Morphogenesis and form  ·  Article

Developmental versus hereditary effect of the spermatozoon

A spermatozoon can do two things at fertilization. It can start the egg developing, and it can pass on paternal characters. Loeb argued that these two effects may be tied to different substances.5 Egg fragments and crosses between species were the test cases.17 Morgan doubted the earlier view that the nucleus alone fixes the form of the larva.3

Earliest held
1901, Morgan, T. H.
Most discussed in
The Dynamics of Living Matter, 1906
In the library
11 passages in 5 works
Rewritten
2026-11-16
01

Egg fragments without nuclei

Morgan (1901) reviewed work on sea-urchin eggs. Pieces of egg without a nucleus do not segment or develop. If a spermatozoon enters such a piece, it segments and, as Boveri and Wilson showed, produces an embryo.1 Boveri fertilized a non-nucleated piece of one species with sperm of another. The embryo was of the type of the sperm's species, and he concluded that the nucleus determines the larva.2 Morgan replied that this evidence was not beyond question.3 He held that it was still to be shown whether the protoplasm influences the larval form in such a case.4

02

Two kinds of effect

Loeb (1906) separated the developmental effect of the spermatozoon from its hereditary effect. He wrote that experiments on artificial parthenogenesis suggest the possibility that the two agencies are connected with different substances.5 He also stated that merogony experiments show that a fragment of egg protoplasm with no nucleus can develop when fertilized by a spermatozoon.6 In 1912 he restated the distinction between the hereditary effect and the activating or developmental effect. He said that his paper dealt only with the second.8

03

Remote crosses

In 1912 Loeb reported that eggs of a sea-urchin fertilized with sperm of a more remote species, such as a star-fish, give a sea-urchin larva with no paternal characters. He cited Godlewski, Kupelwieser, Hagedoorn and Baltzer as confirming this.7 He said this shows that the egg is the main instrument of heredity, while apparently the spermatozoon is restricted in what it transmits to the offspring.7 In 1916 he described the same result for heterogeneous hybridization. There the spermatozoon acts practically only as an activating agency on the egg.9 He added that this result could not have been predicted.9

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. If, however, a spermatozoon enters one of these pieces, the piece will segment, and, as Boveri and later Wilson have shown, it will produce an embryo.Morgan, T. H., 1901 · Regeneration · open at passage 169
  2. He found that the embryo that develops is of the type of the species from which the spermatozoon has come, and he concluded that the nucleus determines the character of the larvaMorgan, T. H., 1901 · Regeneration · open at passage 169
  3. The evidence from which Boveri drew his conclusion is not beyond question.Morgan, T. H., 1901 · Regeneration · open at passage 169
  4. It remains, therefore, still to be shown whether or not the protoplasm has any influence on the form of larva that comes from a nonnucleated piece, fertilized by a spermatozoon of another species.Morgan, T. H., 1901 · Regeneration · open at passage 170
  5. The experiments on artificial parthenogenesis or chemical fertilization suggest the possibility that the developmental and the heredi- tary agencies in the spermatozoon are connected with different substances.Loeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 476
  6. On the other hand, the experiments on merogony show that a fragment of egg protoplasm which has no nucleus can develop when fertilized by a spermatozoon.Loeb, J., 1906 · The Dynamics of Living Matter · open at passage 476
  7. If, however, the eggs of a sea-urchin are fertilized with the sperm of a more remote species, e.g., a star-fish, the result is a seaurchin larva which possesses no paternal charactersLoeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 25
  8. The analysis of the process of fertilization by the spermatozoon shows that we must discriminate between two kinds of effects, the hereditary effect and the activating or developmental effect.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 276
  9. In the case of the heterogeneous hybridization the spermatozoon acts practically only as an activating agency upon the egg and not as a transmitter of paternal qualities.Loeb, J., 1916 · The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · open at passage 85
Linked ideas
Loeb used development of eggs without sperm to argue that developmental and hereditary agencies are separate.
Morgan asked whether egg protoplasm shapes the larva, against Boveri's view that the nucleus decides.
Another account of how heredity is carried, set against the claim that the egg is the main bearer.
Loeb's physicochemical treatment of heredity and the paternal contribution.
Chemical routes to starting egg development without a spermatozoon.
Paternal inheritance of characters, the hereditary side of the distinction.
Where it is discussedPassages matching developmental effect of spermatozoon, hereditary effect, specificity of fertilization, spermatozoon of another species
1906The Dynamics of Living Matter · Loeb, J.5
1901Regeneration · Morgan, T. H.2
1912The Mechanistic Conception of Life · Loeb, J.2
1916The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · Loeb, J.1
1906Plant Response as a Means of Physiological Investigation · Bose, J. C.1