Electrical response of living tissue
Electrical response is the electrical change a living tissue shows when it is excited. Bose argued that it is a molecular event that does not depend on visible movement2. He also held that it marks the living state and vanishes at death4. Keith Lucas, as reported by Bayliss, found no reason to doubt that it is identical with the excitatory disturbance. Lucas added that stricter proof is desirable before accepting the electrical change as the basis of excitation5.
- Earliest held
- 1888, Binet, A.
- Most discussed in
- Comparative Electro-Physiology: A…, 1907
- In the library
- 1,869 passages in 49 works
- Rewritten
- 2026-11-10
Nerve as the first case
Bose (1902) began with a contrast. A nerve, unlike muscle, shows no visible change when excited. Its excitatory state was shown by the contraction of an attached piece of muscle, which served as an indicator1. In 1889 Beck in Kraków began work as an assistant to Cybulski. Inspired by Du Bois-Reymond's book on animal electricity, he turned to the electrical response of a nerve evoked by sensory stimulation7. Coenen and Zayachkivska report that this work set off a dispute over priority for discovering electrical brain activity.
Bose and the plant response
Bose (1906) held that the shock of a stimulus causes a molecular change in plant tissue. Movement is one expression of it. Electrical response is another, and for that the molecular change alone is the only condition2. In 1907 he reported that electrical responses of plant tissue match animal tissue in sign3. In 1913 he reported that dead plants give none, and that heating to 60° C. abolishes the response4. Trewavas (2025) quotes Bose's 1926 preface, which claims that every plant is excitable and answers a stimulus with galvanometric negativity9.
Electrical versus mechanical
Bose (1926) tested whether the electrical signal was merely an artefact of movement. He held a Mimosa leaf in a fixed position and found the electric response unchanged. He concluded that the mechanical and electrical responses are independent expressions of a common excitatory reaction6. Bayliss (1915) noted that some observers doubted the electrical change and the excitatory disturbance were connected. Keith Lucas, as Bayliss reports, found their experiments open to objection and saw no reason to doubt the two are identical. He also said that stricter proof is desirable before treating the electrical change as the basis of excitation5. Bayliss added that in muscle the electrical response can occur without contraction.
Later questions
Stratford and colleagues (2019) frame bacterial electrical signalling in terms of input and output relations. They asked whether the response of bacterial cells to an electrical stimulus depends on their proliferative capacity. They state that this remains unclear8. If responses do differ with proliferative capacity, an identical signal could produce different outputs.
UNLIKE muscle, a length of nerve, when mechanically or electrically excited, does not undergo any visible change.
Bose, J. C., 1902 · Response in the Living and Non-Living · open at passage 22for the exhibition of electrical response, the molecular change itself, which is concomitant to excitation, is the only condition.
Bose, J. C., 1906 · Plant Response as a Means of Physiological Investigation · open at passage 110And these electrical responses of plant tissues, it was further noted, are identical in sign with the corresponding responses given by animal tissues.
Bose, J. C., 1907 · Comparative Electro-Physiology: A Physico-Physiological Study · open at passage 168Dead plants do not exhibit this characteristic electric-response. When a plant is subjected for a time to a temperature of 60° C. its electric response disappears, such abolition being indicative of the death of the plant.
Bose, J. C., 1913 · Researches on Irritability of Plants · open at passage 248Keith Lucas (1912, pp. 502-508) shows that none of their experimental results are free from objection and that there is no reason for doubting the identity of the two.
Bayliss, W. M., 1915 · Principles of General Physiology · open at passage 1718The mechanical and electric responses are therefore independent manifestations of a common excitatory reaction.
Bose, J. C., 1926 · The Nervous Mechanism of Plants · open at passage 248Beck’s interest was directed towards the electrophysiology of the nervous system, in particular, the electrical response of a nerve evoked by sensory stimulation.
Coenen A, Zayachkivska O, 2013 · Adolf Beck: A pioneer in electroencephalography in between Richard Caton and… · open at passage 1However, whether cellular responses to an electrical stimulus differ depending on their proliferative capacity remains unclear.
Stratford JP, Edwards CLA, Ghanshyam MJ, Malyshev D, Delise…, 2019 · Electrically induced bacterial membrane-potential dynamics correspond to… · open at passage 4I was able to show that every plant is excitable and responds to a stimulus by electric responses of galvanometric negativity the response being abolished at the death of a plant
Trewavas A, 2025 · Plant intelligence dux: a comprehensive rebuttal of Kingsland and Taiz · open at passage 47
| 1907 | Comparative Electro-Physiology: A Physico-Physiological Study · Bose, J. C. | 645 |
| 1906 | Plant Response as a Means of Physiological Investigation · Bose, J. C. | 359 |
| 1913 | Researches on Irritability of Plants · Bose, J. C. | 171 |
| 1926 | The Nervous Mechanism of Plants · Bose, J. C. | 126 |
| 1915 | Principles of General Physiology · Bayliss, W. M. | 98 |
| 1928 | The Motor Mechanism of Plants · Bose, J. C. | 84 |
| 1927 | Conditioned Reflexes: An Investigation of the Physiological Activity of the… · Pavlov, I. P. | 68 |
| 1902 | Response in the Living and Non-Living · Bose, J. C. | 62 |
| 1918 | Life Movements in Plants · Bose, J. C. | 55 |
| 1924 | Physiological Foundations of Behavior · Child, C. M. | 40 |