Bioelectricity  ·  Article

Semipermeability: pore (sieve) theory versus solution theory

A semipermeable membrane passes some substances and holds back others. Physiologists used the idea to explain osmosis, tissue currents and the stimulating effect of the galvanic current.12 Writers of the period described the membranes as colloid films, soap films or mosaics.57

Earliest held
1900, Loeb, J.
Most discussed in
Principles of General Physiology, 1915
In the library
23 passages in 9 works
Rewritten
2026-11-16
01

Membranes and ions

Loeb (1906) reported that Ostwald had suggested that semipermeable membranes might be permeable to only one class of ions, positive or negative. Ostwald thought this could explain muscle and nerve currents.1 Loeb added that Bernstein held a specific permeability for cations to be necessary to explain the current of action.1 Loeb judged that potential differences in tissues could hardly arise except by separation of anions and cations.1 Loeb also described his own earlier idea. The polar effects of a galvanic current, he thought, came from ions blocked by the membranes. He expected that experiments with salts would show which ions were responsible.2

02

Models and composition

Loeb (1916) noted that Traube had made drops enclosed in a semipermeable membrane that swelled in a solution of lower osmotic pressure. He said this imitated only the increase in volume, not the synthesis of specific cell material.4 Lillie (1923) recalled the Pfeffer and Morse membranes, made of water-insoluble colloid held in the interstices of a supporting structure. Their permeability changes with salts. Lillie wrote that living membranes are probably similar in a broad sense, but vastly more complex, chiefly because of metabolism.7 Osterhout (1922) listed Czapek's view that the plasma membrane is made of soaps and Nathanson's view that it is a mosaic of lipoid and non-lipoid particles.5 He argued that a mosaic gives entry only if each element runs unbroken from outer surface to vacuole.5

03

Location and cost

Osterhout described several semipermeable surfaces in the cell of Griffithsia: the plasma membrane, the plastid surfaces, the vacuolar surface and the nuclear surface. He expected them to differ somewhat in permeability. Killing the cell destroys them, and the pigment then diffuses out.6 Child (1924) reported that Lillie treated changes in permeability and polarization as essential to excitation and transmission. Child saw no need to confine these events to the outer surface, since limiting surfaces also exist between colloid phases inside protoplasm.8 Bayliss (1915) pointed out that cells spend energy keeping these membrane properties intact. He said this must be allowed for when interpreting oxygen consumption by tissues that perform no external work.3

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. Bernstein pointed out that, in order to explain the above-mentioned current of action, a specific permeability of the semipermeable membranes for cations must be assumed.Loeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 189
  2. the polar effects of the current are due to the ions which are blocked in their prog- ress by the semipermeable membranes in these organsLoeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 227
  3. The consumption of energy by cells for the purpose of opposing the mixing of their constituents by diffusion, maintaining intact the properties, electrical or otherwise, of the semipermeable membranesBayliss, W. M., 1915 · Principles of General Physiology · open at passage 2589
  4. Traube has shown that drops of a liquid surrounded with a semipermeable membrane may increase in volume when put into a solution of lower osmotic pressure.Loeb, J., 1916 · The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · open at passage 55
  5. Czapek (1914) has suggested that the plasma membrane is com- posed of soaps. Nathanson (1914) regards it as mosaic of lipoid and non-lipoid particles.Osterhout, W. J. V., 1922 · Injury, Recovery and Death in Relation to Conductivity and Permeability · open at passage 440
  6. This can easily be shown by killing the cell, whereupon the semipermeable mem- branes are destroyed and the pigment at once begins to diffuse out.Osterhout, W. J. V., 1922 · Injury, Recovery and Death in Relation to Conductivity and Permeability · open at passage 441
  7. water-insoluble colloidal material (Cua FeCye) held in the interstices of a supporting structure forms the essential composition of the semipermeable membranes used in the osmotic pressure determinations of Pfeffer and MorseLillie, R. S., 1923 · Protoplasmic Action and Nervous Action · open at passage 307
  8. Such semipermeable membranes or limiting surfaces are commonly believed to constitute the external boundaries of all cells and protoplasmsChild, C. M., 1924 · Physiological Foundations of Behavior · open at passage 467
Linked ideas
Bernstein's cation-permeability argument, reported by Loeb, is an early form of the ionic account of membrane potential.
Traube's enclosed drops and the Pfeffer and Morse membranes are artificial models of semipermeable behaviour.
Offers a different account of how cells hold and exchange substances, without a bounding membrane doing the selecting.
Osterhout linked injury and death to changes in conductivity and permeability of the membranes.
Resting membrane potentialprecursor of / follows
Selective permeability to one class of ions was proposed as the origin of tissue electrical potentials.
Loeb's idea of ions blocked at membranes was an attempt to explain polar effects of the galvanic current.
Concerns the permeability and water loss that Lillie used to interpret both activation and the hypertonic step.
Meigs, reported by Lillie, found smooth muscle lacking the semi-permeable membrane that the solution theory assumes.
The solution and membrane theory behind plasmolysis, which Bose cautioned could not explain every effect of a strong solution.
Where it is discussedPassages matching semipermeable membrane, Traube pores, Overton lipoid theory, Nernst solution theory of semipermeability
1915Principles of General Physiology · Bayliss, W. M.10
1906The Dynamics of Living Matter · Loeb, J.3
1922Injury, Recovery and Death in Relation to Conductivity and Permeability · Osterhout, W. J. V.2
1923Protoplasmic Action and Nervous Action · Lillie, R. S.2
1924Physiological Foundations of Behavior · Child, C. M.2
2018Formation of Proton Motive Force Under Low-Aeration Alkaline Conditions in… · Matsuno T, Goto T, Ogami S, Morimoto H…1
1916The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · Loeb, J.1
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.1
1926A Bipolar Theory of Living Processes · Crile, G. W.1