Morphogenesis and form  ·  Article

Membrane formation and hypertonic treatment in parthenogenesis

In Loeb's work, artificial parthenogenesis ran in two steps. A fatty acid such as butyric acid made the unfertilized egg raise a membrane, and the egg then began to develop but was left sickly6. A short later exposure to hypertonic sea water let it go on to a normal larva7. Loeb called the second step corrective.

Earliest held
1906, Loeb, J.
Most discussed in
The Mechanistic Conception of Life, 1912
In the library
97 passages in 7 works
Rewritten
2026-11-16
01

Membrane formation alone

Loeb reported in 1916 that membrane formation induced by butyric acid starts the processes underlying development, but the egg is sickly and perishes rapidly6. In 1912 he described a difference between acids. The lower fatty acids, from formic to capronic, caused cytolysis of the cortical layer only. From heptylic acid upward, membrane formation was followed after a short pause by cytolysis of the whole egg3. Eggs treated with saponin and washed free of it behaved as if a fatty acid had been used. They began to develop but went no further than the first nuclear division at room temperature4. In 1906 Loeb noted that eggs taken from benzol sea water soon after membrane formation did not all undergo cytolysis1.

02

The hypertonic step

Kostanecki had found that hypertonic sea water alone could make the unfertilized eggs of a mollusk, Mactra, undergo the first segmentations2. Loeb later found that this method gave swimming larvae in other mollusks. On the eggs of Lottia gigantea, he wrote that it seems the fatty acid treatment combined with hypertonic sea water gives better results than the osmotic treatment alone2. He also reported Bataillon's result that frog and Petromyzon eggs, losing water in a salt solution, segmented as far as the morula stage2. Loeb's eggs treated with saponin and then hypertonic sea water for half an hour developed to normal plutei, larvae with skeletons4. The membrane step could use different substances if the egg was not injured too much1.

03

Protocol and corrective view

Loeb gave a schedule in 1916. The eggs spent two to four minutes in butyric acid sea water, then ten or fifteen minutes later went into hypertonic sea water, where they stayed for a time that depended on species and temperature6. Bayliss described the method in 1915, citing Loeb. He said the time in the hypertonic solution can only be found by trial, with samples withdrawn every five minutes5. Loeb suggested in 1905 that membrane formation alone starts development but usually leaves the egg in a sickly condition. In his view, the hypertonic solution or lack of oxygen allows recuperation7. He judged the oxygen method less reliable7. In 1906 he also said that embryos might differ in vitality according to the membrane-forming substance, and that further experiments were needed1.

04

Permeability reading

Lillie in 1923 discussed eggs for which an after-treatment with hypertonic sea water is needed to complete activation. He argued that the initial effect of the activating agent must be to increase permeability. Alkali earth salts have the reverse effect, which would explain why they counteract activation8. In the same work he reported that during division the egg's plasma membrane undergoes a reversible change, with loss of coherence and increased permeability9.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. As long as the formation of a membrane is induced by a substance which does not injure the egg too much, the subsequent short exposure to hypertonic sea water may lead to the formation of an em- bryo.Loeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 451
  2. Kostanecki | found that by a treatment with hypertonic sea water, the unfertilized eggs of a Mollusk (Mactra} could be caused to undergo the first segmentationsLoeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 466
  3. If, however, the higher fatty acids of the same series from the heptylic acid on and upward are applied the membrane formation is always followed after a short pause by a cytolysis of the whole egg.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 255
  4. If, however, the eggs are treated for half an hour Tvdth hypertonic sea-water they can develop to normal plutei, i.e., larvae with skeletons.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 228
  5. The actual time they require to remain in this solution can only be found by trial, so that samples are withdrawn every five minutes, after they have remained for fifteen minutes.Bayliss, W. M., 1915 · Principles of General Physiology · open at passage 1299
  6. It was obvious, therefore, that artificial membrane formation induced by butyric acid initiates the processes underlying development of the egg but that for some reason the egg is sickly and perishes rapidly.Loeb, J., 1916 · The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · open at passage 167
  7. The writer suggested in 1905 that the artificial membrane formation alone starts the development but leaves the eggs usually in a sickly condition and that the hypertonic solution or the lack of oxygen allows them to recuperate from such a condition.Loeb, J., 1916 · The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · open at passage 188
  8. apparently the initial effect of the activating agent must be to increase permeability, while the alkali earth salts have the reverse effect.Lillie, R. S., 1923 · Protoplasmic Action and Nervous Action · open at passage 590
  9. These experiments show clearly that accompanying the division of the cell body there is a reversible change in the properties of the plasma membraneLillie, R. S., 1923 · Protoplasmic Action and Nervous Action · open at passage 602
Linked ideas
The general topic of which the membrane and hypertonic method is the best-known sea urchin procedure.
Covers cleavage caused by hypertonic solution, as in Kostanecki's mollusk eggs and Bataillon's frog eggs.
Lillie noted that calcium and magnesium salts block activation by alkali salts, which he read as opposing effects on permeability.
Concerns the permeability and water loss that Lillie used to interpret both activation and the hypertonic step.
Relates to the reversible change in the egg's plasma membrane during furrow formation.
Another account of how the salt medium governs whether and how the egg develops.
Both concern Loeb's artificial parthenogenesis in sea urchin eggs using hypertonic sea water; B gives the membrane-plus-hypertonic method, while the passages give no direct account of A's streaming and knob formation.
Where it is discussedPassages matching membrane formation of egg, artificial membrane formation, hypertonic sea water, cytolysis
1912The Mechanistic Conception of Life · Loeb, J.34
1916The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · Loeb, J.26
1906The Dynamics of Living Matter · Loeb, J.20
1923Protoplasmic Action and Nervous Action · Lillie, R. S.12
1915Principles of General Physiology · Bayliss, W. M.3
1922Injury, Recovery and Death in Relation to Conductivity and Permeability · Osterhout, W. J. V.1
1924Physiological Foundations of Behavior · Child, C. M.1