Minds of small things  ·  Article

Reasoning versus instinct in animals

Reasoning versus instinct asks whether an animal's act comes from inherited habit or from inference drawn from experience. Romanes, in 1882, collected cases he took to be reasoning, and he also described instincts as arising by intelligent adaptation.13 Some later authors treat adaptive behaviour as the essence of intelligence and propose, partly as hypothesis, applying it to plants and cells.45

Earliest held
1882, Romanes, G. J.
Most discussed in
Animal Intelligence, 1882
In the library
12 passages in 7 works
Rewritten
2026-11-17
01

Anecdotes of reasoning

Romanes (1882, Animal Intelligence) reproduced a report by Mr. Bidie of the Government Museum of Madras, sent to Nature, which Romanes introduced as an instance of reasoning in a cat.1 A tabby had hidden her kittens behind bookshelves in a library. About a week later the kittens were found in a dressing-room, where earlier broods had been nursed. A servant said the old cat had brought them one by one. In Bidie's account, the mother carried them in her mouth from the library to the dressing-room, where they lay quite exposed.2

02

Instinct shaped by intelligence

In a section on instincts, Romanes described those of pack-hunting species of the genus Canis, which lead to a combination among members of a pack to capture prey by stratagem. He said these instincts no doubt arose, and are now maintained, by intelligent adaptation to the requirements of the chase, and he named them collective instincts.3 He supported the point with an account from Sir E. Tennent. On this reading, an inherited habit can have an intelligent origin.

03

Intelligence as adaptive behaviour

Trewavas (2025), in a rebuttal of Kingsland and Taiz, quotes Beer (1990). Beer wrote that the more universal ability of animals is to cope with a complex, dynamic and unpredictable world, and that this penchant for adaptive behaviour is the essence of intelligence.4 Trewavas applies the same test to plants. In his 2026 paper, Polygonum plants placed in shade made leaves of greater area, which he called an intelligent adaptive response that gathers as much light as possible.5 The test is whether behaviour adapts to circumstance.

04

Cells and roots

Calvo, Baluška and Sims (2016) propose that plants, like animals, may perform active inference. They suggest that root salt avoidance, if it occurs, implies an intelligent adaptive strategy that modifies root growth.6 Baluška and Miller (2018) argue that the cell and its intelligent adaptations stay incompletely understood if explored only through epigenetics and genomics. They place a sensing apparatus, the senome, alongside genes.7 These authors extend the vocabulary of intelligent adaptation to organisms without brains.

SourcesEach quotation was checked word for word against the passage it opens.
  1. Mr. Bidie, writing from the Government Museum of Madras to ‘ Nature’ (vol. xx., p. 96), relates this instance of reasoning in a catRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 1030
  2. the mother had carried them one by one in her mouth from the library to the dressing-room, where they lay quite exposed.Romanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 1030
  3. These instincts, which no doubt arose and are now maintained by intelligent adaptation to the requirements of the chase, I shall call ‘collective instinctsRomanes, G. J., 1882 · Animal Intelligence · open at passage 1074
  4. If roots enjoy salt-avoidance behavior then this implies an intelligent adaptive strategy that calls for the active, salt-induced, modification of root growthCalvo P, Baluška F, Sims A, 2016 · "Feature Detection" vs. "Predictive Coding" Models of Plant Behavior · open at passage 50
  5. Our understanding of the cell and its intelligent adaptations will always remain incomplete if exclusively explored through epigenetics and genomics.Baluška F, Miller WB, 2018 · Senomic view of the cell: Senome versus Genome · open at passage 15
  6. I wish to emphasise instead the more universal ability of animals to cope with the complex dynamic and unpredictable world in which they live. To me this penchant for adaptive behaviour is the essence of intelligenceTrewavas A, 2025 · Plant intelligence dux: a comprehensive rebuttal of Kingsland and Taiz · open at passage 12
  7. This intelligent adaptive response is to gather as much light as is possible in this light-poor environment.Trewavas A, 2026 · Aspects of plant intelligence (ii) · open at passage 27
Linked ideas
Both ask what behaviour counts as evidence of mind, including whether adaptive response is enough.
Treats the instinct side of the contrast, which Romanes saw as sometimes arising by intelligent adaptation.
Trial and errorrelated to
Learning by trying is a standard way to separate experience-based behaviour from fixed instinct.
Basal cognitionrelated to
Carries the adaptive-behaviour definition of intelligence to cells and organisms without nervous systems.
Calvo and colleagues frame plant root behaviour as active inference, a modern model of inference from experience.
Adaptive responses in single cells bear on whether intelligence needs a brain.
Nest building was a standard test case in the debate over instinct and reasoning that Romanes joined.
Treats the boundary between intelligent and instinctive action that the lapsed-intelligence theory blurs.
Frames instinct against reasoning, the contrast James drew when calling parasitic laying a perception-impulse.
Treats the same contrast within animal behaviour, where Romanes found cases hard to classify.
Romanes's horse-tamer case raises whether sudden calming reflects reason, emotion or instinct.
Where it is discussedPassages matching reasoning in a cat, instance of reasoning, inference from experience, intelligent adaptation
1882Animal Intelligence · Romanes, G. J.6
2026Aspects of plant intelligence (ii) · Trewavas A1
2025Plant intelligence dux: a comprehensive rebuttal of Kingsland and Taiz · Trewavas A1
1900Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology · Loeb, J.1
1915Bodily Changes in Pain, Hunger, Fear and Rage · Cannon, W. B.1
2016"Feature Detection" vs. "Predictive Coding" Models of Plant Behavior · Calvo P, Baluška F, Sims A1
2018Senomic view of the cell: Senome versus Genome · Baluška F, Miller WB1