Minds of small things  ·  Article

Instinct versus reason

Romanes said the two can be told apart in a general way, yet held that no distinct line can be drawn between them. Authors disagree on whether a real boundary exists. Romanes held that one shades into the other1. Wasmann, as reported by Rádl, drew the line at consciousness of the end to be attained8.

Earliest held
1859, Darwin
Most discussed in
The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2, 1890
In the library
1,222 passages in 90 works
Rewritten
2026-11-19
01

A continuum in animals

Romanes (1882, Animal Intelligence) said that no distinct line can be drawn between instinct and reason1. He still held that the two classes of action are definite. Particular cases are hard to classify because instinctive actions are often mixed with a little judgment, in Pierre Huber's phrase, and the reverse also occurs2. Wasmann, as reported by Rádl (1930), took a sharper view. He defined intelligent action by consciousness of the end to be attained, and he allowed intelligence only to humans. Animals, even the highest, were for him dominated by instinct8.

02

Instinct in the psychologist's account

James (1890, The Principles of Psychology) argued that there is no material antagonism between instinct and reason. Humans have all the impulses of lower animals and many more3. On his account reason cannot inhibit an impulse. Only an opposite impulse can do that, though reason may draw an inference that excites the imagination and releases it3. Metchnikoff (1903, The Nature of Man) used the contrast in another way. He read the fear of death as a pure instinct, independent of rational will, following Schopenhauer's phrase "blind will"4.

03

Mechanism and tropism

Loeb (1912, The Mechanistic Conception of Life) found no sharp line between reflexes and instincts. Authors tended to say reflex for a part of the animal and instinct for the whole animal, as in tropisms5. He rejected the test that treats purposeful action as a sign of consciousness. On that test, if an animal reacts as a rational human would, it counts as conscious6. Timiriazeff (1912, The Life of the Plant) applied similar reasoning to the root. He held that no rational will, habit, taste or instinct need be assumed to explain how roots discriminate, since simple physical laws suffice7.

04

Instinct in plants

He proposes the developmental cycle from seed to flower to seed, which seems invariable in gymnosperms and angiosperms9. He treats the response to gravity as a second candidate. Trewavas holds that variable behaviour, most divergent from supposed instinct, matters most for plants9.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. Now it is notorious that no distinct line can be drawn between instinct and reason.Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 46
  2. actions in the main instinctive are very commonly tempered with what Pierre Huber calls ‘a little dose of judgment or reason,’ and vice versé.Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 49
  3. In other words, there is no material antagonism between instinct and reason. Reason, per se, can inhibit no impulses ; the only thing that can neutralize an impulse is an impulse the other way.James, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 2600
  4. This " blind will " is no other than a pure instinct which is independent of our rational will.Metchnikoff, E., 1903 · The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy · open at passage 270
  5. they speak of instincts where the reaction of the animal as a whole is involved (as is the case in tropisms)Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 125
  6. If an animal or an organ reacts as a rational human being would do under the same circumstances, these authors declare that we are dealing with a phenomenon of consciousness.Loeb, J., 1912 · The Mechanistic Conception of Life · open at passage 129
  7. It is therefore quite unnecessary to presuppose any rational will, habits, tastes or instinct in order to explain the discriminating property of the rootTimiriazeff, C. A., 1912 · The Life of the Plant · open at passage 229
  8. Here there is consciousness of the end to be attained. By this criterion we can distinguish between intelligent actions and merely instinctive ones.Rádl, E., 1930 · The History of Biological Theories · open at passage 666
  9. The equivalent “instinct” in vascular plants might be the developmental cycle; seed to flower to seed.Trewavas A, 2026 · Aspects of plant intelligence (ii) · open at passage 21
Linked ideas
Treats the same contrast within animal behaviour, where Romanes found cases hard to classify.
Concerns where instinct comes from, a question the continuum view of instinct and reason raises.
Tropismpart of / contains
Loeb explained many instincts as tropisms found in plants and animals alike.
Inherited habit is one side of the instinct and reason contrast.
Rádl's test of awareness of the end is one proposed criterion for intelligent action.
Purposeful action is what Loeb said cannot by itself show consciousness.
Both concern instinct. Jennings lists tropisms, habits and instincts as fixed responses that develop from trial and error, a continuum view; Loeb ties tropisms to heritable instincts. Migration itself isn't mentioned.
Darwin lists the cuckoo's and parasitic bees' instincts among natural instincts explained by selection; Romanes treats cuckoo egg-laying as a special bird instinct within his instinct-versus-intelligence discussion. A is a case study for B.
Loeb treats stereotropism as one of the tropisms (with heliotropism, chemotropism) that compose instincts, e.g. Fundulus mating; so A supplies a mechanistic explanation within B's instinct debate, reducing instinct to tropisms.
James says instinctive reaction and emotional expression shade imperceptibly into each other, linking instinct to emotion; Cannon treats fear and rage as fighting emotions and instincts with shared visceral effects.
Where it is discussedPassages matching instinct and reason, distinction between instinct and reason, intelligent action, rational
1890The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · James, W.258
1882Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J.202
1903The Nature of Man: Studies in Optimistic Philosophy · Metchnikoff, E.118
1908The Science and Philosophy of the Organism · Driesch, H.60
1859On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · Darwin60
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.49
1908The Animal Mind: A Textbook of Comparative Psychology · Washburn, M. F.38
1925Elements of Physical Biology · Lotka, A. J.31
1902Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · Kropotkin, P.30
1957An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine · Bernard, C.29