Evolution and evolvability  ·  Article

Brood parasitism and plundering instincts

Brood parasitism is the habit of laying eggs in the nests of other species, so that others rear the young. Writers from Darwin to James used it as a test case for explaining instinct. Darwin reported it as commonly admitted that the cuckoo's laying interval caused the habit2. Romanes found a gradation of perfection among Melothrus species4. James read the habit as a perception-impulse, not foresight7.

Earliest held
1859, Darwin
Most discussed in
Animal Intelligence, 1882
In the library
44 passages in 7 works
Rewritten
2026-11-18
01

Darwin's cases

Darwin (1859) noted that many bees are parasitic and always lay their eggs in the nests of other bees. He judged this more remarkable than the cuckoo, because the bees' structure as well as their instincts had been modified1. For the cuckoo, he reported it as commonly admitted that the cause was laying at intervals of two or three days2. A cuckoo building its own nest would then leave early eggs unincubated, or have young of different ages in one nest2. He added that the American cuckoo does build its own nest and has eggs and young hatched successively3.

02

Romanes and Melothrus

Romanes (1882) described Melothrus, an American genus allied to starlings, as having parasitic habits like the cuckoo's. He said the species show a gradation in how perfect the instinct is4. Citing Hudson, he reported that one species usually sits on its own eggs and rears its own young, though it is probably occasionally parasitic5. Hudson, a strong disbeliever in evolution, was struck by the imperfect instincts of another species. He quoted Romanes and asked whether such habits were small consequences of a general law of transition6.

03

James on perception-impulse

James (1890) gave a different kind of explanation. He held that the cuckoo's and the cow-bird's propensity to lay in other species' nests is a pure perception-impulse7. On his account these birds have no bodily disposition to become broody, so no link joins seeing an egg to the impulse to sit. Eggs ripen in the oviduct and the body tends to get rid of them7. James said the birds might seem to act with full consciousness of preserving the species, but that this is not so7.

04

Later reception

Rádl (1930) wrote that Darwin explained animal instinct in this fashion. He observed that the cuckoo, bees and the ant-heap did not seem very remarkable either to Darwin or to Darwin's opponents8. He named Romanes among those who followed Darwin's method8. Bernard's Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine (1957 edition) cites Jenner's 1788 paper on the natural history of the cuckoo in a footnote. The footnote sits where Bernard separates sciences of observation from sciences of experimentation9.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. This case is more re- markable than that of the cuckoo; for these bees have not only their instincts but their structure modified in accordance with their parasitic habitsDarwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 388
  2. It is now commonly admitted that the more imme- diate and final cause of the cuckoo’s instinct is, that she lays her eggs, not daily, but at intervals of two or three daysDarwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 386
  3. But the American cuckoo is in this pre- dicament; for she makes her own nest and has eggs and young successively hatched, all at the same time.Darwin, 1859 · On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · open at passage 386
  4. Some species of Melothrus, a widely distinct genus of American birds, allied to our starlings, have parasitic habits like those of the cuckoo ; and the species present an interesting gradation in the perfectiun of their instincts.Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 760
  5. They usually sit on their own eggs and rear their own young; but Mr. Hudson says it is probable that they are occasionally parasiticRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 760
  6. Mr. Hudson is a strong disbeliever in evolution, but he appears to have been so much struck by the imperfect instincts of the Melothrus Canari- ensis that he quotes my wordsRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 761
  7. The propensity of the cuckoo and of the cow-bird to lay their eggs in the nests of other species must also be interpreted as a pure perception-impulse.James, W., 1890 · The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · open at passage 2591
  8. These instincts, in spite of all their diversity as seen in domestic animals, in the cuckoo, among bees, in the ant- heap do not seem to have been regarded as very remark- able, either by Darwin or by his opponents.Rádl, E., 1930 · The History of Biological Theories · open at passage 663
  9. Jenner, On the natural history of the cuckoo. {Philosophical Transactions, 1788, Chap. XVI, p. 432.)Bernard, C., 1957 · An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine · open at passage 89
Linked ideas
Treats the origin of instinct, the question the cuckoo and Melothrus cases were used to test.
Frames instinct against reasoning, the contrast James drew when calling parasitic laying a perception-impulse.
Nest building is the habit that parasitic species skip or modify, as with Melothrus and parasitic bees.
Darwin's selection argument is the setting in which he explained the cuckoo and parasitic bees.
James warned that parasitic laying looks purposive, as if species preservation were intended, yet he denied the birds act with that purpose.
Darwin linked the cuckoo's early migration to the inconvenience of building its own nest and incubating.
Darwin's chapter outline lists instincts compared with habits alongside the cuckoo and parasitic bees' instincts. Romanes only describes cuckoo host choice, with no explicit link to plasticity.
Instinct versus reasonpart of / contains
Darwin lists the cuckoo's and parasitic bees' instincts among natural instincts explained by selection; Romanes treats cuckoo egg-laying as a special bird instinct within his instinct-versus-intelligence discussion. A is a case study for B.
Brood parasitism serves as a case of apparent end-directedness: Darwin notes instinct acts without knowing its purpose, and James explains nest-laying as a perception-impulse that only appears aimed at preserving the species.
Where it is discussedPassages matching cuckoo, parasitic habit, laying eggs in other birds' nests, Molothrus
1882Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J.27
1859On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of… · Darwin9
1902Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution · Kropotkin, P.2
1957An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine · Bernard, C.2
1894Materials for the Study of Variation Treated with Especial Regard to… · Bateson, W.2
1930The History of Biological Theories · Rádl, E.1
1890The Principles of Psychology, Vols. 1-2 · James, W.1