacated by those males who are obliged to leave from exhaus- tion, or to take the position of fearless and jealous protectors for the young pups in the fall. The courage with which the fur- ‘seal holds his position as the head and guardian of a family is. of the very highest order compared with that of other animals. I have repeatedly tried to drive them when they have fairly estab- _ lished themselves, and have almost always failed, using every stone at my command, making all the noise I could, and finally, to put their courage to the full test, I walked up to within twenty feet of a bull at the rear and extreme end of Tolstoi Rookery, who had four cows in charge, and commenced with my double- barrelled breech-loading shot-gun to pepper him all over with mustard-seed or dust-shot. His bearing in spite of the noise, smell of powder, and pain, did not change in the least from the usual attitude of determined defence which nearly all the bulls assume when attacked with showers of stones and noise; he would dart out right and left and catch the cows which timidly attempted to run after each report, fling and drag them back to their places; then, stretching up to his full height, look me directly and defiantly in the face, roaring and spitting most vehemently. The cows, however, soon got away from him, but he still stood his ground, making little charges on me of ten or fifteen feet in a succession of gallops or lunges, spitting furiously and then retreating to the old position, back of which he would not go, fully resolved to hold his own or die in the attempt. This courage is all the more noteworthy from the fact that, in regard to man, it is invariably of a defensive character.
The seal, if it makes you turn when you attack it, never follows you much farther than the boundary of its station, and no aggra- vation will compel it to become offensive, as far as I have been able to observe. The apathy with which the young are treated by the old on the breeding-grounds is somewhat strange. I have never seen a cow caress or fondle her offspring, and should it stray but a short distance from the harem, it can be picked up and killed before the mother’s eyes, without causing her to show the slightest concern, The same indifference is exhibited by the bull to all that takes place outside of the boundary of his seraglio. While the pups are, however, within the limits of his harem-ground he is a jealous and fearless protector; but if the little animals: pass beyond this boundary then they may be
carried off without the slightest attention in their behalf from — their guardian. Early in August (8th) the pups that are nearest the water on — the rookeries essay swimming, but make slow and clumsy pre- — gress, floundering about, when over head in depth, in the most awkward manner, thrashing the water with their fore-flippers, not using the hinder ones. In a few seconds, or a minute at the most, the youngest is so wary that he crawls out upon the rocks
or beach, and immediately takes a recuperative nap, repeating © the lesson as quick as he awakes and is rested. They soon get — familiar with the water and delight in it, swimming in endless — evolutions, twisting, turning, diving ; and when exhausted, they — do, either going to sleep on the spot, or having a lazy frolic — In this matter of learning to swim, I have not seen any ‘driving’ of the young pups into the water by the old in order to teach them this process, as has been affirmed by writers on the subject of seal life.
Otter.—The fact that otters admit of being taught to catch fish and bring them to their masters, shows no small degree of docility on the part of these animals. ‘I have seen,’ says Dr. Goldsmith, ‘an otter go to a gentle- man’s pond at word of command, drive the fish into a corner, and, seizing upon the largest of the whole, bring it off in his mouth to his master.’ And several other cases of the same kind are given by Bingley.! Weasel.—‘ Mdlle. de Faister described her tame weasel to Buffon as playing with her fingers like a kitten, jump- ing on her head and neck; and if she presented her hands at the distance of three feet, it jumped into them without ever missing. It distinguished her voice amidst twenty people, and sprang over everybody to get at her. She found it impossible to open a drawer or a box, or even to look at a paper, without his examining it also. If she took up a paper or book, and looked attentively at it, the weasel immediately ran upon her hand, and surveyed with an in- quisitive air whatever she happened to hold.’ ?
Polecat.—Professor Alison, in his article on ‘ Instinct,’ in Todd’s ‘ Cyclopedia of Anatomy,’ quotes the following ac- count from the ‘ Magazine of Natural History’ (vol. iv., p. 206 ) touching a remarkable instinct manifested by polecats. ‘I dug out five young polecats, comfortably embedded in dry, withered grass; and in a side hole, of proper dimen- sions for such a larder, I picked out forty large frogs and two toads, all alive, but merely capable of sprawling a little. On examination, I found that the whole number, toads and all, had been purposely and dexterously bitten through the brain.’ The analogy of this instinct to that which has already been mentioned as having been much more re- cently observed by M. Fabre in the sphex insect is _ noteworthy.
Ferret.—I once kept 4 ferret as a domestic pet. He was a very large specimen, and my sister taught him a number of tricks, such as begging for food (which he did _ quite as well and patiently as any terrier), leaping over sticks, &«. He became a very affectionate animal, delight- _ ing much in being petted, and following like a dog when _ taken out for walk. He would, however, only follow those persons whom he well knew. That his memory was ex- ceedingly good was shown by the fact that after an ab- sence of many months, during which he was never required to beg, or to perform any of his tricks, he went through all his paces perfectly the first time that we again tried him.
I strongly suspect that ferrets dream, as I have fre- quently seen them when fast asleep moving their noses and twitching their claws as if in pursuit of rabbits. Another fact I may mention as bearing on the intelligence of these animals. On one occasion, while ferreting rabbits, I lost the ferret about a mile away from home. Some days afterwards the animal returned to hishome. Similar cases have been communicated to me by several sporting friends, but certainly the return of a ferret under such circum- stances is the exception, and not the rule.
_ intelligence of this animal, which for the most part are certainly exaggerations. Still there is no doubt that the creature does display a degree of sagacious cunning unsur- passed, if not unequalled, in the animal kingdom. This — may be shown by the two following quotations from the statements of trustworthy writers. The first is a letter — kindly sent me by Dr. J. Rae, F.R.S., in reply to my — request for information concerning the intelligence of this — animal :— .
The narratives of most travellers in America tell wonderful stories of the glutton or wolverine, but I do not know that any of my experiences of this extremely acute animal indicate what I call reasoning powers. They are very suspicious, and can seldom or never be taken with poisoned bait, trap, or gun. The poisoned baits are usually found broken up, but not eaten by them ; traps are destroyed or entered, but not where the trapper desired ; and guns, except when concealed after the Eskimo fashion by a covering of snow, are avoided. .
In 1853, on the Arctic coast, when about to change our © domicile from a tent to the warmer snow hut, my man had © carried over about 100 lbs. or more of fine venison steaks to. ~ the snow houses about a quarter of a mile from our tents; and as there were at the time no traces either of foxes, wolves, or — wolverines about, the meat was placed overnight in one of the — huts, and the door left open. During the night two wolverines. came, but, evidently dreading some trap or danger in the open ~ door, would not enter that way, but cut a hole for themselves through the wall of the snow hut, and carried off all our fine steaks, a considerable quantity of which was picked up close to our house when the thaw took place in the spring, it having been hid in the snow, but completely spoilt for use, by a well- known filthy habit.
Dr. Rae has also drawn my attention to the following account contained in the Miscellaneous Publications of the — Geological Survey of the United States.! The writer of — this account is Captain Elliot Cones :—. To the trapper the wolverines are equally annoying. When — they have discovered a line of marten traps they will never — abandon the road, and must be killed before the trapping can — be successfully carried on. Beginning at one end, they proceed’ from trap to trap along the whole line, pulling them succes- — sively to pieces, and taking out the baits from behind. When — they can eat no more, they continue to steal the baits and cache
1 Vol. viii., Washington, 1877:‘A Monograph of the North Ameri- can Mustelida.’ them. If hungry they may devour two or three of the martens they find captured, the remainder being carried off and hidden in the snow at a considerable distance. The work of demoli- tion goes on as fast as the traps can be renewed. The propensity to stea].and hide things is one of the strong- -est traits of the wolverine. To such an extent is it developed that the animal will often secrete articles of no possible use to itself. Besides the wanton destruction of marten traps, it will carry off the sticks and hide them at a distance, apparently in sheer malice. Mr. Ross, in the article above quoted, has given an amusing instance of the extreme of this propensity. The desire for accumulating property seems so deeply implanted in this animal, that, like tame ravens, it does not appear to care much what it steals so that it can exercise its favourite propen- “sity to commit mischief. An instance occurred within my own knowledge, in which a hunter and his family having left their lodge unguarded during their absence, on their return found it completely gutted—the walls were there, but nothing else. Blankets, guns, kettles, axes, cans, knives, and all the other paraphernalia of a trapper’s tent had vanished, and the tracks __ left by the beast showed who had been the thief. The family set to work, and by carefully following up all his paths re- covered, with some trifling exceptions, the whole of the lost property.
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.