Minds of small things  ·  Article

Individuality of cell responses within a tissue (aggregation of protoplasm)

Aggregation of protoplasm is a visible change in a living cell. The lining layer, the primordial utricle, shrinks and the contents gather into granules or spheres. Darwin watched it in glands and hairs treated with carbonate of ammonia.14 The timing and degree differed between cells and between whole organs.23 Child (1915) asked when an aggregation of protoplasm counts as an individual.8

Earliest held
1875, Darwin, C.
Most discussed in
Insectivorous Plants, 1875
In the library
125 passages in 6 works
Rewritten
2026-11-14
01

Darwin's observations

In Insectivorous Plants (1875), Darwin irrigated a bisected bladder with carbonate of ammonia. After 8 hours 30 minutes the quadrifids held many granules and the primordial utricle was somewhat shrunk.1 On two summits bearing colourless glands, the primordial utricles of most glands were somewhat contracted within 5 minutes. They were thickened in specks and had turned pale brown.2 In The Power of Movement in Plants (1880), he reported that the absorbing hairs of a clover calyx showed aggregated contents at once in a weak solution. Slow movements of the contents followed.4

02

Variation between preparations

Darwin's bladders did not respond alike. Two bladders left 21 hours in a gum solution without effect were then given ammonia. Their quadrifids changed in nearly the same way, one after 9 hours and the other after 24.3 Darwin also tested whole leaves. Ammonia blackened the glands of the leaf and induced inflection of many tentacles. The tentacles later re-expanded and the glands recovered their colour.5 These reports record the pace of each preparation. They do not explain why paces differed.

03

The utricle as a physical layer

Verworn (1899) gave a scheme of cell turgor, after de Vries. The utricle lies against the cell wall when the cell is turgid. It pulls away from the wall under a salt solution as turgor falls.6 He listed ways turgor can change. One is a change in the tension of the utricle through active changes in its protoplasm.6 Timiriazeff (1912) described the utricle as the protoplasm driven back against the wall by a large vacuole, so that it takes the form of a bladder.7 Neither author discusses ammonia here.

04

Individuality and aggregates

Child (1915) judged the degree of individuality by how definite and constant the order of an organism's behaviour is. He noted that in the simplest cases it can be hard to tell an individual from a mere aggregation of protoplasmic substance.8 Meyer, Ansorge and Nakagaki (2017) describe the slime mould plasmodium as one cell that is an aggregate of protoplasm with a network of tubes.9 Neither Child nor Meyer and colleagues connect these views to Darwin's observations.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. After 8 hrs. 30 m. the quadrifids contained a good many granules, and the primordial utricle was somewhat shrunkDarwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 878
  2. Two bisected bladders, which had been previously left for 21 hrs. in the solution of gum (one part to 218 of water) without being affectedDarwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 878
  3. in 5 m. the primordial utricles of most of the glands were somewhat contracted ; they were also thickened in specks or patches, and had assumed a pale brown tint.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 889
  4. carbonate of ammonia 7 gr. to 1 oz. of water) their proto- plasmic contents immediately became aggregated and afterwarda displayed the usual slow movementsDarwin, C., 1880 · The Power of Movement in Plants · open at passage 1010
  5. a drop of a solution of carbonate of ammonia (2 gr. to 1 oz. of water) was placed on the disc, and this blackened the glands and in- duced inflection of many of the tentacles.Darwin, C., 1880 · The Power of Movement in Plants · open at passage 474
  6. Finally, a change in turgor will take place when the tension of the primordial utricle increases or decreases because of active changes in its protoplasm.Verworn, M., 1899 · General Physiology: An Outline of the Science of Life · open at passage 599
  7. so that the protoplasm assumes the form of a bladder, called the primordial utricleTimiriazeff, C. A., 1912 · The Life of the Plant · open at passage 391
  8. it is sometimes difficult to determine whether a particular aggregation of protoplasmic substance is an individual in the biological sense or merely an aggregation.Child, C. M., 1915 · Individuality in Organisms · open at passage 15
  9. The plasmodium is an aggregate of protoplasm with a network of tubular elements.Meyer B, Ansorge C, Nakagaki T, 2017 · The role of noise in self-organized decision making by the true slime mold… · open at passage 8
Linked ideas
Covers the same aggregation response in plant cells, and is the closest companion to this entry.
Treats the ammonium salts that Darwin used to trigger the aggregation described here.
The bladders and quadrifids that Darwin irrigated with carbonate of ammonia belong to this trap.
Other chemical agents acting on plant protoplasm, set beside the ammonia results.
Takes up Child's question of what counts as one individual rather than an aggregation.
Asks at what level a unit counts as a self, which bears on cell versus tissue individuality.
B's cell-by-cell protoplasm aggregation under carbonate of ammonia is one instance of A's Darwin tests on excitation by chemical agents; Child's individuality passage is only loosely thematic.
Passages show carbonate of ammonia inflecting tentacles and aggregating protoplasm, later redissolving as tentacles re-expand; B's per-cell variation is a cellular-level aspect of A's response, but passages don't explicitly discuss individuality.
Darwin's passage says particles on Drosera glands visibly affect cell contents, promising evidence under 'aggregation of protoplasm'; B is that same aggregation phenomenon examined for per-cell variation. Passages don't state it explicitly.
Both describe responses to the same stimuli. Animal matter and carbonate of ammonia cause aggregated protoplasm in cells (B), and meat or ammonia also trigger slow leaf closing (A's stimulation context).
Both concern the primordial utricle's response to absorbed substances. Darwin says the apparent shrinking in aggregation is false and protoplasm keeps flowing, contrasting with irreversible gland damage. The passages don't discuss glands.
Where it is discussedPassages matching individuality of the life of each cell, aggregation of protoplasm, primordial utricle, carbonate of ammonia
1875Insectivorous Plants · Darwin, C.110
1899General Physiology: An Outline of the Science of Life · Verworn, M.8
1880The Power of Movement in Plants · Darwin, C.3
1912The Life of the Plant · Timiriazeff, C. A.2
2017The role of noise in self-organized decision making by the true slime mold… · Meyer B, Ansorge C, Nakagaki T1
1915Individuality in Organisms · Child, C. M.1