Minds of small things  ·  Article

Instinct and migratory behaviour

Instinct is the name for acts done without prior experience, alike by many individuals, and without knowledge of their purpose. Darwin gives the cuckoo's migration and egg-laying in other birds' nests as one example of instinct. He declined to define the term and relied on this common sense of it1. Loeb later argued that the theory of tropisms is the theory of instincts, if due consideration is given to the role of hormones in producing some tropisms and suppressing others. He added that daily depth migrations of aquatic animals are in all probability set by a periodic change in heliotropism7.

Earliest held
1859, Darwin
Most discussed in
Animal Intelligence, 1882
In the library
1,654 passages in 160 works
Rewritten
2026-11-17
01

Early observations

Darwin (1859) treated instinct as an action that an animal performs without experience and without knowing its purpose1. He quoted Kirby on land crabs that travel to the sea in a straight line and scale houses rather than be turned aside3. He also cited Leroy on late-hatched swallows, whose migratory instinct was too weak to carry them off alone4.

02

Loeb's tropism analysis

Loeb (1900) chose the daily depth migration of pelagic animals for laboratory work, because bird migration was hard to study experimentally5. He judged that birds add complications. An inherited element causes restlessness at the time of migration6. Memory may also play a part, as in the carrier-pigeon. In 1912 he held that what is inherited is positive heliotropism, with migration following from changing external conditions. In 1918 he wrote that the theory of tropisms is the theory of instincts, once hormones are allowed for7.

03

Later reading of Darwin

Pecere (2026) quotes a Darwin notebook entry of 1838-39. It proposes that instinct is a modification of bodily structure connected with locomotion. Darwin then doubted the locomotion link, because plants have instincts8. Darwin, Romanes and Loeb locate instinct differently. Loeb places the cause in the sensitivity of peripheral structures, not in central control5.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. An action, which we ourselves should require experience to enable us to perform, when performed by an animal, more especially by a very young one, without any experience,Darwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 370
  2. When the old nest is found inconvenient, and they have to migrate, it is the slaves which determine the migration, and actually carry their masters in their jaws.Darwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 389
  3. They migrate in a straight line, and rather than allow them- selves to be deflected from it, ‘they scale the housesRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 559
  4. when swallows are hatched out too late to migrate with the older birds, the instinct of migration is not sufficiently imperative to induce them to undertake the journey by themselves.Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 737
  5. For this reason I have made use of another class of periodic migrations, namely, the periodic depth-migra- tions of pelagic animals.Loeb, J., 1900 · Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · open at passage 280
  6. In the case of the birds, there is present in addition a purely inherited, instinctive element which causes restlessness at the time of migration.Loeb, J., 1900 · Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · open at passage 288
  7. the theory of tropisms is at the same time the theory of instincts if due consideration is given to the role of hormones in producing certain tropisms and suppressing others.Loeb, J., 1918 · Forced Movements, Tropisms, and Animal Conduct · open at passage 291
  8. Instinct is a modification of bodily structure (connected with locomotion.) no, for plants have instinctsPecere P, 2026 · Plant cognition after Darwin: historical and epistemological remarks · open at passage 30
Linked ideas
Tropismpart of / contains
Loeb's claim is that migratory instincts are tropisms, so the two articles describe the same mechanism from different ends.
Loeb's book on forced movements is where the identification of tropism theory with instinct theory is stated.
Changing heliotropism is the cause Loeb gave for the periodic up-and-down migration of small aquatic animals.
Romanes' purposeful-looking migrations contrast with Loeb's reduction of instinct to compulsory turning.
Loeb separated inherited restlessness from acquired memory in bird migration, which is the line between instinct and learned habit.
Loeb noted that associative memory complicates instinct analysis in pigeons and migrating birds.
Treats the instinct side of the contrast, which Romanes saw as sometimes arising by intelligent adaptation.
Loeb treats stereotropism, with heliotropism and chemotropism, as a component of instincts; he argues tropisms explain instinctive acts such as Fundulus spawning contact, making A an element of B.
Loeb treats stereotropism, with heliotropism and chemotropism, as elements composing instincts; e.g., fish mating is stereotropism. Instinct is explained tropistically, so A is a component of B's explanation.
Gives further cases of instinct in animals.
Darwin linked the cuckoo's early migration to the inconvenience of building its own nest and incubating.
James says instinctive reactions and emotional expressions shade into each other, so instinct is the neighboring topic.
Both concern instinct. Jennings lists tropisms, habits and instincts as fixed responses that develop from trial and error, a continuum view; Loeb ties tropisms to heritable instincts. Migration itself isn't mentioned.
Where it is discussedPassages matching instinct, migration, land crabs, migrate in a straight line
1882Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J.208
1890The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · James, W.193
1859On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · Darwin106
1903The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy · Metchnikoff, E.102
1902Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · Kropotkin, P.66
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.55
1908The Science and Philosophy of the Organism · Driesch, H.53
1908The Animal Mind: A Textbook of Comparative Psychology · Washburn, M. F.45
1925Elements of Physical Biology · Lotka, A. J.40
1930The History of Biological Theories · Rádl, E.35