Minds of small things  ·  Article

Response to inert particles versus nitrogenous matter (cork, thread, cinders)

Darwin tested the tentacle glands of a sundew with small inert bodies: boiled cork, boiled thread and cinders from the fire. He also touched glands with a needle. The inert bodies produced only slight, late inflection, and the needle gave an uneven result.123

Earliest held
1875, Darwin, C.
Most discussed in
Insectivorous Plants, 1875
In the library
21 passages in 3 works
Rewritten
2026-11-19
01

Darwin's trial

Darwin (1875, Insectivorous Plants) describes placing two bits of boiled cork, one of boiled thread and two of cinders taken from the fire on five glands. He used an instrument that had been immersed in boiling water.1 He says these precautions were more than needed and were taken on account of statements by M. Ziegler. Darwin mentions Mrs. Treat's account of Drosera rotundifolia nearby. One cinder caused some inflection in 8 hours 45 minutes. After 23 hours the other cinder, the thread and both bits of cork had also caused some inflection.2

02

The needle and the timing

Darwin also touched three glands about six times each with a needle. One tentacle became well inflected in 17 minutes and re-expanded after 24 hours. The other two never moved.3 The contrast in timing is plain in his own figures. The inert particles acted after hours, and the needle acted in minutes on one tentacle out of three. Elsewhere in the book Darwin gives numbered records of the same kind, with times of first inflection, extent of inflection and re-expansion.

03

Aggregation and ammonia

Darwin then turns to the cell contents. He states that the fluid within the cells of the tentacles undergoes aggregation after the tentacles have become inflected. He says this happens especially if the tentacle has been given a solution of carbonate of ammonia.4 He also reports seeing the usual movements in the masses of protoplasm. Darwin does not compare cork and ammonia directly in these trials. He only says that aggregation happens especially with ammonia.

04

State of the responder

Jennings (1906, Behavior of the Lower Organisms) reports a related point for the sea anemone. A touch with a needle that would cause a strong contraction in a hungry animal often caused no reaction in a satiated one.6 He adds that a stronger chemical solution was needed to cause contraction in the well-fed animal. Jennings was writing about an animal and Darwin about a plant, so the two do not describe the same case. Jennings ties the response to the condition of the animal. Darwin's trials here do not address the state of the plant.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. Two bits of boiled cork, one of boiled thread, and two of coal-cinders taken from the fire, were placed, by the aid of an instrument which had been immersed in boiling water, on five glandsDarwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 608
  2. One of the particles of cinder caused some inflection in 8 hrs. 45 m., as did after 23 hrs. the other particle of cinder, the bit of thread, and both bits of cork.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 608
  3. Three glands were touched half a dozen times with a needle ; one of the tentacles became well inflected in 17 m., and re -expanded after 24 hrs.; the two others never moved.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 608
  4. The homogeneous fluid within the cells of the tentacles undergoes aggregation after these have become inflected ; especially if given a solution of carbonate of ammoniaDarwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 608
  5. After 40 m. some inflection ; after 2 hrs. 18 m. about twenty-eight outer tentacles inflected ; after 5 hrs. 20 m. about a third of the tentacles inflected ; after 8 hrs. much re-expanded.Darwin, C., 1875 · Insectivorous Plants · open at passage 348
  6. A disturbance in the water, or a touch with a needle, that would produce a strong contraction in the hungry animal, often causes no reaction whatever in the satiated specimen.Jennings, H. S., 1906 · Behavior of the Lower Organisms · open at passage 645
Linked ideas
Covers the nitrogenous and ammonium stimuli that the inert particles are set against.
The inflection of tentacles measured here is the response described in that article.
The needle touches and their uneven result bear on touch thresholds and repeated stimulation.
Gives the chemical and organic stimuli treated alongside the inert particles.
Slow, weak response to cork and thread resembles filtering of spurious stimuli.
Aggregation of cell contents after inflection, especially with ammonium carbonate, is treated there.
Paper balls and coal cinders on exterior tentacles (B's inert-particle tests) were carried to the centre (A's movement), but slowly and erratically, from 1 hr to never; Darwin suspects traces of animal matter.
Where it is discussedPassages matching bits of cork, boiled thread, coal cinders, touched with a needle
1875Insectivorous Plants · Darwin, C.12
1881The Formation of Vegetable Mould through the Action of Worms · Darwin, C.8
1906Behavior of the Lower Organisms · Jennings, H. S.1