Evolution and evolvability  ·  Article

Instinct, its origin and lapsed intelligence

Instinct is behaviour that serves a species without being learned afresh in each life. Two accounts of its origin stand out. One says instincts are habits that lapsed into inheritance.3 The other says natural selection kept accidental tendencies to act.4

Earliest held
1859, Darwin
Most discussed in
The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2, 1890
In the library
927 passages in 38 works
Rewritten
2026-11-18
01

Darwin and the early cases

Darwin (1859) gave instinct a separate chapter in the Origin of Species. He feared that the hive-bee's cell-making might seem to many readers a difficulty large enough to overthrow his theory.1 He set aside the origin of the primary mental powers, as he did the origin of life, and dealt only with the diversities of instinct within a class of animals.1 Romanes (1882) collected cases of animal behaviour. He described the gad-fly as showing a singular refinement of instinct in where it lays its eggs on the horse.2

02

Lapsed intelligence versus selection

James (1890) set out the two leading accounts of how instincts evolved. He named Lamarck and Darwin. Lamarck held that animals have wants and form habits to meet them. These habits turn gradually into propensities that cannot be resisted or changed.3 James notes that Lewes called this the theory of lapsed intelligence. Darwin's theory, in James's words, was the natural selection of accidentally produced tendencies to action.4 Darwin argued that the instincts of the hive-bee and of many ants could not have been acquired by habit and then inherited.5

03

Instinct, morphogenesis and mechanism

Driesch (1908) reported that older physiologists often compared morphogenesis with instinctive life. He said the comparison treated both as governed by one vital principle.6 He stated that it was not yet known whether this view was legitimate. He used the comparison to raise another question, besides the problem of the nature of the instinctive stimuli. The answer, he said, may one day let us admit or deny the autonomic nature of instincts.6 Loeb (1912) held that human wishes and sufferings arise from instincts comparable to the light instinct of heliotropic animals.7 He said the chemical basis of some of them is indicated well enough to raise the hope that their mechanistic analysis is only a question of time.7

04

Recent criticism

Trewavas (2026) reviewed how the idea of rigid instinct fared. He cited Blumberg's critique, which concluded that instincts are not satisfactorily described as inborn, preprogrammed, hardwired or genetically determined.8 He also cited Lehrman's criticism of Lorenz and Tinbergen, which stressed learning and development.8 Pecere (2026) recalled that Darwin saw a continuous transition from instinct to intelligence in organisms.9 Pecere asks whether the genealogical connection of living forms suggested to Darwin that plants might share some cognitive capacities.9

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. I must premise, that I have nothing to do with the origin of the primary mental powers, any more than I have with that of life itself.Darwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 369
  2. The gad-fly, whose eggs are hatched out in the intes- tines of the horse, exhibits a singular refinement of instinctRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 554
  3. habits which transform themselves gradually into so many propensities which they can neither resist nor change.James, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 3254
  4. Mr. Darwin's theory is that of the natural selection of accidentally produced tendencies to action.James, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 3268
  5. the most wonderful instincts with which we are acquainted, namely, those of the hive-bee and of many ants, could not possibly have been thus acquiredJames, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 3268
  6. The old physiologists, such as Treviranus and Johannes Miiller, often compared morphogenesis with instinctive lifeDriesch, H., 1908 · The Science and Philosophy of the Organism · open at passage 99
  7. Our wishes and hopes, disappointments and sufferings have their source in instincts which are comparable to the light instinct of the heliotropic animals.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 58
  8. Blumberg 48 provides an excellent critique of instinct concluding that they are not satisfactorily described as inborn, preprogrammed, hardwired or genetically determinedTrewavas A, 2026 · Aspects of plant intelligence (ii) · open at passage 20
  9. Darwin maintained that there is a continuous transition from instinct to intelligence in organisms.Pecere P, 2026 · Plant cognition after Darwin: historical and epistemological remarks · open at passage 29
Linked ideas
Darwin's account of instinct is an application of natural selection to behaviour.
Habit and plasticityin tension with
The lapsed-intelligence view derives instinct from inherited habit. Darwin rejected that route for the hive-bee and ants.
Gives further cases of instinct in animals.
Treats the boundary between intelligent and instinctive action that the lapsed-intelligence theory blurs.
Tropismrelated to
Loeb compared human instincts to the light instinct of heliotropic animals.
Basal cognitionrelated to
Recent work asks whether instinct and intelligence form a continuum reaching plants and simple organisms.
Treats the origin of instinct, the question the cuckoo and Melothrus cases were used to test.
Loeb treats stereotropism as one of the tropisms (with heliotropism, chemotropism, geotropism) that compose complex instincts, e.g. Fundulus spawning contact; instincts are 'often nothing more than' compulsory orientation.
James says instinctive reaction and emotional expression shade imperceptibly into each other; Cannon likewise pairs the fighting emotions and instincts. The passages don't address instinct's origin.
Concerns where instinct comes from, a question the continuum view of instinct and reason raises.
James's cases of tameness, wariness and pointing in dogs ask how training becomes near-innate instinct.
Where it is discussedPassages matching instinct, lapsed intelligence, originally intelligent actions, accidental adjustments favoured by natural selection
1890The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · James, W.191
1882Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J.189
1903The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy · Metchnikoff, E.99
1908The Science and Philosophy of the Organism · Driesch, H.52
1859On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · Darwin51
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.45
1908The Animal Mind: A Textbook of Comparative Psychology · Washburn, M. F.38
1925Elements of Physical Biology · Lotka, A. J.26
1902Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · Kropotkin, P.26
1916The Organism as a Whole, from a Physicochemical Viewpoint · Loeb, J.24