Physiology and the whole organism  ·  Article

Ether and chloroform vapour: loss and recovery of sensibility in sensitive plants

Ether and chloroform vapour were used to put plant tissue out of action and then to see whether it came back. Darwin reported leaves made insensible to touch that later regained sensibility.12 Bose recorded loss and return of plant pulsation under chloroform.4 Verworn reported Engelmann's experiments showing a similar reversible stoppage in frog ciliated cells.3 Loss of response could be reversible, but recovery followed only short or mild exposure. Longer, stronger or excess doses caused injury, permanent arrest or death.

Earliest held
1875, Darwin, C.
Most discussed in
Insectivorous Plants, 1875
In the library
9 passages in 6 works
Rewritten
2026-11-12
01

Darwin's leaves

In Insectivorous Plants (1875), Darwin exposed leaves to ether vapour in closed vessels and watched the sensitive filaments. A leaf kept for 3 minutes in a large bottle with ten drops became insensible, and it recovered its sensibility after 52 minutes.1 Another leaf, exposed for 20 minutes to 15 minims of ether, partly closed its lobes and lost all sensibility in its filaments. It recovered after 24 hours but stayed rather torpid.2 Darwin also noted that two leaves given a longer and stronger exposure were greatly injured.1 The longer, stronger exposure injured leaves, while the shorter ones recovered.

02

Animal cells compared

Verworn, in General Physiology (1899), discussed narcotic effects on contraction and ciliary movement in animal cells. He reported that narcotics depress contraction movements, usually after a short stage of acceleration. Engelmann exposed the ciliated cells of a frog's pharynx to ether or chloroform vapour in a gas-chamber. The cilia first quickened and then stopped.3 If the action was not too long, the motion returned once fresh air was admitted.3 Verworn cited the Hertwigs for similar behaviour in sperm flagella brought to a standstill by these vapours.

03

Bose's records

Bose used recording instruments to follow the vapours in time. For the pulsating leaflets of Desmodium, chloroform gave an immediate excitatory effect, then depression and arrest. Pulsations revived about half an hour after the anaesthetic was blown off.4 In the ascent of sap work (1923), ether and chloroform acted on transpiration. Ether first raised the rate and then depressed it under continued action.5 Chloroform in the soil lowered exudation from a cut stock. The plant recovered after two hours as the vapour dissipated.6

04

Dose, accommodation and death

Bose argued that the effect depends on dose. In The Motor Mechanism of Plants (1928), he held that an agent toxic in large doses stimulates in minute ones. Chloroform is absorbed slowly, so the first effect is that of a small dose.7 When the dose was kept up in a closed chamber, depression ended in abolition of response and death.8 In Researches on Irritability of Plants (1913), Bose called chloroform far more toxic than ether, since a slight excess caused permanent arrest of pulsation.4 In The Physiology of the Ascent of Sap (1923), a second application of chloroform needed a larger dose, which he called accommodation, or acquired immunity.6

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. A leaf exposed in a large bottle for only 3 m. to ten drops was rendered insensible. After 52 m. it recovered its sensibilityDarwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 663
  2. the sensitive filaments were now quite insensible. After 24 hrs. this leaf recovered its sensibility, but was still rather torpid.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 663
  3. If the duration of the action was not too long, the motion appeared again after the introduction of fresh air.Verworn, M., 1899 · General Physiology: An Outline of the Science of Life · open at passage 958
  4. Effect of vapour of chloroform. Immediate excitatory effect followed by depression and arrest. On blowing off the anesthetic, pulsations were revived after half an hourBose, J. C., 1913 · Researches on Irritability of Plants · open at passage 714
  5. The immediate effect was an enhancement of transpiration as seen in the upset of the balance upwards, followed by depression under the continued action of the anaestheticBose, J. C., 1923 · The Physiology of the Ascent of Sap · open at passage 257
  6. the plant exhibited a recovery after two hours. I then applied chloroform for a second time, when the phenomenon of accommodation, or acquired immunity, was shownBose, J. C., 1923 · The Physiology of the Ascent of Sap · open at passage 311
  7. An agent which in large doses proves to be toxic is found to be stimulating when given in minute quantities.Bose, J. C., 1928 · The Motor Mechanism of Plants · open at passage 192
  8. It will be seen how rapidly chloroform produced a depression culminating in abolition of response and deathBose, J. C., 1928 · The Motor Mechanism of Plants · open at passage 385
Linked ideas
Treats other chemical agents acting on plant excitability, the wider class to which anaesthetic vapours belong.
Drugs also depress or stimulate plant protoplasm, the same kind of dose-dependent reversible effect.
Bose's small-dose stimulation and large-dose depression bear on how response grades with intensity.
Darwin tested loss of sensibility to touch of the filaments, the same threshold response.
Bose followed the abolition and return of electric response under chloroform.
Recovery after the vapour is removed, and accommodation on repeat dosing, concern restoration of a working state.
Vapours that suppress sensibility in leaves offer a parallel to cyanide vapour leaving a leaf insensitive for nearly two days.
Where it is discussedPassages matching sulphuric ether vapour, chloroform vapour, leaf rendered insensible, recovered its sensibility
1875Insectivorous Plants · Darwin, C.2
1928The Motor Mechanism of Plants · Bose, J. C.2
1923The Physiology of the Ascent of Sap · Bose, J. C.2
1899General Physiology: An Outline of the Science of Life · Verworn, M.1
1927Plant Autographs and Their Revelations · Bose, J. C.1
1913Researches on Irritability of Plants · Bose, J. C.1