Animal Intelligence
A box containing some bottles of Florence oil was placed in a store-room which was seldom opened; the box had no lid to it. On going to the room one day for one of the bottles, the owner found that the pieces of bladder and cotton at the mouth of each bottle had disappeared, and that much of the contents of the bottles had been consumed. ‘The circumstance havi excited suspicion, a few bottles were refilled with oil, and the mouths of them secured as before. Next morning the coverings of the bottles had been removed, and some of the oil was gone. However, upon watching the room, which was done through _ &@ little window, some rats were seen to get into the box, and insert their tails into the necks of the bottles, and then with- drawing them, they licked off the oil which adhered to them.
Lastly, Rodwell gives another case similar in all essen- tial respects, save that the rat licked its own tail instead of presenting it to a companion. statements was a very simple one. I recorded it in ‘ Nature’ as follows :— It is, I believe, pretty generally supposed that rats and mice use their tails for feeding purposes when the food to be eaten is contained in vessels too narrow to admit the entire body of the animal. I am not aware, however, that the truth of this supposition has ever been actually tested by any trustworthy person, and so think the following simple experiments are worth publishing. Having obtained a couple of tall-shaped preserve bottles with rather short and narrow necks, I filled them to within three inches of the top with red currant jelly which had only half stiffened. I covered the bottles with bladder in the ordinary way, and then stood them in a place infested by rats. Next morning the bladder covering each of the bottles had a _ small hole gnawed through it, and the level of the jelly was _ reduced in both bottles to the same extent. Now, as this extent corresponded to about the length of a rat’s tail if inserted at the hole in the bladder, and as this hole was not much more than just large enough to admit the root of this organ, I do not _ see that any further evidence is required to prove the manner
in which the rats obtained the jelly, viz., by repeatedly intro- _ ducing their tails into the viscid matter, and as repeatedly licking them clean. However, to put the question beyond doubt, I refilled the bottles to the extent of half an inch above the jelly level left by the rats, and having placed a circle of moist paper upon each of the jelly surfaces, covered the bottles with bladder as before. I now left the bottles in a place where there were no rats or mice, until a good crop of mould had grown upon one of the moistened pieces of paper. The bottle containing this crop of mould I then transferred to the place where the rats were numerous. Next morning the bladder had again been eaten through at one edge, and upon the mould there were numerous and distinct tracings of the rats’ tails, resem- bling marks made with the top of a pen-holder. These tracings were evidently caused by the animals sweeping their tails about in a fruitless endeavour to find a hole in the circle of paper which covered the jelly.
With regard to mice, the Rev. W. North, rector of Ashdown, in Essex, placed a pot of honey in a closet, in which a quantity of plaster rubbish had been left by builders. The mice piled up the plaster in the form of a heap against the sides of the pot, in order to constitute an inclined plane whereby to reach the rim. A quantity of © the rubbish had also been thrown into the pot, with the — effect of raising the level of the honey that remained to : near the rim ofthe pot ; but, of course, the latter fact may — have been due to accident, and not to design.! This isa case in which mal-observation does not seem to. have been — likely. | Powelsen, a writer on Iceland, has related an account — of the intelligence displayed by the mice of that country, — which has given rise toa difference of competent opinion, — and which perhaps can hardly yet be said to have been ~ definitely settled. -What Powelsen said is that the mice — collect in parties of from six to ten, select a flat piece of © dried cow-dung, pile berries or other food upon it, then ~ with united strength drag it to the edge of any stream they wish to cross, launch it, embark, and range them- — selves round the central heap of provisions with their heads joined over it, and their tails hanging in the water, perhaps serving as rudders. Pennant afterwards gave credit to this account, observing that in a country where berries were scarce, the mice were compelled to cross streams for distant forages. Dr. Hooker, however, in his ‘Tour in Iceland,’ concludes that the account is a pure — fabrication. Dr. Henderson, therefore, determined on trying to arrive at the truth of the matter, with the fol- lowing result :—‘I made a point of inquiring of different — individuals as to the reality of the account, and am happy — in being able to say that it is now established as an impor- tant fact in natural history by the testimony of two eye- witnesses of unquestionable veracity, the clergyman of Briamslaek, and Madame Benedictson of Stickesholm, both — of whom assured me that they had seen the expedition — performed repeatedly.
Madame Benedictson, in parti- cular, recollected having spent a whole afternoon, in her younger days, at the margin of a small lake on which ~ these skilful navigators had embarked, and amusing herself and her companions by driving them away from the sides of the lake as they approached them. I was also informed that they make use of dried mushrooms as sacks, in which they convey their provisions to the river, and thence to their homes.’! Before leaving the mice and rats I may say a few words upon certain mouse- and rat-like animals which scarcely require a separate section for their consideration. Of the harvesting mouse Gilbert White says :—
One of their nests I procured this autumn, most artificially plaited and composed of blades of wheat, perfectly round, and about the size of a cricket-ball, with the aperture so ingeniously closed that there was no discovering to what part it belonged. It was so compact and well filled that it would roll across the table without being discomposed, though it contained eight little mice that were naked and blind. As the nest was per- fectly full, how could the dam come at her litter respectively, so as to administer a teat to each? Perhaps she opens different places for that purpose, adjusting them again when the business is over ; but she could not possibly be contained herself in the ball with the young ones, which, moreover, would be daily in- creasing in size. This wonderful procreant cradle, an elegant instance of the efforts of instinct, was found in a wheat-field, suspended on the head of a thistle.
Pallas has described the provident habits of the so- called ‘ rat-hare ’ (Lagomys), which lays up a store of grass, or rather hay, for winter consumption. These animals, which occur in the Altai Mountains, live in holes or cre- vices of rock. About the middle of the month of August they collect grass, and spread it out to dry into hay. In September they form heaps or stacks of the hay, which may be as much as six feet high, and eight feet in diame- ter. It is stored in their chosen hole or crevice, protected from the rain.
The following is quoted from Thompson’s ‘ Passions of Animals,’ pp. 235-6 :-— The life of the harvester rat is divided between eating and fighting. It seems to have no other passion than that of rage, which induces it to attack every animal that comes in its way, without in the least attending to the superior strength of its enemy. Ignorant of the art of saving itself by flight, rather than yield, it will allow itself to be beaten to pieces with a stick. — If it seizes a man’s hand, it must be killed before it will quit its — hold. The magnitude of the horse terrifies it as little as the — address of the dog, which last is fond of hunting it. When a — harvester perceives a dog at a distance, it begins by emptying © its cheek-pouches, if they happen to be filled with grain; itthen — blows them up so prodigiously, that the size of the head and — neck greatly exceeds that of the rest of the body. It rearsitself | upon its hind legs, and thus darts upon the enemy. If itcatches — hold, it never quits it but with the loss of its life; but the dog generally seizes it behind, and strangles it. This ferocious dis- position prevents it from being at peace with any animal what- — ever. It even makes war against its own species. When two harvesters meet, they never fail to attack each other, and the stronger always devours the weaker. A combat between a male and a female commonly lasts longer than between two males. They begin by pursuing and biting each other, then each of them retires aside, as if to take breath. After a short interval they renew the combat, and continue to fight till one of them falls. The vanquished uniformly serves as a repast to the conqueror.
If we contrast the fearless disposition of the harvester with the timidity of the hare or rabbit, we observe that in respect of emotions, no less than in that of intelligence, the order Rodentia comprises the utmost extremes. The so-called ‘ prairie-dog’ is a kind of small rodent, which makes burrows in the ground, and a slight eleva- tion above it. The animals being social in their habits, their warrens are called ‘dog-towns.’ Prof. Jillson, Ph.D., kept a pair in confinement (see ‘American Naturalist,” vol. v., pp. 24-29), and found them to be intelligent and highly affectionate animals. These burrows he found to contain a ‘ granary,’ or chambers set apart for the reception of stored food. With regard to the association said to exist between this animal and the owl and fattle-snake, Prof. Jillson says, ‘I have seen many dog-towns, with owls and dogs standing on contiguous, and in some cases on the same mound, but never saw a snake in the vicinity.” The popular notion that the owl acts the part of sentry to the dog requires, to say the least, confirmation.
Most remarkable among rodents for instinct and in- telligence unquestionably stands the beaver. Indeed, there is no animal—not even excepting the ants and bees —where instinct has risen to a higher level of far-reaching adaptation to certain constant conditions of environment,. or where faculties, undoubtedly instinctive, are more puzzlingly wrought up with faculties no less undoubtedly intelligent. So much is this the case that, as we shall presently see, it is really impossible by the closest study of the pyschology of this animal to distinguish the web of instinct from the woof of intelligence ; the two principles _ seem here to have been so intimately woven together, that in the result, as expressed by certain particular actions, it cannot be determined how much we are to attribute to mechanical impulse, and how much to reasoned purpose. | Fortunately, the doubt that for many years shrouded
the facts has been dispelled by the conscientious and _ laborious observations of the late Mr. Lewis H. Morgan,! whose work throughout displays the judicious accuracy of a scientific mind. As this is much the most trustworthy, as well as the most exhaustive essay upon the subject, I _ shall mainly rely upon it for my statement of facts, and _ while presenting these I shall endeavour to point out the psychological explanation, or difficulty of explanation, to which they are severally open.
The beaver is a social animal, the male living with his _ single female and progeny in a separate burrow or ‘ lodge.’ Several of these lodges, however, are usually built close together, so as to form a beaver colony. The young quit the lodge of their parents when they enter upon the _ summer of their third year, seek mates, and establish new lodges for themselves. As each litter numbers three or four, and breeding is annual, it follows that a beaver lodge _ never or rarely contains more than twelve individuals, while the number usually ranges from four to eight. _ Every season, and particularly when a district. becomes
overstocked, some of the beavers migrate. The Indians — say that in their local migrations the old beavers go up © stream, and the young down; assigning as a reason that in the struggle for existence greater advantages are — afforded near the source than lower down a stream, and — therefore that the old beavers appropriate the former. — But although lodges may thus be vacated by the old — beavers, they are not left tenantless; their lease is, as it — were, transferred to another beaver couple. This process — of transference of ownership goes on from generation to generation, so that the same lodges are continuously occupied for centuries. |
These lodges, which are always constructed in or near — water, are of three kinds—the island, bank, and lake lodge. The first are formed on small islands which may ~ happen to occur in the ponds made by the beaver-dams. The floor of the lodge is a few inches above the level of the water, and into it there open two, or sometimes more entrances :— These are made with great skill, and in the most artistic — manner. One is straight, or as nearly so as possible, with its floor, which is of course under water, an inclined plane, rising gradually from the bottom of the pond into the chamber; while the other is abrupt in its descent, and often sinuous: in its course. The first we shall call the ‘wood entrance,’ from its evident design to facilitate the admission into the chamber of their wood cuttings, upon which they subsist during the season of winter. These cuttings, as will elsewhere be shown, are of such size and length that such an entrance is absolutely neces- sary for their free admission into the lodge. The other, which we shall call the ‘beaver entrance,’ is the ordinary run-way for their exit and return. It is usually abrupt, and often wind- ing. In the lodge under consideration, the wood entrance de- scended from the outer run of the chamber entrance about ten feet to the bottom of the pond in a straight line, and upon an inclined plane; while the other, emerging from the line of the chamber at the side, descended quite abruptly to the bottom of the moat or trench, through which the beavers must pass, in open water, out into the pond. Both entrances were rudely arched, with a roof of interlaced sticks filled in with mud in- — termixed with vegetable fibre, and were extended to the bottom
of the pond or trench, with the exception of the opening at their ends, At the places where they were constructed through the floor they were finished with neatness and precision; the upper parts and sides forming an arch more or less regular, while the bottom and floor edges were formed with firm and compacted earth, in which small sticks were embedded. It is difficult to realise the artistic appearance of some of these entrances without actual inspection.
Upon the floor of the lodge there is constructed a house of sticks, brushwood, and mud, in the form of a circular or oval chamber, the size of which varies with the age of the lodge; for by a continuous process of repair (which consists in removing the decayed sticks, &c., from the interior and working them up with new material upon the exterior) the whole lodge progressively increases in size: eventually in this way the interior chamber may attain a diameter of seven or eight feet.
feet back from its edge, and entered by an underground passage from the bed of the stream, excavated through the natural earth up into the chamber. The other is situated upon the edge of the bank, a portion of it projecting over and resting upon the bed of the channel, so as to have the floor of the chamber rest upon the bank as upon solid ground, while the external wall on the pond side projects beyond it, and is built up from the bottom of the pond.
Lastly, the ‘lake lodges’ are constructed on the shores of lakes, which, being usually shelving and hard, require some further variation in the structure of the lodges. These, therefore, are of interest ‘as illustrations of the capacity of the beavers to vary the mode of construction of their lodges in accordance with the changes of situa- tion.’ One-half or two-thirds of the lodge is in this case ‘built out upon the lake for the obvious purpose of covering the entrance, as well as for its extension into deep water.’
All these forms of lodge are, historically regarded, modified burrows. The beaver isa burrowing animal. Indulging this propensity,, — he excavates chambers underground, and constructs artificial - lodges upon its surface, both of which are indispensable to his. — security and happiness. The lodge is but a burrow above ~ ground, covered with an artificial roof, and possesses some — advantages over the latter as a place for rearing young, There are reasons for believing that the burrow is the normal — residence of the beavers, and that the lodge grew out of it,in — the progress of their experience, by a process of natural sugges- _
inhabit it have burrows in the banks surrounding the pond. — They never risk their personal safety upon their lodge alone, — which, being conspicuous to their enemies, is liable to attack. . . . As the entrances are always below the surface level of the — pond, there are no external indications to mark the site of the — burrow, except occasionally a small pile of beaver-cuttings a foot or more high. These, the trappers affirm, are purposely left there by the beavers to keep the snow loose over the ends of their burrows during winter for the admission of air. ia af
Mr. Morgan adds the very probable suggestion that this habit of piling up cuttings for purposes of ventilatiom may have constituted the origin of lodge-building. It is but a step from such a surface-pile of sticks to a lodge, with its chamber above ground, and the previous burrow as its: entrance from the pond. A burrow accidentally broken through at its upper end, and repaired with a covering of sticks and earth, would lead to a lodge above ground, and thus inaugurate a beaver lodge out of a broken burrow.
It is evidence of an important local variation of in- stinct, that in the Cascade Mountains the beavers live chiefly in burrows in the banks of streams, and rarely construct either lodges or dams. Dr. Newbury, in his report on the zoology of Oregon and California, says: ‘ We found the beavers in numbers, of which, when applied to beavers, I had no conception,’ and yet ‘ we never saw their houses and seldom a dam.’ Whether this local variation be due to a relapse from dam- and lodge-building instincts to the primitive burrowing instinct, or to a failure in the
full development of the newer instinct, is immaterial. Probably, I think, looking to the high antiquity of the building instinct, and also to its being occasionally mani- fested by the Californian beavers, their case is to be re- garded as one of relapsing instinct. In selecting the site of their lodges beavers display much sagacity and forethought. The severity of the climate in these high northern latitudes lays upon them the necessity of so locating their lodges as to be assured of water deep enough in their entrances, and also so protected in other respects, as not to freeze to the bottom ;! otherwise they would perish with hunger, locked up in ice- bound habitations. To guard against this danger, the dam, also, must be sufficiently stable through the winter to maintain the water at a constant level; and this level, again, must be so adjusted with reference to the floor of the lodge as to enable them, at all times, to takein their cuttings from without as they are needed for food. When they leave their normal mode of life in the banks of the rivers, and undertake to live in dependence upon artificial ponds of their own formation, they are compelled to prevent the consequences of their acts at the peril of their lives.
On the upper Missouri, where the banks of the river are for miles together vertical, and rising from three to eight feet above its surface, the beavers resort to the de- vice of making what are called ‘ beaver slides.’ These are narrow inclined planes cut into the banks at intervals, the angle of inclination being 45° to 60°, so as to form a gradual descent from a point a few feet back from the edge of the bank to the level of the river. As Mr. Morgan observes, ‘they furnish another conspicuous illustration of the fact that beavers possess a free intelligence, by means of which they are enabled to adapt themselves to the circumstances in which they are placed.’
Coming now to the habits of these animals in connec- tion with the procuring and storing of food, it is first to be observed that ‘the thick bark upon the trunks of large trees, and even upon those of medium size, is unsuitable 1 To obviate this possibility, they often select as their site a place where a spring happens to rise in the bottom of the lake or pond. _ for food; but the smaller limbs, the bark of which is — tender and nutritious, afford the aliment which they pre- | fer.’ To obtain this food, the animals, as is well known, — fell the trees by gnawing a ring round their base. Two or three nights’ successive work by a pair of beavers is enough to bring down a half-grown tree, ‘each family — being left to the undisturbed enjoyment of the fruits of — their own toil and industry.’ ‘When the tree begins to © crackle they desist from cutting, which they afterwards continue with caution until it begins to fall, when they plunge into the pond usually, and wait concealed for a time, as if fearful that the cracking noise of the tree-fall might attract some enemy to the place.’ It is of much interest that the beavers when thus felling trees know how to regulate the direction of the fall; by gnawing chiefly on the side of the trunk remote from the water, they make the tree fall towards the water, with the obvious purpose of saving as much as possible the labour of subsequent transport. For as soon as a tree is down, the next work is to cut off the branches, or such as are from two to six inches in diameter ; and then, when they have been cleared of their twigs, to divide them into lengths sufficient to ad- mit of the beavers transporting them to their lodges. The — cutting into lengths is effected by making a number of semi-sections through the branch at more or less equal distances as it lies upon the ground, and then turning the branch half round and continuing the sections from the opposite side.
‘To cut it (the branch) entirely through from the upper side would require an incision of such width .as to involve a loss of labour.’ The thicker the branch, the closer together are the sections made, and con- sequently the shorter are the resulting portions—the reason, of course, being that the strength of the animal would not be sufficient to transport a thick piece of timber of the same length as a thin piece which it is only just able to manage. —
In moving cuttings of this description they are quite in- genious. They shove and roll them with their hips, using also their legs and tails as levers, moving sideways in the act. In this way they move the larger pieces from the more or less elevated ground on which the deciduous trees are found, over the uneven but generally descending surface to the pond... . _ After one of these cuttings has been transported to the water, a beaver, placing one end of it under his throat, pushes it before him to the place where it is to be sunk.
The sinking is no doubt partly effected by mere soaking ; but there is also some evidence to show that the beavers have a method of anchoring down their supplies. Thus they have been observed towing pieces of brush to their lodges, and then, while holding the large end in their mouths, ‘ going down with it to the bottom, apparently to fix it in the mud bottom of the pond.’ A brush-heap being thus formed, the cuttings from the felled trees are stuck through the brushwork, without which ‘ protection they would be liable to be floated off by the strong currents, and thus be lost to the beavers at the time when their
Lastly, as a method whereby the beavers can save themselves the trouble of cutting, transporting, and anchoring all at the same time, they are prone, when cir- cumstances permit, to fell a tree growing near enough to their pond to admit of its branches being submerged in the water. The animals then well know that the branches and young shoots will remain preserved throughout the winter without any further trouble from them. But of course the supply of trees thus growing conveniently near a beaver-pond is too limited to last long.
We have next to consider the most wonderful, and I think the most psychologically puzzling structures that are presented as the works of any animal; I mean, of course, the dams and canals. The object of the dam is that of forming an artificial pond, the use of which is to afford refuge to the animals as well as water connection with their lodges. Therefore the level of the pond must in all cases be higher than that of the lodge- and burrow-entrances, and it is usually maintained two or three feet above them.
Text read by machine from a library scan; expect stray characters. The scan is linked from the book’s page.