Romanes, G. J., 1882  ·  passages 870 to 899 of 1414

Animal Intelligence

870

At Peel’s River, on one occasion, a very old carcajou dis- covered my marten road, on which I had nearly a hundred and fifty traps. I was in the habit of visiting the line about oncea fortnight, but the beast fell into the way of coming oftener than I did, to my great annoyance and vexation. I deter- mined to put a stop to his thieving and his life together, cost what it might. So I made six strong traps at as many different points, and also set three steel traps. For three weeks I tried my best to catch the beast without success; and my worst enemy would allow that I am no green hand in these matters. The animal carefully avoided the traps set for his own benefit, and seemed to be taking more delight than ever in demolishing my marten traps and eating the martens, scattering the poles in every direction, and ciching what baits or martens he did not devour on the spot. As we had no poison in those days, I next set a gun on the bank of a little lake. The gun was con- cealed in some low bushes, but the bait was so placed that the earcajou must see it on his way up the bank. I blockaded my path to the gun with a small pine tree, which completely hid

871

it. On my first visit afterwards I found that the beast had gone up to the bait and smelled it, but had left it untouched. — He had next pulled up the pine tree that blocked the path, and — gone around the gun and cut the line which connected the bait _ with the trigger, just behind the muzzle. Then he had gone back _ and pulled the bait away, and carried it out on the lake, where he 4 lay down and devoured it at his leisure, There I found my string. — I could scarcely believe that all this had been done designedly, for _ it seemed that faculties fully on a par with human reason would be required for such an exploit if done intentionally. I there- — fore rearranged things, tying the string where it had been — bitten. But the result was exactly the same for three succes- sive occasions, as I could plainly see by the footprints; and what is most singular of all, each time the brute was careful to cut the line a little back of where it had been tied before, as if actually reasoning with himself that even the knots might be some new device of mine, and therefore a source of hidden danger he would prudently avoid. I came to the conclusion that that carcajou ought to live, as he must be something at least human, if not worse. I gave it up, and abandoned the road for a period.

872

With so much for the tricks and the manners of the beast behind our backs, roaming at will in his vast solitudes, what of his actions in the presence of man? It is said that if one only stands still, even in full view of an approaching carcajou, he will come within fifty or sixty yards, provided he be to wind- ward, before he takes the alarm. Even then, if he be not warned by sense of smell, he seems in doubt, and will gaze earnestly several times before he finally concludes to take him- self off. On these and similar occasions he has a singular habit—one not shared, so far as I am aware, by any other beast whatever. He sits on his haunches and shades his eyes with one of his fore-paws, just as a human being would do in scrutinising a dim or distant object. The carcajou, then, in addition to his other and varied accomplishments, is a perfect sceptic—to use this word in its original signification. A sceptic, with the Greeks, was simply one who would shade his eyes to see more clearly.

873

Beavs.—There is no doubt that the intelligence of these animals stands very high in the psychological scale, although the actual instances which I have met of the display of their intelligence are few. The tricks which are taught performing bears do not count for much as proof of high sagacity, as they for the most part consist in teaching the animals to assume unnatural positions, scarcely for their high intelligence. Still even here it is. worth while to remark that all species of bears would pro- bably not lend themselves to this kind of education, for the emotional temperament manifested by the different species is unquestionably diverse. Thus, making all allowances for exaggeration, it seems certain that the grizzly bear displays a courage and ferocity which are foreign to the disposition of the brown bear, and indeed to that of most other animals. The polar bear likewise displays much bravery under the influence of hunger or

874

usually deems discretion the better part of valour. The following incident displays considerable intelligence on the part of this animal. Scoresby, in his ‘ Account of the Arctic Regions,’ gives the instance to which I allude :— The animal with two cubs was being pursued by a party of sailors over an ice-field. She urged her young to an increase of speed by running before them, turning round, and manifest- ing, by a peculiar action and voice, her anxiety for their pro- gress ; but finding that her pursuers were gaining upon them, she carried, or pushed, or pitched them alternately forward, until she effected their escape. In throwing them before her, the little creatures placed themselves across her path to receive the impulse ; and when projected some yards in advance, they

875

As the polar bear is not exposed to any enemies except man, this method of escaping is not likely to be instinc- tive, but was probably an intelligent adaptation to the particular circumstances of the case. Mr. 8. J. Hutchinson writes me as follows with regard to this same species :— One Sunday, at the ‘ Zoo,’ some one threw a bun to the bears, but it fell in the water in that quadrant-shaped pond you will remember. The bun fell just at the angle, and the bear seemed disinclined to enter the water, but stood on the edge of the © pond, and commenced stirring the water with its paw, so that — it established a sort. of rotatory current, which eventually — brought the bun within: reach. When one leg got tired it used the other, but in the same.direction. I watched the whole per- — formance with the greatest interest myself.

876

I quote the following from Mr. Darwin’s ‘ Descent of Man’ (p. 76), which is so precisely similar, that the fact of bears reaching the high level of intelligence which the fact implies can scarcely be doubted. ‘A well-known ento- mologist, Mr. Westropp, informs me that he observed in Vienna a bear deliberately making with his paw a current in some water which was close to the bars of his cage, so as to draw a piece of floating bread within his reach.’

877

THE rodents, psychologically considered, are, of all orders in the animal kingdom, most remarkable for the differ- ences presented by constituent species. For while the _ group contains many animals, such as the guinea-pig, _ whose instincts and intelligence cannot be said to rise above the lowest level that obtains among mammalian forms, it also contains other animals with instincts as remarkable as those of the squirrel, intelligence as con- siderable as that of the rat, and a psychological develop- ment as unique as that of the beaver. In no other group of animals do we meet with nearly so striking an exempli- fication of the truth that zoolegical or structural affinity is only related in a most loose and general way to psycho- logical or mental similarity. Up to a certain point, however, even here we meet with an exemplification of what I may call a complementary truth, namely, that similarity of organisation and environment is in a general way related to similarity of instincts (though not neces- sarily of intelligence). This is obviously the case with the habit from which the order takes its name; for whether the instinct of gnawing is here the cause or the result of peculiar organisation, the instinct is unquestion- ably correlated with the peculiarity. And similarly, though less obviously, is this the case with the instinct of storing food for winter consumption, which is more prevalent among the rodents than in any other order of mammals— rats, mice, squirrels, harvesters, beavers, &c., all mani- festing it with remarkable vigour and persistency. Here | we probably have a case of similar organisation and en- vironment determining the same instinct; for the latter

878

is not of sufficiently general occurrence among all species ; of rodents to allow us to suppose that the species in which — it does occur have derived it from a common ancestry. Rabbits are somewhat stupid animals, exhibiting but small resources under novel circumstances, although in- heriting several clever instincts, such as that of rapidly deciding upon the alternative of flight or crouching, which is usually done with the best judgment. I have, however, often observed that the animal does not seem to have sense enough to regard the colour of the surface on which it crouches, so that if this happens to be inappro- priate, the rabbit may become conspicuous, and so its crouching a source of danger. I have been particularly struck with the fact that black rabbits inherit the crouch- ing instinct as strongly as do normally coloured ones, with the effect of rendering themselves highly conspicuous, This shows that the instinct is not necessarily correlated with the colour which alone renders the instinct useful, but that both have developed simultaneously and indepen- dently, and by natural selection. The fact also shows that. the crouching of rabbits is purely instinctive, and not due to any conscious process of comparing their own colour with that of the surfaces on which they crouch. No doubt the instinct began and was developed by natural selection placing a premium upon the better judgment of those individuals which know when best to seek safety in flight and when by crouching—protective colouring being added at the same time by the same agency.

879

Another fact, which every one who shoots must have observed, goes to show the stupidity of rabbits, or their inability to learn by experience. When alarmed they run for their burrows, and when they reach them, instead of entering they very frequently squat down to watch the enemy. Now, although they well know the distance at which it is safe to allow a man with a gun to approach, excess of curiosity, or a mistaken feeling of security in being so near their homes, induces the animals to allow a

880

‘man to approach within easy shooting distance. Yet that in other respects rabbits can learn much by experience must be evident to all who are accustomed to shoot with ferrets. From burrows which have not been much ferreted, rabbits will bolt soon after the ferret is put in; but this is not the case where rabbits have had previous experience of the association between ferrets and sportsmen. Rather than bolt under such circumstances, and so face the known

881

sportsmen may conduct their operations; the mere fact of a ferret entering their burrows seems to be enough to assure the rabbits that sportsmen are waiting outside.! In its emotions the rabbit is for the most part a very timid animal, although the males fight severely with one another—having more strongly developed than any other animal the strange but effectual instinct of castrating their rivals. Moreover, even against other animals, rabbits To show this I may quote a letter which several years ago I published in ‘ Nature :’—

882

I have occasion just now to keep over thirty Himalayan rabbits in an outhouse. A short time ago it was observed that some of these rabbits had been attacked and slightly bitten by rats. Next day the person who feeds the rabbits observed, upon entering the outhouse, that nearly all the inmates were congregated in one corner; and upon going to ascertain the cause, found one rat dead, and another so much injured that it could scarcely run. Both rats were of an unusually large size, and their bodies were much mangled by the rabbits’ teeth.

883

I never before knew that domestic rabbits would fight with any carnivorous antagonist. That wild rabbits never do so I infer from having several times seen ferrets turn out from the most crowded burrow in a warren young stoats and weasels not more than four inches long. 1 It is particularly remarkable that if under these circumstances a rabbit bolts and, seeing the sportsman, doubles back into its burrow, being then certain that the sportsman is waiting, it will usually allow itself to be slowly and painfully killed by the ferret rather than bolt a second time, This is remarkable because it proves the strength of an abiding image or idea in the mind of the animal.

884

It is evident that the show-fight instinct cannot have been ¥ developed in Himalayan rabbits by means of natural selection, but it is no less evident that if it ever arose in wild rabbits it _ The following observation of my own on a previously unnoticed instinct displayed by wild rabbits is, I think, of sufficient interest to render. Most people are aware that — if a rabbit is shot near the mouth of its burrow, the — animal will employ the last remnant of its life in struggling into it. Having several times observed that wounded

885

the wounded animals had themselves come out before — dying, possibly for air, or had been taken out by their © companions. I therefore shot numerous rabbits while they were sitting near their burrows, taking care that the distance between the gun and the animal should be such as to insure a speedy, though not an immediate death. Having marked the burrows at which I shot rabbits in this manner I returned to them at intervals for a fort- night or more, and found that about one-half of the bodies appeared again on the surface in the way described. That this reappearance above ground is not due to the

886

only did two or three days generally elapse before the body thus showed itself—a period much too long for a severely wounded rabbit to survive—but in a number of cases decomposition had set in. Indeed, on one occasion scarcely anything of the animal was left save the skin and bones. This was in a large warren. It is a curious thing that I have hitherto been unable to get any bodies returned to the surface, of rabbits for this by supposing that the stench of the decomposing carcass is not so intolerable to the other occupants of the burrow when it is near the orifice as it is when further in. Similarly, I find that there is not so good a chance of bodies being returned from an extensive warren of intercommunicating holes, as there is from smaller war-

887

rens or blind holes; the reason probably being that in the one case the living inhabitants are free to vacate the offensive locality, while in the other case they are not so. Anyhow, there can be no reasonable doubt that the in- stinct of removing their dead has arisen in rabbits from the necessity of keeping their confined domiciles in a pure state. The hare is a more intelligent animal than the rabbit. Possibly its much greater powers of locomotion may be one cause of its mental superiority to its nearest congener. I have never myself observed a hare commit the mistake already mentioned in the case of the rabbit, viz., that of crouching for concealment upon an inappropriately coloured surface. But the best idea of the comparatively high intelligence of the hare will be gained by the following quotations. The first of these is taken from Loudoun’s ‘Magazine of Natural History’ (vol. iv., p. 143) :—

888

It is especially conscious of the scent left by its feet, and of the danger which threatens it in consequence; a reflection which implies as much knowledge of the habits of its enemies as of its own. When about to enter its seat for the purpose of rest, it leaps in various directions, and crosses and recrosses its path with repeated springs ; and at last, by a leap of greater energy than it has yet used, it effects a lodgment in the selected spot, which is chosen rather to disarm suspicion than to protect it from injury. In the ‘Manuel du Chasseur’ some instances are quoted from an ancient volume on hunting by Jaques du Fouillouse. A hare intending to mislead its pursuers has been seen spontaneously to quit its seat and to proceed to a pond at the distance of nearly a mile, and having washed itself, push off again through a quantity of rushes. It has, too, been known, when pursued to fatigue by dogs, to thrust another hare from its seat and squat itself down in its place. This author has seen hares swim successively through two or three ponds, of which the smallest was eighty paces round. He has known it, after a long chase, to creep under the door of a sheep-house and rest among the cattle, and when the hounds were in pursuit, it ‘would get into the middle of a flock of sheep and accompany them in all their motions round the field, refusing by any means to quit the shelter they afforded. The stratagem of its passing

889

forward on one side of a hedge and returning by the other, with only the breadth of the hedge between itself andits enemies, is of frequent occurrence, and it has even been known to select its swat close to the walls of a dog-kennel. This latter circumstance, however, is illustrative of the principles of reflection and reason- ing ; for the fox, weasel, and polecat are to the hare more dan- gerous enemies than the hound; and the situations chosen were such as those ferocious creatures were not likely to approach. A gentleman was engaged in the amusement of coursing, when a hare, closely pressed, passed under a gate, while the dogs fol- lowed by leaping over it. The delay caused to her pursuers by this manceuvre seems to have taught a sudden and useful lesson to the persecuted creature ; for as soon as the dogs had cleared the gate and overtaken her, she doubled and returned under the gate as before, the dogs again following and passing over it. And this flirtation continued backwards and forwards until the dogs were fairly tired of the amusement; when the hare, taking advantage of their fatigue, quietly stole away.

890

The following note, by Mr. Yarrell, is significant of a process of reasoning derived from observations of the course of nature, such as would do no discredit to a higher race of creatures :— A harbour of great extent on our northern coast has an island near the middle of considerable size, the nearest point of which is a mile distant from the mainland at high water, and with which point there is frequent communication by a ferry. Early one morning in spring two hares were observed to come down from the hills of the mainland towards the sea-side ; one of which from time to time left its companion, and proceeding to the very edge of the water, stopped there a minute or two, and then returned to its mate. The tide was rising, and after waiting some time, one of them, exactly at high water, took to the sea, and swam rapidly over, in a straight line, to the oppo- site projecting point of land. The observer on this occasion, who was near the spot, but remained unperceived by the hares, had no doubt they were of different sexes, and that it was the male (like another Leander) which swam across the water, as he had probably done many times before. It was remarkable that the hares had remained on the shore nearly half an hour ; one of them occasionally examining, as it would seem, the state of the current, and ultimately taking to the sea at that precise period of the tide called slackwater, when the passage across could be effected without being carried by the force of the stream

891

€ither above or below the desired point of landing. The other hare then cantered back to the hills, (Loudoun’s ‘ Magazine of Natural History,’ vol. v., p. 99.) : When followed by dogs, it will not run through a gate, though this is obviously the most ready passage ; nor in crossing a hedge will it prefer a smooth and even part, but the roughest, where thorns and briars abound ; and when it mounts an emi- nence it proceeds obliquely, and not straightforward. And whether we suppose these actions to proceed from a desire to avoid those places where traps may probably have been laid, or from knowing that his pursuers will exactly follow his footsteps, and he has resolved to lead them through as many obstacles as possible, in either case an estimation of causes and consequences is to be discovered.

892

It is a remarkable thing that both hares and rabbits should allow themselves to be overtaken in the open field by weasels. I have myself witnessed the process, and am at a loss to account for it. The hare or rabbit seems per- fectly aware of the dangerous character of the weasel, and yet does not put forth its powers of escape. It merely toddles along with the weasel toddling behind, until tamely allowing itself to be overtaken. This ano- malous case may perhaps be akin to the alleged phenomena of the fascination of birds and small rodents by snakes ; but in any case there seems to have been here a remark- able failure of natural selection in doing duty to the instincts of these swift-footed animals.

893

We must not close this account of the intelligence of the hare genus without alluding to the classical case of Cowper’s hares. The following abstract is taken from Tegg’s edition of ‘The Life and Works of William Cowper,’ p. 633 :— Puss was ill three days, during which time I nursed him, kept him apart from his fellows, . . . and by constant care, &c., restored him to perfect health. No creature could be more grateful than my patient after his recovery, a sentiment which he most significantly expressed by licking my hand, first the back of it, then the palm, then every finger separately, then between all the fingers, as if anxious to leave no part of it un-

894

saluted ; a ceremony which he never performed but once again — upon a similar occasion. Finding him extremely tractable, I made it my custom to carry him always after breakfast into the garden. ... I had not long habituated him to this taste of liberty before he began to be impatient for the return of the time when he might enjoy it. He would invite me to the garden by drumming upon my knee, and by a look of such expression as it was not possible to misinterpret. If this rhetoric did not immediately succeed, he would take the skirt of my coat between his teeth and pull it with all his force. He seemed to be happier in human society than when shut up with his natural companions.

895

Rats are well known to be highly intelligent animals. Unlike the hare or rabbit, their shyness seems to proceed from a wise caution rather than from timidity ; for, when circumstances require, their boldness and courage in combat is surprising. Moreover, they never seem to lose their presence of mind ; for, however great their danger, they seem always ready to take advantage of any fayour- ing circumstances that may arise. Thus, when matched with so formidable an opponent as a ferret in a closed room, they have been known to display wonderful cunning in taking advantage of the light—keeping close under the window so as to throw the glare into the eyes of the enemy,

896

darting forwards time after time to deliver a bite, and then as often retiring to their vantage-ground.! But the emo- tions of rats do not appear to be of an entirely selfish cha- racter. There are so many accounts in the anecdote books of blind rats being led about by their seeing companions, that it is difficult to discredit an observation so frequently confirmed.? Moreover, rats have been frequently known to assist one another in defending themselves from dan- gerous enemies. Several observations of this kind are recorded by the trustworthy writer Mr. Rodwell, in his somewhat elaborate work upon this animal.

897

1 3ee Watson’s Reasoning Power in Animals, and Quarterly Review, c. i, p. 135. Again, as showing affection for human beings, I may quote the following :—‘ The mouse which had been tamed by Baron Trench in his prison having been taken from him, watched at the door and crept in when it was opened; being removed again, it refused all food, and died in three days.’! With regard to general intelligence, every one knows the extraordinary wariness of rats in relation to traps, which is only equalled in the animal kingdom by that of the fox and the wolverine. It has frequently been regarded as a wonderful display of intelligence on the part of rats that while gnawing through the woodwork of a ship, they always stop before they completely perforate the side; but, as Mr. Jesse suggests, this is probably due to their distaste of the salt water. No such disparaging explanation, however, is possible in some other instances of the display of rat-intelligence. Thus, the manner in which they transport eggs to their burrows has been too frequently observed to admit of doubt. Rodwell gives a case in which a number of eggs were carried from the top of a house to the bottom by two rats devoting themselves to each egg, and alternately passing it down to each other at every step of the staircase. Dr. Carpenter also received from an eye-witness a similar account of another instance.® According to the article in the Quarterly Review, already mentioned, rats will not only convey eggs from the top of the house to the bottom, but from bottom to top. ‘ The male rat places himself on his fore-paws, with his head downwards, and raising up his hind legs and catching the egg between them, pushes it up to the female, who. stands on the step above, and secures it with her fore-paws till he jumps up to her; and this process is repeated from step to step till the top is reached.’

898

‘The captain of a merchantman,’ says Mr. Jesse, ‘trading to the port of Boston, in Lincolnshire, had con- stantly missed eggs from his sea stock. He suspected that he was robbed by his crew, but not being able to dis-. cover the thief, he was determined to watch his store- | room, Accordingly, having laid in a fresh stock of eggs, ' he seated himself at night in a situation that commanded — a view of his eggs. To his great astonishment he saw a ’

899

number of rats approach; they formed a line from his egg baskets to their hole, and handed the eggs from one to another in their fore-paws.’ ! Another device to which rats resort for the procuring — of food is mentioned in all the anecdote books, and it seemed so interesting that I tried some direct, experiments — upon the subject. I shall first state the alleged facts in — As to oil, rats have been known to get oil out of a narrow- necked bottle in the following way :—One of them would place himself, on some convenient support, by the side of the bottle, and then, dipping his tail into the oil, would give it to another to lick. In this act there is something more than what we call instinct ; there is reason and understanding.?

Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.